High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/1024/2022disposed of

Harbhajan Singh Since Deceased Through His Lrs Ajay Bawa And Others v. State Of Punjab And Others

2026-03-30Mr. Justice Harkesh Manuja7 pages

- %$"-/ %$"-/ %$"-/ %$"-/ :< :< :< :<-/ -/ -/ -/<:<< <:<< <:<< <:<< E E E E ".( (-# ".( (-# ".( (-# ".( (-# 9:

9::9 :9 :9 :9<:< <:< <:< <:<C

''"00%#$

''"00%#$ '-#&"#$ '-#&"#$ '-#&"#$ '-#&"#$

"#$

/-!

/-! %#3"",*%!8%+!&,-.%$" %#&""'(#)*+&,-.%$" 2($* $*"%''"00%#$ 1!1%!"2%0++ 1#3%4 %34(!(#)*+&,-.%$" !"

'-#&"#$- B$-A DDDD + !%0 + !%0 + !%0 + !%0 56 7 2%7 -/ '!"

"#$ %''"%0+ .*%00"# #)" *% 4""# 0%(& $- $*" 31&)8 8"#$ &%$"& 9:;<:< < '%

"& 47 $*" 0"%!#"& &&0 ( $!(.$ 1&)"+ %!# %!

!%#+ *"!"(#%/$"! $-4 4" !"/"!!"&% $*" = "/"!"#." -1!$F+ 2*"!"47 !"/"!"#." '"$($ $(-# '!"/"!!"&%$$*" (# $%#."-/%''"00%#$ >0%#&-2# #"! *%,(#)(#,-?"&".$(-#9:

:-/ $*"%#&.@1(

($(-#.$+;A/-! *-!$=$*";

;A.$F+2% &( 8(

"& 5<6 !( ("/07 $%$(#)+ -#" %!&18%# # (#)* 2% $*" -2#"! -/ 0% %#& 8"% 1!(#) ;B< %#%0 ; /-!8(#) '%!

!$ -/ $*" !","#1" "

$%$" -/ ,(00 %)" -(#&2%0+"*

(0%#&( $!(.$%!#%!%# %!& &18%#(#)**%&$2- +#%8"

"07+ %2% 1!81?* * (#)* %#& %2% %*%!%3 (# #)* /$"! $*" &"%$* -/ %!&18 8%# (#)*+$*"%/-!"

"8"#$(-#"&0%#&2% (#*"!($"&4 47*( $2- (#"@1%0 *%!"

(" 9C %#%0 A

"%.* 1!$*"!+%2%1!8 81?*(#)**%&/-1! #%8 8"07 %2% (! (#) )*+ %2% %!4*%3%# (#)*+ %2% 102%#$ (#)* %#& %

-)(#&"!(#)* *1 +$*"/-1! -/%2%1 1!81?*(#)*(#*"!($"&:A %# #%0 :< %''!

!-G0%#&"%.* #$*"-$*"!*% %#&+%2% %*%!%3(#)**%&- -#07 -#" -#+#%8"07 7+%2% %#&*(!(#)**"'"& ()!""$%40"2*(.*( !"0",%#$/-! %&31&(.%$(-#-/$ $*".% "(#*%#&( "G$!%.$"&*"!"

"1#&"!

H S. Parduman Sin ngh _____________________ _______________ Bawa Gu urmukh Singh Bawa Maharaj Singh _____________ _________________________ Bawa Bir Bawa H Singh Sin Harbhajan Bawa Kulwant Bawa Y Yoginder Randhir Singh gh gh Singh Sing 596 %$ $"!+,(&"#-$(/(.%$(-#&%$"&:C CA;;(

1"&1#&"!".$(-#-/ $*";A.$+9 9B %#%0 -/0%#&- -1$-/$*"%/-!"

%(&;B< %#%0

;

-/0%#& -!()(#%007-2#"&47 %!&18 8%#(#)*/-!8(#)'%!$-/!","# #1" $%$"-/,(00%)"

"-(#&2%0+"* (0%#&( $!(.$ %!#%!%#+2% %.@1(!"&/-00-2 2"& 47%#%2%!&&%$ $"&:B<A;A'%

"&47$*"% %#&.@1( ($(-#-00".$-!/-! * *-!$ =$*"F*"

")!-1 "-/$*"%''"00%#$ $*%$+%2%%!4*%3%#(#)*+4"

"(#) " "G$"#$ -/ >;$* *%!" -/ $-$%0 %# -2#"! $- $* 0 %.@1(!"& 0%#& -/ 9B %#%0

+2% "#$( ($0"&/-!'!-'-!$(-#%$".-8'-#"# #$-/$*".-8'"# %$(-#%2%!&"& 56 (# #." $*" '!"&"."

