High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/5716/2016dismissed

Ram Parkash & ORS v. Bhagat Ram

2017-02-07Mrs. Justice Manjari Nehru Kaul14 pages

! " #$ % &' (' & ))** (& + && ,' - ( # &)(

$ &( ' ./)( ". (

(' ))** (& ))** (& (& ' . * (' ) &( -* & )) * - &(('0-#( (

) && !* ( * &( ( 1-" 1 * '

2' ! (' )) * - &( (' 0-#( (3

) && !* 4.*1-1 .&"1 * '

"2 &&#&& , *!&( ("('

* &( )&&&&

! 2 ! &) )

# - #( ( &** ( 5 6( ! (' (& . (' )* (

&)( 7& / "/ 8/** "$

' ( - "1 * '

&( (. # & - * & * 9 &: ( &( *('' ( (' )* ( *( (. * . ! & * %'& *& ) # ( 0( &( - (' (&

# * (- (' &( ) ) (! -)! ('&(2 & *&&-'( !(')* (

;' &( 2 & & - #( ( &** ( 5 6( ! $ 2 <# & # $ % &' # $ % &'& * # . (' )* (

;' & * & ( (' &( ) ) (!2 & 6 (& 3* %'& ( ('&"(' (' . & * %'& & &(#! ;'& *2 & - ( 6(

= > 5 5" (' &# & * %'2 & .

!(' ))** ( (" #*!" #$ % &' '&&$ 2 <# (') & 1 ( <# &'%'

# " &(& 1 * '

&& ! &#(2 &# - -('&) !#((' %& (' &() - (' - #((&** ;' ( " 5 5" (' &# & "

"?2 &) ( !(')* (

( ( #$ % &' '&&$ 2 <# 3

5" ('(') (&2('(' #( * &( 6( (' &()* ( (

# = > ( 3

> ;' ( !('& - 2 & *&# (' %& ('&) - (' - #( ;'&6(&2 &*!2(&& !1 ( <# ;

*% (' 3

> (' &# & "?2 & . ! ( # $ % &' '& & $ 2 <#

# (' )* (

(# 6( & * 2 & 6(

# 3

> ( 3 && !( !('& - 2 &# (' %& ('3 ) - (' - #(" 2'' 2 & - 2(&& ! 1 ( <# ;

*% (' @('&# " &3

> ( #$ % &' '&& $ 2 <# ' .& >""?

#(')* (

( ('(( * & *& ( & 3* %'& ;' ( "(')* (

) (' &# & ="? ( . & # $ % &' $ 2 <# (#

6( & *2 &6(

#3 ( 5 ;'& 6(& 2 & # (' ) & < )* * " ;

*% (' 1 ( <# "('2(&&& 72. " 5 " ))** ( ( #$ % &' '&&$ 2 <# ' :&((')* (

( 6(('&()* ( (

# 5 ( 5 " ((' ))** ( ( ) && ( &( (& (=" #*!" $ 2 <# &(&-(' *. (( !(' %& ('& - #((&** @(&(' & ('

(' ('' & *2 !&

! 2**-()

#'&) ( (' - #( -'(

#(' ( 6( (' - #((** *- ('&( ,(" ( (*!"$ 2 <# & ))** ( ( #$ % &'6) (

:&((')* (

()&()('6( ('& * & (' (' '&&"(2''(')* (

- ;' ( ".( ( 3

" (' (& 2 :&( ( ' -&(

3 (') )& 6( ('& * . )* (

)( * & * & ( ,( (' ))** (& (&(# (6(('& * . (' )* (

, ('&()* ( (" (' )* (

' * ! -( ) ) ) ! &

# $0 ( * , % 2 (' & * %'& - = >=(= > & * %'& '"& &(' . ('& #((' (& ( * & *& ( (('(# 6( & * ;'

2 ( (' (& (' -&(

" 1 * '

*- 2(' (' ) ! & &'

(' #&** &6)&&" ((' (&(( )(6( (' & * ;' )* (

#. ))* ( -&(

" 1 * '

-((- '& ) & # %" ( -&(

& ( ))'&&- ( &('- (' ((' &&'* 2 ;')* (

' & ! 2**-()

