← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/4840/2015dismissed

Harbans Lal v. Gurjit Kaur And ANR

2016-01-07Mr. Justice S.C. Datta21 pages



     

 !"#$#%&'&() *

+   

         

   ),- -.- 

 

        !

  

"

#

 $% 

    

 #

 &

 "

   

 '"

#



( ) *

+ +,*-

,

   

 



 * !

,  ,

  .

 

 /

 * !

/      ,  

&$   "    

  

     

     

      

           

 



 !

 "   

         

" "         



   #$#       

      %&  '(  &) !

   

    *&    +                      &         

   

        "    ,      -     & 

  

     

           %

        ./

0 1 + %   ! .

 - &    



  

 +          +   +    

 +   

            +     



     +     (1 + %  .

'2  )    +  

        (

 3 "

-  3   

"

      

   

  -   &    #.

   &    

             "

  

 + 3 

 4

 ( 5

(     0      0  

 " 

 

      

 

   

 

          

 

  "        



   0 

#

"

 &    " 

 

  

   

         4

 (  ##7   "

    

  $ $8/

4

 (        $ $8/"

   "

         +     3   

       7$



   "

   

  $ $8/

4

 (  7    $97 4

 ( 

  (    0         

   7/   

   

     7/  "

         +                      :$7  4

  (  

  "        $ 7:/  

  

"

     + 

      ;:$7

 (     

  

  " 



   +

       +"

    

    #$ /           

     +"

      

  

 (        + 

 

      

               "    "        4

 (  & &  

     

  &     

     

   #$ / "

  "

    + 3 

 $8 -   4

 (  $$

&        

 

     &   

 & &       4

 ( &      0:9$ 3 /    &    0 <   &     0  =

 3   4

 (  &                 

     4

 (       +     &      

   & 

 

  ,       +       & 1  "

  ;           "      + &     -"



     

  

        

            4

  (         

+"

                

  "             

   &                    

        $

         "

 & 

 " 

    9              +

0; %    

;  &  

 "     

 "

    ;  

     %      

"  >  

   



9



  



     





  

       ! "

    $ % 



  $ & '  (

       &   %       * 

 &           

"    

"   "  

 % 1     

 - &  

     

             

   

"

 

, 

" 

     

   % > )* 

 



  



 





+  

 

    +  " 

 

 

  

 



+           )* 

,  %& - . 



 



   

+ 



+

   "   +  " 

   )* 

""

 



+ +  " 

 

7





 





 

   

 )* 

" 







   "





 

 "

 

 

       

&             +  

&  ?=# 

5   "   3    @ @

    &                      - &     

   





  "  

-  -  -   

 1

 2     .

33, 4   

  9'

)A%A'%& ) 7# 

  > /





   

 



 #  "



0

   /

     

12

 / 

3  12  0  



 , 

455 6 "  -

  44 -  





 "

   77

    #

$

 #

  %&

.  48

) 

(*

  

+

"  +

  

 

      9  

  

  3"



 ,  %&

  :

.

  + 

"  +

  #

 

  

 



;



0 

   

  

 

 "



 (

   

,  %&





+#

+ 

+ 





"  +

   /

 + 



+ 

"     



"

 "



 

       

+

   

  





 #

+ 

 ,  %& /  "







 "



 

+" '  



"  

       

    554)%* ,;;

&<# 

 

-'

5& 6"

&& 

    

   

-'

5=% ,;

&%

 # ,  %&



  #

  

+#

  12#  

  #







   



 "



  /

   

8





   "



 

""



"

 

12 

  "

  

9  

12 



  

  #       

  -

 

  

0



" 

92 ,

 ;

  )

*#



   :

> 



"

, 

 

+

 







    +#

+ + 

+ 

  

"  +

   > 

 , 

  

  



0  

 

   

 

  # #

 





  

 

 "



  -

  





  +

 

  #

 

+#  " 

#    

 ""



  -

#

  









 

  #

  # 

0  

   

   

 0  

  

  

       ( '     

!