-!H(#H(#$"!"

$ - -/ $*" %''"00%#$ 2% #","! '

'%(& %#7.-8'"# %$(- -#(#$"!8 -/-!()(#%0%2%!&&% %$"&:B<A;A'%

"&47$*" +

4"(#)%))!(","& &+*" -1)*$!"/"!"#."1#&"!".

.$(-#9:-/$*";A.$2*(.*2 2% /-!2%!&"&$-$* *"0"%!#"& "/"!"#."-1!$+2* *"!"(#$*"'!(,%$"!"

'-#&"#$ /( (0"& %''0(.%$(-#/-!( ($ &( 8(

%02*(0" $%$(#)$*%$ %2%%!4*%3%#(#)**%&%0!"% %&7

-0&8-!"$*%#* *( *%!"(#$*"3-(#$*-0&(#) % %#&$*1 +2% #-$"#$($0"&/-!%2 2%!& -/ .-8'"# %$(-# # # $*" %(& %''0(.%$(-# 8-, ,"& %$ $*" (# $%#." -/ $*" '!(, ,%$" !"

'-#&"#$ +$*"

"0"%!#"& "/"!"#."-1!$,(&"- -!&"!&%$"&9:;<:<!"3".$"& .0%(88%&"47$ $*"%''"00%#$ ))!(","&$*"!

"-/+$*"'!"

"#$%''"%02% /(0"& &%$ $*"(# $%#."-/% %''"00%#$ 56 8'

'1)#(#) $*" %/-!"

%(& -!&"!+ 0"

"%!#"& "#(-! .-1# "0 !"'!"

"#$ $(#) $*"%''"00%#$

148($ $*%$% '"!$*"2%!&'

"&47$*"-#:B<A A;A+ $*"'%78"#$2%

$-4"8%&"4% "&-#$*"!".-!

!& -/!()*$ %,%(0%40"%$$*"$(8"

"-/ %.@1( ($(-#("3 3%8%4%#&(/-!$*"7"%!A;BH;; "$*1 + 148($ $*%$-#."+% '"! $*"-!()(#%0!","

"#1"!".-!&(#$*"/-!8-/3%8 8%4%#&(/-!$*"7"%!A;BH;;% %!4*%3%#(#)* *2% !".-!&"&% -#"-/$*".-H

*%!"!+*"2% "#$($0"&/-!%2%!& &-/ .-8'"# %$(-#'!

!-'-!$(-#%$"07$-*( *%!"(#$*"

"3-(#$0%#& 56 "% %!#"& "#(-! .-1# "0 %0 - '-(# #$ -1$ $*%$ $*" %.@1( ($(-# (# '!"

"#$.% "'"!

!$%(#"&$- '".(/(.?*% !%#184 "!

2*(.*2"!"#","!%0("#%$"& &47 %2%%!4*%3%# #(#)*%#&.-# "@1"#$07+*".

.-#$(#1"&$-*-0&*( *%!"$*"!

!"(# %#&2% "#$($0"& &$-!"0"% "-/.-8'"# %$(-#+%..

.-!&(#)07 5<6 "% %!#"& "#(-! .-1# "0 /1!$*"! .- -#$"#& $*%$ $*" !"/"!"#." '"$($ $(-# '!"/"!!"&%$$*"

(# $%#."-/%''"00%#$ +*%,(# #)(#,-?"&".$(-#9:-/$*";

;A .$+.-10&#-$* *%,"4""#&".0(#"&4"(#)4%!!"& 470(8($%$(-#% $*"%''-!$(-#8 8"#$ 2% -1)*$ /-! -#07 %/$"! $*" %''0(.%$(-# 1#& "! ".$(-# <;H -/ $*" ;A .$+ '!"/"!!"&%$$*" (# $%#."-/%''"00%#$ &"

".0(#"&47$*"-#<:<<:

:<: %#& $*"!"%/$"!+ $*" -43".$(-# 1#&"! ".$(-# # 9: -/ $*" .$ 2"!" '!"/"!

!!"&

(88"&(%$"07 -# :<:C<:<: $*% %0 -4""#.

