Sukhwinder Singh And ORS v. Malook Singh And ORS
!
"#$$%
'() &*+,- "
.& "/,"
,.!
$$$$$0011"!
2.!*!
)1
+& "/,"
,.!
$$$$$$!0 "!
$34
'() &*+,- "
.& "/,"
,.!
$$$$$0011"!
2.!*!
)1
+& "/,"
,.!
$$$$$$!0 "!
$'''
'() &*+,- "
.& "/,"
,.!
$$$$$0011"!
2.!*!
)1
+& "/,"
,.!
$$$$$$!0 "!
)#
56 )$& 76&
.!"#8 ).$ $&$. -19 :
9
.,0011"!
"11,001!$ $ ;,,.,0 ..!
1 1"-!00.<=>11 - ! ,?* /<"@ $
>. .. ,0 .. ."
$ $ ;,,.,?* /<"!, >.0 . ", /!@ 8$8 8$8 76&
9$6
, !?* /<"
< "- 11 !0 !
& !$%9 34"
'''
'9 1 !
.>.: =9, !,:>"
+" <&
'$
88 <0*/" ",0.!"./*1.! 001 !, ?* /<" "
. $$9 0!! >= , 1."
"1 !. * /9 70*.,19
.< "/,?* /<""
. '$$90!! >=, 1."
"1 : 1 * / &"
. : !
"9 70*.,19 :
-, , , !*
, 01 "
!-!0.1= . $ . !
, ! . , , 01 "
! ,
,11"/ ,. !1 ! A$4$44A9 B$$44A "
$$4449C* >= $! " 9> "/, /".1 ."=
<& "/, 9-, -!, . / "1
-".
,1"
9 ",>! !
".1 -.
."=
$3$44A9 " *.
"! $ ! " "
$0.!"0011"9-, ,00" >, ! *! "
!
".!0 :1=$ ,01 "
!1!
1 < ,<& "/, 9-, "B$$444$ !.: ",.<="
. , ! . .<"9 , !1 " : 11/ &"/ ?19 !. 70*.,1$ , */,.9"<1=9) , "
.7*.-, -!
0.<""1=!1 "" 7 "/
<7"
",!0 "!
.!, 0
, ! */,.9<& "/,< /. 7 ., !. .<" < ,.<=$ ,01 "
!1!
1 < ,<& "/, -!,.1*"1
!$ ,=1!
1 < ,,< & "/,< "
"4$'$44A-,",-!> *=.!
/$<& "/,-! " > "
!, >"
88
+ "/ ., <$* !.: ."
. >=01 "
!9<& "/, C* ; 11 '$%$44A "
!$ $9 ", ,.,"
91 < ,-,"
<& "/,< "
<79,: ! : 11/&"/ ?1"
!= - ,, <$ 1
+ .<& "/,"
, " *"
!.: ! ."
. >= " $ "
, ! !
"9 < & "/, 00 " &-."& "/, $, !/".10 -.
."= "$3$44A>=-=
./ !. C* >
. &*>/ !..97..0*.9"
,1!
C* ; 11
,!<
", ! *.$ "! $"
0.
.< ,1!. !
.< " !
<& "/,-,",-!> *4=.!
/$
,C*
!1 !-!"
" $ .,. "/> ,,0. !9,1 *.
,*"./ !. ; 11 '$%$44A9!*0>=,01 "
! :.
*!/.
*"
!$ ,:,.
,1." *"!1
.,0011"!"
,:1!
. *11=/ ",.
*/,, 1$
,; 11-!*"./ !. $ -!,1 >=,1 -.
*.,,; 11 C$,!>"!. > >=2 ?=7*<.9-,
,00"! >1.+
&,. !, .& "/,,1 -19 :
9 -, -!.0.!" "/,01 "
!>
.,1 *.$ -!
- .+ "/ " !. *.!0.< !!970*.,19"
!!
,:>">.
*/, ".>=)1
+& "/,$ ,1 *.,1
8'8 ,-,"1.+ >>.
*/, < !. *.!0.< !!
: 11/ &"/ ?19 -,= ./*1. -. . -! "
>.
*/,
!. > "/,; 11!,01 "
!, < , .: 11/ 11! "
, 1-"-,.,..-. .!$ ,,*<> <0.!!
< & "/,-! "+!<* / $ ,.-!"
.!
"-,=, "+ ", ,*<>-!"
+" <, "+0
.0* "/,*<> <0.!!
<& "/, ",; 119-, ,-!! >>.
*/,>=2 ?= 7*<.91.+$ ,1 *.1!
!>1 : ,,01 "
!
-.!.: "/, $ ,01 "
! 1 0.
*, 0!!0 ."
+
9-, ,-..,.0.
* >= , "!$ *.,.9,. 0./.
"/,0.
.<"
1!. !"
.< " !-!1!
0.
* >=, "!$
,1 *.1!
