← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/6464/2016dismissed

Atma Singh Deceased Th His Legal Heirs Malkiyat Singh And ANR v. Budh Singh And ORS

2018-07-18Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan16 pages

       



!"# $#%&'&() *+, -.

- "/!&(01$#%#!'#$"12*013!($!("1#2 44#++!("'

5#2'*'

*$1&(01!($"1#2'

#'4($#("'



 6- 

7 !"# $#%&'&() *+,.

- !242##"&(01!($"1#2'

44#++!("'

5#2'*'

*$1&(01!($"1#2'

#'4($#("'

) 8 3 93 

2#'#(")  

         

 !

 ""     #$       %&  !' # "  ( $  "      ! )  ! *    )  +$" ,  ()  - *+$" $) ", 93  

    "  +$"   .          

 "$   )  "

 !

%&  !'

 "  +$"   '!  !

 )   

 /0$" 1  )   "+$"   2 % !

 )   30$"4/ 5 (

 $  6 " (   /0$" 1  )  $)      "  

$  "6     $         !7-   $ "!2

 !%     2   $  !%!2 !7       "$$       $ "  2            

  2   $   -  $ "&2 !     +  )   !2& 6&% $   $   "#$

((

/1  )  8    $"  $                +$"  -!!2&&  3$ '!-    !!2&&       



   

        $)9$  $ )   "  $               )  )    )       $       ))  8  $"$     

2&   - !2229$   $ "  !-      2   $     $ - %4:$)  ) "    "5

$     )     "

" 

$  )   $    )  "$

"  

: 8   $" " : "  '% !' 2 !&  & % $     )  : "8  $"$       %   &  2:$)   $  & "  $   ))  8   $"  +$    "    "

" " "

  "  $) "$ 

   

 

  /   !          $"    )   " "  '"  "$    "        6 $       "     )   "       $ 8   " ;

"   ) "

$ ) ) "(   .

    !2&% &. "  

<$  " 

 )  "     "   "" 3$ '!- !!2&& $)3$  $)0$" 3  ( 

 !!2&&   ($         )       "    (              )  "    "  $)     ) $  $  "  " $     $)  )   "    9$  $  

-!!2&&(  ) <$   

  $ )    )  (  +$"  -!!2&&  3$ '!-  !!2&&  



 

$ $    )) = )  +$" 

    ""     $ = )   $   <$ "4   5  $ "  !-  ) " 

  "  $ -%/ ! "  ' )  +$" 1$  )   "  $  : "

 '%  !' 2 !& & %    %     &  2    :$  )         $    &   " (      "  .

     &>     " "   <$ "1. / !      "  :

  /      $

"$     )   .  )   $"

+$"     )" $ $

- $   





       ) )   "         )       3$ 8   "     "  .   

" $  "$  " " )      6 " " $

6      ) $ )     (      " ;

"     " 3     "  " $    $$  

"   " "   3$       "   3 9$ 

$  "  $)9$     "  /  ' +            "$ / -% +           .

   !2&% &(     $ $  $ "  !-      - !222  "     $" <  8 <$      ) $    : "   $ "!

   + "   + "  + ": " !&   & %   (       : "                + "  : " '%  !' 2 2  : "    "   / &        $    1  "  "$ ?

@  



  



       

          



  

      



    

   

   !

 " #

  $   %  & !

 ' & 

 "        !

  



 

  

 !    

     

  

  



       

   

  



     "  $  

( 

 " )*         

  

    

 !    

      

  

  

   )  

+   " (#*    $$) ,&-.



 " #

       +   



     / 

   /  +   "   

 " # #        +   

  

 !    



       

  

*  



 



    

      

! 

   !   

   (  

    !

    !

   



    

  

   #  

    



 

   





 

      

  0 

  0

   

     

    "    



 

        

    " (  #

   

  

  

7   

  

     !      



     1 $  

   

   



 1   

   



 

  

 1   



   

  2            

 

 

 34

2       1    

   

     

5 



    5 

   

   1 )  

    

  ! 

    1 *  



  



 

   0      1 (  



  

5     

 

   1 #  

 2!

2  6   

       

   1    

   

  

0 







  

   1   8 ( 3$$$ !& !  !&"          ):

     #   "   8*!.            

 .

    !2&&.    "    3$ -& !!&    " $ -  $ )  "$    "

 -%

- )) $   $  $   .$ 2 !!!'  $  "   3 9$ 

$ .

