← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2352/2014dismissed

Sukhwinder Singh And ORS v. Malook Singh And ORS

2015-10-13Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan7 pages

  

 

          

 

 !

"#$$%

'() &*+,- "

.& "/,"

,.!

$$$$$0011"!

2.!*!

)1

+& "/,"

,.!

$$$$$$!0 "!

$34

'() &*+,- "

.& "/,"

,.!

$$$$$0011"!

 2.!*!

)1

+& "/,"

,.!

$$$$$$!0 "!

$'''

'() &*+,- "

.& "/,"

,.!

$$$$$0011"!

 2.!*!

)1

+& "/,"

,.!

$$$$$$!0 "!

)#

 56 )$&  76&

.!"#8 ).$ $&$. -19 :

9

.,0011"!

"11,001!$ $ ;,,.,0 ..!

1 1"-!00.<=>11 - ! ,?* /<"@ $

>. .. ,0 .. ."

$ $ ;,,.,?* /<"!, >.0 .  ", /!@ 8$8 8$8 76&

9$6

, !?* /<"

< "- 11 !0 !

& !$%9 34"

'''

'9 1 ! 



       

    .>.: =9, !,:>"

+" <&

'$

88 <0*/"  ",0.!"./*1.! 001 !, ?* /<"  "

.   $$9  0!!  >=  ,  1."



 "1 !.  * /9 70*.,19

.< "/,?* /<""

.  '$$90!! >=, 1." 

 "1 : 1 * /  &"

.   : !

"9  70*.,19  :

  -, ,  ,  !*  

 , 01 "

!-!0.1= . $ .  ! 

 ,  !  .  ,  ,  01 "

!  ,

,11"/  ,.  !1  !   A$4$44A9  B$$44A  "

$$4449C* >= $! " 9> "/, /".1 ."=

<& "/, 9-, -!, . / "1

-".

,1"

9 ",>! !

".1 -.

 ."=

$3$44A9  " *. 

"!  $    ! "   "

$0.!"0011"9-, ,00" >, ! *! "

!

".!0 :1=$  ,01 "

!1!

1 < ,<& "/,  9-, "B$$444$  !.:  ",.<="

 .  , !  . .<"9  ,  !1  "  : 11/  &"/ ?19   !.  70*.,1$  ,  */,.9"<1=9) , "

.7*.-, -!

0.<""1=!1  ""  7 "/

<7"

",!0 "!

.!, 0

, ! */,.9<& "/,< /. 7 ., !. .<" < ,.<=$  ,01 "

!1!

1 < ,<& "/,  -!,.1*"1

!$ ,=1!

1 < ,,< & "/,< "

 "4$'$44A-,",-!> *=.!

/$<& "/,-! " > "

!, >"

88

+ "/ ., <$* !.: ."

. >=01 "

!9<& "/, C* ; 11 '$%$44A "

!$  $9 ", ,.,"

91 < ,-,"

<& "/,< "

 <79,: !  : 11/&"/ ?1"

!= - ,, <$ 1

+  .<& "/,"

, " *"

!.: ! ."

. >= "  $  "

 , ! !

"9 < & "/, 00 " &-."& "/, $, !/".10 -.

 ."= "$3$44A>=-=

./ !. C* >

. &*>/ !..97..0*.9"

,1!

C* ; 11

,!<

 ", ! *.$ "! $"

0.

.< ,1!. !

.< " !

<& "/,-,",-!> *4=.!

/$

,C*

!1 !-!"

 "  $  .,. "/> ,,0. !9,1 *.

,*"./ !. ; 11 '$%$44A9!*0>=,01 "

! :.

*!/.

*"

!$ ,:,.

,1." *"!1

.,0011"!"

,:1!

. *11=/ ",.

*/,, 1$

,; 11-!*"./ !. $ -!,1 >=,1 -.

*.,,; 11 C$,!>"!. > >=2 ?=7*<.9-,

,00"! >1.+

&,.  !, .& "/,,1 -19 :

9 -, -!.0.!" "/,01 "

!>

.,1 *.$ -!

- .+ "/ " !.  *.!0.< !!970*.,19"

 !!

,:>">.

*/, ".>=)1

+& "/,$ ,1 *.,1

8'8 ,-,"1.+ >>.

*/, < !.  *.!0.< !!

: 11/ &"/ ?19 -,=  ./*1.  -. . -! "

  >.

*/, 

!. > "/,; 11!,01 "

!,  <  , .: 11/ 11! "

, 1-"-,.,..-. .!$  ,,*<> <0.!!

< & "/,-! "+!<* / $ ,.-!"

.!

"-,=, "+ ", ,*<>-!"

+" <, "+0

.0* "/,*<> <0.!!

<& "/, ",; 119-, ,-!! >>.

*/,>=2 ?= 7*<.91.+$ ,1 *.1!

!>1 : ,,01 "

!

-.!.: "/, $  ,01 "

!  1 0.

*, 0!!0 ."

 +

9-, ,-..,.0.

* >= , "!$ *.,.9,. 0./.

"/,0.

.<"

1!. !"

.< " !-!1!

0.

