High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/4799/2015dismissed

Punjab State Ware Housing Corporation v. M/S Shiv Shankar Rice Mills And ORS

2017-04-25Mr. Justice Hari Pal Verma9 pages

!"#$!! "!%%&& '() *+ "' ,"$ *"--! % !"

# "$

....

( *( &,)/(0(/1 1

(0%%&& ...

% (3( 0%%&

) ( $$ %(% 40 0( 0%%&50

0 0(5

6 7 8 (0( 0%%&

1/ && 5

00( 0%%& %(% 9)% : ( 3

& (3( 0 %%&

) ( 0 - / ( 5 0 $$ ( &3

& 40%(%%& 8 (0( 0%%&

1/ && 5

&3 3

& 40%(%%&

(3( 0%%&

) ( $$

&3 ; 3 (

& 40%(%%& 8 (0( 0%%&

1/ && 5

&3 ; 3 (

& 40%(%%&

0 %%&&.%&

.)<: (0 ) 4 $ (% ( =0( ( (( >%&

?@ 0

0 %( 4)&( %%& 4 0 <) 4/ (

% :3 &(

& (

) 41 4()(1 50(:30 (%%&4 0<) 4/ ( % :3&(

&$ &) 4= ( @14()(1 5

/ ( &3 10%&

) (( 2(3

A1B7+. 52(10

) 150

A;15 0 (5 :30%&

/ ;B 0 (% .

0 &

(( 2(3

1B1BA+. & 4 5 0 ( 4 0 %&

. )(

/ 0( (1 5 &30 /50

05(C) (

( :30( &$ )(%(0

:3 0(% .

=0( ( (( > /?@10

/1 () 4

0&&() (0/ 3&

*+0 209(

* &&1( 1* 91 (

4()(1

(0&/33( /0 &%( %( ( 0

.7.

0&&( 00&&(5/ && 4%

( %(/

0 : & 2( 40()&(

5 0 )3 &1 ( /%&3 4 0 (/ D

0 4(/1 ( :5 0 %( "03(.7100&&( 0 /5 && 0 %&

( 0 %)(% / && 4 0 %

4&31 4(/ 5 6 ) :5 0 %( 7 %(0(/D

04(/10

/ ()( 0 ()& (

52(1 0 )(

/5 & ( 2/ && 0(4 ( /0 %(/1 0 / /(

1;177+. ( /0%&

/ )54

( /0 / 6 :3( 45( 4

&&4& /

4&3 (03(.108$14()(1 ( ) && %

3 (0%)(% / && 4 0 / )& ) &0 /

0 )

4 / ) 11+.

4&310

/ )5

:30 /2

7BA BA) 0( (4 0:0 %&

1 0( / A17B+.

5( 0%&

%(/5 0 (50) (( 2(3

(

/ ) A17B+. 04( ) 00%&

( 2 0) / )%&) 0(6% 0) !0 /

:30 )(

5 ) 0%&

+ .

/ 0 %&

(%&31 3 40 0 / 0

/ (/ E )(:&E 0)

:30%&

0 /0 2 &)( &3 0) / )1 03 ( %% ( /

& / %(0% &

3 (0 ,0( 10 /5: ) /90%3/) (0 % &

3 ( 4 4 0 &

(5 0( (1 0 %&

%(/0&4&( 40 %0&& / 2 )( )(

/ /:(( "0: 00 / ) A1B7+.54

:&3

&0) 0 :5 0 (5:30%&

/0 A1B7+.%&) 0(6% 0 ) 10 // 2 %%&

) (!( ( ; )& $$ ( / / 0 / 50(:3 0

&) 0

/ ) A1B7+.50

05 0(5

:30 /) ( )("0 /(10

/ 0 ( / 1B1BA+. & 4 5 0

( -( ( & $ )(1 2

<) 4/ (

1 ( 0 / 0 )(

/ 0& 00 / & ( 2(0 / ) 1B1BA+. 1;177+.& 45 0 (F;G%( )/ ( /0

& ) A; && )&(& H & & ( 2(0/ ) A;1+.& 45 0 ( F;G%()/5 ;B &&(& H 0/ )

44( 2 4 0 (

<) 4/ (

% :30( &$ )(10%&

. /

%%& 52(10%%&5&

/ :30- 5( %%&&$ )(2

<) 4/ ( " 0 (

)/ 10%%&&.%&

0%(4)&( %%& -( )& ( 0 %%&& 0 (4) 0 0 <) 4/ (% :3: 00 )(:& 5(4 &5

)(:& 502 %( %(&3 (( &3 (%( 0&5

0 0 0 / 0

A1B7+. 0 5 0 (5 0 ) 1 0( (1 50 & && 5 4 / / 0 /1 0 )( :& 5 02 5( 4&3 5( 0/ ) :30 /

0* &&(0 & 2( (

( ) 4G 4 ( /0%

( 5 00 / %(0* &&(1 &3BC) &&(

& 2( :30 / 0* &&(0 & )& &3;17;;+.%3:& 0%%&&.%&

) &(

150 &%(0 0

)& :30# 2(/ "

10:

4 %3:& (/ %

3 0%%&&.%&

0(4

71BB1A+.4 &(

)%%& :30* &&( 0)

7;;C) & 0/ /1&& 5 0* &&(0:

4/ ) 4 1A17+. ) 0( 2(:&/ )

/ A17B;+.

