Dal Singh And ORS v. Ajmat Singh And ORS
"# $$ %#& '( "#
$
)#
# *"
+ # , -"
# .( "& /&$+ ,
# 0& & - + , $$ # ) 1 -#+ , #$
# 3 !+ , #$ 2
$$ ", $# !& # $$ ! $ 6"
*&# 6 - ( "( 8 #
"7 # - #
$
# ,- " *&#+ :&
-""
'&
;<""# -# #7
#, & ##
# 7 !, # &
$&#$ & (
, #
# - #
$
=> )# # 6 ### "#
( # #! &
!"#$!%" &'( &') &'#
#!$!($!*%%#+#&$!*'"+'%$%*'"+'%$%$!*%"+ #!$!)*'"+'!$%$%*",+!$%*(%-+!$!*!-+&*'"+(*'"+) *'"+#*,'+,*'"+'*'"+-*'"+%"*,!+%!$!*((+%& *'"+%(*'"+%)*,'+%#*'"+%,*'"+%'*'"+%-$%*((+ !!*'"+!&*'"+!($%*("+'&$#*"%"+ .
!#$!( ()(#(, ,-$!&'*!(+,#$%$%*&&+%"$%*#%#+!"*'"+!%*'"+ ,,$!)*'"+#,$%'$!*)'+%-*"'+!!*#%#+,#$-$!*),+%% *,#+ %!*'"+ %-*'"+ !"*'"+ !,*%%!+ / %'($%'' / &()&('/ -"$)*'"+ -$%*'"+%"*'"+%%*'"+!"*'"+#,$!)$%*%%)+-%$!*'"+ &*'"+(*'"+%!*'"+-%$%-*'"+!!$%*#(+ 0 /1 2 1 0 /1 21 2 3 4 3 1
5 3 %-)' 16 1 0 / 1 2 1
4 7 7 3 37 "!%"%-,(7 %',! 3 3 6
21 8 0 1
1 2 !-"(%-,!1
3
2 97 1 !'"&%-'% 2 !-"(%-,! 1 7.
6
7 : 1 0 ; 7 1 ; 1 1 7 : 1 2 !'"&%-'% :7 !"', 7 7< !!!( 7 : 1 1 7 ; 7 1 : 1 1 7 ; 7 1
7 7 7 %& 3 21 =
2 1 :2
7 !"', !!!( 7
7 7 6 3 7 : 1 / !"', !!!( 7 3
7 !#'! 3 9
55 > 5 1 7 0 1 7 1 7 2 !-"(%-,!
7 !'"&%-'% % 21 ('%--' 3 7
7 !),!""-
7 !,,!""- < #%!"", % 4
7 32 ,'!""- 3 %"'!""-9 32 / 7
7 5 7
/ 3 7 (!%!'%-), 7 7
5 7
%(&) !"&%-#& =
:
1 / 1 7 7 7 2 %(&) 7
5 7 !-"(%-,! 7 0 1
79 6 3 %'!' 7 0 1 7 7
!-(%-,!3 #"
%-,-
%',!
0 1 75 7 3 3 !'&%-'% 3 ! %!%% !)#%--#3 7 7 3 7 % 3 %"'!""- 3 32 % ! & 32 / 3 2
7 1 / 1 ? : 1 97 9 !#,%--( 97 1 ?0 !-&%-'% !-(%-,! 8 9 < 7 @ 0 /1 2 A %
7 !-(%-,! 30 1 3 7 7
2 !-&%-'%
7
3 :7 5 7 7
7 : 1 1 7 ; 7 1 5 : 1
7 2 1 : 1 ; 7 1 1
7 21 :7 3 !!!( %',!
3 7 7
!"', !!!( 6 &*+ 5 7
%',! 7 B &+ $
2
!"& 2"
"# % '( "#+ # 6-
!-"
"# "# ( 7 ((6# ,
9 & $& 6-
$# "# & #
.#7 + $#(6 # , $#, 1# # )#$#7 +
+ -"
#$ + ",
? # -"
.#7
!+
@
16 A ( - -"# ($#
16 ( - $ 2
#, & ##+ & ( "
6' + (&
#, & &"# .-,#+ $
($#
16 A #( -"
-"# $
($#
16 #( -"
#7 -"
#!# #
#, & ##
4 4 , (&
4 + "-,#+ (&
$$#, * #
+ $
" #7
!+ "##+ '(6 7#
## #
$
($#
16 A 6& 1" #7 !
##
? '(6 7#
@ @
1"# "#7 & #& !
