High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/43557/2019dismissed

Ashmit v. State Of Haryana

2019-11-06Mr. Justice Hari Pal Verma7 pages

!" #$% &" '''(&& " )$*$ +&,&

-,.,," '''$/ &"

00000 ($& "1"+"2!+ #

,&3&% "+*4+%,5!#

&%/&& " $"6,5,/&7,*!#"#"6"!-,.,," "(,/)8!#

,&, "7""+%,!#

/4,,&" "+*4#55,3,4,"1,3,%,+5%/$ " 9% * &$ #:*$ & , &,8 $* ;&& ,44;*$&:/& $" $&,$$/ $

9% /&& %,$ 4 &% /$& /&& * +& < "(""

5,&

,&/,& . ,4=> " ,&""* +& $ ! ! ! ! ! , 2,3&%+& >( 5$&,&( 4+&,& 4?$!+$,!$&&+$," 9% ,

$, => 3,$ 5$& ,& &% %$&

@$%,7,$%3,"#$/&%=>! <"",&,

*& "(""!3%$% 3,$/,$$5&% *5%7

8,A,4$&&$ ,$& 5 & ,8&!/&&

#$% & $&,&, *$5% . ,445% , , 3%&%

&* ,8! $%

* &%,& , , 2%,

* $$&

/&& #$% & 3,$

,85% ,, & $$5 % *$$3%$%%,&* ,8! $%

*&%,&7$%,,,;*!3% ,

&%,$$&$/& 4.

#$% &!%,,4$ ;

&% , *$5, ,85% "9%

/4,,&&& $& /&% ! *&&%/&& &%,&%&%,&%344 &,%& /$,3%4, *$5%!%,$8%& ,44% ,&%"9%

/4,,&$&44,$8% &%,& %%,,.5*5,5,$&%!%,

3,&%.,&,48,

*&&"+% *&%,$8% &%%$% *4,44 &%/ 4 $%344,44&%/ 4! *&,.,$!% *$& &, *$% , ,8 % " 9%, &! $% , , ,44 & &% +*/&&

( 4,

% &%,&&%/&& ,4 53&%3

%$ , 4. 3,$%*45, *$$, ,85% "9%+"("%,,$$*%&%,&% 344$,(,344

!$ ,$& ,$&,3%,& %,$,4454. 5,/%"- 3 !*5&%$/ $$!3%$%3,$ &*5& 3,$%% *$!7$%,2%,

%,/*44%

/4,,&%,!3%,$, ,5, ,,, 3 %5%&

&*& 3%%$% 44 3"9%, &!#$% &/&& 3,&& 5 ,,,

3 %%,, & $, %$4 !$%,$%5%&, , &%$/ $$!%5%&, $*

;*.",3%4! *8 3/$ ,4$ ,%&%,%/*44%

%"9%, &!,44&%,*$ &%,$%% ,4.,&& $,&%%

", ,& 4#$% & /&& &%,& % ,&% $ &445 % & $,&% &%

4 /%

/4,,&" + &%

/4,,& %, &% * %

!&%/ $$

$,&%5&%

!7$%,/*44

%%,!3%,$/&& #$% &5, , % 4 &%8", ,5, %,;*. &%4 &$

%$&

,%3&%, $%,/

;&! 3%% $% 3,$ % 45 % %," > &% ,& ! ( ,%&%$/ &,, ,$,&%%

,,& 3,$% % *$"9%, &!,;*,*$;*. %4 &45"(&& #$% &%, $&,&& ,5&%

/4,,&$&%% *$,& 844%, & 4,85 % ," 9%, &! ,44 &% ,*$ $&,& ,555 % $ , , & %,5%$!&%/ 45 & 3

%4,& 4&%,*$ &%,& 3&$ *5%,% 3 *%&%.344 ,&%"*5&%$!, , 5, , $& 3 &% 4 & $

/4,,&B$ 8! 3%,$ % , ,B$

&%7$%,/*$%%& 3,$&%3,44"9%

/4,,&8/&

C*$&5&%/ 4& %,

! *&&%/ 4 5&%

"9%. &,44 3%& ,44,&% % *$

&%/% "9%, &!$%,44&%+*/&&

( 4

% ,&%B$ /% ! 3% %, ,% &% $/ . &%$ & " 9% +*/&&

( 4 ,$$* % &%,& &% +( -,C*,& 344 ,% &% $% &4.! *& *5 &%$ & ! , , %, 5 % /% 3%% 3,$ $,&% & ,;, 7,$3, , #,;&! 3% *&% 5, &% /% & #$% &,4&% *,3,.

