Punjab State Warehousing Corporation v. Madan Mohan Thtai
!"!#$!%&'((
#&'&)'*!%&'+((
+ ,-. ( . ..
- ****
!"
!
$
!"
/'%!!0 &)%1234 ( %&'
"
())(()&* + ,
- .
/
&*)&()&0 +! - % ,!' .
/ %('
+"
+! ##"
.
/
1 2
!
- &3&445 6 2
2 7 "" 2!" # "$+ 28
- % ' ,
.
/ 9 " +" !
: "" ;##"
#
2 # (&&&444 (0&&444 (<&&444 (=&&444
2 7 "" "!"
2 "
$
"
# "$# "
+ &44&14(&44(1432"
" > :# 2" # 2
+
- 2 - "
3))0&4442 2"
+
#
, - 9 %
' 2
?@ + ;##"
2
@ +
+ " A& 2
2
" A(
" "$ 2 62
,
#" A( @ +##"
"
#"
"$# "
+ &44&14( &44(143 B"
<))
#
-
# "$ # <C &)C
"$ .9 "
( )< )3 )==81# #
%3' ; # @ +
2
,
2" 2
! 2" + # 54 <( 0=40= " *)C" " "" # #5(&030D 2 "
+ &44=144 ( )< )3 )==81 "
+.9 %> :'# "
+ &44&14(&44(143 2 +2
+
2 7 2
+
+
#
!"
" "
+2
(0 55 &<<53#
#
1" # "!
$
+# !
1 %0'
" # #2 1
- 3 -
! "
! #
$% ! & '
( %*' $ "
! +
" !
&*)&()&0
1 ## " A& !
#!
! "$"
#
#
E
@
$
#
! "
2 $ +
##
" +
1 +
%5'
1 ##
2"
!
())(()&*##
"
2 #2
! 1 )
' *
+ , -
%+ %
% $ % #./
, 0$ 0 1
- 4 - $% 2 %
3 ) 4 5 6'* 5
%
$
% 2 1
% % , % 1
% $
2 2 % $ 7+'
8 $ % 2 1 % $
% $
2
% 8
2 % 8 $ %
$%$
$ 92 % !: ;
$ " 0 $ < % 9
$
% 2 5 %
% %
%
$ % , 8 !6 < , , 5
1 , =' >
??& "&... %
0 1 ;
$ =>
???"??? @???A??? $ $%' *
5
B ???
8 !6
- 5 - #5 9 %
3 #."
$% 1
5
$
%5 $
% 3
$ ' '( %<' :
" # " 2 !
!
+
#"
2
" # #
+
6 "
"
"#
> "
! # $ "
" )5&(()&( 2
"
# #
+2 " #"
+
##
+ %=' !
+ " 2 !
"
#"
+" !
"$
-
!
"
2 2 7 $ "
+
# 2 2 "$
2"
2 #
+# "
%4' ;
" #
!
+
#
!"
+"
- 6 -
" 1
2 ## + ++ 6 #
"
5 #
" # "$ 2
2 #
!
"
.9# # # ##"# 2# "!"
.9
# +
# %&)' " #
" %&&' 2" 3) &444 @ + 2 ""
""
%?B3' " A& 2 2 " A(
"$2 62
+""
@ +
1 ## #
+ "+ 2 "
"
)()3())4 %?B,3' + #
#
# +
$
# 7!
2"2 ### "!
+ 1 ## 2 +
+ " %&(' .
" 2 !
""
# 1 ## # F
6 - %
' 2" + " 2
- 7 - "$"
# "
?B,* ,=+ ##2
2 "$
2 " ##
# )&)3&445
&0)5()))"
"
+ 1 ## %&3'
""
#+ "
+ # E 2 " & 2
1 B
$2 " #"
+ " "
+ & 2
# %&0' ?! + " + ! B
" #+
2 "$
!
2
2
-%
' ( A
"
1 B
" 1
#
%?B('
+@
+ +
"
+ " @ # # 2"2
" 1
#"
2
!
# " # "$ 2 !
+
( A
,
F
*)C + ( "
" 2 "$
!"
2 ! " 2 22
"$ #B *)C " "# #+ B
9 ! " 2 +
- 8 -
" " # "$ "
%&*' .
# 3 : #
D +
%
' " 2 +" !
%?B&' E "
"
$ + #"
"
E
-
"$ # 2
E
!
##"
"$
"
! "$2"2
2 "#"
"
B #
! "$ 7!
" " "
# +
2 "
" %&5' 9 ! 2 # !
" # + + " 2 %&<' , &5)&()(* CC
/'%!!0 &)%123
)%1!
1. Whether speaking/reasoned?
Yes/No
2. Whether reportable?
Yes/No