# ( ( 7 ((6# -""
" ", ### 0 #&
'(
B(#
B 8 ! # ## "# 6 ! "# & 2#( + , # @ ( 2#( && 7 " ! ## ( 2#( -
# # @
& , # $$ - $$ ! # #
-# (
( (+ (&
@ $#
7#
-# ## - #
$
#6
16 A
# !
6-
2#( ,
" 0 #& B(#
"# " #&
#
+ (&
2 @ C? )@
,&# 2#( , 2#( , $ - #
$
$# .-,#+ &6:& 7+ (&
C? )@ #, " $
#, & ## - # $# #! - #"$ ? 6#
7#
#(#8 &(
C?
#, (& + &(
# (&
"
##
2#( , ?& <
,&#
!"+ &" , ",#
"
2#( ,+ (&
2
C?
,&#
!"+ &" , ",# 1" (&
### - 2#( , #! 7+ !
#
7#
! + "# #(#8
C? -"
#$
(&
'(+ 0 -#' '
0&(#+
- $# & ! + &" , ",#
# < ?& ( 2#( , A7 -7 #
@+ C? C? +
D"
"# "
# ## 1" #$# "# 2#( ,
' # (&
2 @ 6 ! +
& , -"
#$ (
16 A
&# $ 7 &+ ( &# "7 - ! #
@ ( ($#( #& -# 1"##+ -
$$# 6# *&# #&
(
& & # ## 9E & * *, )#&#+ 6"
$# -#
$#
( (+ (&
2 * #+ /#
,&# 2#( :& "# "#
#$ #,
# (&
" ! * # ## (&
$# #
,&# ( 2#( + "##+ (&
C? ) ## $#,& (&
"
$#
6, 9 (7 ( "#
"&!"
7 6& #
( -#
( ( ( + -" !, 2 3# # *&#+ (
!#& ( " 6( ( 6## " #& # '& 3# F# $$ *&# " # # *&# -"
#$ & 2 $ # '& ## & 6& $#,& (
& .-,#+ #( # *&# "
#( 1" *&# " "# # & $# !"
-"
"# 6 ! "#&!"
$
*&# 6 - ##
" + # # *& $$#
6" $$ + " &6( + "
-# ! 7 (+ 6 6## (
.+ -" 6# !+ " &6( (# " #7
#, & ##
!, # &
. + " &6( (
-&
6!
#&
# #8 & (
8
#(
(&
. &#"# &6( # - #
$
#( 7#
-"& ## $# # $# -"
"# $
# 7 &!" 
"# " + # & #$ + " &6( ", $#, ($#( 6"
*&# ", ## 7 " ( 6##
# 7 #!&( # & $#+ " *&# $#(# 7 &$
'& &$
-""# 6## (
" !+ -& $$#$#
)#999 "& 3(
+
4+ $#, $# (
-"
#$ & # #
-""
?# & # CD :555E1 )#
3
F .
/ ), .
7 / 7 / )' 3
3 .
B )# -& -"
$ #
"& $# $##6 #
"# 7# 9 $#, ( -& 6!
#&
-"
#!" & # #& G&
"# ;-""# #!" & # #&
"
#, & #7 ( &"#=
# ,- " *&#+ -# # :&
"
!, #!" & #
"# -# &
7 $
" #7
#, & ## 1" $ "
6# 7 & *&# -"
2
!"& 2"
"# % '( "#+
<" #-
6-
& #
#&( + "
#7 # ###
#, & ##
# 7 !, # &
&
-& #+
$# + -"
( $
1"&+ # *&# 6 - ", ##
## ( 6##
2- ! ?( # !,
# F# $$ *&# ( $$ #
6# # & #
# , $#, # 8
"&!"
( ( -#
( 6&
$$#
,
( -#
(
& &"#H + "##+
# 4
(&
4
C? ) + !,
( 7 &# "
$
7#
@+ -"
(&
# + 2#( ,
- # $#$#7
B&!( #
< ?& ( 2#( , "
" !
#
# + " *&# # ,-
$# + # ,
", (&"
# $ 7 9 - -"
&( #7 , #+ &( #7 , !,
$## &#"#+ # 7#
7#
@ # $# $$#?( 7 7# -"# ,
6 ## ( # $#
7# #( # - - $# "
&#"#+ # F# $$ *&# " #-
,# # !
!#& '(
$$#
, '( + $#7 $$ )
?$ ", # ,# '( ,# # & #-
! + "
$#& "# , .-,#+
$$# +
,# # & #-
!
( -#
( ( (
4 2? #
!