&%,$/&%/,&4.

5&%/ 4!#+>+* &%,,44 3% & *,3,.

&% , & 5& &% /%

% " ,3%4! &% +( -,C*,& , &% / 4

,4$

&% A

( 4 +&,& ,4$ ,% &%" 9%

/4,,& %, ,,& &% 3% 4 $& . & &% ,

&%,&&%,&*5&%$ 5%&!$%3,$,.5,/ 4.&% ,5% %,!3%% &,%/*$! $*&,%/$ ,4/,/$%,

$,&%,3,.">&%$,/*$!,,

$"!D,$%!,#9 ,, &&.,$34.5"*5&%$ 5%&!&%

/4,,& *4 &, $/&,4$

&%,*$"- 3 ! 4$&5%$*

5$!&% / 4,*&% &$%,,$8%& 5&%$4 &,&

&%% $/&,4, &%, &! % $&,& & 344 " # & ,%5 &% % $/&,4! $%

, * $ *$ ,*$

&% ;*$ $*

&% &" 9%, &! 5,5 $ *$$$!$%5 & %$&,& &&% /$

% ,&%1,8,," "1"+"2!4,$ *$4,//,5

&%/&& %,$,5*&%,&&%/&& $ &,%,$ ,4$4. /4,& &% ,$ . &%

/4,,&" > ,&! &%

/4,,& %,$ / &% &

, 4.

-,3,+5%4*5&%/&& !3% $$

-,3,+5%" 9% &%,*$,7$%,!, ,,,;*!3% ,

&%,$$&$ $/& 4.

&% /&& " E &% 4 $ 4,& $ %, ,4$ /4,&3%%4*#,;&+5%!3% $$ 4,3

-,3,+5% , &%4,& ,;,7,$3,"9%

/4,,&$4 $4,& $

!,$$%$ *$$$&

-,3,+5%"+%$&%,*5%&

,&,4*4

-,3,+5% ,&%

&%/&& , 44&5,& ,$ 5, /4

4,$,4,./5 &36 /,47$%,

/4,,& , 2,43,&

-,3, +5% &% *&

+* $ ,4 1*,4 ,5$&,&! E44, ,! $&& +$," > & $&&4 $ 3&%2,43,&!3% $,4

-,3,+5%!&%/$&=>%,$

5$&$ ,$&

*&/$$**/ &% "9%/ 4,%&% $/ &,&%/$

/ 4

,4$!&%

/4,,&%, , %

&%,*$/$ $"+%%,,445&%,&&%/ 4

&%4/5&&5&%/%

&%,*$! *&&$%5%4. /

, 4&%,&,$54/% , %,

& &3

&/$ $ $ *4&, *$4."

, $,&% .&3 /$ $"9%

/4,,&%,$8&&,3& & /4,&&%& , 4.

-,3,+5%&%$,$3%%$ &%3$, ,4$,$"9%,445& %, &,8 /4, <""! 3%,$ &% => 3,$ 5$& """#$/&%?

/4,,&!&%$ $*% &;*.

&%/$

/4,,&,&%;*$3%%%, & &%?

/4,,&!33&% 4*&3,/ "9%$ $*% 3%&%

*+& >($,&&,&&%,$">& $*5&,4!

*$! .4,5 !&%&,4 *&3 *4,;*,& &% *4/, 4&.