" #$ %

%#$ %

<<< )* ';'

);* ?4 ,;#  !  &

 %

-'

5?8 ,;

<=4# '( )  

 (" *  5?8 )* -!'

) * &%= +)',&

-  . (*  -'

5

! %%4 '   

 +

:

%/  <%

)* ';'

);* 5?#

92 ,

 ;







+ 

"  +

    

  

  



+





  



 /    



"

  

 

  

+     @

 "





 #









  "   

 0    3 

"

 

 



 

 

  

+

/







    ,  %&

48

 

  







    ;"

 







    # "

  +  " 





"

   

  

12  

 

 



 

0



-   #

 



 

, 

455



        



  



  " 

 "   

"

    -

      > A  !

9" ;

-   

    

-0 -'

5&

! =<

0 

 

 



 

+

  

 7 77 





  +  "  # "

 



    "  

, 



  



""

 

 

> A 

"



- -' 5%= ! =?8#

 "  

 "     "



 

  "     -

 "

%# 58< !'

4#

 9" 







0



  +  " 



  

 



    







 

 # , 

, 

/ 





" 

    9" ;

  

 # -'

5=4  44#

 



"

"



 

 

   



+ 



+  " 



 



0

  - 1

   * 

<<<) * !'

85#

0   

 9" ;

12

 ; "



  



  :

/ A

"

   

 "





   

 /     )* B  )=*

, 

0

  "

 

  

 -

#



 "

 6 

 

 



 "

, 

)=*)*

 

 



"

   /  



"

 

   





#   

 



 /

"

0   



  

 

+  "



#  "  

 

+  "  

 

 /#

   

"   

  





   

  



0

3  ,

 

,  %&



 

3  

# +  " 

 

#





, 

455 A  

#

0 

12

0 





6 "  -

  44      



 6  



 1

2 0   "







 

 

 "  

 







 "

 # # 

  

  -    

  

 

  -



  1

2 



 







 

,  %&



+  

 

 "



  /

  

  +





 1

2











  

 "



 

, 





#

    



  

 , 





  

 

"

  

    



 "





   / 

1+ 2  







 

$ A  '  9" ;

.&

 

-'

5=% '

 / 



 "

  ."    

" 

92 9" ;

    :

/#

    

     

 #

 



 

 

 "



 -





  

 



3 

"

   

 

 



CCC -





""

 

"  



 



 

+

+

 



+







  

 



/ +



 

#  "



"

D

 #

 "  +  " 





 '

=<EB

 " 





EB 6 

+



 

   

 /

  



  

 

  "      

""

  

      

 #



  



 

0  

 

   

   

  "

 







; "

   

 #

#



 



  

 

 

"









  ( -    

 %-'

5?< '

<#

1 + 2











@



0 

  &

6 "  -

 

44  "

3  12

16 "  2

/ 

  :

A 

 

 "  

     ,  %





 

 "  

  -

  

B 

 

0  "

     " 



A

 "

3  A#



+  



"

 





 "  

,  &

6 "  -

 

   

   

"

 

 





,  &

6 "  -

 



   

 

 "     ,  







 "

6 "  -

  (

/#

3  12



 



 16 "  2

  6 "  -

  *5

4  5       $6755 68  2   - !

  ( 9 



 





A

 



    

 +

 

A 3"

#

  "   #

"F 

6- / 

 



 

E %& / - .  48

#  #



+

" 

  



 #  A

  

+

 

 +    #

 ""

  ""

 +

 

  

+

  

   "

#

 



+

F# 

 

 

 

 "

"

 #



 "  /  A

  

  

+ 



+

"  +

  #

  E %& / - .  

 

 

 9" ;

 ; ' $ +  D G $ + 2345+#+

$ 5

  9" ;

 9



 A    "

 2346+#&

$&

  "    

6





 

  

A G    +

 

    





 ) *

 #

 "



  ,

   

 

 "



 # 

 

 97

;

 ; 

H   H A+ !