# F# $$ *&#
#:&# &#"# &
9 - -"
$&#& ( ( $ ! $$ $#7+
$$#& 7 !# $$ $#7 :& #$ + $#7 #$
$#( #, 67 :& ( #$ 7 .-,#+ &"
,
$# !
+ & $$# #$ '(+ &# "# 6# " *&#+ " ( ! 8 $
7#
$
! $#
2? #
!
# F# $$ *&# -"
#$ (&
4
C? )
## -""
" ( "# ( 7 &# ## & # F# $$ *&#
" $ ,#7 ",7 #
,#& (& -""
",
# #, & &"# 9 (7
"# (& #
?# "# ?&, & $#, & #
4 )& '6 3 , & . + (& # C?&, &"# #
6
*&#
+ (&
#( 7 ,
!, # &
,
2? #
!
# F# $$ *&# :& 7 ## & F# $$ *&# " "
7#
@+ -"
(&
#, & + 2#(
,
- # 3# F# $$ *&# " ,# 8 #
& $& ( 2#( & $& - # " "#
# - ( 7 &# 2#( , - # " "# -"# #( " - '( B 8 F!!& 2#( -- "
& (
&# B(#
B 8 0# D&!"# '( 9
# -""# 0#
# &!"# .-,#+ -&
(8 # B(# 0# ! "# 2#( , # ##
"# ,&#
6 # @ ( 2#( , " ! , 7 # @
@
-""
#
# @ F# $$ - $$ + ! ( -# ( 1"&+ 2#( , -7 #( - # " 1"##+ F# $$ *&# ##
6#,
7#
@+ -"
(&
+ ( 2#( ,
- # $#$#7 2? #
!
# F# $$ *&# -# 9 (7
"# F# $$ *&# " ##
6#, #
< ?& ( 2#( , @
"
" !+ "##+
( 6 " !+ -& $$#$# 6#, $ " # #
, - 9 -& $$#$#
# 6-
& #
4
$ 1" *&# -"
!& # $$ 2
" #7 " *&# (& & # 6-
-#
#&( #
&#"#+ # $
#:&# " ! "7 #
( 1" # $
6-
( 7 ((6# &# #$# #
# #
# #+ # #!" 6-
( 2#(
" "
B(# "
0#
"# " "
'& ( # 7+ -#
#:&# " , 7 < ?& ( 2#(
@
" !+ (7 # ,
( 2#( " ?& #!# <
@
6:&" "# # $#$#7
,&# + &" , ",# # "# ( 2#( , -& "# -",# - ( 2#( ,
"# "
$# < 1"##+ -#
# < " "7 -#
#:&# " <
2-+ & ?( , , 6
## 9 (7 !
# '(6 , 6
## 7#
C? )
#& $#& "#+ $$# ( 7 B" ##
$
$#$#7 #6
$# 6 + -""
"
?# 6, &6+ ($#
- 8"#
&(6#
( + "-,#+ -&
(&"
!
&#"#+ '(6 7#
## #
$
#6
$# 1"&+ $$# $
! $# 1" $
&
'(6 7#
@ @
C? )
4+ (&
4
# .-,#+ # -""
",
(
##+ * #
?# #, $-# #& $$#, (&
.-,#+ $#
,# #,# $
$## )# 8$ #7 & ( 7
@+ (&
+ ( 7 B" -# ## - #
$
#6
$# 6
16 ;A> 1" (&
& 7 #
'(6 7#
@ @+
$#6 ( # -"
7#
+ (&
#
#:&# 2#( , " " ! ## # @
,&# 0# B(# -""
- #
@ #, & &"# -# ?$
(&
"# -""
" !
.-,#+ #, & &"# (( 6 & # (&
$# #! 7 - ( 2#( !
# # 1" ### & -"
(&
"# ( 2#( +
6 < @
?& "#
,&# + &" , ",# !"+ A& ### (( #, & &"#+
@ !
$# -# # ## !
3# F# $$ *&# " ##
!
# ?&
+ C? )@ ( 7 &# 1" -"
#$ (&#
8 & ($#
0"- 2 $# '(6 7#
# # 7 $#, $# " $ # "
$#$#7
# -"
#,
$# '(6 7#
+ ($#
8"- 2 ( "# ( 7 &# # #
7#
1"&+ $# " &$
&#"#+ #, & ## #( 7#
# 7 $#, $# " $&#& # ## $
& '7 $
# 6
. + # $ *&# 6 - # ## # $#7 $$ - $ ( & $$ + 7+ # $ +
,- 6,
!
D "#$%#$&'($)*+,-.&$)'/,$0 $'./ "#$%#$&&$(/&%)12$ $'./