High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/48691/2023allowed

Sachin @ Lala v. Ut Chandigarh And Another

2024-11-18Ms. Justice Harpreet Kaur Jeewan5 pages

! "# $%&' )(

*+ %,"%&%-&. / &+'((

12 (((((( 3!( (( (((((((((0 0 '

4 20(0 5 6 !%&+7 " ! "# $$*+ " ! &+'

"((0(*!8*9: $#%.*+ : ,%"+7 ; +<+<%& "( "(*=<#3<=: $$9(((((7*&$<>*"7 *!!<!+ $?@0*7 0<&>7( "(3*"<&$ "0<&>7: $#%.*+ : ,%"" !;%&$ &+%( ( AAAAA 5 6 :( "*@ "<&+7 <&!+*&+; +<+<%&,<9 $-&$ "0 .+<%& "(((<!

,%"B-*!7<&>%,%( $*+ $ ((

&& C-" " ><!+ " $ -&$ "0 .+<%& &*&$0 .+<%& %,+7 "%+ .+<%&%,7<9$" & ,"%/0 C-*9,, &. ! .+:

,%"!7%"+D+7 0 .+E9*+ "%& $ 9 + $?@+7 ;%9<. *+%9<. 0+*+<%&0*"*&>;-":((7*&$<>*"7*&$*99 +7 .%&! B- &+<*9 ;"%. $<&>! *"<!<&> +7 " ,"%/ %& +7 ?*!<! %, .%/;"%/<! $*+ $

&& C-" ,, .+ $? +8 &+7 ;*"+< !(

7 ;*"+< !8 " $<" .+ $+%*;; *"? ,%" +7 +"<*9%-"+,%" " .%"$<&> %, +7 !+*+ / &+! 8<+7 " >*"$ +% +7 .%/;"%/<! $*+ $

&& C-" : *! ; " +7 %"$ " $*+ $

(

( 7 " 9 #*&+;*"+%,+7 !*<$%"$ "" *$!*!-&$ "' CCCC CCCC CCCC CCCC F2 *"& $ .%-&! 9 ,%" +7 ; +<+<%& "!

!-?/<+!+7*+<&%"$ "+%9<# ; *. ,-99@:;*"+< !7*# &+ " $<&+%.%/;"%/<! $*+ $

&& C-"

:*..%"$<&>+%87<.7:?%+7+7 ;*"+< !7*# *>" $ &%++%;"%. $,-"+7 "8<+7+7 <&B- !+<%&(+<! !-?/<++ $+7*++7 ; +<+<%& "7*!!%9 /&<G $/*""<*> 8<+7 +7 #<.+</H" !;%&$ &+ %( 7 " <& %&

(+<!,-"+7 "!-?/<++ $+7*+ # &;"<%"+% +7 /*""<*> * /*9 .7<9$ 8*! ?%"& %-+ %, +7 " 9*+<%&!7<;? +8 &+7 ; +<+<%& "*&$+7 #<.+</%& ((

(2 *"& $.%-&! 9!-?/<+!+7*+*9+7%->7%& +7 $*+ %,*99 > $<&.<$ &++7 *> %,+7 #<.+</8*! !7%8&*!)@ *"!(%8 # ":$-"<&><&# !+<>*+<%&<+ 8*!" # *9 $+7*+!7 8*!@ *"!%,*> # &*++7 +</ %,<&.<$ &+(+<!!-?/<++ $+7*+.7*"> !-&$ " 0 .+<%& %,+7 0 .+7*# ? &$ 9 + $*&$ +7 .7*99*&7*!? &;" ! &+ $*>*<&!++7 ; +<+<%& " %&9@-&$ "0 .+<%& &( %+<. %,/%+<%&( &+7 *!J<&>%,%-"+:"(*=<#3<=:

$$9( (( ,%" (( 7*&$<>*"7: *.. ;+! &%+<. %& ? 7*9,%," !;%&$ &+%(((7*&<$>*"7K87 " *! "(3*"<&$ "0<&>7: $#%.*+ 87%<!;" ! &+<&%-"+ *.. ;+! &%+<. %& ? 7*9, %, " !;%&$ &+ %( .%/;9*<&*&+*&$!-?/<+!7<!3*J*9*+&*/*:87<.7<! +*J &%&" .%"$( 2 *"& $ $$9(((,%"((7*&$<>*"7:

