Gurdev Singh v. Balbir Singh & ORS
! "#$ %$&'(')*
+,%$-')./ 00$11")# 2$,(+( "13',')./")%#/$,( $(0)%$)#(
* 45 6 5 ,$($)#*7 , "18$$#')./9%-&"#$9 ,#/$"00$11")# :/$#/$,#/$$0,#$,( 1&"1)$;(0"0$,<"=3$"11;$%#($$ #/$>+%.<$)#?
3$,$ $,,$%##/$$0,#$,,)# @ :/$#/$,#/$>+%.<$)#(/+1%3$,$0,#$%')#/$%'.$(#? 77 77 5 9
5!
<0+.)$%')#/$0,$($)#,$.+1",($&)%"00$"1'(#/$ >+%.<$)#")%%$&,$$%"#$%@ @ 90"(($%3=#/$%%'#')"1 '(#,'&#+%.$9"1")%/",9,$-$,(').#/$>+%.<$)#")%%$&,$$%"#$% A @9 0"(($% 3= #/$ 1$",)$% '-'1 +%.$ +)', '-'(')!9 /'11"+,9-'%$;/'&/#/$(+'# #/$01"')#'
"00$11")#/$,$')!9;"( %$&,$$% ,'$ 1=(#"#$%9#/$01"')#'
"00$11")#/"% '1$%"(+'# , %$&1","#')")%0$,<")$)#')>+)&#')9&1"'<').#/"##/$("1$%$$% %"#$%
A9,$.",%').#/$(+'#1")%9$B$&+#$%3=/'( "#/$,
77 ",(/") ')./ ') "-+, %$ $)%")# 9 '( '11$."1 /$ 01"')#'
"00$11")#&1"'<(#/"##/$(+'#0,0$,#='(')#')%+"<'1=9 &0",&$)",=")%")&$(#,"10,0$,#=/$%$ $)%")#;"(#/$ 6",#" #/$ ')# ')%+ "<'1= $ '( " <") 3"% ,$0+#$9 $B#,"-".")#9%,+)8",%")%('<01$#)/$,$;"())$$%#($11#/$ 1")% ,1$."1)$&$(('#=,#/$,$;"(")=%$3#"."')(##/$')# ')%+"<'1=$ $)%")#(1%#/$1")%9-'%$("1$%$$%%"#$%
A9;'#/+#1$."1)$&$(('#=")%;'#/+#&)('%$,"#')")% ;'#/+# &)($)# #/$ 01"')#'
, ( 9@9
7 /$ ("1$ &)('%$,"#');"()#0"'% $ $)%")#%'%)#"00$",),/$ '1$%#/$;,'##$) (#"#$<$)#$ $)%")#')#/$;,'##$)(#"#$<$)#(#"#$%#/"#'# ;"(($1 "&C+',$%0,0$,#= %$ $)%")#")%#/"#'#;"((1%
,1$."1)$&$(('#= #;"((#"#$%#/"#/$/"%#"8$)"1") ,< %$ $)%")#(")%,$1"#'-$(")%#0"=3"&8#/$("<$9#/$("1$%$$% ;"($B$&+#$% /$1;$, +,#/$1%#/"##/$(+'#0,0$,#='(")&$(#,"1 0,0$,#=")%'#;"((1%;'#/+#1$."1)$&$(('#=/$,$ ,$9#/$(+'# ;"(%$&,$$% ,%$&1","#')")%0$,<")$)#')>+)&#') $ $)%")# ;$)# ') "00$"1 /$ 1$",)$% %%'#')"1 '(#,'&# +%.$9 "1")%/",9/$1%#/"##/$(+'#0,0$,#=;"(')/$,'#$%3=(+,-'-,(/'0 /$,$ ,$9'#;"()#")&$(#,"10,0$,#=C+"#/$01"')#'
"00$11")## ;"( +,#/$,/$1%#/"##/$01"')#'
"00$11")#")%%$ $)%")#/"-$
7@7 &))'-$%;'#/$"&/#/$,")%#/"##/$,$'()#/').) '1$#(/;
#/"##/$("1$&)('%$,"#');"()#0"'%")%),#/$,$;"(;")#
1$."1)$&$(('#= /"-$ /$",% #/$ 1$",)$% &+)($1 , #/$ 01"')#'
"00$11")#")%/"-$"1(&",$ +11=.)$#/,+./#/$ '1$ 0,-$ #/$ ")&$(#,"1 0,0$,#=9 )1= &0= #/$ >"<"3")%' /"( 3$$) 0,%+&$% # (/; #/"# %$ $)%")# "1).;'#//'(3,#/$,')/$,'#$%#/$0,0$,#= ,</'( "#/$,&0= <+#"#');"( '1$%#(/;"(#;/$#/$,%$ $)%")#/"%")= #/$,3,#/$,,('(#$, -$)'
'#'("((+<$%#/"##/$0,0$,#=;"( ,'.')"11= ;)$% 3= 6",)"'1 ')./ .,")% "#/$, #/$ 01"')#'
"00$11")#!")%%$ $)%")#')/$,'#$%#/$("<$ ,</'(
"#/$,3=;"= (+&&$((')9$-$)#/$)'#&"))#3$("'%#/"##/$(+'# 0,0$,#=;"((1%;'#/+#1$."1)$&$(('#=/$;'1%"11$."#')(;$,$ 1$-$11$% "."')(# %$ $)%")# #/"# /$ '( <") 3"% /"3'#(9 %,+)8",% ")% ('<01$#) ;$-$,9 %$ $)%")# %'% )# &/"11$).$#/$("1$%$$%9$B$&+#$%3=/'<"#/$,9/$%$&'%$%)## 0+#')"00$",")&$ $"1(%'%)#"00$",')#/$;'#)$((3B# (#"#$#/"#/$/"()#,$&$'-$%#/$("1$&)('%$,"#') /$<$,$
"&##/"#'#'(,$&,%$%')#/$("1$%$$%#/"##/$("1$&)('%$,"#') ;"( 0"'% # /'< "# /<$9 '( ) .,+)% # 0,$(+<$ #/"# ("1$ &)('%$,"#');"()#0"'%/$;")# ("1$&)('%$,"#');"(# 3$0,-$%3=#/$-$)%,,#/$01"')#'
"00$11")#/$%$ $)%")#
77 /"%%'(&1($%')#/$$-'%$)&$9#/$(+,&$( ,<;/'&//$&11$&#$% #/$ ("1$ &)('%$,"#') /$ 0,$(+<0#') '( #/"# #/$ ,$.'(#$,$% %&+<$)#'( ,&)('%$,"#')")%;")# &)('%$,"#');"(#3$ 0,-$%3=#/$01"')#'
"00$11")#+,#/$,9)1=%$ $)%")#8)$;
,;/'&/0+,0($/$)$$%$%#/$<)$= $%$&'%$%#"3(#"')
,<#/$0,&$$%').(/$,$ ,$9'#/"(#3$"((+<$%#/"##/$,$ ;"( (<$ )$$% ') #/$ "<'1=9 , ;/'&/ #/$ 1")% ;"( (1% /$,$ ,$9#/$,$'().,+)%#')#$, $,$')#/$ ')%').( "&#( ,$&,%$%3=#/$ ',(#"00$11"#$ +,# $)&$9#/$0,$($)#,$.+1", ($&)%"00$"1'(%'(<'(($%
5 !
(>8(