High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1598/2014allowed

Jaswant Singh v. Malkiat Singh & ANR

2019-12-05Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan11 pages

!""#$!""%

&&'' (#$ ') !" "#

& *#

# !'+, #"&&''

# - +, #"#&

....

/#'0+"#"&' ') !" "$ !"+# ,''!1"$ 1"$ 1' + 2"'$0+ #3"#&$# "#! ''04#$!"$ ! 5#- !"+ # " ,#0 ,''! ) ! #5 & #+40 0& &##5 !#5 6 7+' 5$# ! ) ' 7 5#' $ ,''! 1"$ 1"$ 1' + 2"'

$0+ # 3"#&$# $''0 #4 " " &'

&#,# "&' + 4 !

#"$' " # !#5 ''"5 ""5 6 +

6 7##, !" 5$ +

9:5#"'5$ '

#&"$&#&#04 "&# 7;+6 9+$ """ #,

9:,!#5 6 +

#5 7

<$40 ,$#"&' #'# 5$ +

9 '#, 6 7:''"#'# # ! #5 ,!#5 6 7:"' 4<$ " $#5 "# &&'& ! "3!"

=$###, 40" "#!#:" & "$&#&#0"'#04 ',#40" "&' # !"&' +""' 0 4 #0 '' !&##5"&# #+" ,#" " # 5&#5

#&"&&' ""4#"#& ! "3!"=$#:

" 4 "&' :"&' "' #, & "3!"=$# "3!"=$#0" ' "$' ## !"#&#0#!" "5 ,##

:"&' "'#,'!'

$& " + """'#'#&'0:"&' "'$#&#5 -$ + "# " "

7 $45 # 5 ' !"5&#5

'#$'" 5"'5"&' +" 4#$!""$ >$

4 !&$ +" &&# ' # 5 !"$: ""# &#'5 #04- ""$ 5 4':""$ 54##:""&' " '$ #$ '"$:""&' &&#5' !" $40" $

5#+" # ! ", ! # 0 !#5 " " &'

# !"5+" #"$&#&#0&#" "3!"=$#;

$" ", !#, 05 0#5"&' 8 5&' &#0 "

&&' $ # ##$' =*= '' ,##

6 40 " #' =$# 3 " ' &# #

5 ) !,#$'!'4- + 5# !" " #!"+'# # "$&#&#0 # ! " !#<$ 0'

,$#"&' + "#"''!!#5 ''" "#!"$" /"" &#0#5'"$

"&' !"&#+'' !$ #

?""#" "<$ !#5 '' 7 # " ' 5$# ! 17 ,''! 1"$ )"$ 1"$#+' "" "&' @

?""#"&' #5 #0 '' !&##5 "&#" #@ **

?""#"&' '##& 40 0&&##5 "!#5 ''@ **

?""#"$ 5 4'@ *

?""#"$ " '5 @ **

;

?""#"&' " '$ '"&# $@ *

/" " &# ' , $&&# "# #&,'5

#"# !"'# $ '#"&#+"#'

=$#$8 ! " ,$#" &' +$8 ! " ,$#" &' + $ 8 7 ! " &' ,$# " +$8

; ,$#"&' ! " +$8 ,$#"&' ! " $' '0,-$!5 #;

"#'=$# '=,'$! # ,

+$0+# "$"&' #"#,#0 +

9' ! "" #A B&#

$5#5"<$ "!#5 ''' !"$ $$# #A;B&#

$5#5" #''$'#'C

2"&' !!#,40"-$!5 # ""' &&'4#"=$##$!+ 3"#&$#+ "" !

' # $!+ 3"#&$#+ " , -$!5 #

7 & " &&' $ " &' ## 4 ##&&##5 !#5 6 7 4""#& 9 ##- #<$

"' " &# 5 "#5" # "&' #&"4' ' # "#'=$# " "5 D 4#," "#& '<$"' #5" #+" "&' 9&&'' "''4 '!"5 <$"#$!"! 0"=$#

/ ! ""-$!5 #& 40"#&&''=$#+" !"" '"&# !$'# &&'4#"=$#+ "" $"#& + "",&$ &&# "#$!"$ '

; D","#'# $ '#"&#4! !

