← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/6294/2016dismissed

Jagjit Singh v. Janamjit Kaur And ORS

2018-10-31Mr. Justice Amit Rawal6 pages

 

    

 

!"##$%&%'( $")#*+ , - !./%"%'.0 11#22!'" 3#*&4& !'!5/%"6!4* "0#*&  #&1'7#'"&  !

"#$%& '( )* & *)+%

*#&#'"( *!./%"%'.0!11#22!'"%'1#*&' 88888  *)+%,' 11#22!'"912!%'"%0!&!&&!%2#7"0#/47.5#'"&!'77#$*##& "0#$4*"&)#2:,:0#*#);"0#&4%"*2!;%'.$0!22#'.#""0#&!2#7##7&!'7 <!*%4&54"!"%'*#1*"&,0!&)##'7%&5%&&#7'"0#)!&%&"0#%'7%'.& .%<#''1*#2%5%'!*;%&&4#&,+,=, !'7 ":!&!<#**#7%'"0#12!%'""0!" !/645!*!>4*!%'.0&'

!/!  4*7%"  %'.0,  !"0#*    7##'7!'"   ,  :!&  :'#*    "0#  2!'7 5#!&4*%'.  =+  )%.0!&    )%&:!&  &%"4!"#7  %'  3%22!.#  !':!2!,  #0&%2 !5!'!,%&"*%$"  !"%!2!#"*!'&#**#72!'7 5#!&4*%'. +)%.0!&  )%&:!&%'"0#'!5#0%&75#&"%$&#*<!'" *#5%'.097##'7!'" :%"04"!';$'&%7#*!"%'!'754"!"%'7##7 +7!"#7 =? ?%'

"0%&*#.!*7:!&##$"#70#&!%7"*!'&#*:!&%'$''%<!'$#:%"0#!$0 "0#*);$'$#!2%'."0#!$""0!"%")#%'."0#&4*124&2!'7 !/645!* !>4*!%'.0#'/;#7"0#1&&#&&%'"0#&4*124&2!'7:0%$0:!&2!"#* $'<#*"#7%'"+?@!'!2&!&*#2#$"#7%'"0#/!5!)!'7%*"0#;#!* 9 4"!"%'7##7 + ?:!&:*'.,%22#.!2,%'1#*!"%<#!'7

 %'##$"%<#3!*%4&"0#*&!2#7##7&:#*###$"#7); !/645!*!>4*!

%'.0!'7 *#5%'.0%'$''%<!'$#:%"0#!$0"0#*!&*##**#7"%'"0# &4%" !/645!*!>4*!%'.0!.*##7"&#22+@!'!2&?5!*2!&2!'7" 7#$#!&#75!*%'.0,!"0#*"0#12!%'"%,4"+?@!'!2&&4*124&2!'7 <%7#!.*##5#'""&#227!"#7

=+)#!*%'.60!&*!AA -9 ,

-9 ,?AA =9

,= -9 , 9  !'7$51*%&#760#:!"A60!"4'% +?AA

?,

,

=,60!&*!AA = -9 , -9 ,?AAA ?9 ,= -9  , 9  ,?AAAA

9? ,&%"4!"#7:%"0%'"0#*#<#'4##&"!"#3%22!.# !*'!2!,#0&%2 !"*!',%&"*%$" !"%!2!!"#**#$#%1"+A9!&#!*'#&"

5'#;4"""!2&!2#1*%$#=A9 &&#&&%'"0#*#:!&7#2%<#*#7 "5!*%'.0)#%'.@':'"#!$0"0#* "0#*  ":  &!2#  7##7&    -   !'7  

  :#*# #B#$4"#7%'!<4*5!*%'.0!'7!*!%'%'.0,!"0#*7#$#!&#7 5!*%'.0$$*7%'."!.*##5#'", !/645!*!>4*!%'.0!.*##7" .#" "0#&!2#7##7 2!'7 5#!&4*%'.+@!'!2&?5!*2!&*#.%&"#*#7'

