← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/5071/2015dismissed

Surya Parkash & ORS v. Dhanpati

2017-09-21Mr. Justice T.H.B. Chalapathi12 pages

      

!" "#$%$&'

(



           

    ' ) * +*,   

  ! "    #### +*, * $  ""   

  

   "

 "" %% & %'

'

%  "( 

) "

% 

""*    ' %  &!

   ( )(   +,+-.+/ "

 " "   '   ( %  "

 &!

 ( )(   -00-.+/  

 )(  "                                     

   

      

                 

   !   

"#          

 

$ 

 "        %&              



   

  "          

" '          (   )   



      

       

          )

   #%*# 

           ((        

  )

     

       +","#%*"-  )    +","#%* 



 

 +""#%*,"  

 

  

                 ((           "-    

 #"#"#%%        .  "

/ ((      #"#"#%%          . 0        1  2        

  

   3  !      

     

  ((   





   "-   

  

                  !  "



 

                  !     #"%"#%%4        

     

"#     

  

"5   

    

 (

   

     "'  2            

"#   



 

     

     

 6    

7"#"&##"

8                    

   

"8      2    

       

  

   "9    

 

      

 :( #;<             =9''

;<             =9'

,;<         (  =9'

4;<      -  %# 4+ ## '=9'

7;  <                        =9'

*;<             =9' 

+;<               =9'

>;  <                (   

  =9'

%;<      

 -  ,7( '=9'

#&;)"

5  

     2 

                        "'    '<#"<      

 2 

 

$)?

 '<



 '<,  0

 '<4"@   #"%"#%%4

  

"++ #%%     "  )B ;   C) 

  



   @$"'<#"

           

          

     

        "         

                  #%"#"&#7"        

  

    .     4"4"&#7"8   

  

 " 1  " "   *   2 ("  '    "

  %'  (  3  (4

 "

( 

) '  % "

 !



)(  +,+,,0 567+8& 2  

 

 

"   

 "  3  (

        (  * *

*

   "     

""*    "

   9:+,:+ '

(%

      (* *

*

   "  "   *   !

 )(  -;<+,:-  (

"

 

   ( 7



 -;<+,:- "  *  ('   

'

'    ' 

3   1'! '

"   *  

   '

'       '    "     

""       (* *

*

 " 

"" "

    '

'  "

%   = '

"

   !

)(  +,+,,0 567+8& 

    "  '   % "

"           *"             "

  %       ('  (



% %   !  6 "  -;<+,:-1'!     % ""

"   '  '

% %'  

   "   

 

"   '

' ' " 

""  '( "  " 

! % ! (%   =

  9     ,  " 

 )(     +,+,,0  567+8&  '

  

%"     * 

  

 

  

  

 

     

    

    

            

  

        

                   

                                !

 "

  # 

   $%&'  (      )$$   

  

*     +

               

 ,        

   

 ,  

             

  

     

     

  

  +

   # -"- ..# /0  $%1$( 2'&% 0             

 

     



      

     



   +

# 3"

  4 /0 $%55 &'1  # -*   6

7        

  

 

/    

    

        

        

       

0    

 

 + - 3

)8$  9 9 "

-                :    

      ,  

 0   

    

  

  





 



 

   

 :   

         

   : 



           :

              

   

  

    

   

   

  

 



       

/   

 

:

9                   

     



 

  -   

  

      

   



     ,  



  

  :   

          

     

  



 

 

 

  

   





      :

    

   :   

 /

  

 ;

 %     "     %!    % !  (  %      ='

(     (

'       *"      !  

% "

     "(



&((       "   %  '

 ( >    '

 

  %  "  

 

  '

' ' " 

""

 !

   "  

"" 

!

%"



    "( 

) ?

 

 "  '

 % ( % "    

""   "    (    ( " '

   % "'

(   ('



   "   @ '    !

 

"!" 

""



"   *  2  

   '



""'  

6 " 

  (    6

 ( " "   

&%'"& /-/,"-.+; 

            %   (  '    " 

   -99-.+; "'

'  %

& * /    

      +

   

 

                     

           

     

 

       

 

      

         

  - 4( <4# 

 +



   

   

     

   

       

           



= , 

 >?

>% )>$1 ;

 (  "   %!        %

 &   

%!  !

    

 

"

  

 %'"   !""

!

+9,-,.+; ""   !    "          '

      "  +/    "  ( 

     

!

 "

  ! 

 % '" ""

!

   !

 '   "%

& %   

 6

 "   *  " " ' %  " 

    "    ! 

""*   8  '

 "''  

 ! "   

& "





   

  %%  % " (  

 ( !   "( +,:-  %( 

  "' 1!

    

&"           ! % " %% "

    ?

        3    '

 %       %  6 !  '



  "     

""   ?



"    !  %   (

         

    "      "(  (" ""  %   

 '   % 





   !    2    %     *"   % "

   "      '      "   %'  "(  (

)

"!" 

"" 

   $     "   (   "     % "    %'((  "' '



   ! ( )(       ( !%



  "

    @" !

)      =  6(

 

  " "   '  !

 ! %  

  ! !  "

 % "

 

+/ +,"   ( )(  '

 !%       * 0

 @ (A$B+

 9 9        

     

 3= %     

   @ (A$B/    +

 

  

C /   

 

 :

9        

     

 !

  +

  -   

      

 

    



               ,      

    

    

  :  

         

  

!

  +

 

 

  

   

 





      :

   

   :    

0 



3

% 

 @ (A$B+     

    



   

 

               

 0     

  $ % $%%'@ (A$B+         

!

  +



   

    $ % $%%'       

      

  :               

     

    

A                

    

     

    

   

     

 

 

    

         

  

 

 

:     



 

 

 @ (A$B+ 

  

      D             

 

 @ (A$B+ ;  

  " 

   "  "     

               !  

    "  

( )(   %  %'1   " 3  "'(   %  3  "' '

3 " 

     "

& '

6

  )   +.." &"& !

2

   % '

 '

% 1 A%(&

 -. & & /"&0- & &0 &!1"-2%*"3%14. -/$&$ &0!1"-%5 ( #$6$7 89  &!%1 : -$2%;-%1!! 4$< -$5

=

(  ( '  

 &



  "   (   "  

%! '

  "(  

& " 

!

'     (   ! %""(  '

  %  ?

  ( "  "

"   % (

    '

    %!    % !  (  

       (   '! '

    -+,-.+;

+*, /-

  A B

E B3

A  C E B3