Guljari Lal v. Kotak Mahindra Bank
-1-
!" #$%$ &'( ( ) )) (( $ $ & * + *%,% -- - ((( %. &" &
' /)(0 0 0
0 0 1(
! " # $%
&' (% )() (% * + ,%- %& " . /# %
% ##" (%%( (%
* +, - .0
" % "
(1() (%)* +,&- .
0" "
.!"
"# . # "# "
# %& 2 % " ./# 2 .,3 42
"
$ 5 "" 4
6 *.2- ." "
2 " " " ,67 8 ,3 4 #" 9% .2
-2- # " 2### 3 4# # # 2 #.2 2 " "
! ((:
(1 %:(' (% 2 3 434 0 5
#91( 4 ""
.2 , # # ; ! 2 2 # 4 <= /< !2
# # $%
&' (% )() (%
* + ,%- %& 2 % " ./# %
% #. # # . ## (%%( (%
+ +, ##" # 9 .
0" "
# # . # (1() (%)* +,&- . ! "
# # $%
&' (% )() (%
* +,%-##" (%%( (% * +, - 1() (%)* +,&- .! " "#
-3- & ># # "# &%( (%)2 2"2 ,
!
"
"
#$ %&' ( &
( & ) '* +,
"
( -
..(./(/0.1(
( 2
*
3
( 2
"*
" (
"
(5
# # " #2 +### .
2 ,3 4 %%% (%)52 ,
-4- 4=2 22 .
42 . " ,3 42 #/ # # 7 1
"
# " !! . 4
6 $ 5 "# * +, -22 " 2 $ 76
46
? 9 76 # " # " " 5 * +, - " 5 ! .. 2" " ., , 2 9 76 22 " 5 3 . 4!2 "2,3 4 ! 9 76 , 4 2 2 #! . $ 5 "/ " # 4 6 "# 5 9
"# 9
-5- "
. .+" #"
# "
5 # 2 5 # . "
( 2" !" .#2##" : / ' 3"# 2. + # 2 "! " =/9$# # . 5<. #
!
" ( 2 + , 60(77777777777 ,777777777777 ,777777777777 ,777777777777 ",777777777777 ",8 *92 $
92 $ :
",777777777777 ",;
$92
*
:
*****************************5 @# A
-6- /#$% & ' ()
"
, <( 2 *
% +6/ 3 3
92
$
(2 &3
% +6/3 3 "
3
(2 "
* "* (2 & 3
" % +6/3 3 (2
3
(5 @# A >" !
( " ./# 5<. # *
+$ , ( )# #( - )!." , =.(4
/0/3 3 .1>= * ? @/0/(
().,' #
A "
-7-
.1/
.B
*
C
"
?
"
"
), # *
" 3
%
: ), 3
) , " *
/00( )/, 2
)., #
"
? " # *
" 3
%
* ( )=, 2 "
).,
" "
3
*
(@ =/(D% % )., % /0/#
$ A A
), : ),
-8- "
(4
"
( & "
#
# * ( 4
'
% .=6
# # (4
#
"
(% /0=
#
" % /0/
( 4
% /0= % /0/(% /0+
# A
),
:),
(4 " "
3
(9
(
-9- ==(4 " % /0/ #
"
' /E /00E /= F /00<( 4
( 2G H
"(- # )/0.+,.+%33 <=6 3
% /0/ "? @..( % /0/ 3
I
*
"
(2
# * ( ./(4 I
* .1 3 3 .1>=)',' )3 ' /E /00E, (((/=</00<(4
(4
?
