Kuldeep Singh & ANR v. Balkar Singh & ORS

  

           

"#$%$&'(')*

+
 ,-.%$$/')01")%")#1$2 //$..")#( 3$2(-( ".4"2')01")%#1$2(  $(/)%$)#(

 *  56   , 6  2$($)#*7 2, 1/2"8$)'2%9&"#$8:'#18 2)4'# '%1"8%9&"#$8 2"//$..")#( )$22$(/)%$)#(#+ 2,"')'8 "2;")"8 22$(/)%$)#(#   <1$#1$2#1$ $/2#$2(.&".)$:(/"/$2=";>$"..:$%# ($$#1$?-%0=$)#@
 >$2$$22$%##1$ $/2#$22)# A <1$#1$2#1$?-%0=$)#(1-.%>$2$/2#$%')#1$%'0$(#@ 77 77 , 6 

6!

=/-0)$%')/2$($)#2$0-."2($&)%"//$".'(?-%0=$)#")% %$&2$$  %"#$%   
A8  /"(($%  >;  .$"2)$%  %%'#')".  '(#2'&#  -%0$8 =>"."89'%$:1'&1:1'.$"..:')0"//$"."0"')(#?-%0=$)#")%%$&2$$ %"#$%
 8/"(($%>;.$"2)$% '9'.-%0$ -)'2'9'(')!8=>"."8 9'%$  :1'&1  (-'#     /."')#'(  :"(  %$&2$$%  2$(#2"')')0  %$$)%")#(  2= ')#$2$2')0')/$"&$-./(($((')/."')#'(9$2(-'#.")%8%'(='(($%#1$ (-'#>$')0)#="')#"')">.$")%-2#1$21$.%#1"#.$"2)$% '9'.-%0$1"()

7
7 ?-2'(%'&#')#$)#$2#"')8#2;")%%$&'%$#1$(-'# #:"(-2#1$21$.%#1"# /."')#'("2$"#.'>$2#;#"9"'.2$=$%;"9"'.">.$##1$="(/$2.":%$&."2$% ')">9$(#"#$%2$/2#(")%/29'(')(&)#"')$%')<"4"2%&#8+ 1$(12#&)#29$2(;:1'&12$B-'2$(#>$)#'&$%2/-2/($ %'(/("./2$($)#2$0-."2($&)%"//$".'(#1"#/."')#'(1"%'.$%"(-'# 2/$2=")$)#')?-)&#')2$(#2"')')0%$$)%")#(2=%'(/(($((')0#1$= 2&'>.;")%'..$0"..;2=(-'#.")%8-..;%$#"'.$%')1$"%)#$/."')# ."')#'(8,-.%$$/')01")%,"):"2?'#')018&."'=$%#1"##1$;0#(-'# .")%=$"(-2')0 C4")".(
="2."().$"($2="20"11"1,-=$(1 "1'>#12-01;$%1"1>%-.,";-=89'%$(".$%$$%%"#$%



")%(-'#.")%=$"(-2')0 +4")".( ="2."(9'%$.$"($%$$%%"#$%
A

2"/$2'%;$"2(,1"(2"0'2%":"2':$2$&)#')-$%'))"=$%$"% /$2()(8"..$0$%#>$ /2$%$&$((2(%$$)%")#(#+ ."')#'( =9$  (('(#")#  ..$&#28 
)% 2"%$8  "2"2"8  2  &22$&#')    41"(2" 0'2%":"2' 3'%$2%$2%"#$%

8 8
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

7A7 ;$"2(:'#1-#>#"')')0.$"9$ -2#8#1$2$2$8.$"($%"#$%
A

A'( '..$0".8)-..")%9'% ##1$("=$#'=$8#1$;#4/.$"#1"#%$$)%")#(:$2$%$#"')$% >;  /.'&$   ."')#'(  :'#1  1$./    /.'&$  #4  2&'>.$  /(($((')  >; #2$(/"((')09$2(-'#.")%>$')0&-.#'9"#$%>;%$$)%")#( 
)% 2"%$%'% )#..:&22$&#/2&$%-2$#".#$2")%&22$&#2$9$)-$$)#2'$(1$2$2$8 2%$2%"#$%

'('..$0".#:"(-2#1$2(#"#$%#1"#/."')#'($)#$2$% ')#  /(($((')    (-'#  .")%  '..$0"..;  ")%  #  /2#$&#  #1$'2  /(($((')8 /."')#'('.$%&'9'.(-'#"0"')(##1$=."')#'("2$')-)"-#12'D$%8'..$0". ")%2&'>.$/(($((')(-'#.")% 2=#1$/.$"%')0(8..:')0'((-$(:$2$2"=$%*7  <1$#1$2#1$/."')#'("2$$)#'#.$%##1$2$.'$/$2=")$)# ')?-)&#')"(/2";$%2>;#1$=@ 
 <1$#1$2(-'#/."')#'(1"9$).&-((#")%'")%&"-($ "&#')#'.$/2$($)#(-'#@  A

