Naresh Chadha v. V.P. Mehta

 
   
 


 !"# $#%&'&() *+

 !,#'--!$-! ..#//!("

0#,'1'

2 #-"!


#'.($#("


) 3 4
 4


,#'#(") ,
!(5!(4!6-!(.!/7$0%!"#7

,"-#!..#//!(" 8#,# #,,#$""-#
#.,"#,',("9

:-#"-#,"-#51$;<#("'-1/$8#,#.,"#$&("-# &;#'"9  4
7 
4  -&'&'"-#'#%($!..#!/ #($!("&(!%&0&/'1&"7 &(>-&%-"-#./!&("&

'1;-",#%0#,= 
'+7?

7?+ @A -#'1&">!'

$#%,##$&( !01,

,#'.($#("-#,#&(8="-#/#!,(#$&0&/

1$;#   1(&,  &0&'&(7  -!($&;!,-7  "  "-#  #B"#("    ,#%0#,=  

' 7++7

@A7  !($  "-#  &,'"  !..#!/  &/#$  8=  "-#  .,#'#("  !..#//!("  >!'

$&'<&''#$8="-#/#!,(#$$$&"&(!/ &'",&%" 1$;#7-!($&;!,-

-#,#%0#,='1;-">!'(!%%1(" 1"'"!($&(;!,,#!,'

,#("7""-#"1(# 
' 7++7

@A7
'**7C@A">!,$'1"'"!($&(;>!"#, %-!,;#'  !($ 
'C7+ @A  ">!,$'  #/#%",&%&"=  %-!,;#'  !($ 
'?7

@A ">!,$'.!'"&("#,#'"DCE.#,!((1<7"&//"-#$!"# &/&(; "-#'1&" $$&"&(!//=7"-#./!&("&

!/''1;-" 1"1,#&("#,#'"DCE.#,!((1<7"&// "-#,#!/&'!"&( "-#$#%,#"!/!<1("8="-#!..#//!("-#,#&(! "#,,# #,,#$ "!'"-#$# #($!("



*

,&# /=7"-# !%"'7!'"!6#( ,<"-#51$;<#(" "-#/#!,(#$ &0&/ 1$;#7!,#"-!""-#$# #($!("-!$"!6#("-#;,1($!($ &,'" /,'

1'#* 7#%",* A7-!($&;!,-7(,#("  ,<"-#./!&("&

D
'*7

@A.#,<("-7#B%/1$&(;>!"#,!($#/#%",&%&"=%-!,;#'7>&"-#

#%"

,<

*>#0#,7"-#,#!

"#,7-#$# !1/"#$&(.!=&(;"-# 1//,#("

#0#( ,<0#<8#,

*7(>!,$'7/#!$&(;""-#./!&("&

&/&(;!.#"&"&( 1($#,#%"&(* 1(5!8!'",8!(
#("
#'",&%"&(%"7? ?7( * 

78# ,#"-#/#!,(#$
#("(",//#,7-!($&;!,-7'##6&(;#0&%"&( "-#$# #($!("(0!,&1';,1($'7&(%/1$&(;((A.!=<#(" ,#("-# /#!,(#$
#("(",//#,70&$#-&'51$;<#("$!"#$C

C7!//>#$"-# .#"&"&(7  !/'  !''#''&(;  "-#  .,0&'&(!/  ,#("  ,<  0#<8#, 

*  "&// C

C7!

"#,!//>&(;!$#$1%"&( 
'+C7

@A,#(".!&$!"0!,&1'

'"!;#'7 1,"-#,;,!("&(;"&<#""-#$# #($!("".!="-#!''#''#$!<1("

1."&//C*

C7>-&%->!'"-#,#!

"#,#B"#($#$"&//**

C>#0#,7 %<./&!(%# ("-!0&(;8##(<!$#8="-#$# #($!("7"-#/#!,(#$
#("

(",//#,,$#,#$-&'#0&%"&(7>-&%-,$#,>!'%-!//#(;#$81""-#!..#!/ >!'$&'<&''#$ #(%#7"-#./!&("&

&/#$"-#'1&"1" >-&%-"-&''#%($ !..#!/!,&'#'7'##6&(;,#%0#,= "-#!,,#!,' ,#(" ,<0#<8#,7

*7 "&//"-#$!"# #0&%"&(7!/(;>&"-&("#,#'""-#,#1.(!($ ,.!=<#("

"-#,%-!,;#'7!'$#'%,&8#$#!,/&#,-#,#&(!80# ("-#>,&""#('"!"#<#(" #($!("71.(("&%# 8#&(;&''1#$"-&<7-#"6!(85#%"&("-!""-!"./"(>-&%-"-#-1'# >!'%('",1%"#$7>!'!//""#$""-#>& #

7!'!/#''##7&(!( .#(!1%"&(8="-#-!($&;!,-$<&(&'",!"&(!($!''1%-7"-#.,.#,"=

* ("-!0&(;8##(%(0#,"#$&(" ,##-/$.,.#,"=7<"!("'-#-"!7 >& #

7,#<!&(#$!/#''##!($("&"'>(#,!($"-#,# ,#7>!'

