High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/5978/2016dismissed

M/S Bihari Builders & Infrastructure Pvt Ltd v. Mandeep Singh And ANR

2018-03-21Mr. Justice Hari Pal Verma13 pages

!" #"

$%" "&&'' %()

$ * & ! "# $ #% ++++ $( (,-./ /

(-&&'' ++++

$(1( - &&'

' ) ( 2

( - 2#$# ( '1 1

4-&(&&' ! (-( -&&'

/3 '' .

- '1 1

4-&(&&'

&&''+ -

' -&(4)'(

&&'4 -5) 43 ( 26& 71'(

' (

8) 4/ 4(/ -'

/.-(71-&&'

' 71 &&''+ 4 -5) 43 ( 9:

& 71'( # '8) 4; ( </ 4(/ -'

++ %

5) 43 ( 9:/ '( # '

8) 4 ; ( < ( - ) - &'

( &

&( (3 4(3 9(4(

&( &(1

( -(& +&'

(-7' '

;3 4- )'

4-<.

3 - ( & (3 4'

/ .

( = )-' &'

)(-( 3 - .0(/ - '

6>= 71 &(&&''+

(4(

&( &(1.(-'

7 ''4'/)''

4 -( 4- -&'

( '1 /-&'

' ) (& .( 71 .1 &

&( (3 4(3 ''

9 &(3 (4( -) &( &(1/ '

-&' &(-&'

/- - ( 4(3 ''-) &( &(1.

--&'

9?:9 ' &( ( ( 0 :'@-(3 1 ( &.= -

"-' .(A) ( 7 = > "-( (/ ( 0 :/6:/+

( 3-&'

( 3/- ' .-

3 - '&4 -4(3- 3(/ ')3 /6:/+. &

71 - &'

"- (3 4 3 )

:/2/>+.(A) ( 7&

71-&'

-3 - )4)/>.-&'

- (1 4 '

-) &( &(1 3 -(&( -( .

( 4( ' &(

- (& ((/-&'

' )

( &(3 4 (( 4 - 3 ( 3 '

&( &(1 =+&(1.4(

4 /7) '' 0 '

( (/

-&( &(1 0

6>"-&'

(A) '

' = )' - 0 )(/7) . '1 4-3( &(= (- -("-&'

(3 ( 1 ''

4 &( (3- &( - ( ''

( 1 .

4 &( (3 - &( B- ' = )-' /&() .

' (&

&( (3

4(3 9 C

-0 47 ) / &&(

@0( ) 75 ')

)

) 7(( 71 -#$#"-= ) 4(3 '' 9.

71 . - 0( ( 0 1(3 1 ( 3-&'

.&' - 5 4- ) - 4-/(

% ''4, '.- &( &(1 '(.- &&( - &)( -:@'

' / (.-

- 4( ''?:9'@-&( ("-

7-'

5 4- 4 &)( -( - 4(3/7) - )'7)1(.5 4- -&(

4- "-&'

- 5) 4 )- ( D

&( 5 4- '('1/ ;&(&&''<

' &( .( 3A) 4-3 7 '

1 "-) . 7 ( +5 ( 3 +5 ( (1&( ' 3 --

+:+

-( (-

) ' -( (/- 4-(&( "-) 7(( ) (C( ()'#$#C 3( / . - - 0(( 4(3 .

--&'

9 - &)( - &( &(1 ( )0(

( 3-(0)( (3@ 4 A) .-

-( 7'&() &( =& 3@ - & ' ..

- /- '

0( & "-) 7

-( ' "-( '# )( (3 - '' .

)+ E B--( - - ( 4(3 ''.