* >=, "!$

,1 *.1!

"

  ,,.<& "/,;9"! "/ - "!!

,; 119 0 ! ,, !.1 . & "/,9-,  !

" ,.,", ,.

!$ ,. !"

.!

"-,= , - 11 ! ",. , ! */,.) , "

.7*.9-, ,

!0 "!

. , <"

+, < "/1"

"

0.

>>1=< /,,: >"."

. "/ " . ,.+ "

!.: !"

1

+ "/ ., <$

,.

.9  ,  ; 11   '$%$44A   C$  -!  ,1    > !*!0 *!"

-! $ < "/  $3$44A C$;("

; 11

,!<  "

$9 -!,1 >=, *., $

+ :0. ",C*

8%8 , "

,; 11$ -! *.,.,1  ,<& "/,-!

>.

*/, <: 11/&"/ ?1"

,: 11/&"/ ?1 11! " !.  70*.,1"

!*> !. , 1-"$-! <  >=- "!!!

",-, 1/ "/ 1"

,. <&"/ ?19 ",!

!!70*.,1$ ,.

.9,. !"

.!

"-,=, "

,; 11-."

C* 70*.,1 ., 1-"$ *.,.9  -!"

  ,-.

"/

.!!

<& "/,

1"

,. =9 $$'A91 ) ,1191"

,. =9-!/ :"$-!0.

: < ,!<"

C "1.+9)*"  01 .0 . "91"

,.

 =9  ,  <  & "/,  ":.  .!

 ,.$   ,  6<>.

. 

1"

,., ! ,; 11$ ,1 *.1!

*> !<$",; 119,/

-!<" " !% =.!/ "!4=.!!1 < >=, "!"

=.!

!1 < >=,01 "

!$ C01" ", >"/ :"!

-,=,/

<& "/,-!. * ,1

, !/$  ,

"!, 1!

1 < ,,=*! 1

+ .,*. " 1

<& "/,9-, ,<"!,<& "/,-!!

<*, < 11=*"

,,*! 0!!*. "(!

1 ", !> $ , !

-!,!

,1,

<& "/,9, "

,:/ " *

,: 11/$ $ !"

.1 <& "/, .,-! <  1=11 ""= *" ">=<& "/,$ !

1!

>"

  , .,C*

- , " -< ",!9 ,!1 !-.C* >= $ "

, !

8B8 !

"  "

*! "$   70 "/  " : - ,  1 !  .1 "!, 0 

 , :"

!- , $9,=""

>.< !> "

0*.,!.$ "

9, :.11:

"/ :!, <0.!!

", <& "/,9" C8&.: <"9-, -!>-"4 =.!

/"

-!0.<""1=!1  "79, < <7 "

 ,. .9> ,,0. !!. <+ "/

.! /.>, !

0.

0.=>=  "/ " ., ,.! .=$  ,  !

! ,: < "

 "4$'$44A$  "B$$444$

,01 "

!, "

 < ) , "

. 7*.! 0.=  ,!*  , */,!,-!"!!.=0.= ",!*!!

!0*> "/ 1!!8, .

<& "/,$ ,; 11

!"

"!

! "

 !1!

9,0.

0.= ! /

,1/1, .!

<& "/,$ 6." *"!1

.,0011"!,!. .. *, .  ! 

 , 0C   *.  " 

       



 3 : 1%43"

         

         



 %&%B 0.!!,, ",."0 -.*"

.& %">C. ! :.=!0. "/1=$ <

,: -,-,"" ,.,01 "

!"

.,

"!. /,0.

0.=9,1 *.. /,1= .

,,0.

0.=

<& "/,!, ><*  "

, !

"*.1, .!9-, , ! ,.- !1!

,1/1 *=

,.:"*

*, .  !  "  ,  ; 119  !1  !  "

 .  !  !

$

,.

.9  -,  ,  1 -.   *.  ,!  . 9  !  ,  "*.1

"!D*"9-, ,

-,.!*1

,!* 9 "/1 <

> ,,0. !$) . :.9, .*<!"!

,!.!*, ,:" , ",."0 -.!. >C. ! 9, ! ! ! -,.!*,0 -.!!, ,:>"C. ! $ ",! .*<!"!9-,"> ,,0. !-"

/.>,1"

<& "/,9<

,: -,

.1"



 :?*! 9,1 *., . /,1= .  !.  11 .970*.,19 <*,1"

 "

1/1, .!

<& "/,:", */,9,.-!"

!0 0.=.

- , ./.

   , !<$      ,  ,  1 -.  *.  ,!  :.= < "*1=C< " ,"

:.= "

. "/!

,. "$  , "/!-. "*.. >=,1." 

 "1  !.   * /9  70*.,19  :

  ?* /<"  "

. 

$$$/.- ,, "/!. >=> ,, *.!

>1 - "<. !$) . :.9"

!*>!" 1D*!

1-. !! "

,0.!"001$ "911,,.001!!"

!< !! $ 0= 

 , !  .  >  !"    ,   !.    11 .9 70*.,19

. "

.< ""

"!!.= "$ 76&

 

$$% !?+!