.-#$"#&"&$*%$$*"!"/"!"#."1# #&"! ".$(-# 9: .-1 10& #-$ *%," 4""# !"3".$"& 88%!(07 %#& $*" %''"00%#$ 2 2"!" !"@1(!"&$-4"%/ //-!&"&-''-!$1#($7$-0"%&",(&"

"#."(# 1''-!$-/$*"(!.0%(88 %&" (#$*".0%(8'"$( ($(-#%#&+$*1 $*"(8'1)#"&-!& &"!2% 0(%40"$-4" "$% (&"4"

"(#) ,(-0%$(,"-/'!(# #.('0"

-/#%$1!%031 $(." 5C6

! .-#$!%+ 0"%!#"& .-1# "0 /-! $* *" '!(,%$" !"

'-#&"#$ >0%#&-2# #"!

148($ $*%$$*"

"!"/"!"#." -1)*$47$*"%''"00% %#$ 1#&"!".$(-#9:-/$*";

;A .$ 2% 2*-007 7 8( .-#."(,"&+ % %2% %!4 4*%3%# (#)* *%& %0!"%&7 -0& *(

*%!"8"% 1!(#) ):A %#%0 < -1$-/$* *"3-(#$0%#&8"% 1!(#);B< %# #%0 ; %#&$* *1 +*%&#- ( $(#)!()*$$-.0 0%(8.-8'"# %$(-#(#!"

'".$-/ %.@1(!"&0%#& 5C6 "% %!#"&.-1# "0/1!$*"! 148($ $* *%$-#."/!-8$*"-2#'0"%&(#)

-/ $*"%''"00%#$ + +($2% "

$%40( *"&$*%$*"*%& %0("#%$"&8-!"$*%#*( -2# * *%!" /!-8 $*" 3-(#$ *-0&(#) + $*1 + #- /1!$*"! $!(% %0 2% 2%!!%#$"& 47 $*" 0"%!# #"&

"/"!"#."-1!$ $(#$"!8 -/".$(-#9:-/$*" ;A.$%#&% 1.*+$*"(8'1)# #"& -!&"!.%00"&/-! #-(#$"!/"!"#." 5B6 * *%," *"%!& 0"%!#"& .-1# "0 /-! $*" '%!$("

%#& )-#" $*!-1)* '%'"!4--?% 2 2"00% !".-!& -/$*".% "% %81#%40"$-/(#& $%#."(#

148(

(-# 8%& &"-#4"*%0/-/$*"%''"00%#$ 5;6

!- -8 $*" !".-!&+ ($ ( ",(&"#$ $* *%$ $-$%0 0%#& (# $*" *%#& -/ /

%!&18%#(#)* *2% ;B< %#%0 ; %!0%(#,( (00%)"-(#&2%0+"* (0%#&( $ $!(.$ %!#%!%#( $2- +#%8"07+%2%1!81 1?*(#)*%#&%2% %*%!%3(# #)* (#*"!($"&9C %#%0 :A -/0%#&"%.* %2%1!81?*(#)**%&/-1!

#%8"07%2% (!(#)*+%2%%!4*%3%#(#) )*+%2% 102%#$(#)*%#&% **"

"/-1! (#*"!($"&>$ $* *%!""%.*-1$-/9C %#%0

-)(#&"!(#)*

-# "@ @1"#$07+%2%%!4*%3%#(#)* 2% "#$($0"&$-"G.01 (," *%!"

"-/ :A %#%0 :<

%''!-G$8%74"#- -$(."&*"!"$*%$$*"!"( #-&( '

'1$" !"0%$(#)$-$*"

*%!"%#&"#$($0"8"#$-/%2%

%*%!%3(#)*-!*( -# %#& &*(! (#)*I%#&$*".

.-#$!-,"!

7( .-#/(#"&$-$*""#$ $($0"8"#$-/%2%%!4*%3%#(# #)* ,(JH%H,(J*( $*!

!""4!-$*"!

5A6 # $*" '!"

"#$ .% "+ $*" '!(#.('%0 0 "8'*% ( -/ $*" "#(-! .-1# # "0 !"'!"

"#$(#) $*"

" %''"00%#$ ( -# $*" .-#$"#$ $ -/ $*" 2%!& &%$"& :B<A A;A '%

"&47$*" +% '"!2*(.*$*"'%78"#$- -/.-8'"# %$(-#2% $-4"8%&"

"(# /%,-1!-/$*"0%# #&-2#"!

(#%..-!&%#."2($*$*"

"(!!()*$ %#& *%!"

!".-!&"&(# !".-!& -/!()*$+ +% -#$*"&%$"-/%.@1( ($(-#'!

