High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1650/2014dismissed

Lila Etc v. Rajo Devi Etc

2015-12-10Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan4 pages

"#$%$&'(')* +',"")%")#-$.

//$,,")#( 0$.(1( "2$3'")%#-$.( $(/)%$)#(

* 4+ 5 + .$($)#*6 ."2')%$. 7",8%3&"#$8.#-$"//$,,")#( 9-$#-$.#-$$/.#$.(,&",)$:(/"/$.;"7<$",,:$%#($$ #-$21%=;$)#>

<$.$$..$%##-$$/.#$..)# ? 9-$#-$.#-$21%=;$)#(-1,%<$.$/.#$%')#-$%'=$(#> 66 66 + 8

;/1=)$%')#-$/.$($)#.$=1,".($&)%"//$",'(#-$ 21%=;$)#")%%$&.$$%"#$%? ?8/"(($%<7#-$%%'#')", '(#.'&# 1%=$8 5"'#-",8"'.;')=#-$21%=;$)#")%%$&.$$ %"#$%

8 /"(($% <7 #-$ ,$".)$% '3', 1%=$ 1)'. '3'(')!8 5"'#-",83'%$:-'&-#-$(1'##-$/,"')#'( .$(/)%$)#(-$.$')!.

/(($((') :"( %$&.$$% ")% #-$ %$$)%")#( "//$,,")#( -$.$')!

:$.$%'.$&#$%#3"&"#$#-$(1'#,")%8%$#"',$%')#-$/"."=."/- #-$/,"')#")%-")%3$.#-$3"&")#/(($((')#-$(1'#,")%# #-$/,"')#'(.$(/)%$)#(:'#-'))$;)#-#-$.%$.8"',')=:-'&-

#-$/,"')#'(.$(/)%$)#(:',,<$"#,'<$.#7#=$##-$/(($((')<7 :"7$@$&1#') 1'&$#("7#-"##-$/,"')#'(.$(/)%$)#(-"%',$%#-$ (1'# &,"';')= #-"# #-$7 ".$ :)$.( #-$ (1'# ,")% ")% #-$ %$$)%")#("//$,,")#( ".$ ') 1)"1#-.'A$% /(($((') -$ %$$)%")#("//$,,")#(8)#-$#-$.-")%8&)#$(#$%#-$(1'#)#-$ =.1)%#-"##-$7".$')"%3$.($/(($((')#-$(1'#,")% #",(&;$(1##-"#$".,'$.#-$/,"')#'(.$(/)%$)#( -"% ',$% " (1'# . /$.;")$)# ')21)&#') "="')(# #-$ %$$)%")#("//$,,")#(')#-$ 1.##-$,$".)$% '3',1%=$ 1)'.

'3'(')!85"'#-",8'):-'&-(#"#1(B1.%$.:"(/"(($%:$3$.8 %1.')=#-$/$)%$)&7#-"#(1'#8#-$/.$($)#(1'#./(($(('):"( ',$%8&,"';')=#-"#%1.')=#-$/$)%$)&7#-$/.$3'1((1'#8#-$7 -"3$<$$)%'(6/(($(($% -$%$$)%")#("//$,,")#(",(#C#-$/,$"#-"##-$ (1'#'(<"..$%1)%$. ")%1)%$. ?1,$

%$ '3',.&$%1.$8D ')(-.#4 4! -$,:$."//$,,"#$ 1.#"'.;$%#-$')%')=#-"##-$ /,"')#'(.$(/)%$)#(".$/.3$%#<$:)$.(#-$(1'#,")%-$ "%3$.($ /(($((') #-$ %$$)%")#("//$,,")#( '( )# /.3$% $=".%')=#-$/,$"(1'#<$')=<"..$%1)%$. 8'# :"(-$,%#-"##-$/.$($)#(1'#:"(',$%%1.')=#-$/$)%$)&7#-$ /.$3'1((1'#-$.$.$8#-$.$'()B1$(#')',')=#-$(1'#"#$.

6?6 <#"')')=#-$/$.;'((')#',$".$(-)$ #:"(-$,%#-"##-$ /.$($)#(1'#./(($((')'(<"($%)%'$.$)#&"1($"&#') -$.$.$8'#'()#<"..$%1)%$. -$'.(# "//$,,"#$ 1.#",(#C#-$3'$:#-"##-$(1'#'()#<"..$%1)%$.

")% ?1,$ -"3$-$".%#-$,$".)$%&1)($,.#-$"//$,,")#(")% -"3$",(&".$1,,7=)$#-.1=-#-$',$ $.$#-'( 1.#8#-$;"')&)#$)#')#-$,$".)$% &1)($, . #-$ %$$)%")#("//$,,")#( '( #-"# #-$ /.$($)# (1'# '( <"..$%1)%$. ")%",(<"..$%1)%$. ?

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

.1)%$. ?1,$ >

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

.1)%$. ?1,$ :',,)#<$"##."&#$% -$(1'#.#'#,$&"))#<$",,:$%#<$%$$"#$%.#-$($#$&-)'&", .$"()( -$.$".$&)&1..$)#')%')=(#: 1.#(<$,:")% #-$.$'()=.1)%#')#$.$.$')(1&-')%')=(.$&.%$%<7#:

1.#( <$,: $)&$8 #-$ /.$($)# .$=1,". ($&)% "//$", '( %'(;'(($%

+ !

(2C(