? =,)4"4'*"4'!"#2;0##B1%*#7!'7$427'".#""0#&!2#7##7 *#.%&"#*#72#.!2'"%$#7!"#7= =:!&&#*<#741'"0#:%7:

!/645!*!>4*!%'.0:%"0*#.!*7""0#!.*##5#'" "&#22!&"0# 12!%'"%!"#*"0#7#!"00%&!"0#*,0!&)##'%'$'"%'44&,1#!$#42!'7 4'%'"#**41"#71&&#&&%'

*#5%'.0!)*%$!"#7":&!2#7##7&  =,": ?+ =%'*#&1#$"2!'75#!&4*%'. +-@!'!2& +5!*2!&%'!<4* 7##'7!'"+!'77##'7!'"& " %'*#&1#$"2!'75#!&4*%'.+ @!'!2&?5!*2!&,1&&#&&%':0%$0:!&!2*#!7;:%"07#$#!&#75!* %'.0 ##'7!'"&11&#7"0#&4%")#%'.'"5!%'"!%'!)2#!&%":!&

- 0%");1*<%&%'& *7#* 42# ,%#,

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

0);%2%'.!11#!2:0%$0:!&7%&5%&&#7!'7"0%&4*"0!7!2& 7%&5%&&#7 #.42!*#$'711#!2'"0#*&4%":!&%2#7);4@0"%!* %'.0!'7!0%'7#* !2%'.0,%':0%$0!2&5!*%'.0$427'"1*<# "0#!.*##5#'""&#22!'7"0#&4%":!&7#$*##7<%7#/47.5#'"!'77#$*## 7!"#7  %*&"!'7&#$'7!11#!2&:#*#!2&7%&5%&&#7!'7"0# 1*#&#'"&4%":!&'"0%'.)4"!'!""#51""*#1#'"0#5!""#* '"0#)!&%&"0#12#!7%'.&"0#1!*"%#&,"0#"*%!24*" *!5#7"0#22:%'.

D0#"0#*"0#"*!'&#*5!7#); !/645!*!>4*!%'.0 %'!<4*7##'7!'"<%7# !1!"?=7!"#7  ? %&%22#.!2,'422!'7<%7!'7%&2%!)2#")#&#"!&%7#,!&1#* .*4'7&5#'"%'#7%'"0#12!%'"E

 D0#"0#*  !/  645!*  !>4*!  %'.0  #B#$4"#7  !'

!.*##5#'""&#227!"#7

=+%'<4*5!*%'.0F4!

&4%"1*1#*";!"#*!$$#1"%'.#!*'#&"5'#; &+A9E

+ D0#"0#*  "0#  &!2#  7##7&  <!&%@!   =  7!"#7



 =,<!&%@!   =  7!"#7   =,  <!&%@!   =+ 7!"#7  ?+ =,  <!&%@!   = 7!"#7 ?+ =, &4)&#F4#'"

54"!"%'&+,++,+!'7+?!*#2%!)2#")#&#"!&%7# )#%'.%22#.!2!'7*#&42"*!47E

D0#"0#* "0#  #B$0!'.# 5!7#  ); 7##'7!'"  +  :%"0 0%'7#* !2%'.0<%7#54"!"%'-7!"#7 =? --%& %22#.!2,'422!'7<%7E

?

