High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/5380/2024dismissed

Jitender And Another v. Mohinder Singh (Since Deceased) Through His Lrs And Others

2025-08-26Mr. Justice Vikram Aggarwal9 pages

!""!# $! ! %& # ' (# "!# (#)"!# $*! +( ,-%. "/0' + "!1 !# +2#"- "/0+ "!" +,# #2'# 2/"0+ "!03!#*! ! '

#"# "22"0+ "!03!#*! 5 66 "- !# *! "**/ "! *3 ' ! 3"

"! 3 ! 7!"-("! "! " 3 */"

( "! *" 5 " "! 5 *" "+8 " * ! /- ' !#7" *! ! !/3 , ( ,- 3"!*" 0!#"**/ "! 3"

"! 3!"- #" , 3

" 3 !# " 9 ! , *",-!# ! :10 * 3"! *" 5 ""! 5 *" "!, !"2 "+8 " * ! /- ;#( !- !!!"(!#"7"!""*** "!*/"

!# "3 / ;# !"! *! ! 0*3 +!

/ 3!# ! !

! 3 6 "0 "" / "! 5

*" ,- !# ! 3+ ! "/ / ( ' < 0 =# 1" 0 1# #,> ! ,7 !!,-!#*! ! > (7!,!!!#"3! "/1 7 ;# "#"" #9 # !- "1"' (#1"!# 1 * 3!#/"7" (2""/ 7"/" !

"! % //"( =""0 ;# / ="1" 2#"0 < ! ! =# 1" //- , !# */" !0 # "3! 3 ! " !# ? ! /"@ : 8

! " "(7!!//5 3" 3!#*/" ! 33 # ' (# " !# ;# !!"/ "/ "! 1" 3 8 "! 00 & 00 & 1" *" " "! 7- " !# "/ 1" ! , 8

!,- 5 A0!#"/1"!8

!0!#*/" ! 33 ! !

!" !3* ,-1"-3* *37" 3"(7! !//"!5;# !1"0#10 7 > (7! " "!55*",-!# !3'

, (0!/"0 =# 1" + "**"/ 1" *3 "(" ! !# " 0 1# # 1" "//1 > (7!" "!55 *" ,-!# !3< ! ! (0=# 1" ( /"' +**"/B 55*3,-!#3"!1" 7 "!

'* "/)"!+**"/ B *3,- !#3"!"(" !!#" > (7!*",-!#: (# !1""/ 7 "! ;#7"!!#" ("!!" 3 "/ !-37!#' *7 !3 6 "0!#"(-3!# #/!"!;# #/"!"! ! #" * ! !# ,"/" "/ "! !# !" - 555;#3"! "1"' (#8* (!#* -3 !#"**"/"# /("/*!"! #",, (#!

+ 8

! *! ! 1" *3 ,- !# #/ "(" !!#)3"1"' (# ;# /!!#3 / (3 !1,> ! *! ! "5,-!#/("/*!"! 3"1"' (#=!#,> ! *! ! 1 7 "! " +**"/ 1 *3 "(" ! !# " , ! 1 1 !#"15

;#"3!0" , !37!# 05 1" 3 /1# #1" 7 3*

! "!

% "! 0 !# 8

! ( !*""3" ! 37 !"! 3" 3)3"1" ' (#% "! 0"3!# ! 1" "** ! " " / "/ 77 ! (! !# ** "/ ( ! 3" 3!# #/;# 1" #"//(,- 1"-3 ,-!#)3"1"' (#0!"! (!#"!!#-#"! ,( "-**!

!-!3 /,> ! "(" !!#**"/ ;# *! ! 1" * 3 "! 5

(/-0,> ! "! 1 ,7 !!01# #1 7 ,-1"-3!# 7* ( "! 5 0 /" ( ! !# 3 / ( 3 !# *! *! ! )" /3!#*"! 1#" 5 6! 1" ! /- ( ,- %. "/0 /" ' /*! (!#*! ! &,> !!#"!!#8

! ( !#" ("/- 7 (!#,> ! *! ! 6!1" ,7 !!!#"! ! !!//"1!#"! 3!#" #" !# !/"0!#"/ "!