#'&) ( (' - #(

#(' ( 6( (' - #( (** ( ,( 3 " (' (& ( ( ) -&(

" 1 * '

6( ('& * 7"('&( ;' (& )) (&( (' &( ! *- ##2 ((&( (#(( %-) *# ! 0(& *#( (" & ("&())* *- &((' && -

( - #( 72. " # (&" 2 &') (' &( ) ) (! (' (& 6( (' - #((&** ('& * '& &)(2 & #(( @(2 & *& #(((' ($ 2 <# ' &6) "

( ( & &( ( (' ( $ 2 <# '& (' 2 *2 !& ! 2**- ( )

# (' ) ( ( ( ( .- (' * & * & ( & 3 * %'& @ (" (' *- * ( -( && ! (' )* (

-''&&*2 &2(' - ((') ) (! - &( ( (' 4' - " 1 * '

**- ( ' . 6( ! #$ % &' $ 2 <# . (')* (

;' & *- *(2 &*! )* !(' (&('

-'(' &* (' ))** (& (&' .. - (&**(''& - &( (4' - "1 * '

"(' 2 & & ( ('#( '('

-&(

"1 * '

3 @ ("

(** (' &( &%(' (& -((-(' & *6('& . - -('&() ) (! ( ) !-('

* & *& ( & 3* %'& (' && )* -& (') (&" **2-&&&2

# !* ( *4 ( B'(' )* (

& ((* )&&&& ! 2 ! &) )

- #( ( &** ( 5C$$

B'(' )* (

& ! 2**-()

#'&) ( ( (C$$ 3 B'(' )* (

& ((* ) # ( 0( & ) ! C$$ = B'(' (' *( (. (' )* (

& ((*

. ! & * %'& & **-(')* (C$$

B'(' **- - #((&**& -

( C$ * (' && . & * ! (' (' ) (&" (' ( * 4 (.0-#( (3

('&( . ('

'2 &'*((*((')&&&& &( ) ) (! ! 2 ! &) )

# (' - #( ( &** ( 5 ;' ))** (& (& 2 &(

# * (- (' &() ) (! ;' *. ( & . (& * ( *4 ( & D !!"! " " ! #!!"!!!"

! " ! !""!$ $%$ " " & !&!!

! '

(#!!! )

! $ ! " ! !*!"

$ "!

&! !

+,)- . !

& !! "! !!&!!

! !""!$ & /# / "!&$0 "

!!!&!!! ! &! !

% $

& ! "! & /! ! #%! !& )

! !&!!

&! )!%!& !

! !"!1!"!! !!!!% #! !! ! )!!& &!!

!& !%#!%!!!!&!!

#! "

! ! ! !% !

& !! ! "

! $%

!" &"! !&!#! ! %$ $ %

! " & ! "! &! ! ! !

/0 # &! !%

!& ! !"!#! !$ !&! !

2 ! ! !1!! ""! !! ! "! /!&$!! !&

$ ! ! ! &! !

# ! & &!! $ ! ! 0 )! 2 ! ! % ! %! ! !& )

! ! )!%!!& !

! !"! 2 !!& !"! !!

/!! #!/!!!&$ & !! / ! ! "

/1! !)!#! ! $! !!"

#!&!!

)!!! )&! ! #%

$ &!! !

! &! )! !& )

! ! 1 ! !

)"& ! !!

#! !$ ! &! ! !!

$ 3 ! !&# ! " 2 ! ! "

)&!# ! ! )" $ &!! !! ! &! %$ %!! " ! & !&5 ! !"! !

! " ! ! "

%# ! "

!& ! ! !&3 3 ! ! !!

! !!!"

!& ! 2 )

! #! $ %

!" &"! ! ! !! ! !& & ! /

! %! !!! !)!! %!

!!!!

"1! "! !!!!"

!!"

!!! $%

!" &"! &! $!!

!$%#! !!!!!

! ! %

! ! ""!# % 2 / " " & 0 3 ! ! !

! ! !!! !

$" !"

#! " &! ! "

! !

! !! %$ $ %

! " & "! ! &! &!! )

! &!!

! !