!-?/<+!+7*++7 <&B- !+<%&.*&&%+? B-*!7 $%& +7 ?*!<!%,.%/;"%/<! $*+ $

&& C-"

,, .+ $? +8 &+7 ;*"+< !*!+7 " *" .7*"> ! -&$ "+7 0 .+*>*<&!++7 ; +<+<%& "(%8 # ":

9 *"& $ $$9(((,%"((7*&$<>*"7:<!-&*?9 +% .%&,<"/*!+%87 +7 "<&+7 ;" ! &+.*! :+7 .7*"> ! -&$ "+7 0 .+7*# ? &$ 9 + $%"&%+( ,-"+7 "!-?/<+!+7*++7 & C+$*+ ? ,%" +7 +"<*9%-"+ <! ((

*&$ ;"%! .-+<%&8<+& !! !7*# ? & C*/<& $? ,%" +7 +"<*9%-"+:!%,*"( 2 *"& $ .%-&! 9 ,%" " !;%&$ &+ %( #<.<+/!-?/<+!+7*+<&+7 .7*99*&" ;%"+,<9 $?@+7 ;%9<. ? ,%" +7 9 *"& $+"<*9%-"+:+7 $*+ %,?<"+7 %,+7 #<.+</*!; "/*+"<.-9*+<%&. "+<,<.*+ <!!7%8& *! I(

: +7 " ,%" : *+ +7 +</ %, *99 > $ <&.<$ &++7 #<.+</8*!/%" +7*&@ *"!%,*> ( 7 5 "*9*<>7%-"+<&"9(((%( I) I %,

: $ .<$ $ %&

(

"</ ! :2*8<&$ " %.$L I) : 7*!7 9$ +7*+87 &+7 *..-! $*&$+7 #<.+</7*# &+ " $<&+% * /*+"</%&<*9 " 9*+<%&!7<;: +7 " <! &% ;-";%! <& .%&+<&-<&> 8<+7 +7 ;"%. $<&>!( # & <, +7 +"<*9 %-"+<!*99%8 $+%;"%. $8<+7+7 +"<*9%,+7 .*! : <+ <! !-" +7*+/*+ "<*98<+& !! ! *" &%+ >%<&> +% !-;;%"++7 .*! (7*+/ *&!:<+8%-9$? *,-+<9 C ".<! +%.%&+<&- +7 ;"%. $<&>!( & #< 8 %, +7 *?%# : +7 ;*"+< ! *" $<" .+ $ +% *;; *" ? ,%" +7 +"<*9 %-"+H99*B* *><!+"*+ ,%"" .%"$<&>+7 <"!+*+ / &+!8<+7" >*"$ +%+7 .%/;"%/<! $*+ $

&& C-" %& ((

:+7 $*+ *9" *$@,<C $? ,%" +7 +"<*9 %-"+ ?@ /%#<&> *& *;;"%;"<*+ *;;9<.*+<%& %" ?@ ;" ! &+<&>+7<!%"$ "(M CCCC CCCC CCCC CCCC

! ; " +7 %"$ " $*+ $ I(

: +7 0+*+ %, ((:

7*&$<>*"78*!$<" .+ $+%!-?/<+# "<,<.*+<%&" >*"$<&>+7 .%&+ &+<%&! &%+ $<&+7 *,%" !*<$%"$ ":<( (+7 ; +<+<%& "7*!!%9 /&<G $/*""<*> 8<+7+7 #<.+</%&

*&$+7*+$-"<&>+7 <&# !+<>*+<%&<+8*!