--&'

9FC$$ B--( 7 +

( - )

FC$ B--( - &'

' &

&( (3 4(3 9FC$$ B--(-&'

'.1(3 ( 1

4 &( (3- &( ( FC$$ B--(-' = 71-

6>( ''4'/)'' 0

FC$$ B--(-&'

' -('

'( FC$$ : B--( - &'

' &(3

FC$$ 2 B--(-) 37(( FC$ 6 B--(-&'

- ' -3( '

( 3- )(FC$ 9 B--(-) -&'

7(( 71- &(

&' (5)

) ( -#$#F C$ 9 B--(-) -&'

7(( ) ( C( ()'#$#/

FC$ '

G "-( '# )(()(

- 0

- "-( )4- -

-= ) 4(3 9/7)-- &' --

+2+ 4( ''-&( &(1 A) 5 4-.-(-&'

4-&&( 7-'

5 4-&)( -(/7)- &'.

& %

5) 43 ( 9:/-( '# )(/

( 7(0 ) (+ E9 B- 0(&'-7@71- - .( 3/-3-7 &

71 -

' &' 7 ) - 7

-(-7@71- ( 3- -.( 3.-

' &('1 71 - (& 0'1/ 0 7.- '('10 7'"- -

-= ) 4(3 97)-

--4( ''-&( &(1 A) 5 4- &'

4-&&( 7-'

5 4- &)( -( 7) - 4(3 A) =$ &() .-

- &( 0 71-&'

.''5 4-/ (0'-- 4( ''-) &( &(1 -&'

5 4- 4-- 3'

&)( -( 0 )(7' - - 3 ) ( 3 - ( +=3 ''-$B "- - && -.

7 = )7 - &'3-- -

- ' 3 - &'

&( 0 - -

4( ''-) &( &(1 0 )(

9-( :9' &( ( -( 0 :' (3 1 ( 3-

= -( & =$B

-&'

.0(-&'

&( 0- -&

:/6:/+3 ( -

( -(( 4)( -.(

+6+

=$ =$: -'&4 -4(3 ''

-( (/ &( 0 - - &'

:/6:/+ &( &13 ( 3 - ( '

- "- .(- &

- 0(-) &( &(1 &( 0 ( 3 - &1 -837

=$2 -- -( (( &( &(1

71.1 '

6> . 7- .--(- 7

- )

( &( 0 - -&'

(3 ( 1 ''

4 &( (3- &( -4(3 ''( 17)- )'

&( (3- (3 4&( -4(37 )

-= ) -' &( &(171-

"- ( + =3 B=3 71- 0(1 ('0 )( 4 - ( =3 / B 5 -,-- -- ( 4(3 ''.

-- 3 )4)/ C 7(' --

4- - 4-7 )(( -@ .

- 37 4 4-7 )(( ( 3-0(174 4 - - 7 & 4 - 3 7 4 4-7 )(( 4(

)')( ' 71 - 3 - % ''4 -(34(- % ''4, '( 40 ''4 ' -- 0' &('

- 3 4- '

- 3 7 ) - = ) 4(3 '' -) &( &(1 .

5 4- .

- 4- 0

- '

- 7 )- 4(3 ''(4(

&( &(1.

-5 4- 0 -- - )'

-0 &)( - &( &(1 ( 3-

+9+ -( (/ -( '( ) 0 7. -

- ' 0 7' ( 3- (&' @ - ( &( .( 3 ' 71- .

-- '

- --- 4 -7'@&&( ( 7 4'

( 35 4- ' --0(

(&&( -) --(. 4 -' &( &(14 - 3 4- &(0 )) ' - - - '

- 3'

( 3- ( + =3 B/ (0' --

-( (

- )

( 0( - '.('

)& 71- '( )' (-&'

;<# '

# )(#99;$< ' -()'

-)(3 %)7 4- -(/ .-'

-.-(- &( ((

3''&' /0(17 1@ . 7 )-' &)( -( &( &(1 -0 ''4

B 4-7 )( &'

7 -'

- - . @ .' 4 '4(3(4(

&( &(1

71- -1( (

0(13''&' - - .( 4'1= -

' &( &(1

- - ( 4(3 ''-) &( &(1.

