High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/6034/2016dismissed

Shiv Dutt Gir v. Kirpal Singh (Since Deceased) Through His Lrs & ORS

2017-07-19Mr. Justice T.H.B. Chalapathi7 pages

!"# #$%&%'()* *

( + , -,.

! "

#### -,. ,

! ""! $ % $& $'!' $&" %"$&

""( ! "(

$ !' $& % )* ++ ,*+)"

""' $& "

+, - ,*+.

/ """! $&

,0" % ! ""'' "1 2 34!1'2 )5!12 0* % $" & ,***( ,**+ !6 7'

' &" ""! '

1 2 308+!1'2 45)!12 .)*

% $" & ,***(,**+ 9 "1 2 34 '1 2 308+! ' &""2 + (' " 1 2 3*!3+!3,!3)!30 !6 6 ' : '$$& "" " 7'

"2 +!' :

&" ' &! 1 $& '&" '"

" 6 ""' " & $ ! '"! (('! ;"2 +! $&'&" $"2 + " ;$ "" (( '

"2 +' !"" % "

" "" $ "" <7 2 .* ! +.

,**)

7 ' "

" 2 + " " $& "" 1 !$' 7!"2 +'!

"" ""

$ % &! ' $ " & ' &"

''"' '$ """

"" "

"2 + = !"2 +

" '

! & $% 9

" " ! "

"' ( + > "" " % &" ?9

, > "" ' ?9 ) > "" '

&?9 " 7 $ 1

!$ $ &' " " $ ! ""& !$& &! " %!

"2 +(

$ !

' $& ! % )* ++ ,*+) < ! " 2 +

$&'&""

!' $ ! % +, - ,*+.

""2 +

@ "

$ "$ % ' 1 & 1(A B:

(0!' 1 2 308+ !'$'1 2 308+ 34 1A !$ "&"! &"

" $

" $ " "

1 2 308+34'% "2 +(

'B:

(+B:

(,"

1 2

3+!3,!05.053 6'$ ' "

1 2 308+34 " < !

"2 +(

" &

!'':' " & 7"! !1 2 308+' ' "

7 $ $"

" 1 2 308+" @!C " $'

'!' % $ 9 ""& $& ! !' & $& $'

' & $ " ' '!!'$ " 6'$$&$ $'

% !' $ !"

%! D &: !

"" '$ !

" $& "

+." % !' $ !

(

!" # #

$ % # & # !"$ !'$ # ()))*) + % , # $& # !" $& # !"- !'# ()))*)

.)*/0 % !'

!'( # ,(,1- 1 # 2 !'/ ,(,/ 2 !'- / 3 # ! # & # !"- !'

4 3

# *

# # #

& #

# # 3 # #

# %

# #

5 " ! "

" & & & " % $& $'

" &;"' $;"'!' ;"

" C ! ':

% +**" C"C

7 ! $ '

'$&@E$ C !/0!'!'!1#'2/!'!'2 !'"3#/4&,#5&360!/1%'%!'2"3#/&7 ) $%8%9 :

!'"&3!;!/%4& </&3""!6%=!/%7 *) 2 ' C " " $! ' " !C " '

!$ "" '&$ 6! " 2" " $

&! ' $ $ !

!' !'

+5 ,*+3 -,. %

7 89 7 :