High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/6143/2016dismissed

Vijay Rani v. Shakti Parshad And ORS

2018-05-11Mr. Justice Arun Monga4 pages

!"##$%&%'(!)* + ,%-!) !'% ..#//!'"

,#0&1& 2!3"% !0&2!4 "2#0& #&.'4#'"& !

"#$%& '( )* & *)+%

0#&#'"( 01'%/!05*46$!"#* 0"2#!..#//!'" 77777 *)+%,' 8

0 "2# 0#!&'& 9#'"%'#4 %' "2# !../%$!"%'* :2%$2 %& &1..0"#4 ;) !' !%4!6%"* 4#/!) 4!)& %' 0#8%/%'5 "2# !..#!/ %& $'4'#4 &"!'4&4%&.&#4

..#//!'"8./!%'"% %& !550%#6#4 "2# $'$100#'" %'4%'5&* :2#0#;)"2#&1%"&##3%'54#$/!0!"%'04#/#"%'5"2#'!9#4##'4!'" %' "2# &!/# 4##4 ;#!0%'5 ,!&%3! <= 4!"#4 =

< :%"2 0#$"%%$!"%';)9%""%'52%&'!9#!'450!'"%'54#$/!0!"%'"2!""2#./!%'"% %&!;&/1"#:'#0%'.&&#&&%'21&#9#!&10%'5> &?)!04&*&%"1!"#4%'

2!//!!10%!'2!"%!' !"%!/!:%"2$'&#?1#'"%!/0#/%#.#09!'#'" %'-1'$"%'&##3%'50#&"0!%'"!5!%'&"4##'4!'"!'42%&!5#'"&09 4%&.&&#&&%'5 !'4 %'"#0#0#'$#* 91$2 /#&& !/%#'!"%'* 2!& ;##' .!0"/) 4#$0##4;)"2#"0%!/10"!'4!%09#4;)"2#@:#0..#//!"#10" 01'%/ !05* /#!0'#4 $1'&#/ 0 "2# !..#//!'"8./!%'"%

&1;9%""#4"2!""2#&1%"!0#9#'"%'#4:!&%/#4!6#00%'5"2#0#%'"2!" !""!'

2!'4*21&;!'4"2#./!%'"%4%#4%'6#9;#0*

>/#!6%'5;#2%'4 ./!%'"%*104!152"#0&!'4'#&' /!%'"%*;#%'5!01&"%$6%//!5#0*:!& '"!:!0#"2#01/#&!'40#51/!"%'&%'"%"/#4##4"2#.0.#0")/#";)2#0 21&;!'4*:2#0#!&"2#0!9%/)9#9;#0&.09%&#4"2#/.2#0##'4!'" 2!3"% !0&2!4*;0"2#04#$#!&#4:2:!&0#&%4%'5!" !"%!/!*1&#4 "$9#%'"2#6%//!5#"!&&%&""2#./!%'"%!'42#0$2%/40#''"2#9'"2 6#9;#0*

*4##'4!'"&#!0$2#4!21&#*:2%$2:!&'&!/#!'4 &2:#4%"""2#./!%'"%2#&!/#.0%$#:!&&#""/#4;)4##'4!'":%"2 4##'4!'":'#021&#!&<* *

A8 /!%'"%!50##4"&#//2#0 21&#$'&"01$"#4%'"2#/!'49#!&10%'5>&?)!04&%',%//!5#@!'5"'# !".!/%'520!&19 *= *

A8!'4%'/%#1"2#0#*#B#$1"#4!'

!50##9#'""&#//'"2#0.0.#0")9#!&10%'5<+&?)!04&:!&&/4" !".!/ C!10* !09%" C!10 !'4 !'-%" C!10 0 ! $'&%4#0!"%' *> *

A8##'4!'"1&#4"5#"!//"2#.!.#0&0#5!04%'5"2#&!/# !'4.10$2!&#&$0%;#4#&%4#&"2#!0#9#'"%'#4.!)9#'":2%$2./!%'"% 0#$#%6#4!"#0&#//%'5":.0.#0"%#&*&2#:%"240#: *

