High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/4315/2015dismissed

Amarjit Kaur v. Gurdeep Singh

2015-09-02Mr Justice Rakesh Kumar Garg5 pages

!"# $#%&'&( )

*!+,&"-!.+ //#00!(" 1#+'.' .+$##/&(23 #'/($#(" 4567-

83#"3#+#/+"#+' 7%!0#9'/!/#+'*!:;#!009#$" '##"3#,.$2*#("<

;#+# #++#$""3##/+"#+'+("< 83#"3#+"3#,.$2*#("'3.0$;#+#/+"#$&("3#&2#'"< +#'#("4+-!(9!0:!0=$1%!"# +"3#!//#00!(" 3&'&'!(!//#!0$&+#%"#$;:$# #($!(">!//#00!("!2!&('""3# ,.$2*#(" !($ $#%+## $!"#$ ?

/!''#$ ;: + !+/+##" -!.+= $$&"&(!0&'"+&%".$2#=!0!($3!+1&$#93&%3"3#!//#!0/+# #++#$;:"3# $# #($!("!2!&('""3#,.$2*#("!($$#%+##$!"#$ @ /!''#$;:3+& ##/!A-.*!+3!.$3!+:="3#"3#(0#!+(#$&1&0.$2# #(&+&1&'&( = !0!($3!+9!'$&'*&''#$

+&# !%"' "3#/+#'#("%!'#!+#"3!"$# #($!(";++9#$!

'.* =>5 +*"3#/0!&("&

+3&' !*&0:(##$'!($&(0&#.

"3#+# 3##B#%."#$!/+*&''+:("#!($!+#%#&/"&( !1.+ /0!&("&

"#++#%#&1&(2' =>5&("3#/+#'#(%# "3#9&"(#''#'(

93&%39!''%+&;#$;:$##$9+&"#+ 32/.+3#+#!

"#+"3#$# #($!("

(#&"3#+2!1#!(:&("#+#'"("3#;++9#$'.*!'!2+##$;:3#+(+'3# +#".+(#$"3#0!(!*.("$#'/&"#+#/#!"#$+#C.#'"'*!$#;:"3#/0!&("&

" 3#+#(%#"3&''.&" (("&%#=$# #($!("!//#!+#$ !($ &0#$9+&""#('"!"#*#("

"!A&(2 /+#0&*&(!+: ;,#%"&(' +#2!+$&(2 (( *!&("!&(!;&0&":= 3!1&(2 ( 0%.'5'"!($&D%!.'# !%"&(" &0#"3#'.&"=("%*#""3#%.+"9&"3 %0#!(3!($'D/0!&("&

3!'%(%#!0#$"3#"+.#!($*!"#+&!0 !%"'="3#'.&"&'

;!$ +((,&($#+ (#%#''!+:/!+"&#'.* ==>59!'+#C.&+#$ ;:3#+ +'#($&(23#+'(!;+!$ +*!+;!('-!.+." "3#'!&$ !*.("= $# #($!(" +#".+(#$ '@=>5 " !+;!(' -!.+ !($ (0: ' =>5&'$.# +/!:*#("3#$# #($!("3!$&( !%";##($# +!.$#$ !($$!"#$

3!';##(+#2&'"#+#$!2!&('"!+!*,&"&(23 .* '@=>59!';++9#$;:$# #($!(" +*3!(&(23!($ !**!'"3!"*(#:%.0$;#+#".+(#$"!+;!('-!.+""3#"&*#

!$1!(%#*#(" '.* ==>5!+;!('-!.+2""3.*;&*/+#''&( (;0!(A/!/#+'=93&%3*&23"3!1#;##(*&'.'#$"%+#!"#"3#/+#'#(" "+!('!%"&(&(+$#+"3!+!''"3#$# #($!("!""3#&('"!(%# !+;!('-!.+ (*#+&"'=$# #($!("$#(&#$"3#+!1#+*#("'!($/+!:#$ +$&'*&''!0 "3# '.&" #/0&%!"&( 9!' &0#$ +* "3# /0#!$&(2 "3# /!+"&#'

009&(2&''.#'9#+# +!*#$45

83#"3#+"3#/0!&("&

&'#("&"0#$ ++#%1#+:!'/+!:#$

! " ! # $

3#/!+"&#'3!1#0#$"3#&++#'/#%"&1##1&$#(%#("3#! +#'!&$ &''.#'3#"+&!0.+"!

"#+!//+!&'!0 "3##1&$#(%#1&$#,.$2*#("!($ $#%+##$!"#$ @ =$#%+##$"3#'.&" "3#/0!&("&

+"3#+#%1#+:

=>5!'/+&(%&/!0!*.(" !($ ' >5!'&("#+#'"("3# /+&(%&/!0!*.("%!0%.0!"#$E?F/#+!((.* +*"3#$!"# !$1!(%&(2 "3#*(#:"&00"3# &0&(2"3#'.&"3#/0!&("&

9!'!0'3#0$#("&"0#$" +#%1#+!'.* >5!'/#($#("#0&"#&("#+#'"("3#/+&(%&/!0 !*.(" =>5E?F/#+!((.* +*"3#$!"# !$1!(%&(2"3# *(#:"&00"3# &0&(2"3#'.&"3#/0!&("&

9!' .+"3#+3#0$#("&"0#$" +#%1#+ .".+#&("#+#'"E?F/#+!((.*("3#/+&(%&/!0!*.(" ? ##0&(2!22+&#1#$="3#$# #($!("/+# #++#$&+'"!//#!03# 0#!+(#$$$&"&(!0&'"+&%".$2#=!0!($3!+1&$# ,.$2*#("!($$#%+## $!"#$ ?

