Virender Singh v. Pankaj Ahlawat
RSA No. 2192 of 2014 -1IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB & HARYANA AT CHANDIGARH RSA No. 2192 of 2014 (O&M) Date of decision : 13.2.2023 ...
Virender Singh ................Appellant vs.
Pankaj Ahlawat .................Respondent Coram: Hon'ble Mr. Justice H. S. Madaan
H. S. Madaan, J.
1.
!"#$
%
$
&
' ( %
)* +!!,-
RSA No. 2192 of 2014 -2- .
/01
2
3
1
2
-2
/01
2 3 &
2 1
4
"*+ !!#
"5+ !!#$
) 67!!!!,-
-2
!+ !!# "++ !!*$
4
2
2
(
2
43 (
)67!!!!,-
8 #9 &
4
6 :
3
&
4 "*+ !!#$
)67!!!!,-
RSA No. 2192 of 2014 -3-
/;
<
4
&
1 !!*
4
$
2
, < ( &
5= !!*
)
> 6 7## 3<?& ( %
(
)
)"7!!!!,-
"=+ !!* > ++6#"" "=+ !!* : & (
;
1
>
: & (
;
(
2
)67!!!!,-
)"# +!!,- $
# $
RSA No. 2192 of 2014 -4- * From the pleadings of the parties, following issues were framed :-
1) Whether the plaintiff is entitled to the recovery of suit amount alongwith interest as prayed or to what extent? OPP
2. Whether the suit of the plaintiff is within limitation of time ? OPP
3. Whether the suit of the plaintiff is bad for non-joinder of necessary parties? OPD
4. Whether the suit of the plaintiff is not maintainable in the present form? OPD
5. Relief.
6..
>
5
;
1 @
2
A1
"
$
$ 6 #
.
% !# !"
7 B
%
2 1
2 1
% 6"" !"# %
;
RSA No. 2192 of 2014 -5-
- 8 "*9
+ B
% $ ;
2 1
;
-
>
"! $
"" $
-2
&
)67!!!!,-
,
"
;
-
4
D4
-"E
4
"6
;
3
RSA No. 2192 of 2014 -6-
2
)
2
4
2E-" :
( 2E- %&
> ++6#"" "=+ !!*
)"7!!!!,-
/;
<
D4
2-" 2-#
5= !!*$
>
)
$
>
>
(
$
4
)
(
> D4
2E7,&
)"7!!!!,-
RSA No. 2192 of 2014 -7- 2E-*2 (<
5= !!*)
2E-*
4
.
( %
F
F D4
2E7,&
F
F
22) 7 #+ !!* ;
1
"# /
2 1
/ ;
<
$
)67!!!!,-
)"7!!!!,-
(
F
$
"* $
%
1 1
/
2
%
;
RSA No. 2192 of 2014 -8-
"=
>
"5
Whether speaking / reasoned Yes / No Whether reportable Yes / No