&% ,*$" 9%

/4,,& $ %, &*,4 ,85

/4,&$,$%%,$ ,, ,4$,

/4,&,5,$&-,3, +5%,%$ , 4.

$" - %,$ *&% $*

&& &%,& &% 45,4 :, ,&

/4,,& 3,$ *& <"" , %$ :, ,& 3,$ *& <""" #$ / &% ?! &% ;*. " $ ,*$ 3&% 4*&3,/ ,,&&%$, & !, &<""!&%

%,$ ,,.

/4,&& %5%,*&% &$,$5,% 45,4 / & ,& <""" 9%

! &% & B$ / , ,

&4.,$&% & %,$

*&%,&&%;*. "%,$ ,*$3&%

4*&3,/ "9% & %,$ /,. ,&%,&&%

3,$5 , %4 &%8" +% & /4. %,4

/4,,& %,$ 4 &% ,$">&%$,/4.!&%,$ $*

&&&%,&,$&%

/4,,&%, ,

$ ,4

/4,&$,5,$&-,3,+5%,

&%$,$ !&%/&& %, 5*5 ,5,$& &%

/4,,&" - %,$ /4,. , ,& 4 &%

* , %,$ 5 ;*. &% /$

/4,,&" - %,$ ,*$;*. &%/$

/4,,&3&%,,3%%4,&

*& 5

*$,&*"9%

!&%,,*$&% $.& &

"+ 4,4.!&%/&& $/ $$$$

/4,,&! *& &% $, %,$

" 9%

! %$ *$& ,4 & 5,& $ C* &% ,$" >& $ &% /&& 3% %,$ 5 , &&

%%8,/* 4/4,"-!&% %,$

&& &%

* +& >( ,$ 344" 9% %, ,55 &%

/4,,& $ ,$ & &,8 % %$ % *$ &

&, &%

! *&&%/* 4, ,4 *4$&,% :*&5 &%$,&& /&"9%;*. " &%4 &%8

/4,,&$*&

&5 .&%/&& ,&%/% & 5,/%#:*<,&&,%3&% &%$$% &/4.$$*

&& $&, 4$%&% ,&&%,&&%$,;*.$, ;*."+%%,$,4$ &%:,. 4 #:*& &&%,& $&%3,$, ,&*%5%&, !$*5.3,$ *&,,/4,& 3,$$&"9%

!&%;*.3,$C*&$ *$" >%, %,4, *$4

&%/,&$" > & $8 ,$$$&,

&% *&5 & ! 3% :, &%

/4,,&!&%$ *& ,&&

!%, C*&%/$

$, & & ,$$$&&%$ *&&%,$"-3,$

&3&%&%/% & 5,/%#:*<,&&,%3&%&%/4. F",

F"&%;*. &%?,&%/% & 5,/%,&&,%!,$

,/*$,4

&%/% & 5,/%!&$% 3$&%,&&%,&&% ,8$ &%4

/4,,&"9% & !3% %,$

/$&! $5&% /% & 5,/%#:*<!%,$$*

&&&%,&&, *4 *&&%,&&%

,8$ &%%8,3&% &" $5 &% ,& &%,& &% , $/ , $ *$ ,445,& $ ,5,$&&% /&& 3%% 4*$,&%5

! 3%%%,*4& ,&4. %,

& &%/&& .&% ,*$! &%,445,&

5 5 &%%8

/4,,&,&% ,&&%,& $%%,$$*

;*. %5%&, 3%%4& $&

/4,&,

%4 &%8!&%$ *& $&%,& 5 *$ , *&& 5,& ,&/,& . ,4& &%/&& " # 54.!&%/$&/&& ! 5

,. &!$ $ $$" >&$ ,4,&%,&&%

$ ,& $ ,%,

$%,44

$&* ,$ , :/$$

/ &% &$

&% ,$ , $ & &%$

&%/$&,//4,&

,&/,& . ,4 4." 9% &,4 *& $%,44 4* 3&% &%

$ ,& $ , %,

,. ,"

!"#$ G,5*&& A%&%$/,85D,$ G$ A%&%/ &, 4