← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/2941/2018allowed

State Of Haryana Through Collector, Mohindergarh & ORS v. Smt. Sulochna W/O Sh. Suraj Bhan

2022-11-10Mr. Justice Anil Kshetarpal12 pages

 



!

"

 #"

$%

'

!

& 

( ) * *  & + ,,)  **  -



' 

-* **..// 01 - * -"2 !

**. !

)

3%2 * $"- !

2 4-

#2  



    

        

  

   

    

      

      



   





    !"

   

#     $

   

!%

   '  

  ) 1, 5671) ) ) *



' 



!

  

' &! +  ' ' ,

&,-

!

(! .!

( ((

 



(

%

( + ( '

 ' -

3 .!

 +  ' ' 6 7-   3 .!

&((  +  ' ' , 3&,- ((

& 

  (

!( 

   

%

 (



 ( %  

   ) 8 ( 

!(

%

(

% '  ! -*

* #,1/ /( & ) (



9) 9: 89))  ( "( ;

( :

3 (  (( 

< ! .!

* 

'!=(

/ $ 

=):5 ' !(  (( # ! ;

$ (



! )5 9> 89)) $ ! % 3&    85  81 94 89)8 >  !  3& 3& '' 

 1999999<=   (

(( ! %'

 ' .!

 ( !

"( ;

( $

&,  81 9> 89)>  ! 

 

 482885)<= ) 8 ) $  '

 ! '' 3& (

(

)4 

  '

(  

! (



 ( % ! '

 

( !

%

 !( ( .!

 .!

 (  ( 

 19999999<=   ?

% (( .!

 (

(  

  =!(

 

 8 8 @ 





 



8 

( 3&

'' /! '  .! 8 :

& 

( 

!(( ! '((

! ' /!

=  

 

 



      

      !!

" 



   #   $$

   !!

%

 

            &

         '   

& !!

( ) :

(, .1  .,( .,) : ) ? (    A  '((

=

!

  * ( !

"

 +&&

!

%  , !

  * !

-    !

.

 /, !

  #&

!

 &

!

 3, !

4  +&

!

  ( !

"

 5  6 !

%  +&& $,  : 8 ?  !     !

'((

 !   

! 

  '  %!(

  (



 ; 8 =

 7/ !8   7/ !8

9 7/ !8- :;

   4. 4 211   &    5 &

7/ !8.

:;

    41 "4"

: :

@ 



 

(    A 

*=)

# (



*=8



 !  B

 *$ +CD - 

 

: 1

  !

'((

 !     '  %!(

  (



 ; 8 = 7/ (8"

 7/ (8.

9 7/ (80 9#   

  9    $:& 7/ (81 9#   

  &;

          

  12 

 4 4% "4"

7/ (82 9#       * "2    "

41 "4"

BA =)9

 8<+ ! (! (- : ;

?  (    A  *=)1



! C!

(

BA  (

!

$ ( BA =))

 (! BA =)8  !

/9, +  ,:.17 + !13 ;17:) 1 ) ?

  

&!

 

  '((



/!

= 1 8 *

'!

"



!  !

 

!    

< (   ! '' 3&

 (



8;

!

 (  &

   

!  &!

 

 !"#$   

  ( 

 %

"



!  !

  '(



(   ! ( '' 3& A  (( % '' (   ! '' 3& ?  

%

( 

 

%

"



!  '(



(   ! '' 3& 1 :

B '

 BA =:

+%

 2>-

 



  ( !  

(

!

89E  

 482885)<=   1 1

 BA =:

%   A ( ' 

.!

 ( !  

   !

  

 !

   " !



!   '( 

(   ! '' 3&



8;

;

&,1, /9, +  71: +   /

1/ .,7  .,) ; )

C

 (

!( 

  (

 %(   ! %"

(

  &! %(

 .!



= ; 8 

 

  

  (

' 

  !  !

 

%!( ' = -2 && # &"!& %'

2 > - -*

* ?,5,

* -/ &

* &

/ 

4 :1

, * :1 # 

, * 0,//7 ) =) 89:1 9: )9 8994 8)9 .

 ;99999<= ));8:4)9<=  =8 8:99 88 )9 8994 8::

.

