← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/5825/2016dismissed

Bhopal Singh & ANR v. Rohtan Through His Lr & ORS

2017-04-18Mr. Justice T.H.B. Chalapathi12 pages



     

 

!"##$%&%'()* 



 

   

 

 (  +,   - ,.



      

 

- ,.

, !

 "



 #

$ "

     %    

    ##

   #&       

     "

 

   

'



"  #

  (

 

  &

" "

  

 

"

'



  "   #

 )         )          





(

  & *

 

     



    

  $&$  $"

"$&  

'

  "  #   $&     

  +  

,

    #

 (

 

   -.-/01  

#

(

 .2-/03   



  

'

"

 



   $&"&

 

  

  

$&   

- 4

3  #

(

 

50

-

54

"

   $  #&  



,#

    

 "

6  7 7

   

!

"   

$ 

50

-

54  

  3202./





$ "  "

     53/0"

$& # 

  &   $,

* $

2.022/

 8 

 #

8

 5 41604

--40220

 8 #





   

  

8  

 $&            (

  





50

-

54" 

   

'

 )

064  (

& %    



0"  $

     

6

6  7 7

" 

   

 

-

9" 

 

   

 !

" $#

50

4:

"

"   & 







 

  &  "

        

        

 50 #     

 



)       -.9-//;      

 5- 

  &  "

 

 54  

        " 

   5;23-

:50 -.9-//;  $  * $ 

   " 



 

 (

 $&  

50 $  "



  (#$

"$ )    

  

$&&



     

 

  (

$&   

" 





 #  "  & 



   ##  

&" $



 



&  



#

"



 "

    <   "&

 

  (#$

-//-'-//4 &  



 $&  

 

 

  < 

   

 

 

 -.9-//; # 

:" 6:  04 : --

:" 03 : -4

-9

:" 0;

: -. 40

:" .3 : 004'003(#$

 &-//-'

-//4 

59 :  046-=3'/> 

 .

:  -36-=-'02> 



9 :  -3=.'/> 

59 :  046-=3'-> 0.=.'/> 006-60=0'2>

006-64=/'0> 006-6-=0'0> 

59 :  --=9'4> 0260=3'/> -/=4'0;>

0060=3'09> 096-=3'/> 026-=3'/>



 1 :  0;=/';> 

 9

:  0-60=0'9> 0-6-=1'04> -0=/';> -4=.'/> 

 .

:  096-=0'

09> -;60=/'02>

-360=3'0/>

:" 6:  4;61/ : 4/ #

/: 04# #

10: 03# )

0603  ;: 09#+

50

&



:

"

& "       

 $  &

5- #

  

  

 (    

50

-

54 *  

50

4# "

#

    



#

"

 

5-$

  

50

-

"" 

   

&   "

50

4

"     &  

 # 

?



   

  ?

$    

50

4

   (

"

 #

 

#  # &$(

@ # 

   

  # "

  0A  



  

 & B@ -A  



   #

& (

& B@ 4A  

  

 

  

 B@+ 3A    

  #

$B @+ ;A    $ # '(

 &  B@+ 1         030-/0-    

    " # 

 0A  

    



 B@  "     $  $   #

&"

  



   

 

$  

   #

  

 &

   $&









&    "    #

(

.2-/03 +

'







'



     

"  # $ #  $&    

 #

(

 -.-/01?

  

 



 ?    

 !

 

 $   



54"$  

,#"'



$ 



54 "   

       "

      $   

"

      

 (



# & !

    '

$     

  

 54 

   

   

3202./ +

'

 50  #&    

  6   # 

   #   #    $            ''



$    #

?"    # $

 

 $&  #

( 

 (

 --40220" 

 &<         

  

 54  "  

     



    $ ' 

)

064  * 

50'

#&

$  $   

  

&





&  

    # 

     &

 #    

     

& 



 

# 

 

  $ $   



50)    &-//;% 

  '

'

5- 

  #   -64    



 $

  $&

'

50   

'

5- !

 

   # 

"

 $&

50'

 

     

  #

 "  

'

 5-

  # 

 

 $   !

 "

 &



"       $& & " #

"

     '    ?"    $ #  &      $   

  "

  # &  

 

## #

$ 

   $&    ""$ 

"

54 ?

 

    

  #   $& 

"

& 

 &(

     " &  $&$  $" @  

 #  $&

'

  " (   

 "<&  % & "!

 

$  

50" &

$     

$  $" &



  $

 #

(



  

 





#  $  <$  " : $&   

 #

"

(

 ? 8$# " 

?



  '

/!'"%01/%2!3#&"! !"#4!'1"/#5&3&%56!4!

!275!8!&/%9!5%!'1"/#5&:  )

 .!66!'!  !6;!605"/2  3  .!4%7!"'!70 "$/0"!66!!'1"/#5&:   <  !$/!""!5%'=/!'1"/#5& 3& 05>%" %'=/!'1 "/#5&:   , *

.!5"!5.!053&.#9!4%'=/:??*     $%@%4 )<

!2!'806!5  !>'%8!;#'  5%@#1%  3&  %&"5%$"

10$!"%'  %$#5:  '!'1  !'1  "/#5&:  )  

0>!5!" < 0>!5!" $ #$ 

$  #

(



 $&  $"" #: &  

   "    "" "

 ( 

  #

(



C



 

'

"$ 

$

 

 #

  #    $            <    "  

 $&   #

( 

<  $&    " $&   

  +  

 ,

    (

 

 

--40220 $& # 



50< (

 --40220

 &$ "   * 



 

  

'



50 $ 

$  

" 

 &

  #< "        

'

: # #  #

           &    $

 $&         ?" 

"       "        $ "  " 

&    &   '

'

5-+

'

5-

$ $ $  $& & 

 #

!

 

$ 



 #" #

" $ %   

&

 

'

5-'7# !

 %& #

 

  

50"#  "



'

5- 

5-' 7#    # &



$

 

  

"" $  "

$ '

'"D

 

 #

 $&

 

" $ 



$   

&  &&# &#

  "  

(

 

   

 &)#



 

  "

 $  







  $& 

+  

,

0; 09  #

(

"  $

  

 

'

     



     

     

                    

  

     

       

                                         !" "#$  



      

     

       %% ""      

        

 &          '(  ( )   '(   

 

(      (   

 ( 

     *   

 (+  &  %$$,-      % (   %)  ( 

    &        %  

        

  

         (   

   

      %

  

           (          .    

      %% ""           +    +   -      / (     &    ""     &   0    -                    &       %  %$$,  

   

             - (  



   



     1 '23

4 +%$ !5%6'77 1##+ 8 '  7    

 (           8  +   

+      8     + 

          

 '    (           

    (     &(           +         

  

   ++   



      

     (     + 

              

 &    

+           



       

9                (      +      (

   

        

                                  &

               +              &

 

   :             -   *          + +    

(                   (     +        

       ( 

   

 +            +               

     

;

+



   

    

    &  

   &     &        #

(



 $&  $"? 

  &% "# $

% "

"  % 



 

 

  

" )

 ( 





0//

   !

  

 

$ "

 "

$& ? E$# !52!'!' !>#'15!'!'1 !'"/#53&,#8&/62!5>%'%!'1"/#5&:?     $%@%4 

!'"&/!A!5%3& 05&/""!6%9!5%: < *? 5  #

"  



  



 #

 

$  "

 #

   

  " 

 # 

 

$ #

"

 &$

< #  5 



$

#   

&  "

   $ $   #  

 



 # 

" "

    

- ,.

 0.3-/09

2'  <2() =)0  <  > =)0