-&'

9 -&'

( 1 ''

4 &( (3- &( -4(3 ''( 1 ''

4 "-&'

- ' 1 3( ' -( (/ -

' &

&( (3 - 4(3 9 ''- )(

0 )( - &'

4 -

++ 44( 0 4 - (

5) 43 (

9:/ &( &&''+ - &( (( &&' .0(/-3.'

3 71-'( .(&&'' # )(0

5) 43 ( 26"- @71

--.7

-(/.'

(

- .(&&''# )(- 7(0 ) (+ E6

) .

) @71 ;&&''< .( 3 7 +

-(-7@71&'

4-7 ( &)( - ' '1-(0)( . 0(

7)&() A) .(' 3 "

(3 -( 5 -,- ( ( 3 & - ..

7) -( 4-'1 7 7(0 71 '( ' .( )( - ( + =3 5 -,-&@0 ')3 -

0 .

- 3 4--)3@ 4 ) --. 7 +

-( - ( +=3 5 - ,-

' - &( ( 4 4 ' = /3 4-&&( - 37 )( '4(3 ) ' -5 4-'- )4- - (( - 3'

71 1 4 - 3 4- -

7 (( . 33 1 ( 35 4-.- 7

- 4)()& 7'@&&(7) ) -0(3 - 7 @ -( 71 3 4- - .( 3 (71 &'

4 3 4-- &&( 7 ) &( ('4(3317 5 4-/ - )'

-0&) 4)( 3@

)3& (A) (3 (&( 7 - ' 3 4-/31771@ 43 4- '&( )

&1 -'4(3B- )(-( ( +

+>+ =3 /B5 -,-

' --@

3 4- &( ) ( '4(37)3 4- . -0 44(3.

-- 3"- .(

3 4-- )'

-0

5 -,- 5 -,-.

)4- 4(-- )4- - 3 &)( - ' 3 4-

' - 3 7 ) - &

4 ) 7) .- - &( ''10(

( 3- )(- ) -3 4-.''

-- 7 47 -- ) - ( +=3 5 -,- )(-( 4( -&'

4- - 4-7 )(( -@.- 3 ( 3-0(174 4 )'

-0 @ - 4-7 )(( 4-7 )( '4(3 ) ' 7) ) -

(.3 9 7 0

(&'1 5 - ,- 3@ 3&'1 '(--@. 7 ) &( ('4(3

)(( 47.3 4- 4-7) ''-.- -- 7(4 -)- )'

3 ( ' 3 - 3'

7 7 +

&)( -( ( 4'1.- '4 4-' = ( 33 4- 3 1-( )4- -A) (

( . &

. ( (( - )3

/9/2+ - 7 ( 0 ( 3 - 3&1 4&( 0'

3&1/ ) ( - .

&1-'&(

- 3 4-

( )' ( &&''+ (4)

-3('1 7 4=+&( ( ( (01&)(& )'- 7 4 (& ( - (0) ( -(.

7 1 @ . .--( - ' ) ( ' . )37( ( ( )' (.

)( .( & 537

(-1(+:

=$2 )73 - ) -(3(@ - ( 7 )-

++ > -04 0 ( )'- )4- -)73

-.- ( ( & - )'

-074 (& ( -(0)( 7) .- &( 5 - ,- - @.

4-/- )'

-0@ 7 )- ( 7 71- 3( -''(3 4-

' 7 )& 1 ) '

7 ( &()3 - - + &&'' 7 +

-(G - (

)3 /- &&''+ -&&( - - # )(/ 3&)4 4-5) 43 ( & 71- )(7' .

( )' (-&&''-(4) --5) 43 (& 71- )(7' .((7 ((1/)5)/&(0(

((1 -0

7( )4- ( &( ( 3- --)

3 7'/ .'