) &(

& 2( +:

4 0%(3 0 5

( BA1+. 0)1: 00

.;.

)(:& 5025( 4&3&& 5 0 / "020( &( )& (0%%&&

0 (4)/1 ( :3 &( )& ( 0 %%&&1 00 /0 0/ ) 0( (10 / )

) :

% (0 ( 0:353 / / 0 /10) / )

0: &) 0 / 0/ / )40:3 0 /5&& 5 :30( & )(1:) ) 0/ /52( 0&&4 :30%%&&.%&

: ( 3 0(0 40( ()/ 0/ )5 ) (0

/%&& 4

)/ 1 0 / 0

(% ( 0

/ )& 45 0 0(/ ) 0

/ "%( 0- 5(%%&&$ )(10%&( :3 0%%&&.%&

0: &5 0 0 && 5 4/(.

> (

4 &( & 5($ )( ) B( ( 10 + / 02

0 / ( ( 2(3

1B1BA+. " ( ( %( 20 /1

/ /0%%( 05 : 6 . % 0 0 03 ( () 4(

0&&( ( /0& /33(

)(0( 0 )( 40 ( %3( .71 %&

+%%&&&& (0 ) // &&

3 0 +(% 03 )%%& &(

B7I) & (

1 (50

035( )3: ) %3)/ ;7;;+.

0 %(/ /5 & ( 2/ && 0(4 ( /0 %(/150

/ ) :1;177+." /9 40 %3/ 0/1

0 ) ( 2(3 5 )/ 1B1BA+. )

4 4 0 %%&&+%&

5 ( .6/ &40:30&(

)& (0%%&&+%&

)( 4( &1:)0 0 0( 0 (

& 3 ( 6( 30 2 )(:& 0%&

+%%&&"0

( .6/ 10 5 0 / 0 %

3/ && (03(.714(/ 67 56 ) :50%( / && 45 : %(0 &)/ 0 4(/ 8( /0 5 1%&

)& %( 20503 0302 %

)/ 1;177+. 0

+(% 503 %&

)/ A1B7+. ( /0 :3

& 40%() 0 &35 %%( 4 :0& 0 %(/ .# 0,)/( 0 % 0%(

)/ 6 0(

)/%& 0

&1 /5 %3)/ 11;+. 0((% 02 &&4 0 %&

0 %3 )/

;1B71A;+./ && 0(4 ;11;+. (% ( 0(4"0 531)/ 117+.

5 ) 5( 0/ &&($ )( /0

!& )( 3 )/

11+.:3 6 BA

& A17B+. 2

A"0 5310 /0 %

)/ 1717B+./ ( 50(0%&

.B.

5 & ( 2( &3)/ 117+. ( ) 40: 2

/ )10%&

0 ( 2 )/ 1;177+. 4

)/ A;1+. )( 40%

0%() 0)1 &(0%&

+ .

/ 0 4 1B1BA+.

/ ( ( /0 + / 0( 0 4 0

& %( 20 0%&

5 & ( 2()/ A;1+. ( /0

+ /50

054

)( 40% 3 0) 2 /

&(:30%%&&00 50 0 %&&3 / :(( 0( &&4& 3 (

((4)&( 3 0

4 &( & 5($ )(

) B 0

4(0(:3

(/ ?

!0: (

450(:30 )(

/ 5 0& & ( 2 / && 4 0(4 ( / 0

%(/ ( /9 4%3/ () 0/ && 0(410

) (( 2(3

4&31/ )

1B1BA+.5 )

44 0%%&&.%&

/0/ && 0%

3() :30

%(/10( (10 /5 & / && 0(4 ( /0 %(/50

0 & 40(C)

& )& "0 : :30%&

/0 / && 0%

3 1 :& 0

00 /0 / && 0%

310* &&( & 0/ && 0(45&& 0(

& 0(4 / :& ) (0% &

3+()&

.A.

0(% (4) ): &C) &5( 0%((4)&( %%& "2 5 : 210 $ )(

( ( 0 %( (4)&( %%& 50

0 :

)((

4&310%(4)&(

%%&

00(%9 4+( J K+

00((% (:&J K+