← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2301/2014allowed

State Of Haryana v. Rohit Talwar

2016-02-11Mr. Justice Augustine George Masih10 pages

    

  

     

   

   ! !"" #$% " &'(! "  !  #$ "  )$$& "  *  !+ ,'*  *  "--'' !-. '*!+ *    

    %%&'

)  "--' ! !'  !   '/ "--' 0 "1 ! "--' *(""!2'

2-- !3  "!+ "'' /*,2/* "-

--' ''(! '  !  '/ "--' ! !! %%& '

)  "--' ! !' !  '/ "--'

 0 "1 ! "--' *(""!2'

2-- !3  "!+ "'' /*,2/* "-

--'     ''(!   '      !     '/  "  --'   ! !!

     &"  --'  "  3  -!  3  "         "''//  "42!/1 !!-!3  "!! ' 

52!/*,2/ ! ! 6  ("3  "--'-!3  -! / "42!/1 !!! !   -!3  "+'52!/752+8*,2/*3 (""

-!3  !' ( " "92 '' -1 42 (!1!*"3''(!

:

 "  "'!2' "--'' 

";(--'' 2 "!'( /( " "(''

!!! '!42!/1 -!3  "+'52!/752+8* ,2/*(" ("'! ( 1 3' "'/"

3 !2!

787<8  '/;!

'!/ *6 7" ! =6 =8! 

")2432 ;!&2 *67" !  =6 =8' /2- "42!/1 "2 ()*('+(+,-

(..  (/0  123+.*  6  );5  >     2 "        !' * " 3 / !3  ";( --'' 2   -! *2'( "2 3'("(/'

 - ! "02''<"42!/1 "2 1(13 (+4(/(+ 2(/05,(*66>);5   !  "-!/"+ 3'?!2! "6 ! "'!"3!'!2-'2*

(""-!/"+

!' * "-+2! 6  - "-!/'?!2! "6     !  "  -!   "+    "''/!  "  !

-!/2! " -'' (" "42! "+'2

3!! "1! --'!+" 3+'!3

"1:2-- "  *"-''2- "42!/1 

"2-12 *(+,/52+)*3+,/52*66 78); 

* "2* ! "1-2/!42!/1 !!!+ 3  !  @ " ""!*'!2' 231

"!/*!!3  "'!;(--'' 2 * !( "'(-'' (" "'+2 "-!    ! !  6 *(""-

 6>*("" "2 ! A!- > "6

    *  "2*   !  "  !  '!  "  3  A1- !  1 ! "2-'23/'!('"* "2* 3-'!2- "42!/1 "02''<" "2 2(/05, (*7.8(.372-8 2 " ! '

"2/" "1! --'

!+" 3+'!3  "-' 32 "- 2

(2'!  3  1 3'    "  1-2/!  12     6 6  ! !

 66 

+2 "   "3  !( "2 2/   "( "--  3/  '!  (   $+  "  !    !'/  "  '!  2-'2  ! !

 6 "3-! "3B "3/'!(1 3  +'1 )2*(""!-2"! --   6 !( "(- "!'!&"2 * "*"

/"

' 3  !3  ";(--'' 2 -- 2  "/ ( / !    " -!  ! "--'   2'42 "+ 31-'!( ") "* "2*31! !1/ "--'3 2-"'!/ "!-!3  ";( --'' 2

:"+!! "2311!3  "'!2'

 "- !( " " *"+/ "2/" "1-2/!

42!/1  &"  "! 32''!2 2! !  - ( " "  -+*--'3' &"/'( -- (1 3 +*("( 3/'!( "'! .'''! 1 )2(C /'/"+!'!!! !  6 !12 >(  !    +2    "  -2"  1   )2  "+/  31  3'2 (- "'!2 "'! +! ('!! ! ! 6> !6> +2/'/"*""23!* !1"!." 92'"1"!!!!

"'!(" !3 " +(!(*!;'*13!

.";' !12 " >6 ( !

"+2/'/"!1 " +(!(1"! ! "'/'"'! -- +2 +!'!!>! ! 66+'23'' ! &" 31 "A'2+(- "!

2 -- D" " --"! '9) (  "!'! "+2* " 1 B( 12  6 6! ! 66  

 "3 !

% +2 "    "3'

2!3  "23 +'@7+'8 21 )3!2 " *,2/*("3 

"3!-!3  "'' *(! ! 6 !

"-''' *  !! !666* "'! ""! 1 3 +* "3/'!(*(!'!2-'2! 2 '!+ ! "   2!  78 "6

 "-- !!  6*1 3 +("+/ 

'!2-'2(""(3 ! "-13''!&" '9 ) ( "32!  ! "12  "1  

&"-! 1+!--' --''

 @7+'8 21 )3!2 " A1- / '!

2! > "6  / " "!!'/

"'!2-'2' "12 6 6! !  66( -!( "2 42! !+' "--' 2'

42 !* "*(+!3  -'' (" "'!" '! 3'!3  "3/'!(1 3 +  6 12"3 "! -3! 2! > "6   6>  &"  !  --'   (  !1!  +!  !  ! !

     :

    "   /  "  2    !'   ( "   92 '  '    -1  42   (  -!  3  -!   ( "2 +'/ "1! 2!

"6 !C "6  &"92 '(("" " 78("

'!*("""3'!3 1 3 +*3/'!(

 6 *(2'!3-  !3  >78 "6  E:

*  "   "    "  !  ! !   6   -!  3  '' *(! "!! !666-!3  "-'

'' *   "3"''/ " E7 8D" "

1 3' "'/"

-342! "+'2

3 

 '/;! '!/ *6 !