!1 !# !*"! ! 3!# !/")"' /#" 3!!#"3!"/"#" ,7 !!!#"!"* "/3!#"7 #1!#"!!#/" > !"!#"/ "!,8

!1 !# ! *"! ! )" ' / ,7 !! !#"! " 3 > ! * /#",*"01# #1"!)"' /"/3!!#* 3 / " " ,7 !!!#"!!#" * #"!, 7*/ 1 !# 6!1" ,7 !!,-/"' /!#"!!#"/0 3 8

!01 /,"(""#""(""* 2#"" 7, )"' / ,7 !!!#"!!#"3!3!#"/1"!, 3 "/ C,-!#8

! ( !" !#", 3*"! ! #" (!"2 */"

0!#"71"!* ,/ )"' /3!"//1# ##", *"37! 7!! 7"" !!# !"("!#! 7/ !# *! "" ,7 !!!#"!!# 7* ( ! !" ",/6 **!3# !! 0/"' /*/"

/ " *

! "

## $%

& '" (( )

* "

( ($&!

0 !1" ,7 !!,-/" /*! ( !# *! !#"! !# //("/ !- !# 7* ( 6! 1" ,7 !!!#"! *! ! "(" ! 7 "/3!#* ,> ! 1"/"- 7 7" (!#,-!#"!!#7"!!#""!!" 3 "/ !- "!#"7 "!,*7 !!!," "(" 6!1" ,7 !!!#"! ! 1"!"> !2#1"!"!"//"* 2#"" 7,17!

!#"(7!!//)" / ,7 !!!#"!,> ! "!"- * !3! 71"" ! //!# 3!#7"!! *!!#'

*7 !36 ""0!#30 !1 /1!,*!!#*! ! ! "2 *!# )" /"/3!"//

7!&"8 1 !# !# *! ! " ,7 !! !#"! !# //("/ !- !# 7* ( 6#" !# ,7 7",-/" /3 !#*"! 6! "7"!!3(" !#"!* !"7"!!#" (, 3 "/ C,-!#'

*7 !36 "0!# #/#"!, ",/!"*!#,3 !3!# *" !# 3" +1"!

1# /!" / (!#3"

!3!# "0!# !3* *37" #" ( , 7 0!#*/" ! 33*3""**"/01# #1""//1 > (7!" "!55;#3"!1 "// *! 8

! !# "/ 1 !# " * 3 !1 7!# *! 3 !# ,"/" "/ "! ;#( /" "**"/1""/ 7 "!#7"!!1"3 "//- /,-!#:D,/'

*7 ! 3 6 " ;#"3!0 !# ,"!!/ !"! ,3 !# 8

! ( ! ;# ,> ! " - * ,/ ,> ! 0 / ( !# ,> ! !#"!!# !/"1" "> !2#"!""0!#30""/

/ ! , 8

! 1 !# ! !# /" , ( *"! ! B!",/-0 !# ,> ! 1" " ! // !# 3 "/ C"! 3 !# 7"!! 37 !# '

*7 ! 3 6 " E !#1 0 * 2#"" 7, 1 7! !#"(7!!//01# #1"

(/-7!

!#> (7!" "/;# !3!#*/" ! 331" " *"-3;#*"-1"" +, - .

*" &" - . - .

- .

, , .

00(12#00) (2 #)2(()2(1)2(12#2)(0 2 2 ,

' &% 3 & .

4* * - ( (1( 5 , - , - .

--*" - ( - 5 , - - .

. - *

6 , -

" -

( 102 . , 7 * &82 9 " . - ( (1(8

() . 0 8

() ' 8

( 1 ,- -- :, 1 (1).

, )-(1( 4 /,

4 & *" , - 4 ,*4, & ,:, - , - - & &- .