" # *9 $+7*+!7 8*!@ *"!%,*> # &*++7 +</ %,+7 <&.<$ &+( ( "(*=<#3<=: $$9(((((:7*&$<>*"7!-?/<++ $+7*++7 <&# !+<>*+<&> %,,<. ": 0 *7 0<&>7: %9<. 0+*+<%&: 0*"*&>;-": ((: 7*&$<>*"7:7*!# "<,< $+7 *,%" !*<$,*.+!*&$" .%"$ $+7 !+*+ / &+%, +7 ;"%! .-+"<C%&)(

(7 ;"%! .-+"<C.%&,<"/ $+7 *,%" !*<$ .%&+ &+<%&!:<&7 "!+*+ / &+(%;@%,87<.78*!!-?/<++ $<&%-"+%& )(

( I(

!; "+7 " ;%"+$*+ $

((

:" . <# $,"%/+7 -$> :

*!+"*.J0; .<*9%-"+:7*&$<>*"7:+7 .%/;"%/<! ,, .+ $? +8 & +7 ;*"+< ! <! > &-<& : #%9-&+*"@ *&$ 8<+7%-+ *&@ .% ".<%& %" -&$- <&,9- &. (7 ; +<+<%& "7*!&%+? &$ .9*" $*!F"%.9*</ $,, &$ "M *&$7 <!&%+<&#%9# $<&*&@%+7 "."</<&*9.*! ( &+7 !+*+ / &+%,+7 ;"%! .-+"<C" .%"$ $?@0*7 0<&>7 %&)(

:+7 ;"%! .-+"<C!+*+ $+7*+!7 8*!7*#<&>*9%# *,,*<"8<+7 +7 ; +<+<%& "( "$*+ %,?<"+7<!I(

*!; "+7 " .%"$%,+7 000.7%%9: 7*&*!*&$ *$7*".*"$(07 7*!,-"+7 "# "<,< $+7*+!7 >*# ?<"+7+%*.7<9$<&0:0 .+%" :7*&$<>*"7%& ((

0-?! B- &+9@: !7 7*! !%9 /&<G $ /*""<*> 8<+7 +7 ; +<+<%& " %&

*&$;" ! &+9@!7 <!7*;;<9@9<#<&>8<+7+7 ; +<+<%& "( )( 5 ;<&><&#< 8+7 ,*.+!*&$.<".-/!+*&. !%,+7<!.*! *&$ <&#< 8%,+7 ,*.++7*+ # &*.7<9$7*!? &?%"&%-+%,+7 " 9*+<%&!7<;

<&+ " ! +7 ; +<+<%& " *&$ +7 ;"%! .-+"<C: !-?! B- &+9@: +7 @ 7*# " ;" ! &+ $+7 <"" 9*+<%&!7<;?@ &+ "<&><&+%*8 $9%.J:<&.*! ,-"+7 " ;"%. $<&>!*" .%&$-.+ $%&+7 ?*!<!%,+7 ;" ! &+:+7<!.*&.*-! * 9%+%,<&.%&# &< &. *&$<!!- !+%+7 /<&%".7<9$*!8 99(# &+7 ,-+-" %, +7 .7<9$ 8%-9$ ? <& $<,,<.-9+@ <& .*! +7 ; +<+<%& " <! ,-"+7 " ;"%! .-+ $%&+7 ?*!<!%,+7 ;" ! &+( ( 5 ;<&><&#< 8+7 <&+ " !+%,+7 ;*"+< !:*!8 99*!<&+7 <&+ " !+%,+7 /<&%".7<9$:<+<!<&+7 ,<+& !!%,+7 +7<&>!+7*++7 ;" ! &+ .%/;"%/<! !7%-9$? *.. ;+ $(

%&! B- &+9@:+7<!; +<+<%&<!*99%8 $*&$%( $*+ $ ((

&& C-" " ><!+ " $-&$ "0 .+<%& &*&$ 0 .+<%& %,+7 "%+ .+<%&%,7<9$" &,"%/0 C-*9,, &. ! .+:

,%"!7%"+D+7 0 .+E9*+ "%&$ 9 + $?@+7 ;%9<. *+%9<. 0+*+<%&0*"*&>;-":((7*&$<>*"7*&$*99+7 !-?! B- &+;"%. $<&>! /*&*+<&>+7 " ,"%/*" %"$ " $+%? B-*!7 $:B-*+7 ; +<+<%& "( &$<&>/<!. 99*& %-!*;;9<.*+<%&!:<,*&@:*9!%!+*&$$<!;%! $ %,( 5 6 %# /? ":

&<+<& 67 +7 "0; *J<&> !H% 67 +7 " ;%"+*?9 !H%