Gurjit Singh v. Dakshin Haryana Bijli Vitran Nigam Ltd. And ORS
!" #"$%&%'( ) *
* +,-%!%'./ 00"11 '! 2",&+&
3&/%' ,4 ' %-1%2%!, '%. 56!# '#!/",& "&0'#"'!&
,"&"'!( , /+1 +! 57#8$ !" ,!/" 00"11 '! 99999
/" 00"11 '! %& ..,%"8"# -+#.5"'! '# #"$,"" # !"#
0 &&"# ;4 !/" 1" ,'"# ##%!%' 1 +#."7 +,+. 57 </",";4!/"-+#.5"'! '##"$,""# !"#
0 &&"#;4!/"1" ,'"# %8%1 +#." +'%, %8%&%'7+,+., 5/ &;""'&"! &%#" '#!/"&+%! %1"# ;4!/"01 %'!%
/ &;""'#%&5%&&"# /" 01 %'!%
7 </ %& $'&+5", "1"$!,%$%!4 ,5 3&/%' ,4 ' %-1% 2%!, ' %. 5 6!# >%. 5? , &/,!7 %1"# !/" &+%! , #"$1 , !%' ! !/" "
"$! !/ ! !/" 5+'! &* 7 @A #"5 '#"# ;4 ,"&0'#"'!A%. 57 8%#" 5"5 : # !"# = :
7 & <"11 & $/ '.%'. ! ,%
! &5 11 0<", 0+,0&" %'&!" # #5"&!%$ 0+,0&"7 %& %11". 17+'1 < +1 '#+'-+&!% %"#7 . %'&!!/"0,%'$%01"& ' !+, 1-+&!%$" '# . %'&!!/"&"!!1"#1 <%'8%1 !%' !/"%'&!,+$!%'& %. 5 "$,"" 0",5 '"'! %'-+'$!%' ,"&!, %'%'. !/" #"
"'# '!& ,5 #%&$''"$!%'. !/" "1"$!,%$%!4 $''"$!%' '# &""3%'. ,"$8",4 %50+.'"# 5+'! < & 1& &+./!!< &!/+&0, 4"#!/ !&+%!;"#"$,""#
"
"'# '!&,"&%&!"#!/"&+%!C,%!!"'&! !"5"'!< & %1"#</","%' 0,"1%5%' ,4;-"$!%'&<",", %&"#!< &#"'%"#!/ ! '43%'# %11". 1 '# +'1 < +1 $!%'/ &;""'! 3"';4!/"%. 5!< &&0"$% %$ 11401" #"#!/ ! !/"&+5 &* 7 @A/ #;""'#"0&%!"#%'"D$"&&0+,&+ '!!!/"#"$,"" # !"#
%' 8+, !/" 01 %'!%
/" #"
"'# '!@%. 5 / # ;""' #%,"$!"#!,"
+'# &+5 & 7 7 @A!!/" 00"11 '!</< & $E+%!!"# !/"$/ ,." !/"
! "1"$!,%$%!4<"8",7 ' 5+'! & 7 @A< & #"0&%!"# 0+,&+ '! ! !/" & %# -+#.5"'! '# #"$,"" # !"#
DC @= /","
!",7 ' ," 1%F%'. !/" ",,,7 '!%$" # !"# = :
DC @)< &%&&+"# &3%'.!/" 00"11 '!!,"
+'#!/"#"0&%!"#"D$"&& 5+'!/"&+%!%!< &!/+&01" #"#;"#%&5%&&"# "01%$ !%'< & %1"# ,5!/"01" #%'.& !/"0 ,!%"&7 11<%'.%&&+"&<"," , 5"# ;4!/"1" ,'"#!,% 1+,!(A C/"!/", !/" 01 %'!%
%& "'!%!1"# ! #"$,"" , #"$1 , !%'7 0",5 '"'! %'-+'$!%' '# 5 '# !,4 %'-+'$!%' & 0, 4"# ,H
C/"!/",!/"01 %'!%
/ &'$ +&" $!%' '#1$+&&! '#%!
%1"!/"0,"&"'!&+%!H = C/"!/",!/"&+%! !/"01 %'!%
%&'!5 %'! %' ;1"%'!/"0,"&"'!
,5H C/"!/",!/"01 %'!%
/ &'!$5"!!/"$+,!<%!/$1" '/ '#& '#/ &&+00,"&&"#!/"!,+" '#5 !",% 1 $!& ,5!/"$+,!H
C/"!/", !/" 01 %'!%
/ & '!