- - ,,

* - .

-- , * * * -

% - * &

, "

; ;#7"!!!# ,> ! " 513 /01# "*"!37!#,> ! 0!#,> ! !#"!!# /" 1" " *"! 3 " > ! 2#1"! 1" "/ " 6 !# ,> !

50!#3//1 (!"1""/!"2 +'

- * :, * 24 & & " . - .

= .

. - & 2

" - , : -" =.,

<, .

&, " ."

- . - , *" *,

;

;# ,> ! 1 7 !1 "! ";#/"!*! 3!# " +=.

*: ."-

, - , , - $ - 4 & - 4 & <, - ,,

-- .

- . -

"* *"$ , , ' .

, * % *"43

-* * - 5 ,, 5 ,, , - ,

- .

. * ,

"* . - , ' :, (# (11( * ,. *"!>* ,.

, & , 2. -

' ,,

--0 2

' . - . -*

"* " . -

% - - - . - , " &

- .

, - - 2 .

, . * ,&

& ! .

% *"..

# = &-* ,

-:, , - . *: *" 430..

* "

- &

; 5 6! 0 !#30 ! !#"! !# " ,> ! 1 " "/ "/"1> !F#"!#"!, /,-!#,> ! !# !"! *! ! , !#", /,-!# #/ !#"**/ "! 3"

"! 3!"- !#"!,!#"! 1 #"//( ,- 1"- 3 5 0 1# # 1" 7 3 *

! "! 0 1# # " "

+( 212) 3 -3 8(( (( ) 4 ?@

, A , $

. B6A8!BC>$9A 4D'=9 =/66!$ @

8 C - .

=/66!$4 B6$ ( @

. * - , 6 #- , - = - ., # 6 5, @2 # 6 5, @21 .

*" 6 4, 3 & 95 , @ C (#0( >A ,

4 & ,

> & *" *: - .

C*".. * -- .

( ) '" .. * -- .

, *

& 3

- 2.

, ) $* " .

- .

. ", ,

; ;# *! ! #" "/ "/ ,3 3 / ( !# "3" *! ! 5 ! !# /

21#!#"3!"/ 1"!,( !;#-2 2!#3!# !,-1"- 3 !"! (!#"!**!

!-33 / (3,> ! #", ( ;# *! ! 1" * 3 A, "- 50

" !# 8

! ( ! 1" ! ! ("! **!

!-!!#<!3 /,> ! !!#**&"3!"/ ;# ("!#<"!#**!

!-!*!# "" *"!373 / (!#,> ! !!#"3!"/0!#-" "//* ! 1# ##"," "/ ;#8

! ( ! (#!/- 7 !#,> ! *! ! 6 #"3 ",/ !/- //("/ !- !#" 1""! ( !3

5 +7! "/ 0!#7"!!#",3 "/ C *!!#:D,/+*8 !B,> ! "("!#/", (> !1"" E !#1 0* 2#"" 7,17! !#"(7!!// " !# */" !0 1# # 1" !

"//- + * "/ 3 !# *"37! 7!! 70!#"**/ "! "!#,> ! 737 ! 7!! 7"!#

7! 0 !, 77" 3!/- /"!#"! !#*! ! " 7*/-", (!#* 3/"11 !#" 1!, -!# ! 7 6 #" ( !# (# !# > (7! / * ,- /" ' / 3 ! ", ;# " > (7! " (" ( "/ "! 3> !**!-;# ",/ !/- * ! !#"! /" 1 !#" > (7!:10!#-1 /!"**/-!!#3"

!3 !#*! "01# ##",!

!#* (*""("*#;# > (7!0!#30! 7!!#" 3!#*! !

6 1 3 !# "3" 0 !# *! ! 3 ! , 37 !" "

(/- 7 ("**/ "! 0 3"-0#"//"/!" *3

! "!#$% !&'()&(&* ("( Whether speaking/reasoned :

Yes/No F#!#*!",/ G&B