!-.""&(#) ("% '"!3%8%4%#&( ( /-! $*" 7"%! A;BH ;; #&-14$"&07+ (# $*" 3%8% %4%#&( /-! $*" 7"%! A;BH;;+ '!"&"."

-!H(#H( (#$"!"

$-/$*"%''"00%#$ !

!".-!&"&% -#"-/$*".-H *%!"!

(# $*"3-(#$0%#&*- -0&(#) +(#$"!8 -/81$%$(-##- -<<B&%$"(0+% '"!$*"!","# #1" !".-!& -2", "!+/!-8$*"8%$"!(%0%,%(0%40"- -#!".-!&+($ $--&&107"

$%40( * *"& $*%$ 4"/-!" $*" &%$" -/ '%

(#) -/ $*" %2%!& 4 47 $*" -# :B<A;A+ % %!4*%3%#(#) **%&%0!"%&7%0("#%$"&$*"0%# #&8-!"$*%#*( *%!"(#$*"3- -(#$ *-0&(#) 5:6 *"

"&"$%(0 -//(," %0"&""& "G".

.1$"&47*(8(#%$%410%$"&/-!8 8% '!-,(&"& 47 $*"

" %''"00%#$ *(8 "0/ (# '%!% # #-<A -/ $*( %''"%0 %!" "G$!%.

.$"& *"!"1#&"!

H %0"&""&&%$"& -* %$%"!% A>>> <;H:

BBH :KC C C C &<:9A;; )*%!*%0(2%0" &9::A;B ><<H;+ A><H<+ : 8(# H ;+ <+ A;H %!%(#)* :+ 9BH+ > H+ C>< <H + ;> <H;+ ;><H<+ A C %#%0

C %#%0

C %#%0 %0"&""&&%$"& %4%%!%(#) %0"&""&&%$"& -* %$%%#$ A>>> >BH<+>:HB+B>9H<+A 9 A 9 A 9 A 9

&:;A;A A>>C + :>< C>9HC+ ;H:+ B>:H<+ >< :>>;H:+ <:HC+ :> CH <9H %!&(%0(#)* C+ H+9B 9B 9B 9B H;

;

%0"&""&&%$"& (!%(#)**% %0"&""&&%$"& %!

*%#(#)* &:;A;A %!($%40"!1 $ A>>< <

< &:B:;A;A CH<+A>><CH:-$%0%#&KB *"

" *% !%#- %!"#-$%.@1(!"& B H :>>> A>>> ><BH >9HC-$%0;HB %#&%02(#&"!(#)* 56 *1 + -#." %2% %!4*%3%# (# #)* *%& %0!"%&7 -0& %!-1#& A %#%0 -/0%#&/ /!-8$*"3-(#$0%#&*-0&(#) ","# #4"/-!"'%

(#)-/$*"2%!&&% %$"& :B<A;A47$* *"+*"2% 0"/$2($*#-!() )*$+$($0"-!(#$"!"

$(#$*"!"8%(# #(#) 0%#& % $*" !()* *$ -/ $*" '%!$("

% -# $*" &%$"

" -/ %.@1( ($(-# 2"!" 3-(#$ %#& #- '%!$($(-#*%&$%?

?"#'0%."%8-#)$*".-H *%!"!

+% !"/0".$"&(#$*"3%8%4%#&( /-! $*"7"%!A;CH;

;B($ "0/..-!&(#)07+*%,(#)%0 0("#%$"&8-!"$*%#*( *%!"(# 3-(#$0%#&*-0&(# #)'!(-!$-$*"%2%!&&%$"&:B< <A;A47$*"+($#","!0("& &(# $*"8-1$*-/%''

'"00%#$ $-.-#$"#&$*%$*"2%

0"/$2($*%#7!()*$+$($0"-!(#$"!

$ (#$*" '".(/(.?

?*% !%#184"!

2*(.*2"!"%.@1 1(!"&(#$"!8 -/-$(/(.%$(-#&% %$"& :CA;;1#&"

"!".$(-#-/$*";A.$(#$* *"'!"

"#$.% " 5<6

"!"/%.$$*%$$*"-4 "!,%$(-#2% % 8%&"47$*"(#$*"2 2%!& &%$"&:B<A;

A$*%$$*"'%78"#$-/.-8'"# %$ $(-#$-0%#&-2#"!

*%004"8%&"

"(# %..-!&%#."2($* *$*"(!!()*$ %#& *%!"

% '"!$ $*"!","#1""#$!("

%,%(0%40"%$ $(8" -/ %.@1( ($ $(-# -/ 0%#&+ 2% #-$ $- 4" $!"