$.'$ 1$.$"2)$% '9'.-%0$ -)'2'9'(')!8=>"."81$.%#1"# /."')#'("2$')/(($((')(-'#.")%)#1$>"('(.$"($%$$%")% &)($B-$)#.;%$&2$$%#1$(-'# )"//$".8.$"2)$%%%'#')".'(#2'&#-%0$8=>"."8#4#1$ 9'$:#1"#/2/$2#;>$.)0(# -(.'=<"4"2%")%:)$%>;"20"1 1"1,"=$(1"1'><1'.$2$$22')0#&/;?"=">")%'EF8&/'$( ?"=">")%'$)#2'$(E#E ")%&/;41"(2"0'2%":"2'E+8 '#:"(1$.%#1"# -(.'=<"4"2%'("#$)")# 1$2$2$8(-'#'()# ="')#"')">.$>$2$#1$ '9'. -2# 1"9$1$"2%.$"2)$%($)'2&-)($.2"//$..")#(")%1"9$

&"2$-..;0)$#12-01#1'('.$"(:$.."(.:$2 -2#2$&2%

$(/)%$)#(#+1"9$)#"//$"2$%%$(/'#$($29'&$1$; "2$/2&$$%$%"0"')(#$E/"2#$ $2$#2'". -2#8 (#")%%$$)%")#(#+:"(#1"# /."')#'(1"9$#"4$)2&'>.$/(($((')(-'#.")%8=$")')0#1$2$>;#1"# /."')#'(5/(($((')'()#%$)'$%$2$#2'". -2#8)/.$":"(#"4$) #1"#  /2/$2#;  :"(  :)$%  >;  -(.'=  <"4  "2%  ")%  (-'#  '(  )# ="')#"')">.$1$.:$2"//$.."#$ -2#1"(2$.'$%-/)&/;?"=">")%'

EF /;?"=">")%'EF'()#&/;?"=">")%'8>-#')"&#&/; 41"(2"0'2%":"2'2#1$;$"2(

+#

7     /;41"(2"

0'2%":"2'(1:(#1"#"20"11"1'(2$&2%$%"(:)$2")% -(.'=<"4 "2%'(2$&2%$%"('2(##$)")#/2'2#;$"2

A7

<1$)')#1$;$"2

+8$)#2'$(:$2$&22$&#$%841"(2"0'2%":"2'$)#2'$(:$2$&22$&#$%') "9-2/."')#'(89'%$2%$2%"#$%

")%'#'(&)#')-')0"((-&1 #'..%"#$1$2$2$8'#&"))#>$("'%2=#1$("'%41"(2"0'2%":"2'#1"# -(.'=<"4"2%'(:)$2)#1$&/'$(?"=">")%'(2$"2.'$2/$2'%8 "2%:"(2$&2%$%).;"(#$)")#")%)#"(:)$2:'#1 -2#1$2 .$"($ >$')0&2$"#$%')"9-2(->#$)")#1$2$2$8):1$2$'#'(-)%#1"# <"4"2%:"(:)$2.")%)"&#8&/;?-%0=$)#E (1:(#1"# -)?"><"4"2%1"%'.$% '9'.-'#CA"0"')(#12'";;$% >%-.  "('#  2  %$&."2"#')  2$0"2%')0  (-'#  .")%  ")%  #1$2   /2/$2#'$( &."'=')0#1"#'#'(:)$2.")% "'%(-'#:"(%'(='(($%)
+C 1$2$2$8.:$2"//$.."#$ -2#$22$%')1.%')0#1"#<"4"2%'(:)$2 ')/(($((')(-'#.")% 2$9$28'#'(&"($))$#1$/"2#'$(#1"# "2%1"(");#1')0#%:'#1#1$(-'#.")%#'(('=/.;")')?-)&#')(-'# :1'&1'(#>$%$&'%$%)#1$>"('(/(($((')1$2$2$8"=#1$

7+7 9'$: #1"# ')%')0(  2$&2%$%  >; .$"2)$%  '9'.  -%0$ -)'2  '9'(')!8 =>"."8"2$&22$&# )($B-$)#.;8'=/-0)$%?-%0=$)#%"#$% 
A8 /"(($%>;.$"2)$%  %%'#')".'(#2'&#-%0$8=>"."8'(($#"('%$")% ?-%0=$)#")%%$&2$$%"#$% 
 8/"(($%>;.$"2)$% '9'. -%0$

-)'2'9'(')!8=>"."8'(2$(#2$% )($B-$)#.;8"//$".'("..:$% ')&$="')&"($1"(>$$)"..:$%8#1$2$2$8/$)%')0"//.'&"#')(8'");8 ".((#")%%'(/($%

, 6 !

  

+
 (?4( <1$#1$2(/$"4')02$"()$% * $( <1$#1$2 $/2#">.$ * $(