 +2378 2946  '  9" ;

 

' ,"  I

9

$  2335+#.$2:3 %





  +  "

 "   

   +E  0  

>    "  #

   "  #

#





+

  / 

 

 A

 

 "  

    

#  #

  A 3"

#

  "    #   

6-

  

 "



   0 

   

 

 #

 

 

 "

 

E %4

6-

"

  / !"  ! ! ;

< # $

  

;

< # $   

 21       -

   2 

,, 4  .

"

!   "  

,

" 

  !

  %  

 2  

-  +

&8 :;-

*

,      



  -

 "

  !   

 %  !

*

5 "      .  "         %

  33   0+

7 +

$

:+ *

,<== >      "



   ?   33!  "

+

$7 :+ *

,<==   !

7



 "   

 %  

"

   

 .   ,    

    %  !

*

5 "   

! ">   !  +"



     2      "       ) - ,      > !  5 " "!

)              

-  5       :

!

  

.

  !!

 ,   ) "           ! "1        

   2!

"

:   ,   

   3

 !  )        .

  !!

  -    

 "  1   " +",   -  -  - 

:

    

  

 

"

   

  $668067

 "3



 

3 

  

.

   ,   !   "

$66@  ) - , "   %  +" "  !"

   A $66@  %

 - 2 

"    

 0+"

"

   

 $668067

! -"   "!    

%   

$

 "   -



 

 

  $668067,

 0+"! "  "    

 * ,   

    

"

   

 02 %  

 02 

  

   "

  !   

%  

  %  +",   

 0+",-

 >  !   - "   % 

"

-



 ""   

 0 +"!    

* ,  

 02  

  - ! +

&8 :;-

*

:

   

     



 ,!

- , -"   3 

:

! 



 

+

&8 ) 0  3 *

,=&<(

    <  )  (  )= 

 (   < 

% 6

 "

"

  

  

  "

 # 

 B  

 #

  B 

3   

 "

#  

   

   #  

 B  )*







 



3  @

)*

   "



 "



3  B

8

)*

"

@ )*     #   



  @

)* 



 ;

"



  # "





 #

 



3 

  @

)* 

"

    B     

;



 

; 

"

  





"@

 

  #



 

     



 B 

"

"

 

"

 

; 

        (

& .  B 





"

 



; 

$

 @   

"

 "



 

  

 

'=( % 

-          - "   "



 "

  +

  &    *    ,  !   -  

-,     -



   

.

" 

   

 !  

  -   > 

 

 *  -

:

 -,   

-

"            -   

1 "  

 

   

- )   3

*

,=&<  :

  ,   

 -"   

  -"

   

, -

      

 +"



    " ,    ,

  

  

 :    

  ( 9& , 0 #





    

"  / 

 

  

 

 

 

"

 

 





0



 "

&

 

 6



   "  +  " 

 

    





# 



      7    /

 #

 

""     "

 



 "



 

    7    - # /   ' "

 B  7 5%4 ) 

 B   7 (*



,

9   "

9 (    !



5?4 ,  &) *

 

   

 

  "

   "

 

"



  )*     

 

  

 

#   



3 "







 



 0 

 

   =

!+  # ,  %



 "

"

  

  

  "

 # 

   

 

   

3   

 "

# # 

   

  #  

   

 



 



3 

   "



 "



3 

"

    #   



  #

 +"

 





 

   ?

 

 "

"



      " #



 

 

 

 "

    

    E "

 9"

    7   

  





>   /   



 

 



  

  "# 



 # 

  E &

   7

 , #

 ;



G

 I 5929#>$# $48:

$  9" ;

  G

D  ' 

5929#>$ :29#   "   

  0  

 

 

 #

 #



 

    #    "     E 



 "

  %4

6-



8

/

 "# 

 



 "  A

 

 "  

  #

   #

  

 "



 #  0 #

 

 "  



 "  # "  





    7



  "   

 

    BB #

"

 #

   #

 #



    

)  * 



 



  "

 



 "

"  

E %4

6- (      

  "       "  

     &  

            

&    :- !  ! !  ;

<  $    

;

< # $= - 

  &       

     0  ,    

"     

, 

"  

         

 0     

   

*

+  

  & +