High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/571/2016dismissed

Santokh Singh & ANR v. Sohan Singh Dosanjh & ORS

2016-07-11Mr. Justice Arun Monga6 pages

!"##$%&%'()*+,

!'"-.%'/. !'".#0 11#**!'"& 2#0&)& .!'%'/.&!'3. ".#0& #&1'4#'"& !

"#$%& '( )* & *)+%,'(-.& 5.#".#0 #10"#0&*$!*1!1#0&6!+7#!**8#4"&##".#3)4/6#'"9 7#0##00#4"".# #10"#0&0'"9 : 5.#".#0".#3)4/6#'"&.)*47#0#10"#4%'".#%/#&"9

0#&#'"( 0 !6!'.!06!,4;$!"#, 0".#!11#**!'"& <<<<< *)+%,' 11#**!'"=1*!%'"%&!0#!//0%#;#4".#$'$)00#'"%'4%'/& !$",8.#0#7+$*!%6%'".#&)%"0&##-%'/4#$*!0!"%'!'41010%#"!0+ 1&&#&&%' 7+ 8!+ 10#=#61"%' >)! ".# &)%" 101#0"+, .!& 7##' 4#$*%'#4 7+ 7". ".# )0"& 7#*8, .8#;#0, ".# 4##'4!'"& 8#0# 0#&"0!%'#4064%&1&&#&&%'/".#1*!%'"%&06".#&)%"*!'4,#?$#1"%' 4)#$)0&#*!8 0 !6!' .!06!, *#!0'#4 $)'&#* 0 ".# !11#**!'"= 1*!%'"%& &)76%"& ".!" ".# &)%", !0#6#'"%'#4, 8!& %'&"%")"#4 7+ $.!**#'/%'/".#/%"4##44!"#4!'4".#0#*%#!&6#'"%'#4%' ".#&)%"%&".!"4##'4!'"&!'4:8#0#".#8'#0&".#*!'4,8.%$.

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

"#'!'")'4#0".#;#'40&'1!+6#'"B:04 7!"!%" ".# ;#'40&

*!%'"%!'"-.%'/..!47##'!'4%&%'$'"%'))&1&&#&&%' *!'4 6#!&)0%'/ C -!'!*& 7#!0%'/ 0#$"'::, -%**!', , , 0#$"':@,-%**!'6,#'"#0#4!"-.#8!"'A@A,-.!"'%':!& 1#03!6!7!'4%0".#+#!0= !'4B:047!"!%8!&7#%'/1!%4"".# *!'4*04& %6%*!0*+, !0!63%" %'/. 1*!%'"% .!4 7##' %' $'"%'))&1&&#&&%'*!'46#!&)0%'/ -!'!*&7#!0%'/0#$"':@, -%**!',A,#'"#0#4!"-.#8!"'A@A, -.!"'%'::!'4*!'4

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

%'"%&##'4!'"%&$*!%6%'/"7#8'#0 ".#*!'4'".#7!&%&".#/%"4##4!**#/#4*+#?#$)"#47+$.!0+! !*E0%&.!'.%&.+!8!6%.!'-#0#;%'.%&!;)0'".#7!&%& ".#18#0!""0'#+4!"#4 1)010"#4".!;#7##'&$0%7#47+ '# !6!'&!* %"4##48!&!')**!'4;%44$)6#'"!&".# $'"#'"&".#18#0!""0'#+,0##00#4%'".#/%"4##4,0#;#!*".!" ;%4# 18#0 !""0'#+, 4##'4!'" .%6&#* 8!& !11%'"#4 !& !""0'#+ 7+ 4##'4!'" & !'4 : !'4 ".# 0%/%'!* 8'#0&, %#, 4##'4!'"&!'4:4%4'"$6#08!04.#18#0!""0'#+4%4 '"#618#0".#!/#'""#?#$)"#".#/%"4##4'!$",".#&)6!'

0 &)7&"!'$#".#/%"4##4%&'".%'/7)"!&!*#4##4!'4,".#0#0#,10#= #61"0+ 0%/." 8!& &)/." ". ".# )0"& 7#*8 .!;# $66%""#4 %**#/!*%"+!'41#0;#0&%"+%'4%&6%&&%'/".#&)%".#/%"4##44#&'" 10#&$0%7#.!'4%'/;#0".#1&&#&&%'!'4,".)&,".#0#%&'/%"4##4 %'".##+#&*!8!'4%'".%&0#/!04,0#*%#4)1'".#3)4/6#'"0#'4#0#4 7+".%&)0"%'123455-2 3

62,0/

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

".#/%"4##4%&'"1#06%&&%7*#"%&'*+8%".0#/!04"".#&!*#4##4 .#0!*#;%4#'$#8%".0#/!04"".#1!+6#'"0#'"%&'"&)%$%#'"' !$",".#1*!%'"%&.!;#6%&#0!7*+!%*#4"10;#".#1!+6#'"0#'", ".)&,".#0#8!&'0#*!"%'&.%1*!'4*04!'4"#'!'"!'4,".#0#0#, >)#&"%'$*!%6%'/10#=#61"0+0%/."4%4'"!0%&# 0#=#61"0+0%/."

%&'*+/%;#'8.#0#".#0#%&&!*#4##4,7)"".#%'&"!'"$!&#%&!$!&#/%" 4##4.#4'0!'4".#4'##.!4'"$6#08!04%'$.!**#'/%'/".# /%"4##4!'4,".#0#0#,".#1*!%'"%&.!;#'*$)&&"!'4%"$.!**#'/# ".# /%"4##4,".)&,0!"%4#$%4#'4%$)**#4)"%' 123#5 5 5 8)*4'"7#!11*%$!7*#"".#!$"&!'4$%0$)6&"!'$#&".# 10#&#'"$!&#.#)0"7#*8.!4#?!6%'#4!**".#3!6!7!'4%#&0".# +#!0&AA=A ,=!'4= !'406#4!'1%'%'".!"".# !11#**!'"=1*!%'"%&!0#%'1&&#&&%'".#&)%"101#0"+6#'"%'#4%'

!0!C 7 % " %%% ,7)"'"8%".0#/!04"101#0"+6#'"%'#4%'1!0! C 7 %; ".#1*!%'"!'4%'6+;%#8,0%/."*+1!0"*+4#$0##4".#&)%" 8%".0#/!04"%'3)'$"%'0#&"0!%'%'/".#4##'4!'"&064%&1&&#&&%'/ ".#1*!%'"%&06".#*!'46#'"%'#4%'1!0!C 7 % " %%% ".# 1*!%'",#?$#1"%'4)#$)0&#*!8%'$#".#1*!%'"%&.!4!%*#4" 10;#".#"#'!'$+,".#+$)*4'"$*!%6".#4#$*!0!"%'!'4 &)%"0 1&&#&&%''".#7!&%&10#=#61"%'.!&7##'0%/."*+4%&6%&&#4.# $'$)00#'"%'4%'/&!$"&!0#7!&#4)1'!110#$%!"%'0!*!'4

4$)6#'"!0+#;%4#'$#4'"%'"#'4"4%#08%".".#%'4%'/& &)7&"!'"%!*>)#&"%'*!8!0%&#&04#"#06%'!"%'7+".%&)0" 11#!*&"!'4&4%&6%&&#4 '8, *)+%

952 '(-.&