Radhey Shyam And ORS v. The Collector And ORS
! "
#$% &''"(")* " )$$& "+!'"!( ,(
"**'' ''-**'./ -! "*
0
' ,' 1/ - 2" ,3 !'4
5 ( 6"0 / *" "" 0 **''
'"
"
" 7)
* 0 /0 ,' 8
"2,'37/0 ,' -"( !'4**'!, 0 "*
(# )' " !-(6"0 * ,"-"/'/"'/' !*" +6
77
(+ ( (+" 77 7 (/ #''- ) +/"
( &' !'4( " )* " *"! ./""-"*
"! *-
"!0, ! /' "!"
"-
//(* /'(/""/* *( (**'
-6*" "" 0 !'0 0
'
"1/ -()* 5
9 '" /' "**'' -"
" **''
"*
694"!(666"
"'
-"/'/"'' / #''-6(")* "
( /"(!' (,-2 " *'
3(0 !2 " *'
3(!-2 " 3 * " *"*" : "7 "8/ -"/'/"'!(;- ;6#''- ) +/"
6 */" , ,4
< /
6" 0 '
! '' /"0""5< "*
!/"- ;- ;66*/" !,''- )+/"
, ' 0"-,4 < <& ' 6-:/ "-" 0 !-( "
"*
! & !/ 6 "
-'
9! "(<5("':-4*' 06, ( " *'
0!( "
(!-( "
* !-( " 4'' "'-"/'/"'' .=& (66 -",'/ !*"-"/'/"'' / #''-)+/"
( 66" " *'
" ">
0"" * ?" "*
( !' (!-"'@/ ''"-"/' /
#''-)+/"
'/ -/*"*" 9*/"/ "' :- "( <5( *" " " **''
/ * /'* /*"*" 0-0'/6"6/ 0.,-0" 0 "*
/' **' 6 ' 0 "*
0 "",//"4- /' 0 !/ "
,/"*"' <"-" ,/" !
-(" "80 **'( !"6 - ' !*" +" 77 7 (/ ",/ #''- ) +/"
& !" 6 / 0 0&'
"(;*'(")* *" !""*"(**''
6" /
0''-'* ' */80
!" "*"( /0 ,' 8
" 2,'37/0 ,'
-"( !'4 * "
"
( 6"0 *6"
" 0 '," "*
&"
"
" ,0* 0 /0 ,' 8
" 2,'37/0 ,' -"( !'4 6/-,-**''
"(0 ''- ,'/A /"" *
/' 06**''( -(""
0 /"0'6(/ ",0 /
'" @/'./(*" "(/'
,0 -"
9, " /0!! 0 '" /'
"**'' 6(,-"/-!*/-
./ -!0/ ''-' ./ -!66/'
'' ""
"0 /"
& /" 0'6 , "-' */ / /* **''
6"-"
*",-"':- "
<5(0" 9 ! *"'
0"-,4 < <(' +"
776*/" 0 !- !: /(, !/ 6 ,/" & " "' :- 4*'! "(<50/! 0" ' ",/""
90 , 6 6/'
0' "' :-( *'' 6 ! " ' ",/""
( ""-' 0".
0 /"0'6 &**''
"(" "(!"' ''-'* /' &"*
"6" (+'' 77!/"- +' "'*".!0
" " 5
<$:) "'60* "(0 '"(*" "( /'
, 0 -" 0 /" 0'6 **''
"'!-!',06"*""':- "(<5( 4*' ,"*6 "!',"-"6"*"-,"* *"*"
5 9/'
0 */ 0 /' "**'' "! **','0'**''-!*/-
"
* 0 /0 ,'8
"2,'37/0
,'-"(!'4(6"! ( ! ' (0 ,' 0 **''
"(0", /"0'6,'/6/'
0!0' /'' ./ *
, * '-'*"4- "" *0 **"-!*",//" **'' ,'- ""! ,'0'! '6 '-**'0 **"-!*",//" ," !/*" /"0 ""- '-*" /?/""(**''
,00'0'"
6"*," */ "( '"(*"
"("-' 0 ' 0 /"0'6 < "*0" ""-/ 0 /' " **''
&"0-/"" -""
0 /"0'6 (6,0 / 00 *"*"
**" *' - , *" / 0 *"( "''-' !*/- ./ -!* 0 /"0'6 &"/0'@/ '6*"**'( 6"@/" " /" 9,6 0,( -!"**'(!
9,6 !' !**'(*""
"
""@/" 0* **' " "(!
!" # $