← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/4317/2015dismissed

Surja Deceased Th Lrs Sube Singh Through His Lrs. Kamla And ORS v. Lakhmi Deceased Th Lrs Ashok Kumar And ORS

2017-09-18Mr. Justice T.H.B. Chalapathi16 pages

     

 ! "!#$%$&' ()



*+,- ./0*"!#!%!"- 1/.213%&" 1!/% 44!55& % 6% 3718$*"!#!%!"- 1/.213%&" 1!/% !%4&"!& %

 9 9 *+,- ./0*"!#!%!"- 1/.213%&" 1!/% 44!55& % 6% 3718$*"!#!%!"- 1/.213%&" 1!/% !%4&"!& % ,' :

3,,;,3<  

 

  ,;,3<=*3-

       

     

                   

    

     !



          

 $% &' '$&&  ( )  ( * + %

    

               &, $- '$&.

     /  #        * 1-&% '$&.

! 34   50  6 57  34   50  9       '

      

! 3

   504  :   57  3

  504    * &:  * & 

  * + 6!#  * %   * '

7    * ;$'-  '% $- '$$+ 



0 < =    * &     * '

   -$ > &             ) 

         #

   #

        !

       #    #

  



#

      % 7 &&      '+ $' &,%.





! 3 4    

   



 3  * '

+4   0 .$$$:( 0 &-$$$:(

  #

  

  3 4    * &     0 .$$$:( 

! 0 &'$$$:(    0 &-$$$:( 

 3 4   0 &$$$:(

 

     =            '+ $' &,%.

/   

    

   

!

  

      

     #  * 11 $- &$ '$$&

>   $' $' '$$'

  * &    * '

 =    '% $- '$$+  

>

>  

 ?

* .;1  $1 && '$$+

        

   

      * '

 

 )    #     

 

   

        '& $, '$$+

    7

 =    

  * 11 $- &$ '$$&      * &

   

 

 <  <

           57 

 #

      * ;$'-  '% $- '$$+ ) 

  #    



 

 * + %  

 !

        # !        

 * '

  

     7  * + %

      * + %    (

 7  #   

! ((    

  

 #  (

@            ( & A  * &          % 7 &&     7  * .-. 7 * ++,  * '1 7 * &+ 3%(&&4  * '

+          ''

7 &$    7 * +%$ 0 * '. 7 * &&:'

31(&;4 '$ 3;($4 0 * 1- 7 * -:'

31(%4 ;:& 31( &'4 7 * ++; 7 * -'.

3$(&$4 1'- 3$(-4    -$ 7 $&       0 

 B @ '

A    '% $- '$$+ =    * &     * '

) 

                B @ - A      !

  

 B @ A     

 B @

.

A           B @

+ A    B @

% A    (!

 B @

;

0

     7         #

                         

   

  * + %  #    (      #    !

  

   (   * + %

              $% &' '$&&

?       * + %   (! ?   

  

 < 

 ( !  '      * + %

  #      (    * + %       #   ?  &;%$          &, $- '$&.

/  

9      

   /   

 

    

!        '+ $' &,%.



 

 

((    * & .

        '+ $' &,%.

       

  

      =      '+ $' &,%.

     

!(  

          '+ $' &,%. 

!   # 

#      

           

   # 7    #

!         

      # #           

       



     "

* 11 $- &$ '$$&

   

  57 ( * &

   

    

 #  

>   $' $' '$$'

?   =     '% $- '$$+         ?

* .;1  $1 && '$$+   

      '% $- '$$+

    

  "

* 11 $- &$ '$$&

 7   # !      



 @ '

 '

""

                   #      

7    ?

* .;1  $1 && '$$+ /           * ;$'-  '% $- '$$+ =         

#      (     

 #  (        * + %

#  

#                

      

   

#    

 

7   /      #      # #           

   

   #  #  =         @    7      #   #        '+ $' &,%.

   

     #

 #    7 

(           * ;$'-  '% $- '$$+ C 

      #    

     

            

  

 9       

 <  # =      

     

        &1      

    

 (

           

       

      

          



       

       

     !"#$"     

$ %$!$$%    $&$!!$$'  

(

) *    

+, - . /,       01.2%3        

   

      

    

 



.   01.2!

