← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/5307/2025dismissed

Devender Kumar Goyal v. Rakesh Kumar Jain

2025-08-11Mr. Justice Vikas Bahl11 pages

         



   

     



 !

   

  

  #$ !

%$   "  #& "%$          '  (

   "  

 "

    )(  *  )   +  ,     -   .    /  0+  1'     2 3 $ % 45. 1 

     645. $ 73   + *  "         

 "

*

     '  (

  )( 5 *   9  $"" '  



   ""   +   " "   !"#$%&'$(#)*+,',%)#-#%.%.'$#  :  

 "     (  "( 

   )(  *(  ;

 %

+  

     

"(" < )     

"  #

 +=%  :   '  % ;=" !

% 

 #*1> 3%* 





$

!

  

    9

 (      ,     "  ?.      *   

  @ 

   (    % 8  ") +  , 

+  . :  

    "      

    (  

(

  "( )(   ""     "("  ? +   1

3      "  

(  (     ( 

       

*

(*  

+ -+  '  !

*   /* + 

  %* 



(  /* "%*

  :   ' % ;=" !

% 

  #*  9

+  

  +   %-+  '  !



(   *     " 

 @ 

 +

(  ( +           

 "("  ? +   1

3    )   "     

  9

  

+  

     "

*      /* "

 

( /*

%   % 8  ") +  

( /*

  

+    % )  +    +



   "(  )(  + 

  !"#$%&'$(#)*+,',%)##&-'$/#$% ? :  

     %       %  +      "  

 "

  

   + 



       )(  "

 +   '    *     9  $"" '    + "   9

+      

 

+

* "%* 

+ 



%

 *

   +  "

( + 

(   

    

    * 

 "

     9

  

+    "* 





*

  :   ' % ;=" !

 *    

8

#  #( %;="!



"       

   )   "    #  #( 

  +"  

( /* +

 #   #(  

   

   ;=" !

  

   > / ( *?$*  ;="!

 * 9

  +     "*  



( 

 +

 *  

 +  + (  

 +      (

   

   -   .    )+ - "

'  2 +

  $ % 4 *    +   @ +  

 0  2@   *     " ( " 



-+  '  !

    +

   +   !

#

  A  9

+     " 

+ "   

+ (  

 9

  +    (

   2@ 

44

 "   

(  " 9

( 

:' *;=" !

% 

  #* > 

#  #( %;=" !

%*  

*

 +"   

(     +

  /*  9

    "     " " +



 $*+1&.&*$/.$/.$ &  &

 '      

    "   "    "" + 

    "

     "  

"

  

     + 



     "(  )(   '  *  $""$  

    *   *      + "     

 

 < &         )   "  -  . 45.$ (

 " *   " "

8 * *  " (*    

(B@?B 

8 

  #   #( % ;=" !

 *  * +    ,

   

        

  



! " #

 $ %& # 

'

( !  )* + 5     (   

    *  +  8   ("

?%?1

3%%< 5 )  %*   



( ( + 8  

+   %"  

+* , , -    !  

.  . '    

 !

 / !  0 111 111 111

3 

!"

# $!%

$& '

($"   !

" $%) "

*'"

% $(   !

$% "     !

$% " +% $ " $+%% !" &' % $()++



,%- %.

   $!   )$.

  /" "- "$ +.    $  '&)  $! ($" )+  +

 ,%- &' % /" "-"$ ",   % ", $( "$1 !'"",% .$%% .   $%)-+2345 + 0 "$1 !'" ", $+%   !

$% "   '((.

%

6!

"

%.

($""'%%%-)+ +

 ,%- $!) $ !

$% "  '((.

%

% % 6!

"

%.

 (($+$", %     &' %  & .'

  !"

%   !

$% "   +$",%-% &"$ "

)+ +

 ,%- $!+  &"$ " 7 $% "

 &"$ "  '&  %  %   "'%%%-)++

 ,%-$!% %

%  2) $( #  %  % % "  ) ,'% ', "$1 !'" ", 8   + "2%  '& 

 2  %  % &"$ " $( !

$% "     !"$!"

$" $( #  % % % " !

$% " .'""

%)2+$",%- % #  %  % % " +   &"$ "  '& % % 9  !

$% "%$++% $ " $+%&' % $( )+  +

 ,%- $!  "

($"

   "

*'"

  $!($" !

