← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1970/2014dismissed

Haryana State Agriculture Marketing Board & ANR v. M/S The Malt Company (India) Pvt Ltd

2017-01-13Mr. Justice Rameshwar Singh Malik13 pages

     

  !

"#$ %$&'(')*+ 



",-")"#"#$.,'&/0#/,$ ",1$#').",%2")&31/0"")%")#3$, 44$00")#( 5( 6(3$ "0#74")- )%'"!8#9#% $(4)%$)#  * :9  ; 9<  

    

   ; 9<2 9!

      

 

 ! "

!

  % &  '

 (#$     $

  !

   



*     

   $ $ 

+ )  

 $

 

 '  ,   % '



  & % $   $   (   - 

  .     

$     # $

   "! ! " /  

* % $ , 

 

 $ - # $   #$      



 

 0 ( 1  $

  



  . 

( 



  (

 -$   . 

 

 -$ -   2 "30 )     2 4

5 " /

  66

!

  #    0 

8/"

 $ 7 448"8/39 (   $ $ #    #

#$ 



/ "

 !

  $        #  7 !58/:539  ;

 $    7 !58/:539   

7 448"8/39 -      $    2 "

# <5= <8= !

  #    0 

8/"

   #     66

  $

 ( ( ;

 $  )$  

# <5= <8= !

  #    0   

" " " / -     2 "

    3 :5 " ! " / 

       ,  2 4

5 " " / :5

+ " ! " / 

 $     2 "

 (  

 #       #    0 

8/

(   

  #   

8/"

#

 -$    

  ( ;

$   $  #   (( (

  <=

,    2 "

!

" /

# <5= !

  #    0 

8/"

  

 # 



# <

= !

    #      $ #   

     #   2 "

( 

   

     #$  ,   ;

9

    

      ;

 ;

9

  # (  2  $      !

" / 

# <5= !

    $  

 <#=

,

    2 "

/ " " /    $ ;

9 2#$  

 # 

$ +  #

  2 "

 

   2 "

     ($  $ ;

 ,   

$  #$

 <=

,  2 "

  $  #$

 

 $   

 >   #$ 0 ( (    0      # 0 #     

    +   ( #$       

    $     $   #$ ,  

 "!

  #    0 

8/

 # ,      $  #$  

 +   (  ( ?#

  @ ,   

#$ + 

 

  #     (  $ 

#$      

 #   # 1 $ <=

,     2 "

    7 /"8!539   # > AA  2 "   / " " /  2 "

+  $  -6#   $ #

 AA $ $   $    > AA    0 )    #  (  

(    (   #    -6# -  ( -6#

 ,

= #$    " / 

  (    > AA  0 ) (    

   > AA  0 ) (  > AA #$  >     #

 $  0 )    

   $ (  #  

        #  # > AA  2 "

 # . 

 $ . 

 $  #   $  (  

#$  (    #$ <=

, 

     #$   (  ( 

#$ (             1 #  *  ( -6# )  -$   +  $ ' (   #  (  

 '    ( +  $ "  (     (  / / " 

(     

 (   

  (

 1  (    ,  #$    

    $

 # 0 #    

>  ,    

 1 $ , $     ;

$  $ #  1 

 #   $  

  

 )  1 



     

  

   $ (

    

 

 

 $         $ -  # #(  

( $      

     $    $  

   -    # $     2 "

  ( '

 %

  $   '

      '

 -

        

(  

   $ #  B      (

  C 

  2 4

5 " " /   

D B C  :5 " ! " / ( 

 # D B% !

C 

 $

  D B% :

C #  D B% C  

 (   D B% / C   (  D B% C #

 

 7 D B% C   $ . D B% 7      0 #  #

    $ (    

 





  #

         $  $ $  %  2 4

5 " " /  :5 " ! " /  1     7 /"8!5 /39 $  -(  

$ (  

 1 

 %    -(  

  # 

      (  ( >  



 

 ! "

! 

 -      

( 

? 



A  0

 $

$ 

 -   

 9 $    

   

$

$ $ 0

#

(  

 (    0      #(      

$   $ ( $

$ 

  )

  (  (    >   

 $   $ #

        $  $  #

    9    

     $ 

 

(   #  $     $ 

   

   0

 #   # # 

#

  (  ( 

 ( $ 

 (       >  ( (

 $

     $   

  ( 



  ,   #   >  

 (    

 

   

   

       

        

       

    !

          

                           

!

"  

   

       !

    #

   $    %%&'(   %)*%+&%*%,

 *+!*,!**+  

' -* -+

  

.

     

            

! 

         *%!*+!**' *!%%!**'                        *+!*,!**+

      !

"                  -! + ,%*%/&) *%!*+!**'   *!%%!**'  .  

                         



    

 !    

  

           00  !

       



1  .  2     34        

5        

     

 

   .   -* 

   

         00       

          !             *      

   !"   1 2       

     00 

   

6  !    

 

    1$  5  76  

34 2  3" 47 !0 !1  

      

       5   34!8 C 0 ( 9  #

 "!

  #     0 

8/

<  6 6=  $      $ ( 

   #    ( 

   (   #   9 $   $   > 

   >     $  $



  

   , # 

( 0    (

 -6#

 (   ",-")"#"#$.,'&/0#/,$ ",1$#').",%(5(3")$(3 '&$")%$)$,"0 '00(2  !?>

 $((,(")$(3##)74")-5(3$ ",1$#77'##$$2 <#<"4/,"")%#3$,(2 >

!9 /)@"A!=  + 6(  "7$(3B",  "((  "/,'  3")1$,  5(  3$  ",1$# 77'##$$200$)"A"%2

9+   6(,$73")%"79"02").,/,5(3$#"#$ /)@"A ")%#3$,(2  /)@"A!=  = "."#@'#)%/(#,'$(9#%5(#"#$ /)@"A2 +9=  7 

    $ (

(  ( -6#

 (   # 

 $  >    ( ( 

9  

 

(         

 "!

 #

 



#$ + 

 

 ,  



       (  $ 

#$

   #

    

 #  $ 1 $ # E    

  $ B  AA  $ # 0 )     (   

(      ( (   $ (  ( -6#

 ( # 



+      9      F1 !5 9  0

  ( ;

 $



 "!

 ( # (

 >    $     (     ( #   $   E     $    >    ( ( 

   

  ( A     ;

 (    # ;

 ( #

   (  ;

 

      ( 1







) )       (  ( -6#

 ","-")") "@$)%,")")%")#3$,5( 9$1(37-",@')'")%#3$,(2

=!

>  

 

+ )

       #   (   

(  7



  ($   #  ( #    

      7 $ ( #  #    7



    (  (    C ; 9<D

!

 

 C 0 3 G32 C # G32