 

                 +   

4%#!$$'* 

   %%$5!$$5

.

 , ,  

 01."6     

         

)

       

 -01 2%/

  

 



          

 %  

   !&$!%54"   



 %!$5!$$501.2     01.27 8    

       3   

  





 !"#$"   

     

  !"5#$"  

 

  

               

 

 6   

 

  

        

 % 1      '$!  !4$ !$$&      

 !

!%$5!$$&  

  

    



! 

           6  

     * 

 

 01.2"    

 !  



 !!    %$  ++  

 

      

 9  *         

  

 2

        3      

   

'$!  !4$ !$$&       0

 

     * 

         

 *    1    

 %   



  

     

        

      

 

     !&$!%54"6 

1   

 



        

               

3 

  !&$!%54"     

    

    

       

  

      

  

    

     

  !&$!%54"    

1          

 3      

  !&$!%54"

           

3   

  !*         '$!  !4$ !$$&*   

    

 

 

      



       8 



 



     

      

 

                  *    :      ;



  :    

 





    

       3 

1 

             1  3 



 

   

    

 ! 

      

   

  

   

       

 

  

  

 %3    

      

        3 

  



       

  !&$!%54"       

   1     

$&$4%54%                             

  

9   



      

    

      !4$ !$$&     

   

  <

    !0$&216%8 /7%15>/*"!#!%!"?@3%-&" 1!/%= )(.&0?&"

/@&) 

               /       

 

       

   

        =      # #     



            7

   /D

  "8.%.&"/&"& 1!/6%   ! 8$5".&" 1!/%=   * - =&$& &"$6% 8/$ 35,&#1&"&" 1!/%= * - =  ! /$%%6% ,"55$@%= 9* -

  ! 0% 1&6%&!%1$35= (

* -

A  

   7 #   /E

   && &'

    &!%1$35E  3 4    

7 8/$ 35,&#1&"E  3 4 ,1"55$@%E  3 4

   #     

(

%%  %!=;             

 

               8     

    0 

 

   6       

   ,    

 



    

3   

 , >    



                

   

       8 

   2

      

*    

     ?-/ 



 *  

8

 

   

   ,        *          ?  -/  

                ? -/ 

         8           @

               

                        

3      

   A    +

   

  

  

- B C     (  C -86;%5&'+&74/ D 6  . 

.  C -%55&-&/++77/8    

  

    1       3   ,    

         8  

6 E

  -%5$%/ 8+75"-9 /*0 9  +       

              

        

     *    

    1      

    1    

 A   

      1       

        +

    

    

         

  *      

    

 

8  *            

   

*  

 

 3    

    

 

8  

  

      

          

 

8    

      0  C   (6*-!$$&/%++!4" !'!* %! %!%"=+

         



          

           C 

 +

   0>                  

 3         

         ,

+

  

  3



 *      *           



     

 1  

      ,   



  *        





3 



  ?      



 6  ) 

.+

  9

-%5"%8+4 4 4&%/* (.

   B-866 0;%7+2./ F3 



*  * 

  

 

@ *,    

  8     

    

     



  

3  



          

       

   F %&6 9 C . G +-%54$-!/80;!57/ ; - 80;!54 2/*F 8 >  

    6  A A

   F(

*,   9 

   -!/-%54%/%@ ;%$&!  B-8660;%!472 /FC  *  *

      

 ;  ,   8  

F8 * 9

 H ;H -%54!-!/@ ;" 4/ (

B -8660;4&%/ F3  

   



                    



*                  

    

   



 F %4+ 

 1 *   

    

       .  

     

   %"3 

  .

  



  

   B-8:+63* 86;%5&!+&'$ F0                       

  



      

 

   *  

 

 *        -+ I/ 

         3    *      *     

      F F  

           *      

                          

9     (                          

    0 D 6   8 (  *-!$$7/ ++4"*' 2'7* %"2%'F

           #  #  #       /      # )   

   )   

   )           

 =   



 &$$ " "  

     

  /D

  /@&&0!&"/&&"& 1!/6%3!7%18@/0$&$&" 1!/%= ) *- 9 *   

 "          

       

      

#   

 # 

 *       0 #

              

     A,;,3<B &; $, '$&%    A 7: F:* A  F:*