!!!%

%$&$ %

" $# $ ! !!! ! /

! !"

! $

)

! %

!&!!"

! $%

!" &"! ! ! !1! "!! ! ! !! "

)& %! & !

( /" ! ! / # % & !!!!! & !#! !"" !! !!! !& )

! ! 0 ! & !

!! ""!!

& !"

! #%

! ! $%

!" & "! ! ! &/ ! "$&! !

!0 # &!! #!

!!!"

" ! %

! " & "! ! &!0&!,)- "# "! "! & ! $! ! )! !& ! " ! # ! & ! !$ ! ! ! )

! !

"!&1

$ ! "

! ! ! 0 "

! ! ! ! ! & ! ! ""!$ ! " $ !"

"!!

&!!! !""!$ ! ! )

!# ! "

! ! "&! 3 ! "$ 1 ! !"

!! !1 "!! !! $ !!!

&! !"

!" " & "#! !!"

0 ! !"!&!!

2 ! ! !

$ !! !E -- . - &((' & 0-#( ) && ! (' ( * 4 (" (' ))** (& (& * )) * (' *2 ))** ( 4 (" ( (' & # 2 & *& &#&& ! * ( *

6 &( (1-"1 * '

.0-#( (

@( & (' & #&( &" (' ))** (& (& ' . *(') &( -* & )) * ;' ))** (& (& ' . #* ( (' **2- & &( ( *:&(& * 2 B'(' ('

' & * ( &( '&2*-&() .'& &C

B'(' (' - ('('* 4 (& *2 (' (& #&( & (') &( &" (( **! ) . &

& ) ) &#)(& #&( ) ( (C B'(' (' -& ('F &())** (4 (&

&*( (( * #& - - - (' .

(" ('&* *( &( &C B'(' ( 2 & # ( (' F &( ))** ( 4 (( **2(') )*&&'

( (') * (">3C B'(' ('&( &) )

# # *! &(&* 2 *(&C

B'(' ( & # ( ) (' F &( ))** ( 4 ( -('&( &) )

# " ( ( # (' -&& &#( ( & (' ( **- &#( 2 & (&'

2(' #!&( !C F &* (' ))** (& (&' & -(' ( 2'*) &&-('#)-0-#(& &"('( *4 ( &2** & ('*2 ))** (4 (' .- ('# ( *. . * *

@(&('# ( * 2(' ( ) & )) '-('4 (#&(( *! . (' ( ' ' ! 2**- ( )

# '& ) ( (' ( (" ((' #&(

(' &) # ((('

((' ( ('& ) &(&( ! 2**-()

#'&) ( ('

( ( &) #&& ('

"('&()* ( ( 6( & * " ' 2 & ( )&&&& &

( #( ;' ' &. &

( #((' ( )* (

*- '#( ! 2**-()

#'&) ( ('( ( 7' &

(' -(' ($B ;

*% ('2 & 2 ( (' # &( #) ) ) & (*8 (' - #( ( &** & *& (' # ) &&2'& #&' #(('& # @('& # "'' &&'2(( *- (('((& (' - #(( &** 7' & #(((' ('& *

(')* (

;' "' 2 & ( &( 2(&& (' ( * 4 ( 2 & ( & ('& 2(&& 7 ' &

(' ( (' ( .2 ( (' ) * (" >3" ( & # ( ! (' ) ( (' &)( )* (

() .'& && 2**-&&(-((' &) )

# (' &( ) ) (! ) && '& . @ (' & &) . #((' ((')* (

& ! 2**-()

#'&) ( (' - #("('&(2 &* *( &#&& 7' &

(' -(' ( .('&(' & * ( G! ('&& **-( 2' &(' : #( && 2**-&&' &( (& @' .' * &* (' ))** (& (& ) &(' ;' & (- - ( ('('4 (& *2(' ( (' - #( :&( 2 & 6( 5 2(' #( * &( (') (&"(' & 6(

#(#((# ;'6(&

' & *!&- !2(&&& ;' & -#( &)( ! * &* (' ))** (& (&&(' (('

' & *(&( *&'(' ('2 & ! 2**-()