"
,,.<& "/,;9"! "/ - "!!
,; 119 0 ! ,, !.1 . & "/,9-, !
" ,.,", ,.
!$ ,. !"
.!
"-,= , - 11 ! ",. , ! */,.) , "
.7*.9-, ,
!0 "!
. , <"
+, < "/1"
"
0.
>>1=< /,,: >"."
. "/ " . ,.+ "
!.: !"
1
+ "/ ., <$
,.
.9 , ; 11 '$%$44A C$ -! ,1 > !*!0 *!"
-! $ < "/ $3$44A C$;("
; 11
,!< "
$9 -!,1 >=, *., $
+ :0. ",C*
8%8 , "
,; 11$ -! *.,.,1 ,<& "/,-!
>.
*/, <: 11/&"/ ?1"
,: 11/&"/ ?1 11! " !. 70*.,1"
!*> !. , 1-"$-! < >=- "!!!
",-, 1/ "/ 1"
,. <&"/ ?19 ",!
!!70*.,1$ ,.
.9,. !"
.!
"-,=, "
,; 11-."
C* 70*.,1 ., 1-"$ *.,.9 -!"
,-.
"/
.!!
<& "/,
1"
,. =9 $$'A91 ) ,1191"
,. =9-!/ :"$-!0.
: < ,!<"
C "1.+9)*" 01 .0 . "91"
,.
=9 , < & "/, ":. .!
,.$ , 6<>.
.
1"
,., ! ,; 11$ ,1 *.1!
*> !<$",; 119,/
-!<" " !% =.!/ "!4=.!!1 < >=, "!"
=.!
!1 < >=,01 "
!$ C01" ", >"/ :"!
-,=,/
<& "/,-!. * ,1
, !/$ ,
"!, 1!
1 < ,,=*! 1
+ .,*. " 1
<& "/,9-, ,<"!,<& "/,-!!
<*, < 11=*"
,,*! 0!!*. "(!
1 ", !> $ , !
-!,!
,1,
<& "/,9, "
,:/ " *
,: 11/$ $ !"
.1 <& "/, .,-! < 1=11 ""= *" ">=<& "/,$ !
1!
>"
, .,C*
- , " -< ",!9 ,!1 !-.C* >= $ "
, !
8B8 !
" "
*! "$ 70 "/ " : - , 1 ! .1 "!, 0
, :"
!- , $9,=""
>.< !> "
0*.,!.$ "
9, :.11:
"/ :!, <0.!!
", <& "/,9" C8&.: <"9-, -!>-"4 =.!
/"
-!0.<""1=!1 "79, < <7 "
,. .9> ,,0. !!. <+ "/
.! /.>, !
0.
0.=>= "/ " ., ,.! .=$ , !
! ,: < "
"4$'$44A$ "B$$444$
,01 "
!, "
< ) , "
. 7*.! 0.= ,!* , */,!,-!"!!.=0.= ",!*!!
!0*> "/ 1!!8, .
<& "/,$ ,; 11
!"
"!
! "
!1!
9,0.
0.= ! /
,1/1, .!
<& "/,$ 6." *"!1
.,0011"!,!. .. *, . !
, 0C *. "
3 : 1%43"
%&%B 0.!!,, ",."0 -.*"
.& %">C. ! :.=!0. "/1=$ <
,: -,-,"" ,.,01 "
!"
.,
"!. /,0.
0.=9,1 *.. /,1= .
,,0.
0.=
<& "/,!, ><* "
, !
"*.1, .!9-, , ! ,.- !1!
,1/1 *=
,.:"*
*, . ! " , ; 119 !1 ! "
. ! !
$
,.
.9 -, , 1 -. *. ,! . 9 ! , "*.1
"!D*"9-, ,
-,.!*1
,!* 9 "/1 <
> ,,0. !$) . :.9, .*<!"!
,!.!*, ,:" , ",."0 -.!. >C. ! 9, ! ! ! -,.!*,0 -.!!, ,:>"C. ! $ ",! .*<!"!9-,"> ,,0. !-"
/.>,1"
<& "/,9<
,: -,
.1"
:?*! 9,1 *., . /,1= . !. 11 .970*.,19 <*,1"
"
1/1, .!
<& "/,:", */,9,.-!"
!0 0.=.
- , ./.
, !<$ , , 1 -. *. ,! :.= < "*1=C< " ,"
:.= "
. "/!
,. "$ , "/!-. "*.. >=,1."
"1 !. * /9 70*.,19 :
?* /<" "
.
$$$/.- ,, "/!. >=> ,, *.!
>1 - "<. !$) . :.9"
!*>!" 1D*!
1-. !! "
,0.!"001$ "911,,.001!!"
!< !! $ 0=
, ! . > !" , !. 11 .9 70*.,19
. "
.< ""
"!!.= "$ 76&
$$% !?+!