High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/5054/2015dismissed

Mewa Singh v. Nasib Singh & ANR

2015-10-05Mr. Justice Arun Palli3 pages

!"# $#%&'&()

#*!&(+, -..#//!(" 0#1'2' !'&3&(+,!($!(",#1 -#'.($#("' ) 4 5 55

1#'#(") 1 !'3&1&(+,6$7%!"# 1",#!..#//!(" 888

9,#",#1 1#.1"#1' /%!/ .!.#1' :!; 3# !//*#$ " '##",#<2$+:#("=

3#1# #11#$"",#1#.1"#1'1("= > 9,#",#1 ",# <2$+:#(" ',2/$ 3# 1#.1"#$ &( ",# $&+#'"= 888 55 1!/ 2&" &/#$ 3; ",# ./!&("&

*!' $#%1##$ 3; ",# "1&!/ %21" 7&$# <2$+:#(" !($ $#%1## $!"#$ ? ?

' #7#( ",# !..#!/ .1# #11#$ !+!&('" ",# '!&$ $#%1## !&/#$ !($ *!' $&':&''#$7&$#<2$+:#("$!"#$ > >

6$# #($!(" &' 3# 1#",&'%21"&(",&'1#+2/!1'#%($!..#!/ !1"&#'"",# /&'6,#1#&(!

"#16*2/$3#1# #11#$"3;",#&11&+&(!/.'&"&(' &(",#'2&" (!'2&" &/#$3;",#./!&("&

6,#.1!;#$ 1!$#%1##

1 &(<2(%"&( '&:./&%&"#16 1#'"1!&(&(+ ",# $# #($!("' 1: $&'.''#''&(+",#./!&("&

1:",#'2&".1.#1";:#("&(#$!" /#""#1@!($ 1:&("#1 #1&(+&(,&'.''#''&(,#.1.#1"; &(A2#'"&(,!..#(#$"3#!1#'&$#("&!/,2'# ",#./!&("&

6 !($ *!' ',*( 3; /#""#1' &( 1#$ %/21 &( ",#

'&"#./!(!..#($#$*&",",#./!&(".!1" &"*!'%:.1&'#$ &( B,!'1! C !($ ",# 1#'" &( B,!'1! C 6 '&"2!"#$!"0&//!+##,$$!(6#,'&/ !''& !",!(!6&'"1&%" !"#,+!1,!,&3 ( ! $2# !($ %:.1#,#('&7# %('&$#1!"&( ",# :!""#1 &( &''2#6!($ ",##7&$#(%# ( 1#%1$63",",#%21"' %(%211#("/; %(%/2$#$ ",!" ",# %("#'" 3#"*##( ",# .!1"&#' *!'(/;!'1#+!1$'B,!'1!C 6!'$# #($!(" ,!$ %(%#$#$ ",# "&"/# !' !/' ",# .''#''&( ",# ./!&("&

A2! B,!'1! C ,# %/!&: ",# $# #($!("' ",!" $# #($!(" *!' 1#%1$#$ !' <&(" *(#1 &( B,!'1! C 6 *!' ,!1$/; !(; %('#A2#(%# !' ",# A2#'"&( "&"/# *!' (" 1#A2&1#$"3#+(#&("&(",#.1#'#("'2&"($6!//*,!"*!' 1#A2&1#$ " 3# $#"#1:&(#$ *!' !' " *,&%, .!1"; *!' &( .''#''&( ",# .1.#1"; %:.1&'#$ &( B,!'1! C

/!&("&

.17#$(1#%1$",#'&"#./!(D

",!"',*#$",# #D!%"$#'%1&."&( ",#$&'.2"#$.1.#1";!($",#'!:#*!' $2/;.17#$3;1!

"':!( (",#%("1!1;6$# #($!("'

!&/#$ " 31&(+ ( 1#%1$ !(; '&"# ./!( " ',* !' " *,&%, .1"&( ",#/!($&(A2#'"&(",#;*#1#&(.''#''&( " <2'" ",!"6 <!:!3!($& 1 ",# ;#!1

',*#$ ./!&("&

"3#&(.''#''&( ",#'2&".1.#1";:2%,'6 ",#<!:!3!($& 1",#;#!1 E D 6.1$2%#$3;((# ",#1 ",!( ",# $# #($!("'6 !/' .17#$ ",!" ./!&("&

*!' &( .''#''&( ",#$&'.2"#$/!($"<2'"",!"6%#1"& &#$%.&#'

> ",# <2$+:#("' !($ $#%1##' D " D E '23'"!("&!"#$ ",# *(#1',&. !' !/' ",# .''#''&( ",# ./!&("&

A2! B,!'1! C 6 &( ! .1#7&2' /&"&+!"&( (%#$#$/;6 ",# '!&$ $#%1##' ,!$ '&(%# !""!&(#$ &(!/&"; ( !%"6 21%,!1!( &(+,6 *, !..#!1#$ !' 9 6 %(%#$#$ &( ,&' %1'' #D!:&(!"&(",!",#*!'(#7#1',*(&(.''#''&( ",#'2&" /!($&(",#1#%1$ 1&+,"',!"3#&(+'6!($./!&("&

,!7&(+ 3##( 2($"3#&(.''#''&(6*!'+1!("#$&(<2(%"&(.1!;#$

1 5#!1(#$ %2('#/ 1 ",# !..#//!(" %2/$ (" .&(" 2" !' " ,* ",# %(%/2'&(' ",!" ,!$ %(%211#("/; 3##( 1#%1$#$3;3",",#%21"'3#/**#1##&",#1%("1!1;"",# .'&"&((1#%1$1'2

#1#$ 1:!(;:!"#1&!/&//#+!/&"; ",#1!1+2:#("*!'!$7!(%#$ ( ",# *!B# ",# .'&"&( !' '#" !37#6 ",#1# ,!1$/; #D&'"' !(; +12($6 /#!'" ./!2'&3/# &( /!*6 " &("#1 #1# *&",",#$#%1##3#&(+!''!&/#$A2#'"&( /!*6:2%,/#'' !(; '23'"!("&!/ A2#'"&( /!*6 !1&'#' 1 %('&$#1!"&( ..#!/3#&(+$#7&$ :#1&"&'!%%1$&(+/;$&':&''#$ %"3#16

!<!( 12( !//& 2$+#