#'&) ( (' - #( @ (' &

! " #$% &'()*+, *-", ..)" (' ( # D && 2**-&&E ' & & !7A * '! $ &'7-'4 ( B'* *!-)

/ $ *&'((, ( )&+" 7A * '! $ &' 7-' 4 ( ' & & . (' ( (' 2 & D !E D2**-E #)*!(' ((') &2 &) ) (

!(('( #& ('( ( ;' *! &(( (2 D &&E D2**-&&E & (' ( ('

# & ( * ) (! (' * (( ( (' ( (' )* (

2 (- )

# / **!" && & % ! 2**-&& @0 $ 1

$"$ &'') 22*3,(45" 7A *) #4 (' &'*(' ( &( &) )

# ( ("(')* (

#&(&( *&''& && 2**-&&()

# '&) ( ( ( ;':&( &(2'(' ('&2 &&'

- ! (')* (

(2** *2 !&)) (& #&( & ' & &( (0 %( #* * 2('& ' * ;' && 2**-&&(') ( (')* (

()

#'&) ( ( ( 2* *& ) ) (' :&( & ( 2'(' (' ( . !('-2''2 & : ( ( #& (' - #((& * ;' "('( #D &&E D2**-&&E' &( ( #

('( (! (& #&( & *. ((('(( ( (') (! . " 6 7

2 &'(5*8, *-",(.&" 2'* *!- )(' 0-#(& (')6 4 ( !// "-// "&''(*),*-",5&8 $$" % $% -

9 % $% &''8*),*-",."(' &

'* ! ('& 4 ( (' ( && 2**-&& (' )* (

( )

#'&) ( ('( (&( :&( * 2" (& :&(

( ;' " ))*!-(' & 0-#( & -('

( (' ( ('

' )) (' -&(

" 1 * '

3 ( -( (' & * 6(

-&( " ( (' ))** (& (& ( # ) &( ('

*. ( ("(&&

(*!&( *&'(' (('

2 &

! 2**-()

#'&) ( (' - #( (-(('& * 6( -&( ;'&4 (' &) &('#(H6 B ?2''&(' &( (#( ( ('

;'& #(&'2& (' ((')* (

' & &( ( * #('& ( -)! (' - #() *-('6() ;' &&)( (' ((' - #((&**2 &6( 5 (' &)( )* (

' & * (' ) &( &( &) )

# (' & - #( 3 ))** ( ( # $ % &' ' & #(( '&&- ( & ' . !) - ('& - #((&** (

5H6 $ ;'(( (' ))** (& (&(' ((&('

2' 2 & ( ' .- (' # - & ( #( **- &#(& - - 6(& &()* ( ( 2 # ( . * *(! & ( *. )( 2' &#( ( 5 5 H6 $ &#( (

5 5 H6 $3" (' &()* ( ( = > * ! 6 . - #( ( &** ( 5 2 & ( 6( &)( # %- ) !#( ( * #( & * %' & "

"? &)(.*!( (' ))** (& (& ! ('

;' " ('

-#()( !* &* (' ))** (& (&(' ( (' & 2 ( . * * 2(' ('

( -( (' & * 6('& . &) (' - #((&** ( 5" ( )( ;' * &( &#( 2 & # . H6 $ 2' ! (' & * 2 & - ( 6( -&( )( 5 ;')* (

' .&(('

-&(

"1 * '

3 (' (

6 !'# 6( -&( ( & *'& . . ( ( 3

H6 $5 *- 2(' * & * & ( & * %'& (' &' ) #

(& & * %'& ' H6 $B3?, ( H6 $B3?H &) . ! $B3 < "

$0 ( *, %"4 *

"7&' ) 2''& )) (

.( H6 $ ;'&"('

' & *(') &(&(3 2'' & 2** 2(' (' ) *#( (

# (' &()* ( ( 5

,('('4 (& *2' .

( -& *( ('#)-0-#(& &) && !(' 4 (& *2 & &( ( * :&( * 2 & .*. (' ) &(

-* & )) * ;' " (' #)- 0-#(& & ) && !('4 (& *2 )'* (') &( -* & )) * &&#&&

" I -(( B'(' &) %-?

& I& B'(' ) ( *