"#$!""##

="&#DD"&'+;7' " &&##5 # E # "& ' &#, " " -$# # & &##5 # #0+ "=$# 4$ !# $"#'5#'04$' $':4$"# " =$# #4##0 4$ $ # 4'+ !$ 40 -$'&# &' &4'## 40=$#&&'

" +" #$5 ''#!# #'&&##5 "&' 2" #'=$#40&#&# '0"$' '!'& " ##," '$ ""&' '& &##5 !#5 ''"$!"&###,#0 " # 2"#', &#"-$!5 "#!#&# 8 + ""##0## 4 !#&#$$ #

# $

6 $

" # $

'''(

)

2" F# &&'' =$# "$ 0 ! -$4'# &"&&'+ "&#!# & &##5 !#5 "&' 8! , !

# #"5$'4!,

2"F#&&''=$#' !",#$#

G< * "&0-$!5 &40 '

#$!+5## =,'&&' $ 6 '405#- !" " $+"5"#5 1##1$# "#! !"H

"$ "# *#5 !" $ " !"" "#& "&&'

2" -$!5 "4 "'' ! 3 I4'3!"=$#40' ! 8

3 ,#+"5# 5&#54

"&# &#$'"##!" ""#"4

&##'! 4 """! $& "3!"=$# # '04 ""0" 5&#5"5#-$"#!""&' 2" 5&#55$4 #',"&$4

" "#&# #$'"5&#5+ 5#- !" ' !##5 " #"$&#&#0 3 "4 5& 40!, !"55"#&#&#0

5#- !" #5 " #"&#&#0#!# !

""!#5 ''"4 # +"$' &4'0 <$"' "#!# ,$#"&' "# " !" "5#- !" !"" ''$ """#"#!""&' + !" # '04 )- 5#- !" <$ !

"' ,$#"&' !" &#0 !#5 ''

2" # &&'' =$# 40 ' 5&&#' , # ! #&# ' !# & &##5 !#5 ''"&' D$#&# !

"'# '#$!+3"#&$# " < '4'' !" #&40"3!"=$#4 ''$,4 "&#5&''0#! !""#" 4 &##'! 4 "&#+ """! $& "3!"=$# D &&'4#"3!"=$#+ !" "&&'' "# #& #"# '$ !5#- !"H 2"&$4 "&# "

#!#"

2")$# !"+" $'5'0'

!" 2")$# !" 5 #-1$# " !"$!"#2")$# !" # ### *#08 5#- !" 2")$# !"+5 1##1$#+ 2")$# !"+ 1$# 8# - !"

$!"#2")$# !" ''- #1$# J$# 5 !"$!"#2")$# !" # ""#### *#08

&#"!#5 # 4 "*#0 8 *#08 +*#08 !, # '"$ $=" )1##+J'8"' !"?'+5##+' 5$# !) '5#'$,''!1"$ 1"$ 1' + 2"' $0+ # 3"#&$# "# ' 5$# ! ) '75#' '!, "*#08

%# $ '#"&&'' "###,#$ -$!5 # 4 !

4#,"&&##5 # 4# '0 ! <$ " #", !#!"&"$ &#&#0

2" -$!5 ###40'# $ '# "&&''

$ % & '$ $ (

')*+, - 40, / " "=$# "# 4#,"#!" 4'! $ # #

4>$#40#5& "#&#0 &#,0 " #

%# $ ' # " &&'' ' &# #, # ) $

*. ,

$ ( ')/$ 040, / " #3!"=$# "# "'' ! " "

!#5 ''"4 # 405&# # "#+ "#'! & ! "#!#" &#&#0:"'! " 5&#5#, """#&# # #''"&#&#0 D 4#, "

4 '$"5&#5# ''$, 5#'04$ ! #&#5

2"##+"4#, '# '# $!+3"#&$# ''0 # ! $ ''# 2"# !# "&&##5 "&' 4$#" # 4) '#$!+3"#&$#+"

&# 2"-$!5 #&40'# '#$!+3"#&$#", '! # 4$ 440 0& "&&'

$' '0 " -$!5 # & 40 '#$!+3"#&$## "-$!5 #&40"#'=$####

2"&&' '' # !'0 "

"5 &&' '' +"5'' $ &&' + 0' &# !'0

/#-

!"#$ %&"'

!()$* "&#

'# !+,

"&#