Jagsir Singh v. Beant Singh

  

         

!"#$#%&'&()

* !+'&,&(+-  ..#//!("

0#,'1'

#!("&(+-  #'.($#("

)  23   4 3  ,#'#(")5 , !1,!6-!,7!8$6%!"#8,!..#//!("  9-#"-#,"-# #.,"#,'/%!/(#:'.!.#,7!;<#!//:#$" '##"-#=1$+7#(">
 <#,##,,#$""-# #.,"#,,("  9-#"-#,"-#=1$+7#("'-1/$<#,#.,"#$&("-#$&+#'"> 55 55 3 

3 -&'  #+1/!,  #%($  ..#!/  &'  !+!&('" "-#  =1$+7#("  $!"#$ ?
8.!''#$<;"-#/#!,(#$ &'",&%"1$+#8!,(!/!8 !&,7&(+"-# =1$+7#("  !($  $#%,##  $!"#$  @
8  .!''#$  <;  /#!,(#$  &6&/  1$+#

1(&,&6&'&( 8!,(!/!86&$#:-&%-'1&"./!&("&5,#'.($#(" :!' $#%,##$, '?8?8

58&(%/1$&(+&("#,#'"1.""-#$!"#&/&(+'1&" ("#,#'".#($#("/&"#!""-#,!"#@A.#,!((17,7"-#$!"#&/&(+ "-#'1&""&//"-#$!"#$#%,##!($1"1,#&("#,#'"!""-#,!"#A.#,!((17 (.,&(%&.!/!71(",7"-#$!"#$#%,##"&//&"',#!/&B!"&(:!'!/' !//:#$ #!,$ '.#,"-#%!'#./!&("&5,#'.($#("8$##($!("5!..#//!("-!$ <"!&(#$!/!( '?8

5(
*
!($#C#%1"#$!.,("#!($ !,#%#&." &( -&'!61, (:,&""#('"!"#7#("8$##($!("5!..#//!("-!$ $#(&#$ "-#  !$6!(%#7#("    /!(  !($ #C#%1"&(   .,("#  !($  ,#%#&." :#6#,8-#!$7&""#$"-!"./!&("&!($$##($!("!,#%/'#,&#($'

5
5 ##($!("5!..#//!("-!$"!D#("-#'"!($"-!"-#-!$'7#%&6&//&"&+!"&( ,#+!,$&(+'7#/!($.#($&(+:&"- !(=&"4!1,8'&'"#,&(/!:#D&(+-8 :--!$&/#$!'1&" !+!&('"-&7  !(=&"4!1,:!'",;&(+"$&'.''#''

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
*
&(!61,"-#./!&("&> 
 9-#"-#,"-#./!&("&&' #("&"/#$,,#%6#,;!'.,!;#$,>

  &''1# !($&''1#
!,#.,6#$  9-#"-#,"-# ./!&("&&'#("&"/#$,&("#,#'"&'!":-!",!"#>  E 9-#"-#,"-#'1&""-#./!&("&&'("7!&("!&(!</#>   9-#"-#,"-#./!&("&-!'(%!1'#!%"&(!($/%1''"!($&" &/#"-#.,#'#("'1&">  

#/&# "-"-# 1,"'<#/:"D"-#6&#:"-!"#C#%1"&(.,("# !($,#%#&."!,#.,6#$-#,#,#8"-#/:#, 1,"$#%,##$"-#'1&"

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

&(+-8:- &' :,D&(+ :&"-   '!&$ $##$ :,&"#,!/6&,&(+-8:!'   (" #C!7&(#$#(",;:!'1($&("-#,#+&'"#,!/6&,&(+-   !7    "-#   6&#:  "-!"  !,$##.  &(+-  :!'  :,D&(+  :&"- !/6&,&(+-!,$##.&(+-&'(",#F1&,#$"7!D##(",;,#+!,$&(+'%,&<#

5E5 .,("#!($,#%#&."&("-#,#+&'"#,!/6&,&(+-!/6&,&(+-(/;&' "7!D##(",;$%17#("&(-&',#+&'"#,:-&%-:!''%,&<#$<;-&7-#,# !,#%(%1,,#("&($&(+'!%"',#%,$#$<;": 1,"'<#/:-#,#&'( .#,6#,'&";&("-#&($&(+'": 1,"'<#/:/!:.&("!,&'#'&( .,#'#("%!'#-#,#&'(+,1($"&("#,#,#&("-#%(%1,,#("&($&(+' ": 1,"<#/:-#,#,#8&('"!("!..#!/&'$&'7&''#$

3    

* '=D' 9-#"-#,'.#!D&(+ ,#!'(#$ ) #' 9-#"-#, #.,"!</# )