M/S Kuber Rice And General Mills v. State Of Punjab And Others
!"!#$!%&'
! #$%&'$()*+, -.
/0#,-%0 ',,/'%.
& #! 1
% 2 3 ! 3
1% 2 !" (2 "#!!1%1 4
5!1
% 2 3 ! -
5! 1% 2 (
( /!
3 " !
67 ! #
0
8
3
9 !
5 7 :
; 3!< " !
4 " < : "
" ; 3 4"5 =:
;"
< (> ?:
=;"
< (3!< 4 !" 4 " <! 1 ! ! ! " 3 " < 2 ! "2 ! 8
1 3!
! ! " "" ! !
#<3< #@ (=?=
! 5! "
13!<!!" 4 !
4 " < 4
5 /! 3 " 9 %<
3 3 !
5!!" 3 " < !# 4
<1!321!3 " 9
1"
!" 3 " 13
!5 !#0*0+
13!
!3 9 4
3 9$ !" 4<09
5!
< =:5; ! # 4
< 1 !! 3#0*0+
=63! !4
44#0*0+
!3 9 4
3 6 < %55 2 5
!
1
+ %(>=6 1 3!
! 3
2 A 3 ! ! 2
!B
! " ! #
$ %
$
& '
&
(
) *
&
'
+ > /!" ! 8! >"" ! 4 " < "
<
4" ! "
<!
#
+ %(>6= 1
" !" 3 5 <! ! 4 1
2 4 A
<
# 1 C 1 #
"" #
4% 1+ !
!" " 13!< 3 ! " !4 4<09
5!! #0*0+
3 61 ! 1 ! " 3 8 4 ,
*-.
/! 8!!<3 !2 < ! " < 3 ! ! 4 < ! " 4
> 5
! ! "
!
%4 #44 D 4
5 4 0
! A1!" !!" 13!
1 ! 3 #0*0+ " 2 !
4 "
!
4C! 1! .( .
5 <! 5 455
2 !2
5 2 76 %" 4 !1 %< 52 < ! 4
6,2
!
< 'C# * 8 /! 1 ! " 9 4 >'3212 4"5 71 5
! " ! 3
5 "
5 4" 9
4 "<4 ! 5
03 !!" 3 4
"2 < 5
4 3 ! "2
! # 4
< ! > ! 1 5
!"
4"" % ! 5
! #0*0+
! " ! "
3 ! "
/! 4"5 ! "! 2 = ?' 1!3 " = #! 1
#
< 3
1 % 2 ""
5 ! " 3 5 !
! 5 2 4 1 3! " ! 4 !23#0*0+
1 !4
5 3
3!! "" 2
5! -
5!! 3#0*0+
! 3! !
0-.
13
<! * 8 0
0
5 !!
< * 8 0
4 <3 !# =:2
;0
5 ! "
= 3 #0*0+
1 !
%4 #44 !
.(%0( " 4 5 < ! 4 % 54 ! <
3 3
.(%0(0
! 5 ! ! 4 ! #0*0+
" 4
614 " < 3 !"
<0
! 5 !!" 3 ! 4
! 3 3
<2 ! "
+ % (>=6 C!41
5 !
4 "
< 1!
3
54 " <
14 13!
!!2
!<"! ! 4 2
0
!5 ! ! "4 C 1 # "" #
4 % 1 !
2"< :C;
5C # !!" < 4<
4 3!
! !<"! 455 " 5 2
0! "
!!
4 !2
38
"
13!
!!2455 !""< !4 "4
1 !<"! ! 4 " 5 1 5 4
!
5 3 4 5 !2
5
! ""< 85 9E !25" < !
5!"2 < !
"
<
2 9 2 ! 4F 44" < !4
4 ! "4
4
< ! "4
<
" <
5 <!4 ,F4" ! 3 5 4 13!!22 4
!4 8
< 2 4
!4 0
4 !
!" !
! <455 2 76
!
.( .
1 3!
! 3 8
!2 455 !<"! ""<2 38
"
1! 1
" 3!
5 2
! "
< 3+
#
3 !5!!
4" !"2
# =:;:2
; !"
<9 <
1 3!
