High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/4954/2015disposed of

Rajbir v. Raj Kumar

2019-04-05Mrs. Justice Rekha Mittal5 pages

!!"" # $ %$& ! '

$& () *+ ,!!""

, *+ , ! ----

.,! !!" ,"" (( / 01!2, "3+"4$( + *3, 5, , 6, "3$ 7 8 2 , 4$(* 9,) ), 2 $ " 2 , !" /!!"" + 2 8* /: ! !" &$ */: ,, 2)&$ ;$"1 3'3 , "3$ ) & !!" ' $", , "3$ )$" +",, $ ) $ 2 , !" ; &!" !" (,! *$) & ; ,) 11 + ,!" /!!"" $<$ , *,) $& + ,!" $$ (, ( $& &11""01*

,!!"" =& ,&" ) &"2 (,), =& ) &!" 1*,3$ ,1$ !2& /:)," 2 $ (+ , *) ! ,)( 01 + ,!" $ !2& 1/:( 01) 01 + ,!" ), , 1/:,""! , =>+ $""2 01*, "

3$ "+ ,!" ,$)&$ ;$"13'3 3$ " ,!!"" )$" ($, (,'?

) =& , 0 , =& ) , <$$ " , ! $, ) )$ ) ,=@$ , ($, ) $ ) 2,3$ " $ !! , *),$2,3$ $ , ! 2! ( +! , $& &2$ "

,+ , "3$ ,"+ ,!" 2 * ,3$ , + ,+ " 2$2,!" ! +,*, *&& $ , ""("2

& (,$& "22 ( ;$"13'3@! 2 ,, !2,3$ &2 ,& &, "3$ , ,*

),") 3$ " ! (, ! * , 2*)$" ($,,!!"" /!" "!21/:&! + 1*,!!"" ) "! ), , ,$""& , " @ $!! , *,, ,! + 1:9, 33+"' $ *0 , 6,37 @,+, $ " ,! *! $,!! 5 , "3$ 9 + (,$& &2$ " , ! *!! ! = 01!2, "3$ * ,$ :

'?! & $(,! $"" +" , !" , " $ + !+" ($ !! $ "$ (" 2A)+ *1/:," ! 2 , !" * , * @

$ $ , (, ,& !$ !A *+ !" , 2"2 3$ A *,! $, 2& $ ;$"13'3==== ' $", &5+ ,,$(,, &5 :!2& 1/:$ , "3$ , &,$ $ "$ , !" !21/:2 +5 ( 1,3@

)$" , , 1/: ) ""2 &!

1 !"$ ,!" !, , 01,3$ ! <$$ " ,!" , ,01 + ,!" (, 2,,3$ , 5 $+) "$ ,!" !21/:.,! *! $", )$" +", ! ) + ! !

,3$ +),B& 2, "3$ ,$ 1:9,3 &! &$ , , ! 2 !,=! $ 2,& (, 3$ ,= "2 & 2 ("*$"! , ! , ,!" /!!"" "!2 1/:*,,! +,&" !! $ 2 (,

& ,* ,"(,+ " 2$2,& + &, *, "3$ + , + " 2$2,!!"" ! + !! $ 2 , ! "+ $"* 2@ ,+), & * "2,", 01!2, " 3$ $ & $"("")

, $"

$ 2.,!!""3$ ),$=& (, &!$(

(, ! !+ , "(, "+ ! + 3'3 , && , 2 & (, !2, "3$ @ ,+),& *, !2,3$

"" ,& & , "3$ $ , ,+ " 2$2, !!"" /!" ), !! $ 2, ! $+ $"*$ ,)+ *!2& /: "$ ( 1/:&!2, "3$ *!2)2& , & ! C , ( ( * , !!" "") .,

!2,3$ ,& &, "3$ ,$ , , &@" ,,!!"" /!" ,"" "$ , 2 $ (+ ,)$" , + " 2$2,!!"" + $"

"2, ! C"$ ,!!"" !2 , !$")$" "&",!!"' , $(,, $ " !! , "3$

?,, ! "