%D"# 0,0", $+,! "" ' !/" 01 %'!H
= B C/"!/",!/"01 %'!%
%&;+'#;4/%&<' $!7$'#+$!75%&&%'7 $55%&&%'"!$H ) "1%"
I 8%#"'$" < & 1"# ;4 ;!/ !/" 0 ,!%"& 6" ,'"# !,% 1 +,! #"$%#"#%&&+" %' 8+, !/" 00"11 '!&&+"& !B<","#"$%#"# . %'&! !/" #"
"'# '!& ;"%'. '! 0,"&&"# +%! %1"# ;4 !/" 01 %'!%
< & $$,#%'.14 #"$,""# ;4 !/" 1" ,'"# !,% 1 +,!7 8%#" -+#.5"'! '# #"$,"" # !"#
"
"'# '!@%. 5 ;"%'. ..,%"8"# 0,"
",,"# ' 00" 1 . %'&! !/"-+#.5"'! '##"$,""# !"#
7</%$/< &+1!%5 !"14 11<"#;4 !/"1" ,'"###%!%' 1 +#."7+,+., 578%#"-+#.5"'! '##"$,"" # !"#
..,%"8"#!/","
,570,"&"'! 00" 1/ &;""' %1"# 6" ,'"# $+'&"1 , !/" 00"11 '! 8"/"5"'!14 ,.+"& !/ ! 1" ,'"# ##%!%' 1 +#."7 +,+., 5 / & ",,"# %' &"!!%'. &%#" !/" <"11," &'"# '#1.%$ 1-+#.5"'!0 &&"#;4!/"1" ,'"#!,% 1+,!'$" !/" 5+'! & 7 @A / # ;""' #"0&%!"# 0+,&+ '! ! !/" -+#.5"'! # !"#
7!/","< &'E+"&!%' &""3%'. '43%'# ,"
+'#;4!/" %. 5 "&0'#"'!@%. 5 %! %& &+;5%!!"# !3 '8"1 01" %' !/" '!%$" # !"# = :
!/ !!/" 5+'!%'E+"&!%'< &#"0&%!"#%'"D$"&&+'#", 0,"&&+," !/"$+,!!%&%' $!!/"$50'"'! %'!","&!7</%$// &;""' %'$,0, !"#/","
,"7'.,+'#%&5 #"+! ,,"
+'# & %# 5+'! 6" ,'"# $+'&"1 , !/" 00"11 '! &+;5%!& !/ ! !/" 5+'! %' E+"&!%'&!##"0&%!"#;4!/" 00"11 '!%'
!%& +,!/",&+;5%!!"#!/ ! !/" 00"11 '! &0"$% %$ 114 01" #"# !/ ! /" / # 001%"# , #5"&!%$ $''"$!%'</%$/< &&+;&"E+"'!14$/ '."#%' '%11". 15 ''",! &5 11 0<",$ !".,4$''"$!%'/" 5+'!$/ ,."#;4!/","&0'#"'!@%. 5
< &,%./!14,#","#!;","
+'#"#;4!/"1" ,'"#!,% 1+,!!%&!/+&0, 4"# !/ ! !/%& 00" 1 ;" 11<"#7 %50+.'"# -+#.5"'! '# #"$,"" # !"#
0 &&"#;4!/"1" ,'"###%!%' 1 +#."7+,+., 5;"&"! &%#"</%1"+0/1#%'.!/"-+#.5"'! '##"$,""# !"#
0 &&"#;4 !/"1" ,'"#!,% 1+,! / 8" /" ,# 1" ,'"# $+'&"1 , !/" 00"11 '! '# / 8" .'" !/,+./!/","$,#<%!//%& ;1" &&%&! '$" /"," %& ' #%&0+!" !/ ! !/" 00"11 '! " ,1%", %1"# &+%! , #"$1 , !%'7 0",5 '"'! %'-+'$!%' '# 5 '# !,4 %'-+'$!%' . %'&! !/" #"
"'# '!@%. 5$/ 11"'.%'.!/"0"' 1!4%50&"#+0'/%50+,&+ '!!!/" $ &" !/"
! "1"$!,%$"'",.4/" 00"11 '!< & $E+%!!"# !/"$/ ,."& . %'&!/%56" ,'"#!,% 1+,!8%#"-+#.5"'! '##"$,""# !"#