!
9 ! 8 4 < !
4 %5 < 4
5!1
#
< -
5! 1 % 2 ""
5 ( 3
4 !!" !
!
! 3 "
! ! !" ! 4
#0*0+
6 /! + % ! 3 8
5 ! 5 4
3#0*0+
13
<
!
<F
3 <!4 1 4F 3 F ! "" !
3 0
4 ! ! " ! <!3#0*0+
!05 < # #
< 'C# * 8 3 !2 2
5! !
! 8 ! ! <!%F
* 8 0
5 ! 05 <# #
!
<! 81 !"
<3 4 4
8 4 4 ! #0*0+
"5 0
4 !
<!'C#* 8
5!#0*0+
!" 4" 1!
<%F
* 80
4 ! !5
! 4 ! 4 3 ! !
# =:;:2
; !"
<9 <
1! 4
! 4 3 <2
6 0!2!
!" !2" !"" 8 2 2 !2
5! "
6 7 %!2< 1
53 !4 ! 1
!
<!3
"3!!!" ! " 4 3 !
4+
#
!" ! 4 ! "
"
5 4 1!43
!" 3 ! 1
4 %
5 !"< <! =3 ! "
5 4 3 4
<
54 " <'3213! 54 3
5
!
#1 " 4< ! 3 ! ! " ! " !2 #0*0+
6 2 ! 1
4 /! 1 <G!
#
H ! 9 3!!!" ! 3 5<
4 " 4 5 < !5 3#0*0+
3! 3
! 3 !
3#0*0+
<G 3!!!"
4 8
! 3! 76 <
455 3 ! .( .
? /!" !
3
5! 4! "
<!+ %* ! !
<F
5 1
! !4
24
% 5
! 8 < ! " ! 3
! 3 #0*0+
? !05 <# #
3
4 <3 !# =:;:2
; !# 4
< > 0
5 !
5 05 < # #
<!* ! 5 !B
- 2
( & (
*
&
*
"
1
& (
$
7 34
'
&
0
1+ % " !
1 ! #0*0+ 3 8< 4"2 3 !
4 ! 2
4"2 2 ! 43! !54 3 = ! " " :>; ! # 0 4 #4"
:5 ;% 11
53!
!1 9 3 1 !
4 4" < ! "
!
1 4<1 !8""" "
" !
4 3 !
!
< <
59 '321
!
3
1 ! #0*0+
3 " 2 F 54 3 !!" 4 5 <+
#
""
5 !" ! !
!2
54 1 !05 <# #
" ! >1 5!" 13 !#0*0+
! 4"2 4?A ! 1
5361! 4
# =:;:2
; # > !
5 3
1 4 5! !2 5 ! " 03 5 3 !2!4 !05 <# #
<! * 8 0
2 3
"
<! 5 <13!
! 4!
3 5
#0*0+
A !
3 8 "
#! "
4 " < 3
! ! 8
4! 0
<1
! <1#0*0+
2
5! -
5!1"" 3
1 !3 1
%
5 ! 05 < # #
?3 ! 2
5!
? ! 5 5 !
4
51!
#0*0+
4 3 '321 5 !
58 2< 4!" 1!
3 ! 5 /!
! 4 ! ! #0*0+
2
5! 3 4"23 !
4 ! / 2 <1 3 """ 8 # =:;:2
; !# >13!
!
" & I'
. * *5 *
*'
&
34
6
0 61 7( 8 34 8!!&
&
9 & 9 34 * 34 6 7(
&
3(&
3(
34 $
$ &
3($
:
*-.
+ (*
( 3( &
&
*
$
$
&
&
5
4 3(
5
4 & 3(
0543 1$5
5; &
%
A
*-.
0<1 ' &
*-.
0 1 ' &
3(
0#1'&
$
0=1 ' &
0>1
&
3( '
5 ' 5
4 &
$
:
*-.
+$
%
?
*-.
" (
(*
(
$ $
$
" + $
5 !
!
< 3 $3 4 / +
!2 4
#0*0+
4 4 , "
: ,; 8
6 3 #0*0+
6 2 " 2< /!