$&'*&''#$"3#!//#!0 "3#$# #($!(" @

##0&(2$&''!"&'

&#$9&"3"3#!

+#'!&$,.$2*#("'!($$#%+##'

$!"#$ @ !($ ?

="3#/+#'#("+#2.0!+'#%($!//#!03!'

;##($&+#%"#$;:"3#$# #($!(">!//#00!(" G 3#!//#00!("&(/!+!2+!/3? "3#2+.($' !//#!0=3!'

*#("&(#$"3!" 009&(2'.;'"!("&!0C.#'"&(' 0!93!1#!+&'#(&("3# /+#'#("+#2.0!+'#%($!//#!045

% & '( )

) *

)

! )

)

+ ,,-.

/ 0

% 83#"3#+"3#%.+"';#099#+#,.'"& &#$&($&'%!+$&(2"3# #1&$#(%# /0!&("&

6'9&"(#''#'=93&%3!*/0:/+1#"3!" "3#/+("#!($+#%#&/"&'! +2#$!($ !;+&%!"#$ $%.*#("<

$ 83#"3#+&(1&#9 "3# !%""3!"/0!&("&

>+#'/($#("3!' (";##(!;0#"'39!'" +*93#+#3#3!$"3#*(#:

"/!:"3#$# #($!(">!//#00!("=&"&'/+1#$"3!""3# /+("#!($+#%#&/"3!';##(%+#!"#$&(+$#+".'.+/"3# *(#: $# #($!(">!//#00!("<

# 83#"3#+&(1&#9 "3# !%"'!($%&+%.*'"!(%#' "3# %!'#&(3!($="3#7$.+"';#099#+#,.'"& &#$;: +#0:&(2./("3#%.0!+#1&$#(%# "3#/0!&("&

'=93&%3 &'/+1#$( &0#";# "3#&+&("#+#'"#$9&"(#''#'< ) 3!1#3#!+$0#!+(#$%.('#0 +"3#!//#00!("!($3!1#2(# "3+.23"3#%!'# &0#9&"33#+!;0#!''&'"!(%#

.('#0 +"3#!//#00!("3!''.;*&""#$"3!"/0!&("&

3!' !&0#$ "/+1#"3##B#%."&( /+("#D+#%#&/"!($/!''&(2 %('&$#+!"&( 3#/0!&("&

9!'("3!1&(2!(:*(#:!($9!'("!;0#"!$1!(%#"3# 0!( =>5( !%"=!+;!('-!.+9!'"3#&('"+.*#("&( &0&(2"3# /+#'#("'.&"!2!&('""3#$# #($!(">!//#00!("# #($!("9!'!$1!(%#$"3# 0!( ==>5;:'!&$!+;!('-!.+!($'3#3!'.'#$"3#/0!&("&

.+$##/&(23!'!"0 ( !%"=930# "3#!*.("3!';##(/!&$" !+;!('-!.+!($"3#/+#'#("'.&"&'!(!;.'# "3#/+%#'' "3#.+"

3!1#%('&$#+#$"3#'!&$'.;*&''&(;."$(" &($!(: +%# &("3!"'.;*&''&(

&*&0!+!+2.*#("9!'!$$+#''#$;# +#;"3"3#.+"';#09 ;."$&$(" &($ !1.+3##B#%."&( "3#/+("#!($+#%#&/"9!'$.0:

/+1#$ 3# '"!($ "!A#( ;: "3# $# #($!(" &' (" './/+"#$ ;: !(:

$%.*#("!+:#1&$#(%#+#1#+="3#+#&'/+#'.*/"&(.($#+#%"&(

"3##2"&!;0#('"+.*#("'%"3#+#&'("3&(2("3#+#%+$"3!";"3 "3#.+"';#093!1#*&'+#!$!($*&'&("#+/+#"#$"3##1&$#(%#("3# &0# 3#!2+##*#(""'#003!'(";##(/+$.%#$;:"3#/0!&("&

!($"3!"

!2+##*#("$#'("%+#!"#!(:$.;"&("3##B#%."&( /+("#!($+#%#&/" "''##*'"3!"/0!&("&

9!("'"*!A#'.+#"3!"3&'*(#:&'2"+#%1#+#$

+*"3#$# #($!("!($("3!"!%%.("/+("#=+#%#&/"!($!2+##*#("9#+# #B#%."#$ 3#+# &' ("3&(2 ( "3# +#%+$ "3!" /+("# !($ +#%#&/" !+#

!;+&%!"#$$%.*#("'=3!1#(3#'&"!"&(&(30$&(2"3!"('.;'"!("&!0 C.#'"&( 0!93!'!+&'#(&("3#/+#'#("!//#!0('#C.#("0:="3#!//#!0&' 9&"3."!(:*#+&"!($"3#'!*#'"!($'$&'*&''#$

%/: "3&',.$2*#(";#'#("""3#"+&!0.+" + '"+&%"

%*/0&!(%#