  ")2432 ;!&2 *6E > ( " 92    >78 "6 (2'!3  * "'+ - "!''(

  !-    2-'2  78  +    "      '!  92!  3  "  % ,+1  " ,+1 2! '(

13/3   2! ")-2;( )243  ;(    3    "  3  " *       !- '!A

78

"-13'2! ")-2;( ")243 ;(  " "! 52' *6>G!

"-13'2! " *A- 3!

!-   "-- !! *"'' /"

" ,+1 2! "!  2-'2 ("" (2'!3  '!32 2"  !- 

)+!!  -(""+!!+ /2! 2" *!- '!"''332!   *  - 1-  * "-1("1" +!

& 8!78 AAAA AAAA AAAA AAAAH 6 &"02''<"42!/1 "2 "!'+! " - *1 (.:(/1;(<+(/0(/123++231(13 (+4(/((/0 (/123+6 6 );5 *(" ("'! "12(   2/ >! 78 "6 (2'!3 /+2''

 >782-  6 *   * A'2!1 -   78* 1!2-  6 *("" -  !3  >78 "6 *1' *7892 '!

3  "  ',+1 *7 892 3   2! )-2;( ")243;(*7892 3 "3 "  &" " '!A-13'2! ")243 ;( ")-2;((2'!3-  ! (1!-

 6>' / "3+ * "2392 02''<" "!/ 1=72-8*"'! 3! *("" -  !3  >78 "6 * " '!A -13'2! ")243;( ")-2;((2'!3 -  ! (1!-  6>  !1

!' *  "  '    +2    1   )2*  ("    -!    *! !   6 * (""-  6> "1(2'!3-  !- "3+ !02''<"42!/1  "'!(!'!2-'2+!!  "'' *(! !  6 *(""!" 3 "''/!! "-!/ !'?!* "1 3 -! "'/"

"42!/1 "2-12 *(+,/527.

8(.372-8(" "3"'! ("-!/2! "6  !'/ "'!2-'2"

!' 32 "'!2

= '?!2 ' "6 1 + / "'! * 2-'2-!/ 3-! "-+!/ 2! "6 1' 32 "'!( 2 '?! '' '' 1 -!

!!  <" 2."231+! '' 1  ! ! >  * (2'! 1B !  "- '(!B-/+( "'/2/   78 "6 *!/ (""* "!'!

2-'2  -13'"''+  " 

6 * -- !! &" '? 2-'2'! '' "! + /*

"2*92!1B!"'!3  =3' 2-1  2   *1  2(5:(/1,  3>,  (/0  (/123+ + 1(13  

(+4(/((/0(/123+666 78&"'1 * "/2!* 3- !  ( "!92  &"  3  92   (2'!  3  (" "  "  2  (2'!  3 1 3' "'/"

-3* !2!

78 7<8 "6 !  "6 &"'+ -  

787<8 "6 !''(

  <    42!   78    +'  2  "''  "+ 42! 78 AAA AAA AAA AAA AAA 

'*!!!'( " 1

(""2! "   92!    3  

'!*  !!!    !'

 ( "  3  0'  11*  "  ''     "  )3!

2 "   "6 

?

 $A'2    2   !  2 "   $A-   !( " "-+ " * "+'!  -!/! B1!2! " "'' 3 ''!92  2 3  "2 " H  -2' "3+-+ ( (2'!''

"( "42! "+'2 A-' 3!:2--

 "*31! "42!/1  "2 ()*('+ (+,- (..(/0123+.*6 );5>*;2<.2(@+(12<"(@*66678 );>!(02( (,+1(13 (+4(/(*66 78); >02 "*

"+!! "3/'!(*1 3 + ( /+  ( +!- !' "'!

2-'2:

-- ";(--'' 2 "-!! 21-  (2! 1 3 +* "3/'!

( ""! 3+! "33+  !!'/ "'!2-'2 3 1 B "'!( '' 

'2!! "'! "3/'!(!'2!!2392 ' *

 '' +'B/ "2 -++' --' 2'

42 (

 "(-'!!! !3 "1 !  "2*      "  --''

!!    &"    "  ''/'

11

!3  "2     /!  "        "  '!  2'    -!  "'!;(--'' 2 "-1' -!!

    "/2!  "32!-  -!/( " "! 1 "2-'292 "3/'!

(*2    "'/"

"+<"42!/1 

"2 )(5(+,/52(/0123+.+1(13 (+4(/((/0123+.6

 787+'86 * "'!(   '!   !

' '1 ! 32 3 -   78 6   *  "  2-'2  '!   !  + !     "       1  ''

213!(

 6  "-- !! - +

" (" " "'!(2 '?!  :+( "3+

'!

-- '(* ";(--'' 2 "(/' -!!  "'! "+'2 "42!    32 +' "--' 2'42  " 32! 

"3/'!(:

1  32 (  1 "  +!"3-!2!3 

  ( 2! "3/'!'! "( +!  :  +(    "  3+*  "  -  --'    ''(!  &" 1-2/!42!/1 ! !  6 -!3  " !! ' 

52!/*,2/"3  !! "42!/1 !!-!3

"+'52!/752+8*,2/! !   ! &"2  !!1! %%& '

:+( "!-' "1--'*- ! 92! -! "--'   !* "* "1 !!1! 3-+<(+4

6