← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/6344/2016allowed

Gurbax Kaur And ORS v. Major Singh And ORS

2022-12-21Mr. Justice Deepak Gupta12 pages

TARUN SAHNI 2022.12.23 13:41 

         

    !"#"$%%    &'( )* &' $+, '# -- ..

$# /# 1'"$2, $+, '#  #-$+ $#  0%3  450   *

 

   

  





 *

6 !  !" # $  # #"  %

!&'(  !)*+  &

',, -!.!*/0*+    *#( ! # (.!*+  $ !,.!

  12  , 

%5

&4 %'7

,08  .!!%

%449 ₹94441 , 2:& 2:

'

#,! !;

12





     

!# ( !! !!

#

%

%449 

< 

& 

',%4

%449 = % """  %45%4450 1'"$2, $+, '# /#7 '

$* &' $+, '#6,!# !  

&4 %'  ,-  %:

4% %449! 2:# ,! !! 

, 5  = 68 % ""(!

(0!  %451%445 ( - # !  %

%449  >  = 68 % ""#(

# ,,,%3 4% %44:



 ,    0       2   : -    

  !! ,,#( ,!,

#           #      ,,  - !,       %44: *#- !,46 %44: 

%45%4450 1' "$2,  $+ , '# /# 7 '

$ * &'  $+ , '##!,,#

  2:!#(# #!!; ! (( ,,  , - !,46 %44:#  

!

, !-(, ! )   # ,    (         

 ; 12  !#( %

%449  ,!!  %

.!)  *( ( - !,46 %44:  %45%4450 1'

"$2, $+, '#/#7 '

$* &' $+, '##( "  !  &  +'     #    ,,        

  (- !,#!

  (,-  ,!,  -(, ! 

=(

%   ), #(,#(

+ 2: ;

$      , !     , ,(#-  *((! #( .!)  # (.! ,.!

 (  !%

%449, 2:

* #/!  60 9  % ,  .!#!  !  ! !!   , !  5     !       ,    

&4 %' 4

635& 5 ' 43

632&9 '43

662& 2 '  !,!  5  !    .! *!, (#(-! 

 (,  !!  !   !!



#(,

?!, ! 60 9  & %,'

  49

633&90' %

66%& 0

'   %%

66% & 4 0' (   #          !        !      !, ! 5   !#(!    !  2:

 @ ( !!#  ,!! ,  !

 2:# ! 0!  ! 2: !,

, !!

< ,

 

%45%4450 1'"$2, $+, '#/#7 '

$* &' $+, '# !!!,- !  2:  .%:

4% %449"      "   !  &  +'         ,-  2: ,!1!!# !

, !! *!%:

4% %449 #( 2:-42 %449 > %:

4% %449 0

&4 %'(,  !          0   ,#        #              *0!  !        ,0  2:; %

%449 #(  (- !



 #  !  < 

# ,  = 68 % ""","  ! 2 2

:

,( *  = 68 % ""#( , &

'#,,,  2 :,!! #(  ; #(!  $ #,#(!! #((,, (!( ,,  ?- !,46 %44: #,, +  #(# #( 

+ !  #,  0% # ! ,!

! 5 #( 

 !  )!, !(, 

$-#(! 

<! ,#("  )( A= %

), - (A= ) ,#,A=+

)    A=+

)        #(      ,! A=+ 5

),"   ,A=+ :

) # -, - (A=+

) ,#A=+

8 :

0! #(, #("  =$ 

 %

%449#(#(  # #(- !,46 %44: "  %45%445   ! $ !$  %!#(! ((-  @$ 

 # ,#  @$  2 

$  53  "C  ! , - !,

4% %4 2#( " 

*      #(        ,  #(    <

" - !,%6 %4

!   #    !           $ , 

#, ; 12  !,0

&4 %' .!  ?" #0 &D;

+ D;

+ D;

+ D;

+5'; #(! .!*/0 .!  1!   $#(  !( *" # 0 ((! ;! 9

!(!, *- !, 46 %44:&D;

9D;

 4'  %45%445 0 1'"$2, $+, '#/#7 '

$* &' $+, '## ,,#

 2:

#0(!  

,#! !   *#!#(" # ,,##(  !  ##  +

# !  ((,, = % ""( $   5%*(  #- !,  #    ,0! %

%449D;

2 

,, ,!      # +) ,-!!

, ;, #(, ! .!, )  #,(,!, !- !, #(" # 1

8 ! !#(  # #! #!  !#,

$ #,#   !"  (

%

$ !    2: .! :

.!)*/0

/ ! - $  !  .!(8 ,!(-( , !

5                  ,    0

&4 %'.! !#,   *! !  #! #(!   ! !,, ! 049   .!

 D;

+ D;

+ D;

+ D;

+5( 633 66%

,  #- , #! -!  

 !!  !  , #  81! > #( 0 ,#8 ! , 0

&4 %',;   

 +) ,-!!

, ! ;, #(,!C  .!#, (!

*         !    5              ! ,0

&4 %'(! #(!  D;

+ D;

+ D;

+ D;

+5!   !

,   ! $, $ ,!!  

5  ! !% 

635  43

632    43

662        #(    ! , D ! 5     !! 3

, 5  !   #((    (  ,(#  5 #!  !#(!  (#,! 

#,#(+) - ,D;

+ D;

+ D;

+ D;

+5

   &4 %' (  !! 12    

2:, 

E7 #;  %

%449&D;

2' (   

C ! ; 12!

#, #(D; 2

C D; 2 #(#(  ;  !

( #



2: (

#(

! !  2:!!

5  !  (&

'

"  %45%44580 1'"$2, $+, '#/#7 '

$ * &'  $+  , '#9 !    2    :        $-   = 68  %""%:

4% %449#  #(, 0

&4 %'  ,      ?   , #(  

        #(  !    0     -  >#(, 2:(  ,0

&4 %' 

6

%

%449D;

2

:

D;

2

  = 68 % ""! 2:#( ,!

E7 #; #!  8(#( 7 #; !  >  ,,#



    2  :  #   ,,  ,!  ,             46 %44:

  "(   - !,D;

9D;

 D;

:(,,

$ ,!,,#

 2: 7 #; (( = % ""

  

>

,,,

(,,D;

:- !,46 %44:

#,,  #

  2:,, D;

: 2:#-,  !! #! !#   

#(!

##(, !!#(  2:(# !    2:; ( !!! ! 0 ,# 

2:!,,%3 4% %44:&D;

:' (; %

%449D;

2 

         2    :      ,       ( ,(!!  

- !,46 %44:&D;

9 4'#

4

,,D;

:"  %45%4450 1'"$2,

$+, '#/#7 '

$* &' $+, '#  ,!  #  $!5%*( ,( #  



          

       

   

 !



"#    

  $

 %

    

  

  

   

            &      

 

               

     

      



    

        

 

  

   ' (  ')         



 

     



           



 

         



   

  

    

 

                  

    

   '* %4

$,#,0( (((  ##!  !  # 

%

$- !,46 %44: "  %45%4450 1'"$2, $+, '#/#7 '

$* &'

$+, '#(  ,! 





     

   

2:     

  - !,#!! 

E7 #; %

%449 D;

2#( 

%%

?" # !          ,          *   , !- !,#(" ##(

 * E (! ! 

 ! :( ' 6   ; *

< ' $&   )0!1 F1 )8# F1

%