#%,"$!"#!/","
+'# !/" 5+'! & 7 7 @A</%$/< &#"0&%!"#;4 !/" 00"11 '! +,&+ '!!!/"& %#-+#.5"'! '##"$,""7&+5 & 7 @A %'&!" # & 7 7 @A< &#"0&%!"#;4!/","&0'#"'!@%. 5" 1%F%'. !/" ",,,7 '!%$" # !"# = :
DC @) < & %&&+"# ",+& 1 !/" -+#.5"'! DC @ # !"#
,"8" 1& !/ ! !/" #%,"$!%' < & , ,"
+'# & 7 7 @A /"," %& ' #%,"$!%' , #"0&%! %'!","&! ;4 !/" ,"&0'#"'!@%. 5 &%&&+./!!;"0,-"$!"#'&+$/ &%!+ !%'7%!$ ''! ;"0,"&+5"#!/ !%!%&!/"$50'"'! %'!","&!</%$// #;""'#"0&%!"# ;4 !/" ,"&0'#"'!@%. 5 %' $501% '$" <%!/ !/" #%,"$!%'& !/" +,! ",+& 1 !/"'!%$"DC @)5 3"&%!$,4&! 1$1" ,!/ !!/"1" ,'"#%8%1
+#." +'%, %8%&%'7+,+., 5/ #5 #"%! 5014$1" ,!/ !!/","< &' #%,"$!%',". ,#%'.!/"$50'"'! %'!","&!/+&7%!%& 00 ,"'!!/ !&+5 &* 7 @A< &%'#""##"0&%!"#%'"D$"&&;4!/","&0'#"'!A%. 5
' ,"&0"$! ! !/" 01" !/" 00"11 '! !/ ! /" / # ! 3"' #5"&!%$$''"$!%'%'8%"< C @ '#%!< &<,'.14$/ '."#%'!&5 11 0<", $ !".,4 $''"$!%' / & 1& ;""' ,%./!14 '". !"# ;4 1" ,'"# ##%!%' 1 +#."7+,+., 5",+& 1 8 ,%+&#$+5"'!&0,#+$"# ;4 !/" #"
"'# '!@%. 5 !/" 4" ,
%!&"1 ,"8" 1& !/ ! %! < & &5 11 0<", $ !".,4 $''"$!%' </%$/ < & ,+''%'. ' !/" 0,"5%&"& !/" 00"11 '!/","%&%'#""#'"8%#"'$"',"$,#!&+;&! '!% !"!/"01" !/" 00"11 '!@01 %'!%
!%&,%./!14/"1#;4!/"1" ,'"###%!%' 1 +#." !/ !!/","%&'!/%'.',"$,#!%'#%$ !"</ !%&!/""D$"&& 5+'!</%$/ / &;""'$1 %5"#7</ !< &!/", !" #5"&!%$$''"$!%' '#&5 110<", $''"$!%'!#%
","'!% !" '#!/"& %#%&&+"%'#""#/ &'$''"$!%'<%!/ !/","$8",4 !/" 5+'! &* 7 @A%'E+"&!%' /"," %& ' E+"&!%' 1 < %'818"# %' !/%& 00" 1 5+$/ 1"&& &+;&! '!% 1E+"&!%' 1 <6" ,'"###%!%' 1 +#."7+,+., 5/ & ,%./!14 &"! &%#" !/" -+#.5"'! '# #"$,"" # !"#
0 &&"# ;4 1" ,'"#!,% 1+,! '##%&5%&&"#!/"&+%! %1"#;4!/" 00"11 '!@01 %'!%
/"," %& ' .,+'# </ !&"8", </%$/ < ,, '!& %'!", ","'$" ;4 !/%& +,! %' !/" 0,"&"'!&"$'# 00" 1 /","%& #"1 4 :# 4&%' %1%'. !/%& 00" 1J""0%'.%' 8%"< !/" $! !/ ! !/" 5 !!", / & ;""' #-+#%$ !"# ' 5",%!&7 E+"&!%' #"1 4%' %1%'.!/%& 00" 1/ &;""',"'#","# $ #"5%$ 00" 1%& $$,#%'.14#%&5%&&"#<%!/',#", &!$&!&
! &/< , "#$ #$%&$'()*+%$',*$-./$+ , "#$ #$%%$&,% '01$./$+ ,