 299999<= )812:;)5<=  :

=:

2> ): 91 89)) 8#=9 ; 8;;9999<= )99>19>1<=  =1 592:

89 9) 89)8 )#=9 :2:9999<= 85919999<=  -2 && # &"!& %'

-

)

=) )1):

94 95 89)9 8#=9 ; )999999<= :5;92)><=   

=8 8:)8 ): )8 89)9  "( :>;9999<= );99999<=  :

=:

8;8) 85 )8 89)9 ;

"( ( 8)9;28:<= :)>4855<= 

=1 9> 92 89)) ))#=)9 ;>;9999<= 1999999<=  ;

=;

:):;

98 )) 89)8  ( )89>;999<= 2999999<= 

=2 8;15 )> )9 89):

) "( ):

( >8)4>;<= :;99999<=  ; :

@ 

 (

 

!( 

 .!

 ( 

 

( (

 %!



 

 ?  /  < C( ?' /   3 '



(

 '  

 (

 

(

( %!

 (

!( ( !%  89E !

 @ 

 (

!( 

 





(

!  BA =:

+%

 2>-

 

*

'

(! ( BA =)9

% /  .!

 (  

 );99999<=  

 BA =8 +%

 8:)8-  ): )8 89)9

 "( (

%!



.!  !% 

% A (

!(

 % ( ! &!

/!

; 1



8;



@     (%  !

 

!  &!, 



 !"#$ ; ;

 BA =) +%

 89:1BA =8 +%

 8:99- 

   ( (  ( !

8)9 .

 8::

.

   F   ( (

  

!(!( ( 

 



 ( %



 .!

 

!(!( ( 



("

'  BA =:

+%

 2>- (  

 

? ' 

'!( !(  BA =:

BA =)

  94 95 89)9    ( (  ( '

 )999999<=  BA =)

?   ' !

 ( ( 94 )9 89)9 '

 )999999<=

$ 

 3( (    ( %!

(     ): 91 89)) ?

  ' !

( '

 )999999<= 94 95 89)9  (   ( < C( ?' /   3 '

 8;;9999<= !

      '

 );;9999<= ?

(   '   ( (

(  %!

( (  % ( < C( ?' /   3 ?   < C( ?' /   3

   %! !

 /

 (

 A   BA =:

%  ( ( !

 ' ' BA =:

+%

 2>-

 



  (  ((  ( ( !

"( 9 ;

( %!

((

( (  %

( < C( ?' /   3

% ( ?   !

 !  

94 95 89)9   ( '

 )999999<= ?   

 

 19;98)9<=

(    3&

&! !(



 



 ;9999<=  

(

! BA =) +%

 )1):-



 ( )8)9 ;

.

 +8#=9 ;- !

   (   (

 .

   BA =8  ): )8 89)9

 ( !

"( +8  "(-  ( ( (  

% ( 

 );99999<=   ' 9> 92 89))  BA =1 +%

 299-  59;

.

 (

% (  

 1999999<=  



(

    

%!

( ( ( %!



; 2

(

   (

 !( 

' (

 BA =)

 !

   B



%!(

'  



'   ; > ?

(   % 

         %!

 

 

(



'!( !(  BA =)

( !

 !     ((

 

(

( "( 9 ;

(

 % ( '

)999999<=

; 4 B

 BA =)

( ! !

  (  ((  

(( % (

 1999999<= 

 

( % '' 3& ?'

 "



 BA =8

!''

( %

 ( ( .!

 (  (

 );99999<=   

  '  BA =1 +%

 299- BA =;

+%

 :):;- BA =2 +%

 8;15- .!

 (   

 1999999<=  '

  A



 .!



!

; 5 #

  '  ' 

  !( ( 



.!

 ( 

 482885)<=   ? !% 

 ' ( ( !''

 ( %(    .!

 (

9) 9: 89))   

 1999999<=   &!-

2 ) &.!( 

!

 

 

2 8 ( (

  

  ((    &.!(  ! (

)4  ((    2 :

(( 

((! (



  (    

(:5A  

2 4-

#2

# $"&

&' =>'*

  =>'* -*

* !-

* # - 2- )

G=851)=89)4

00B @G   @

<

0

H3@&

 

G=;;);=89)> $H3?

&$ <

00B @G   $ @

:

G=:11:=89)4

HC

 <

00B @G   $ @

G=:111=89)4 &H +$B&B B$- 0

$ @

<

00B @G   $ @

;

G=:1:;=89)4 &$B

#3 <

00B @G   $ @

G=:112=89)4

HC $ $ @

<

00B @G   $ @

>

G=:11>=89)4 ?

C$

? $

<

00B @G   $ @

G=:1:2=89)4

$BB <

00B @G   $ @

G=:11;=89)4

C?

? $

<

00B @G   $ @

)9

G=:1:4=89)4 C?B$B

$ @

<

00B @G   $ @

))

G=:119=89)4

B$B

#H

$ @

<

00B @G   $ @

)8

G=:114=89)4 C ?