     /0$" 1  )    "

$ .    $     $

" $"  "$ $) )  "     .$     "  "  " )     $ # $( )  - &!2-%(    ;

" )  " 

$

3$) 3    $"$ '

 %) "

$ . $        "    + "6      " $ # $6 ' "  

 '      "     . $  $+# $ <$ "     "  !2&      "             "6    +      "   "  )$    $  <$ "/ <$

;  "    <  8 )   "

!  !!2&'                      "         )6 6   <$   "  <    <    8    ;:/6- . )       - &!2-%    %-     !2&&  $ '!-   !!2&& 1  3$:   +$" 

 -!!2&&  3$ '!-   !!2&&     $ $   , (    <$ "  $  <  8   "$"#0 

  (   !!2&&=  

$) "$     ($           $   "      

     "               =       

     " "        (   $) ) $  "($  +$"  -!!2&&)

 $)0$" 3  ( ($"        ): $  )$ $       .

     $)    .)

     1.

4;:8!

   - !!

$   !2

' '!.83 "  8  3

(

  $$     .

    $ " " 



" $  $)     )  $)/ 0$  "  (    -  !!(   $    ;:86-&      A  )  - &!2-%      )  $)0$" 3  (

 "   %     %-      (  $    !2&&  .

  "B.     .

+ $ :           $)      $   "           3$    $)  

3$  $)  

$)              $     ($        $) .

 

"  A > "

      $   >       "

$        $  $ "   $   "(     <$ "        $$   "  "    ) .

 =  

 $        

  $   " )$ %         "  $)   (   $)0$" 3  (  $ "  $    "     

 $  $ "   

  ($   -!!2&&    

 $  ) "(  $  $$ 3$            +$"  )  "$

 )"

(   $ 

   $  " .  $ $    $  "  " ;

" $.

   



$ ") " $  " ) "

 " ) ) "C 

  "  ""     " )  ) " " $ -& !& 2!2&'

  "  ) $ )     ( $  !

 !!22%(       "  

   " "  "#$

((

$"     ;

" ( ;:8%%   $)   (()$ >   

 $  ;

"   "$ ;

"  " )

 "  $ $).

 $) )  "   !2&'

      )  $  "$  -! %!22!4;:/6!

5)        )   $ <$        "$       $ "

    $   "   $   $ !. $  $ $ !!&  ' !!2&2      $+$"   !

 !!22%  4;:/6!&5  (     "         +$"       (      " " )  ) )  "    !2&&  $ !& 2!2&'

  "     

  " "  $" <      <$            )  )      $"6 6  " )  " $  $) $ " "3$   $ ( $ > D)$3$.

        

  !" # $ %&%"  "   $)   $             $     

 $ > D)$3$.

    '$    

  ( 



)   

 ( 

*($#+,"--&,".

 ' / 0 1(   -2                     

3$ $  ) +$"  

: -!!2&&  3$ '!-   !!2&&   



 

 $ $    ) ) (  " $     "

( $$) $   )      $ )  +$"     )) (   " $   = )     )  "$   $ !!& -& "4   $5       "      $  !$ ) $    !2&'     $  -! %!22!

  )   "   <$   " 

   (               $"       "       )$  ) "    >$    E3E      !

!!!2&2" )

   "   :$ !& 2!22  (    $    "                  :$    ;

"   

    :$ ;

" ($"  $      )$$)9$   ""    

   ".

"   "1. "       " "  (   $))

  +) 3$ $ "    (   "          )  ($       "   $

       "$  .    " $ -&   !& 2!2&' !!&' !!2&2   +$   "  

"($ ) " "   

"(  

   )   "(    " + $  (    (          +$   )    

"        )  +$"  -!!2&&  ) $ )$  "  3      $          ) )  +$  (  )

 $  $ > D)$3$.

 

  

 



$$  3 0   !"4  $ $ 54-(  $   "$ )  

    " )     ) 6    )       )     ") 

  "                )   "      

  $ )   "   <$      !   

6   !      )  

!    "

 .   -%    ) $ / -%    (      ):       "7(   ) "      ):.   "    2&   - !222  -%            "         )     $   .

           "7  "      -%   

 ") "  "#$

((    "   )    $     "  $  (      -%  ) $ ( ) "

  "     .

     !2&&( $    2&   - !222 1$       :$  : "    '%     !' 2

4;:8&5  $ "- '   : "  !&  & % 4;:/-5"  "  $ "!

 .

 

   $ "!2 '   : "   "  "    "$       .

    !2&&.   $" : "   )  )   $"  ".

 "  -%      $     ) "  )  "$"$)9$ : "(: " '%  !' 2  :$    & $"  "

  ) )  " (  )  -%  )  $    3 9$ 

  2&   - !222  $ "-  !-   : "

!& '% & % !' 2   $ "

!

   - '       ))   $" "$

  " $ !

& ! !&   $   "1  "  $ 2    $  :  "

   3$ 

"      +$"   '!  !

 )    /0$" 1  ) 3 9$ 

. 

    (          )     "  



   93   

*+, -.

-    *  "7   F * )?