Sawinder Singh v. Gurbachan Singh And ORS



 
 


 

!"# $#%&'&( )

!*&($#+&(,- ..#//!(" 0#+'1' 1+2!%-!(&(,-!($"-#+' 
#'.($#("' 
3456
7


8-#"-#+
#.+"#+' 6%!/#*'.!.#+'9!:2#!//*#$" '##"-#;1$,9#("< :#'

2#+# #++#$""-#
#.+"#+'+("< :#'

8-#"-#+"-#;1$,9#("'-1/$2#+#.+"#$&("-#&,#'"<:#' +#'#("3+$-&=$0%!"# +"-#!..#//!("
   

   +"-#+#!'('9#("&(#$&("-#!../&%!"&(=$#/!: $!:'

&(+#4 &/&(,"-#!..#!/'"!($'%($(#$("-#,+1($'9#("&(#$&("-# !../&%!"&( '"!($'$&'.'#$ !%%+$&(,/:

  !*&($#+  &(,-  ./!&("&

4!..#//!("  -!'  $&+#%"#$  "-#  .+#'#("

!..#!/!,!&('""-#;1$,9#("!($$#%+##$!"#$



.!''#$2:-+& 7!+,=&'"+&%"1$,#=1+$!'.1+0&$#*-&%-"-#!..#!/.+# #++#$2:

>!..#//!("!,!&('""-#;1$,9#("!($$#%+##? ?

.!''#$2:

9"9&"!&(,-="-#"-#(/#!+(#$&0&/1$,# #(&+&0&'&( =!"!/!

 *!'$&'9&''#$ +&# !%"' "-#.+#'#("%!'#!+#"-!""12#4*#//%((#%"&(&( @1#'"&(&'&('"!//#$&("-#(!9# $# #($!(" '&(%# ?A)&("-#/!($

"-#./!&("&

*-&%-*!',&0#("-&9&( !9&/:.!+"&"&(-##B.#('#' + "-#&('"!//!"&( "-#"12#4*#//*#+#2+(2:$# #($!("' "!($

""-!""&9#=$# #($!(" *!''#+0&(,&(
#0#(1##.!+"9#("

!'7!1(!(,=$# #($!("*!''#+0&(,&(+9:!($$# #($!("' !($ *#+#'#+0&(,&(./&%#/!&("&

2#&(,!"-9#-!'2##(/C&(,!

"#+!($ 9!&("!&(&(,  "-# "12#4*#//  &(  !//  +#'.#%"'  # -!' ,"  (/: '1+%#  

&++&,!"&(    -&'  /!($  # #($!("    1+2!%-!(  &(,-  !($  "-#+ #($!("'-!0# &/#$!(!../&%!"&(2# +#=!"#-,!+--1+&!( $!"#$ D

!($-!0#!$9&""#$"-!""-#./!&("&

&'*(#+ > "-'-!+#  /!($*"-#:2#%!9#&(&9&%!/"*!+$'-&9$1#"'9#$9#'"&% .+2/#9!($&(+$#+"-!+9-&9=$# #($!(" -!',&0#(!(!../&%!"&( "$# #($!(" +'-& "&(,"-#"12#4*#//%((#%"&( +9-&'/!($" '9#"-#+/!($# #($!("'!+#"+:&(,"'-& ""-#%((#%"&(#(%#"-&'

'1&"

.(("&%#=$# #($!("' !($ !..#!+#$!($ &/#$'#.!+!"# *+&""#('"!"#9#("' # #($!(" &(-&'*+&""#('"!"#9#("-!'./#!$#$ "-!"-#&'"-#!2'/1"#*(#+ "-#"12#4*#//%((#%"&(&($&'.1"#=*-&%- -!'2##(&('"!//#$&(7-!'+!