"%$"& % %.!- %#.$ ,(&"#$07 % %#& "G'0(.($07+ $*" 2% -40(,(-1 -/ $*" %0" $!%# %.$(-# 4""# 8%&" 47 % %!4*%3%#(#)* *% %0!"%&7#-$(."&(#$*"'!"."& &(#)'%!$-/$*"-!&"! 596

!$*"!8-!"+ ","# $*" -4 "!,%$(-# # 8%&" 47 $*" (# ($ %2 2%!& &%$"&:B<A;

;A$-$*""//".$$*%$.-8'"# %$(- -#2% $-4"'%(&% '"!!".-!&

-/ !()*$ % -#$*" &%$"-/'%

(#)-/%2%!&2% $- -4"!"%&&-2#$-$*""//".$$*%$ '%78"#$2% $- 4"8%&"$-$*- "!()*$*-0&"!

- -!'"!

+2*-2"!"$*"-2#"!

-/ $*" %.@1(!"& 0%# #& -# $*" %(& &%$" ,"# -$*"

"!2( "+ ($ )-"

2($*-1$ %7(#) $ $*%$ !","#1"!".-!& &-#-$.-#/"!%4 -01$"$($0"$- %'!-'"!$741$%!"-#07"#$!("

/-!

/( .%0'1!'- "-!

!/-!8%(#$%(#(#)!".-!& %#&$*1 %02%7 143".$$-$*" "@1 1"#$ %0("#%$(-# 8%&"

"47$*"!".-!&"&-2#"!

56 #

1.*.(!.18 $%#."

+2*"#($2%

.0"%!07"

$%40( *"&/!-8$*"!".

.-!& $*%$%2%%!4 *%3%#(#)**%&%0!"%&7 -0&8 8-!"$*%#*( *%!"(#$*"3-(#$0% %#& *-0&(#) ","#'

'!(-!$-$*"'%

(#)-/$*"2%!& &&%$"&:B<A;A47$*"+ +#- .%1 " -/ %.$(-# # 2% %,%(0%40" $- $*" %''"00 0%#$ $- ""? %''-!$(-#8"#$ -/ .-8'"# %$(-#%

%00$*"!()*$ 2($*!"

'".$$- $*"!"."('$-/.-8'"# %$(-# $- --& "G$(#)1( *"& %# #& 2"!" ,"

$"& 2($* $*" ,"#&"

(" $*" "@1"#$ '1!.*% "!

+ 2($*-1$%//".$(#) )$*"!()*$ -/-$*"!.-H *%!"!

(# #$*"0%#&*-0&(#) 56

!$*"!+(#$*"*1840"-'(#(-#-/ / $*( -1!$+$*"(

1"-/0(8($%$ $(-# &".(&"& %)%(# $ $*" %''"00%#$ (# $*" )(,"# / /%.$ %#& .(!.18 $%#."

.%##-$ $ 4"

$%(#"&+*%,(# #)!")%!&$-$*"/%.$$*%$$*"%''

'0(.%$(-#1#&"!".$(-#<;H-/ ;A.$'!"/"!

!!"&%$$*"(# $%#."-/$*"%''"0 00%#$ !"3".$"&-#<:<<:

:<: %#& -43".$(-# 1#&"! ".$(-# 9: -/ $*" ;A .$ 2"!" /(0"& (88"&(%$"07 -# :<:C<:<:*1 +$*"0"%!#"& "/"!"#."-1!$% %$$*"$(8"-/'%

(#)-/-!&"!&% %$"& 9:;<:<"!!"& &!".-!&(#)$*%$$*"!"/"!"#."2% % #-$8%(#$%(#%40"4"(#)4%!!"& &47 &"0%7 5C6 #, ,("2-/&( .1

(-#8%&"*"!"(# %4-,"+#-(#$"!/"!"#."( .%00"& /-! 2($*$*"(8'1)# #"&-!&"!'%

"&47$*"0"%!#"&

"/"!"#."-1!$-# "@1"#$07+ '!"

"#$%''"%04 4"(#)&",-(&-/8"!($ +( *"!"47 &( 8(

"& 5B6

"# #&(#)%''0(.%$(-# +(/%#7+ *%00 0%0 - $%#&&( '- "&-/

%!.*

%!.*9:

9:++++<:

<:<C <C <C <C $(? L* L* *"$*"! '"%?(#)>!"% -#"& "

*"$*"!!"'-!$%40" "