A809"2# ;!'3 ' =

< !'4 !/& &/4 5/4 0'!9#'" 0 *

A8 2# ./!%'"%.!%4!&19<* *

A8"4##'4!'"!&&!/#.0%$#"2#&1%" .0.#0")!'4!/&.!%4 < *

A8"4##'4!'"0"2#.10$2!&# &"!9..!.#0&##'4!'"5""2#&!/#4##4&$0%;#4;#0#0#!$2%'5 "2#./!%'"%%'"2#%$#1; #5%&"0!0 /!%'"%5"!&"'%&2#4:2#'2#0 4!152"#0*!"#00#!4%'5"2# &!/#4##4*"/42#0"2!"4##'4!'":!& 9#'"%'#4!&$8:'#0""2##B"#'"2!/&2!0#%'"2#&1%".0.#0")"%& %'"2#&#$%0$19&"!'$#&*"2#&1%"!0#9#'"%'#4:!&%/#4*0*4##'4!'" 2!4./!)#4!0!141.'"2#./!%'"%

2#!0#9#'"%'#4&1%":!&$'"#&"#4;)4##'4!'";) %/%'5:0%""#'&"!"#9#'"*:2#0#%'.0#/%9%'!0);-#$"%'?1!9!%'"!%'!;%/%") ;#&%4#&"2#0;-#$"%'&:!&"!3#'":!&&"!"#4"2!""2#./!%'"%:!&!:!0# "2#!;6#&!%4/#5!/2#%0&10!3&2! !'%!'4%'04#0"50!;"2#&2!0# 10!3&2! !'%05#4!'4!;0%$!"#4!D%//4!"#4

10!3&2!

!'%D2#'#6#0"2#./!%'"%#/"'#$#&&%")0"2#2#/.4##'4!'"* '#!$2$$!&%'4##'4!'"#B"#'4#42#/.;)6%&%"%'5"2#21&#2# &!/#.0%$#"2#21&#%'?1#&"%':!&&#""/#4;)"2#./!%'"%!'44##'4!'" :%"24##'4!'":%"2"2#%'"#06#'"%' !-C19!02#&!/# 4##4:!&#B#$1"#4%'"2#.0#&#'$#1; #5%&"0!0*:20#!46#0"2# $'"#'"&"2#&!/#4##4%'"2#.0#&#'$#"2#./!%'"%!'44##'4!'"* 91$2 /#&& "2# 9!05%'!/ :%"'#&& 2# &1%" :!& !/& ;!00#4 ;) /!: /%9%"!"%' 2#"0%!/10"*'"2#;!&%&"2#!0#9#'"%'#4./#!4%'5&* 0!9#4"2#//:%'5%&&1#&(8

#&1;9%""#4"2!""2#10"&;#/:2!6##00'#1&/)4%&9%&&#4 "2#&1%"!&!0!14!'49%&0#.0#&#'"!"%'2!4;##'./!)#41.'"2#./!%'"%

2#10"&;#/:!0#;!&%'5"2#%0-1459#'"&!'44#$0##&'"2#D%//4!"#4

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

<* :2#0#!& "2# &1%" :!& %/#4 %' "2# )#!0 0 !// "2%& .#0%4* ' #B./!'!"%'2!&$9#0"20'"!6!%/%'5"2#0#9#4)2#!//#5#4!$$01!/ $!1&#!$"%'%'"2#9'"26#9;#0*

>%&!'!"#0"2152"*0* "2#4##'4!'"2!&.!0"#4:%"2"2#9'#)"$!''";#;#/%#6#4"2!""2# $'"#'"&"2#&!/#4##4:#0#'"0#!46#00:#0#'"%'"2#3':/#45# 2#./!%'"%%&'"!;/#".06#"2##'"%0#.!)9#'"<* *

A8*"21&* !%/#4"4%&$2!05#"2#'1&""2#;#&"*"2#0#9#4):!&"&##3.!0"%"%'* 0*;"2"2#.!0"%#&*%#*./!%'"%!'44##'4!'":#0#$8&2!0#0&

0"2#0#!&'&&"!"#4!;6#*"2#$'$100#'"%'4%'5&!$" !'4/!:!00%6#4!";)"2#10"&;#/:4'"$!//0!')%'"#0#0#'$#* 91$2/#&&!')?1#&"%'/!:!0%&#&04#"#09%'!"%'

#&1/"!'"/)*"2#!..#!/%&4%&9%&&#4

-,.

*)+%

/01 '(23& +141056 70

807

+141 49!

807