D0#"0#*"0#12!%'"%0!&)#$5#:'#*":@!'!2& 2!'7  %'  60!&*!  ?AAA  ?9  '  "0#  )!&%&    !7<#*&# 1&&#&&%'E

D0#"0#*"0#12!%'"%%&#'"%"2#7"1&&#&&%'"0#&4%" 1*1#*";E

= D0#"0#*  "0#  /47.5#'"  !'7  7#$*##  7!"#7 

1!&&#7);06 !%, ,,!5!'!,%&'422!'7<%7, *#&42"*!47!'7%&'")%'7%'.41'"0#12!%'"%E

- D0#"0#*"0#&4%"%&5!%'"!%'!)2#%'1*#&#'"*5E

 D0#"0#*"0#&4%"%&:%"0%'2%5%"!"%'E

 D0#"0#*"0#&4%"%&0%");1*<%&%'&*7#**42# E  D0#"0#*"0#12!%'"%%&#&"11#7*5%2%'."0#&4%"E



 D0#"0#*"0#&4%"%&0%");1*%'$%12#&*#&/47%$!"!E 

+ D0#"0#*"0#&4%" %& )!7 *''9/%'7#*'#$#&&!*; 1!*"%#&E 

D0#"0#*"0#&4%"%&'"1*1#*2;<!24#7*"0#14*1&# $4*"##&!'7/4*%&7%$"%'E 

?

D0#"0#*7##'7!'"+!'70%'7#* !2%'.0,!"0#* 7##'7!'"&"!*#)'!%7#14*$0!&#*&*<!24!)2# $'&%7#*!"%'E 

#2%#G 0#*#!"#*  %&&4#&  ,  +,  =,    !'7    :#*#  "*#!"#7  !& 1*#2%5%'!*;'&411*""0#!*#5#'"%'#712#!7%'.&,12!%'"%"#'7#*#7 %'"#<%7#'$#<!*%4&7$45#'"&B

"B ?!'77##'7!'"&$2&#7 "0#%*#<%7#'$#:%"04""#'7#*#<%7#'$#

. ":!&5!7#$2#!*"0*4.0>%5'%*7#*"0!""0#1*#2%5%'!*; %&&4#&:#*#")#7#$%7#7'"0#)!&%&7$45#'"!*;#<%7#'$#0#"*%!2 4*"7%&5%&&#7"0#&4%");027%'."0!"'!.*##5#'"7!"#7

=+:!& #<#*#B#$4"#7!'7"0#&!2#7##7&,*##**#7"%'%&&4#+,:#*#<!2%7 #$*## :!&410#27!'7"0#&4%":!&0#27")#0%"); *7#* 42# !'7!&:#22!&)!**#7);1*%'$%12#

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

 ,54$02#&& *7#* 42# $427'"0!<#)##'1*#&&#7%'"&#*<%$# 0!<#0#!*7"0#!11#22!'",!11*!%&#7"0#1!1#*)@!'7"0# <%#:"0!""0#*#%&'*$#!'75#*%"%'"0#&4)5%&&%'& '"0#1*#<%4&/47.5#'"&!'77#$*##&'"%$#7);"0#$4*"& )#2:,5!*%'.0:!&!1!*";,:0#*#%'!.*##5#'""&#22:!&14*1*"#72; $427'")#1*<#70##'"%*#.#'#&%&!'77##'$#"0#1*#&#'"!11#22!'" !*#'"0#&!5#!.*##5#'"1#*&'$!''")#1#*5%""#7"*#9!.%"!"#"0# %&&4#'$#"0#1*#7#$#&&*9%'9%'"#*#&"!%2#7"7& *#<%4&/47.5#'"&

 !'77#$*##&7!"#7-- - B !'7 !'7 B  !'7B = ,$1;*#12%$!"%'B ?,$1;:*%""#'&"!"#5#'"B  !'7$1;!%7!<%"5!*%'.0B 0!7)##'1*<#7'*#$*7" #&"!)2%&0"0#!*#5#'"%'#7!$"22"0#!*#5#'"%'#7/47.5#'"&:#*# !&&!%2#741"'I)2#41*#5#4*",)4"5!*%'.0:!&'"&4$$#&&42

%.0":'#*&0%1<#*"0#2!'7:!&$2!%5#7);5!*%'.0,"04&,"0# 5!""#*%'%&&4#%'"0#1*#<%4&&4%"7%*#$"2;!'7&4)&"!'"%!22;%'%&&4#%'"0# 1*#&#'"$!&#!'7!$$*7%'.2;:!&0%");7$"*%'#!@%'"

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

234 '(56& +4/4378 93

 :39

+4/4 /0!

:39