" $%)%



!"

  "

($"

%

 ($"  $%:(

 '

 %  "

*'"

% $(  !

$% "+$+% $ " %

!

%

%)++

 ,%- $! "

($"

 !"

 "

*'"

($" $%:

(

!

" $%)"

*'"

%$( !

$% " ;  !

$% " ") "  $!%&1" % " )'%',0 "$1 !'"",8  + ' %.

2 "<=5>+. %!$ $%$( !

$% "

 $% % '%#$, '

"%%  '

&2  % ' % ($"   !'"!$  $( ?$ $+%#$., @"

 ($"

') %-% .$% "'.$% ") % '%.""

$'&' % $($% "'.$%% !"/ $%".$" ! "$1 !'"", !

$% ""% ( ""

    $!$   $%  % ' % "$'- "% ( ""

 8



<<A33A3A >  !

$% " %$$ " $!% !$ $%

6.

! $% +. 

%$%

&$/ %7" $;$( !

$%%  " /.

%2$ " $!%'%.!))   $( 0 "$1 !'" ", $" %     $( "2% ( " 2 " <=4=+ $ "     + "

(  * *        *     + '   

     



(      

  

:' %;="   * +

( +

 $

 !

    ""   

( + 

(   

   %         +

  

   "   

";="!

     

  

  

  2           ,  *  

(  +

/*

+ B "* *

: ' %;="!

%

 #**   

 +  9*        *  "



" 8     *  

* "+

/* 1 *

(3  

 8

  #   #(  *

   

+"    +

/* %  #  #(  #

 

;="!

  

   >  / ( * ?$ *   ;=" !

 *  9

        " ,   "

 "      +   

 )  

 )  " 

(   &   '   

(

 

        +       % "

          ( "   

    "     "

 *

             9    )( %  *  +   8     * (

  *  

( 

@"  *

(

 3 

"* +

+ -+  '  !

  * " " 2@ * * (

   * * -+  '  !

*  "  "* *

: ' *% ;="!

%

 #*> %*    

  * *

(*  

+ 9* +   

"* * +-+  '  !

+  (+  C  "

+  *   "   

 * + +  '     +

(*   "*  " 

  



   

+" 

( (

        "    

 + "    % %*   

 "    "

  ?,?  4 &  $"" '   )(   5   



 "" + "  * + 

  )( %

("    )(



(  )(   / B+   -" '

      ") 'B /  %

% % '"%.

$ !%2



" <==55<<=   

 + )(

    

 

       *           +      "

 8  +  

 "   

       '

    (

( +   "





(

+

A  ( 

+   



 4    "  + 

 ' *   

 +   9  $"" '   *)   & )(   '  * 9 $"" ' 

    *   *      + "  & 



   ( 

    )(  $ "      "  * *            (         (   "   

 &   ,          '      *   * " *

(        "* *  * +  + 

 + 

& "

 +  " +  +      (   @ 

( 





*   (  

  %* * @ 

*

(

"%* * +* + +   %



   +)     A   "

%* + 

+ 



* *      *  *

( *  

 + %     :  ' %;="!

* 

#   #( % ;=" !

 *

  +   

   ;=" !

   

     >  / ( * ?$ *   ;="!

* >

(  * 

'+  "    

 +9

   

      *

 

* "+

/*

"   %

        *   

*  +      

++ *

( 

+

 " *

 +   9





"     

      



( +



   "    

"     " *    + 

  

 +

(   +       ""   

( + 

(  

   9

 

    

 "



>

(  * 

' +     "   +     "  A    '    (  +       + 

             *   

%      

"

 #%

 "   % +   

 ""     

  @ + 



   *  

 

+

"  D    "       " *    

 *

(  ( *  

 + % "  *    +

 

+%

""    "+ (  +  -+   '   !

 &  (

    2@   44% *     *  @    "      

(     "   *   

    -+   '   !

 * 

  

  "    (    " 9       %   8         

 *

" +

/*

 

 +  + + &

'

  *  8  ") +  

+  +  ' % '  9 $""'  ( "

    ( "   

  "

(

  *   +       %  

"( )(  +"   

("    

 "  +

(  

     + 



 

 

(



 5678   ! !&%9:

5 D   "

(E   F E> D  "+ F E>