? $ @

<

00B @G   $ @

):

G=:11)=89)4 B$ 3

? $ @

<

00B @G   $ @

)1

G=:1:>=89)4   $ @

<

00B @G   $ @

);

G=:118=89)4 

 $ @

<

00B @G   $ @

)2

G=8:11=89)4 3

? <

00B @G   $ @

)>

G=:))4=89)4

00B @G   @

<

?

C$

?

)4

G=8529=89)4

00B @G   @

<

  &0 ?33B  )5

G=85>9=89)4

00B @G   @

<

  @

G=85>:=89)4

00B @G   @

<



 @

8)

G=85>)=89)4

00B @G   @

<

HC $ @

G=85;9=89)4

00B @G   @

<

?

3 I ?

$3 @

8:

G=85;8=89)4

00B @G   @

<

$H3?

&$

G=85;5=89)4

00B @G   @

<

C?

?

8;

G=852;=89)4

00B @G   @

<

33 &$ $ @

G=8525=89)4

00B @G   @

<

# ?

 $B?

8>

G=8514=89)4

00B @G   @

<

HC



G=85>;=89)4

00B @G   @

<

$BB

?

G=851;=89)4

00B @G   @

<

&H @

:9

G=85;:=89)4

00B @G   @

<

@B$B

&@H

 :)

G=:))>=89)4

00B @G   @

<

?$@ ?

@

:8

G=22)=89)4 #B @

 I #B 

 <

00B @G   $ @

::

G=14)>=89)>

00B @G   $ @

<

C?

$ @

:1

G=8549=89)4

00B @G   @

<

0



:;

G=8488=89)4 

? $ @

<

00B @G   $ @

:2

G=85;)=89)4

00B @G   @

<

B$B

#H

@

:>

G=85;1=89)4

00B @G   @

<

$?

 

$

:4

G=85;2=89)4

00B @G   @

<

0?

$B?

@

:5

G=85>8=89)4

00B @G   @

<

@0

G=85>1=89)4

00B @G   @

<

3BB3



1)

G=85>2=89)4

00B @G   @

<

 &$B

@

G=85>>=89)4

00B @G   @

<

B0

 @

1:

G=85>4=89)4

00B @G   @

<

C?B$B

@

G=8511=89)4

00B @G   @

<

0



1;

G=8512=89)4

00B @G   @

<

#B @

 I #B 



G=851>=89)4

00B @G   @

<

&H

 $ @

1>

G=8515=89)4

00B @G   @

<

B@ &$ @

G=:))2=89)4

00B @G   @

<

0 3J?

$B?

$ @

G=85;4=89)4

00B @G   @

<

00

? @

;9

G=852)=89)4

00B @G   @

<

&$B #3

;)

G=8528=89)4

00B @G   @

<

$BB

;8

G=852>=89)4

00B @G   @

<

HC



;:

G=8524=89)4

00B @G   @

<

00

? @

;1

G=851:=89)4

00B @G   @

<

HB  $B?

;;

G=8518=89)4

00B @G   @

<

3

?

;2

G=)48;=89)4

H3@& <

00B @G   $ @

;>

G=85>5=89)4

00B @G   @

<

0 C?3 $B?

;4

G=;9;=89)4 3BB3

 <

00B @G   $ @

;5

G=854)=89)4

00B @G   @

<

?

3 I ?

$3 $B&B B$ 0

?

@

G=85;>=89)4

00B @G   @

<

B$ 3

? @

2)

G=852:=89)4

00B @G   @

<



? @

G=8521=89)4

00B @G   @

<

C ?

? @

 2:

J@C =52=89)5

00B @G   $ @

<

$BB

? J@C =5)=89)5

00B @G   $ @0B

<

  &0  2;

J@C =58=89)5

00B @G   $ @

<

  $ @

J@C =5:=89)5

00B @G   $ @

<

00

? $ @

2> J@C =5>=89)5

00B @G   $ @

<

?

3 I ?

$3 $ @

J@C =51=89)5

00B @G   $ @

<

0H

 J@C =)1)=898)

00B @G   $ @

<

B@ &$ $ @

>9 J@C =)4=898)

00B @G   $ @

<

&?

 $ @

>) J@C =8;=898)

00B @G   $ @

<

@0

>8 J@C =45=898)

00B @G   $ @

<

?

33 $ @

>:

J@C =)19=898)

00B @G   $ @

<

@B$B

&H$ >1 J@C =5;=89)5

00B @G   @

<

0



2 4-

#2 $"&