-10I9
( 2
)., % /0/
#
"
(
4
*
@
@ " # (4 @
@
* (4
@
@
"(
"
( &
*
@
@
"
"
" # (@ =+(4 3
#
-11-
( 2#
D2 "(JA# 4 )/0.E,./%33+/0 3
9
( "( % F # ).116, E %33 >+1 "
(&
#
"
(4
"? @/0(4* "
A
(%
"
(2
('
3
9
("(F # B 9
( "( F # ).116,E%33>+1?.116%33)3, .+00C
(@ KKK @//( 4 #
.10).,), 3 3 .1>=
/0+3 3 .1>=
#
-12-
"
(4
(-
( 4 3 3
/0=3 3.1>=
(2 #
A "
(4
#
"
/0/3 3 .1>=
/0+3 3 .1>=
( 4
(2
# % .10$/0+3 3 & 3
+6/3 3 .1>=
"
"
(4
-13-
(&
(@ 4 " '
"(&#
-
)/0.>,=%33 E/6( '
% /0/3
"?
@/E(((( "
#
(4 3
#
D "( JA # 4 B#
D "( JA# 4 )/0.E,./%33+/0?
)/0.<,.%33)3,./+C(((@ =E(8 "
3
G H
* #
" % /0/ 3 ( =<(2 3 ("('"A2"
&
)/0.1,.<%33<.0
" "
(43
?
@/<( 4
*
-14-
/0+3 3 .1>=
/0=3 3.1>=
('
/0/3 3 .1>= #
"
"
(@ & 3
?
@==(4 #
( 4
(3 #
" #
A #
D B#
D "( JA # 4 )/0.E,./%33+/0?)/0.<,.
%33)3,./+C(((@ 4 " "
J 3 "(% D( )/0/.,E %33+=E( =>(2
" .<' /0/. 3 ?L*
4 3 .=6 -(2(' .66.B/<KC(43 @
-15- % .=6@ @ "
@(4
"
% !
" D 4
/0/ 3 3.1>=( .+= -2' "
/</ /<E 3 3.1>=) 3772
,
.=6 -2 ' ( M
/0/3 3.1>= .=6 -2' " "&
(% &3
#
/0/3 3 .1>=
% .=6
" &3
(2 * 3
"?
B/<K%
# 8 )3 ,- (/ /0/0 .<' /0/.C @.0(% /0/ 3 #
( 4
% /0/ 3 /=(0<(/00< " ' /E /00E #
()%?G H
N M ( "( - # N M ( )/0.+, .+ %33 <=6' "( & #
-
'( )/0.>, = %33 E/6 3 "('"A2" &
N M ()/0.1,.<%33<.0,(4 "
-16-
&3
% /0/
% .=6 ' (3 % .=6" & 3
" # " % /0/ 3
% .=6( 3 "
"*
(2
#
" (9
% /0/ 3
"
"
( ..(4 ' 3 3
J(%(F
"( 3 N '(
% /0/ 3 % .=6 (2"
3
G H
)
,' )
, 3 )
,
#
(4 ' #
(8 ' (@ =6( .+E -2' " "
" "
"
-17- 3 3( 4 % .+E ' /00=
% .=6( & 3
"
" "
"
( 3
/0/ )/,3 3.1>=
% .=6 *
(43
"
"(2#
*
# *
% /0/( 5 =1(2 # " ? ),4 :
),4" :
),4" " : )",4
(5 @# A
#".
4 #
" . . $ 5 "
4 6 / . 4"!2 "
# "" 9 6 .,, 2 .# "2 " 2 . 4 . . 9 2 ##"/# .#
-18- !! ." . 9 76 .# ".
#2 9 76 .,, 2 . 2 ! . /"#* +, -2 2 $ 5 "2 9 76 " "2 =
4 6 5 " . 2!2 " "
..2 #. ,# 2. # 7 " ! #.
4 ! . " "
# =/9$# .4 . ## "
. #7"#
* - #$%* - )
!# ! ( */ * -5<. # # 2 .+ # .2 " !.
" 2 ! / ##"2 # # .
" ./# .##
-19- . ##9 " "# . " .##" ! ##"
2 . , # %( /2 ./# #.# %% 52# . # " 2# 2 2 20 0 ( ( 0 5 *%.
6$&78* % & "' %8 5 ** . *
9: ' %8