! ! !4 13! #0*0+
! " 3 4 " 5
1 ! !
5 <3 !! * 81 54 ! 4 3 ! ! 8 1 ! 5 < !
!#0*0+
1 !4
4 1
! 05 < # #
4 ! 8 % 4 <1!" !
!! 1 "
5 4 1#0*0+
" 4<09
5! ! "5 1 3 ! <05 <# #
<!%F
* 8 "# =:;:2
; # >2
05 <# #
<!'C#* 8
8
! 5 <3 3 !%F
* 8 /! ! 54 !"
! ! "3 !4 13!
!!2 5 4 " < "
!2
5 3 #0*0+
1< <
5 " 54
! 3
/!54 1
! 3
!2 " <
2 ! 54 1
#0*0+
3 31
8
# =:; :2
; 3
%4 #44 8
05 <# #
13!
!
!" ! < !#0*0+
3 4"23 !
4 ! !
4( %1 ! <
5 ! ! * 8 3 !2 < 8
!5 52 4 " </!
!5 ! 3!<!
3 5 ! 1!54
<!
#
! " ! ! 5 <
4
:
3
5 5 1 2 !5! !
!""
< 3 ; /! 05 <# #
2 3
<! * 8 0
3 !# =:;:2
; !"
< ! 1 !
! 8 " < 3
1! 4
5 !" !
4
<1 !2
" 05 < # #
4!2 8 %F
* 8
5!! 5 !2 42 > +
#
""
5 !" ! 5
# =:;:2
; # >!!3 4" <
5!#44 3
2 <!5
!05 <# #
+
#
""
5 ! ! 2
#: !43 2 ; !
5 ! # 3!! ! ! 4"
5 2
!05 <# #
4 <!4 /! 2
! <(
5!1# 4
# 1
%4 #44 181C 1# "" #
4 % 1 8 3 8 "< ! 4 !
! !
""
5 !" 0 2 1
! !
+2
< #44
5 "< #44
#! 4 1 + * 8 5 !
+2 * 8 #44 41
5
@#41
5
.( .
41
5 8 51 C # # 41 !05 <# #
?
<! *0%45!
!#0*0+
2
5!1 "" 3
13!
!3 4 <!4 1!
+
5 :+; !5! 4
5 /! +1 8 2
! 05 < # #
3 < 2
1 !
%4 #44 1 " 4 5 <! 4 54 3 F /! 2 3 ! !!" 3 3 2 <!#0*0+
3
! * 8 0
52
! 3 !2 ! 52 4 " < !
51!
%4 #44 3
" 4 5 <0
!
! 2 ! "!"
4! 8 *0%45!1 1!#0*0+
" 2
5!1"" 3
6A
= 2 3 ! "
1 4 ! " "3 ! 3
3 !5 3#0*0+
1!
4 2!" !
!! < ! 4 ! 5 F #0*0+
05 < # #
/! 2 # 4
# 1
%4 #44 18
"
!F !!05 < # #
3
3 < 2
4 ! +1 8 #
9 <1 ! 4"5 ! F "! /!!54 !!
<!"
! 3
4 < 8
! ! !2
52 76 <
455 3 ! .( .
1 3!
! 3 8
!2
5 ! !<"! 455 2
3 ! 8
0
4 ! 3! ! 4 1 3!
! !2 < 455 ! ""<1
4 1 ! 4
! F !" !
1
5! ! 1 ! " 4 4 3 ! %F
* 8 ! 3 ""2!' $
0 !3 1 4 >11! 3
2 %F
* 8
4 4 0 ! "
!
#1 ! 54 ! !" !
4 !"
<
/! 1
!" "" ! ! <3 !
" ! < 4! "
"< !
"! #
< ! "4 C 1 # "" #
4 % 1 "< :C; C # 5
54
>
4 1""< 3! "4
!<"! 455 " 5 1
!
5 " " <
455 ! .( .
$ / 4 4 3 !%F
* 8! 3 ""2 ! ' $
1 ! " !
" !
3 !
" 38! <"
5 "8
5 6 /!3 "
3 !! 2
(
!)!*+!# ,
8 J @!! "8
5 K ( @!!" K (