7' 7

) +5 ( 3 +5 ( (1 &( &&''+ 7

-( (0'

' "-( (/- 4-(&( $() -(.

7(( ) (C( ()' #$#/ ('

( - (& +&'

' ) ( &(3

.'' - &)( - &( &(1 ( ) 0(

( 3-(0)( (3@ 4 (1A) .-

- ( 7'&() &( =& 3@C-('0 /- ) &( &(1. -& (-= )

' / - '

0( & &(&&''+

/ .-

--- &7 ) '@- 0 -(.

- ' &( 0- (

4/ (-- &( 0

--- -7' '

-- 3 > -

= (= ) ' 7 ) +0 '7 '

1 '

--&'

/-- . ( 1(

&() 7

-( . .( 7 )-= ) ''4 4(3 '' 97. -(& +&'

(& + /3'1/3 4- +3 4-- 0( '

-&&''+ 7 )- )3 -4(3 '' 9 '1 ( & -)33

' 71(& +

/3'1/ & 4-/&( &&''+ -

3 -@ .' 47 )-4(3 '' 9 -0-( '( )' (-&( (-(4)3 ( 71'( )' (- &&''--) 7(( ) (C( ()'#$# ( /- 3 7' (-( --&'

' &(3 4 (( 4- 3 ( 3'

4 -) &( &(1/ .-

-=&(1.4( 4 / 7) & -(7 41 ( (4( 71-

' )(/ 0 ' - ( ( (-( '

&( &(1 &&''+ 0

. '

6> . ' ''-) &( &(1-( . '( 1 4(3 7. - &'

(4(

&( &(1 (.-

-(3 1 /6:/+. ( 0 71 +3 4--

7 )-)

' 71-&'

(&(3 /-( (/ 3 4-. 3& ''-) ' &&''+

/-(. 4( (& +

"- @71&&''+ -- 7

-( 7 (&)( - &( &(1/-- '1 ' @ 0(

-(0)( /7)' 3 &() A) /

& ( +=3 / B+5 - ,- -

' -&( ( 4 4-' = / +3 4-&&( - 37 )( '4(3 ) ' 5 4-"- )4-- (( - 3'

711 4-3 4--

7 (( . 33 1 ( 35 4-.- 7 - 4)()& 7'@&&(/7) ) -0(3- 73 -(713 4- - .( 3 (71 &'

4C 3 4- - &&( - 37 )&( ('4(3/ . )37)& - &&''+ &( 7 - ' 3 4-/7) ) -

(.(3 3(&' B+5 -,---@

+3 4- &( ) ( '4(37)-. -0 4 ) - 4(3 .

- - 3/ 7

& "- -

+ 4-( 4-7 )( @. - -( ( 3-0(174 4/-&&''+ )'

-0 @ ( 3 4-7 )-4(3 = 7.-

) & - (

4(3 '' = /- .- "-( (/-

717 -- )(7' .--;&&''< 7

-( .((1 ( ( 0 -(.

/.- '4 4-'

= 71 0 )( &&''+

/3 1.0(&

-(-( )4- -A) ( ( .( (( -)3 /9/2+- 7( 0 ( 3-# 3&1 "- &'' '17

4 / &( 0'

# 3&1

++ . )'

@ &1'&(

-"- )(7' .-0-'

-- &&''+ 7

-( (

"- &( .((

3''&' ())''1@ . - -( (4( -' &)( - &( &(1 -0 ''4- - /

7 4 4-7 )( &'

+ & 4-/ -( (/

)' 7'

0- . -@ .' 4 ' 4(3(4(

&( &(1 &'

71 /3 (&

''1.--1((

30 ''4&' )7 'A) '.( -&((4)'( &&' -((4)3 ( "-(7 )((

( 717 --

)(7' ./- # )(

1( ( ( -.''

( 5) 43 ( - )(7' .

4'1/&( &&'

#% 50 B--(&@ 4( H B--((& (7'F H