> =*-&%-&'#B%/1'&0#/:*(#$!($ .''#''#$2:-&9-#./!&("&

-!',"(+&,-"="&"/#+&("#+#'"*&"-"-# "12#4*#//%((#%"&(&($&'.1"#/!&("&

&'("1'&(,"-#"12#E*#// %((#%"&(&(@1#'"&(#(:&(,!//"-#+!0#+9#("'=$# #($!(" .+!:#$

+$&'9&''!/ "-#'1&" D # #($!(" !..#!+#$!($ &/#$'#.!+!"#*+&""#('"!"#9#(" #./#!$#$"-!"./!&("&

&'(#&"-#+%('19#+ "-#%((#%"&(&(@1#'"&( (+-/$#+ "-#$&'.1"#$%((#%"&(!($!''1%--#-!'(+&,-"="&"/#+ &("#+#'"&("-##/#%"+&%%((#%"&(&(@1#'"&(#(:&(,!//"-#+!0#+9#("'= #($!(" .+!:#$ +$&'9&''!/ "-#'1&" A
#./&%!"&(  *!'  &/#$  +9  "-#  ./#!$&(,'    "-#  .!+"&#'=

//*&(,&''1#'*#+# +!9#$34

8-#"-#+"-#./!&("&

&'#("&"/#$""-#+#/&# .#+9!(#("&(;1(%"&(!'.+!:#$ +< 8-#"-#+"-#./!&("&

&'#("&"/#$""-#+#/&# 9!($!"+:&(;1(%"&(!'.+!:#$ +< 8-#"-#+"-#'1&"&'("9!&("!&(!2/#&("-# .+#'#(" +9< 8-#"-#+./!&("&

-!'(/%1''"!($&" &/#"-# .+#'#("'1&"<

#/&# ) -#.!+"&#'-!0#/#$"-#&++#'.#%"&0##0&$#(%#("-#! +#'!&$ &''1#'-#"+&!/1+"!

"#+!..+!&'!/ "-##0&$#(%#$&'9&''#$"-#'1&"

"-#./!&("&

0&$#;1$,9#("!($$#%+##$!"#$? ?

?  ##/&(,!,,+&#0#$="-#./!&("&

.+# #++#$&+'"!..#!/ -# /#!+(#$  &'"+&%"  1$,#=  1+$!'.1+  0&$#   ;1$,9#("  !($  $#%+##  $!"#$ 



$&'9&''#$"-#!..#!/ "-#./!&("&

"&//  ##/&(,  $&''!"&'

&#$  *&"-  "-#  !

+#'!&$  ;1$,9#("'  !($ $#%+##'=  "-#  .+#'#("  +#,1/!+  '#%($  !..#!/  -!'  2##(  $&+#%"#$  2:  "-#

>!..#//!("

-#!..#//!("&(.!+!,+!.- ? "-#,+1($' !..#!/=-!'

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

-!0#-#!+$/#!+(#$%1('#/ +"-#!..#//!("!($-!0#,(# "-+1,-"-#%!'# &/#

-&'&'!9#+#'1&" +.#+9!(#("&(;1(%"&( +#'"+!&(&(,"-# #($!("' +9'"..&(,"-#./!&("&

 +91'&(,"-##/#%"+&%%((#%"&(

+&++&,!"&(,-&' &#/$'-# &($&(,+#"1+(#$2:2"-"-#1+"'2#/*&'

"-!"./!&("&

-!'(+&,-"&("-#+#'.#%"&0#'1&".+.#+":!($9+#0#+= #/#%"+&%%((#%"&(-!'!/+#!$:2##("+!('

#++#$=('12'"!("&!/@1#'"&(  /!*-!'!+&'#(&("-#.+#'#("!..#!/-#@1#'"&( !%"%!(("2# !,&"!"#$&("-#+#,1/!+'#%($!..#!/-#+#&'("-&(,("-#+#%+$"-!" 2"-"-#1+"'2#/*-!0#9&'+#!$!($9&'&("#+.+#"#$"-##0&$#(%#!($ &("#+ #++#$&("-##0&$#(%#("-# &/#=-!0#(-#'&"!"&(&(-/$&(, "-!"('12'"!("&!/@1#'"&( /!*-!'!+&'#(&("-#.+#'#("!..#!/

('#@1#("/:="-#.+#'#("!..#!/&'*&"-1"!(:9#+&"!($"-# '!9#'"!($'$&'9&''#$

%.: "-&';1$,9#("2#'#("""-#"+&!/1+" +'"+&%"

%9./&!(%# 
 



 

!    "