("#("&"/#$"!(=,#%0#,= ,#(" + .("-#./#!$&(;' "-#.!,"&#'7"-# //>&(;&''1#'>#,#

,!<#$8="-#/#!,(#$&0&/ 1$;#)A F :-#"-#,  "-#  ./!&("&

 &'  #("&"/#$  "  ,#%0#,=    '1&"

!<1("7& =#'7">-!"!<1("9

:-#"-#,  ./!&("&

 -!'  ("  /%1'  '"!($&  !($  %!1'#  

!%"&(" &/#"-#.,#'#("'1&"9

* :-#"-#,./!&("&

-!'%(%#!/#$<!"#,&!/ !%"' ,<"-# 1,"9

:-#"-#,'1&"&'("<!&("!&(!8/#9

+
#/&# G 

=>!= #0&$#(%#7"-#./!&("&

#B!<&(#$-&<'#/ &('1..,"

-&'./!&("!($"#($#,#$$%1<#("!,=#0&$#(%#8=>!= !%#,"& &#$%.= "-#,$#, "-#/#!,(#$
#("(",//#,7!'&"#./!(7,#%#&."',#;!,$&(; .!=<#(" >!"#,!($#/#%",&%&"=%-!,;#'7!'!/'!%#,"& &%!"# -#$# #($!("!/'#B!<&(#$-&<'#/ &('1..," -&''"!($ !($,#/&#$1.(0!,&1'$%1<#("''1%-!'!(&(0#(",= &"#<'7#/#%",&%&"= %-!,;#'7%#,"!&(,#%#&."'!($!$#"!&/ .,.#,"=

.(!..,!&'!/ "-##0&$#(%#7<!&(/="-#51$;<#(" "-# /#!,(#$
#("(",//#,7"-#/#!,(#$&0&/ 1$;#-#/$"-#./!&("&

#("&"/#$" ,#%0#,= !,,#!,' ,#("781"(/=""-#"1(# 
' 7++7

@A7!/(;>&"- &("#,#'"D E.#,!((1< ,<"-#$!"# &/&(; "-#'1&""&//"-#$!"#

$#%,##H!($ 1"1,#&("#,#'"DE.#,!((1<7,1((&(; ,<"-#$!"# "-#

 $#%,##"&//"-#$!"# ,#!/&'!"&( "-#!<1(" ("-#!8'#(%# !(=

&%&!/#B!<&(#$ ,<"-#$#.!,"<#("'

>!"#,!($#/#%",&%&"=7"-#'!&$%-!,;#'>#,#-#/$"8#(".!=!8/#8="-# $# #($!(" -#'1&"

>!'7!%%,$&(;/=7$#%,##$""-#!80# #B"#(" C ("-# &,'"!..#!/ #($!("7"-#/#!,(#$/>#, !..#//!"#1,"-#/$"-!""-#"#(!(%=8#&(;!$<&""#$!($!,,#!,' ,#("(/= -!0&(;8##(;,!("#$8="-#/#!,(#$&0&/ 1$;# ,<"-#.#,&$+

" **

?7&#"-#.#,&$>-&%->!'>&"-&(/&<&"!"&(1."&//>-&%-,#%0#,= %1/$8#<!$#7!($"-#51$;<#(" "-#/#!,(#$
#("(",//#,7&(!(= %!'#7  -!0&(;  8#%<#  &(!/7  "-#,#  >!'  (  ,#!'(  "  &("#, #,#  >&"-  "-# 51$;<#("!($$#%,## "-#/#!,(#$/>#,1,"-#&("#,#'"!>!,$#$>!' !/'  1($  "  8#  ,#!'(!8/#  !($7  %('#I1#("/=7  "-!"  !..#!/  >!'  !/' $&'<&''#$7>&"-%'"' 
'*7

@A ?

# ,#"-&'1,"7,
!(5!(4!6-!(.!/7/#!,(#$%1('#/ , "-#!..#//!("7<!$#!(!""#<."",#!,;1#"-##("&,#%!'# "-#$# #($!("7 81"1.(I1#,=.1""-&<7!'"->"-#51$;<#("' "-#/#!,(#$1,"'

8#/>,#I1&,#!(=&("#, #,#(%#>&"-7&(0&#> !%""-!"71($18"#$/=7 "-#!..#//!("A$# #($!("-!$8##(,$#,#$"8##0&%"#$ ,((A.!=<#("

,#("8="-#/#!,(#$
#("(",//#,!($"-#,#%0#,= ,#("-!'!/'8##( ,$#,#$(/=""-##B"#(""-!"'1%-!%/!&<>!'!$<&''&8/#>&"-&("-# .#,&$ /&<&"!"&(7-#%1/$(",#!//=.,#''1.("-#<!""#, ',#;!,$'"-#I1#'"&(' /!>,!&'#$&("-#;,1($' !..#!/7 >-&%-  !,#  #''#("&!//=  "-#  '!<#  I1#'"&(  ,#.#!"#$  "-,&%#  &(  !  $&

#,#("

+ <!((#,7&#"-!""-#,#'.($#("A./!&("&

-!$(".,0#$-&<'#/ "8#>(#, "-#'1&".,.#,"=7 &($(<#,&"&("-#'!<#7&(0&#> !%""-!"

,#%0#,= ,#(">!'$#.#($#("1.("-#51$;<#(" "-#/#!,(#$
#("

(",//#,7-/$&(;"-#!..#//!("A$# #($!(""8#!"#(!(" "-#,#'.($#("A ./!&("&

!($!''1%-"-#>(#,'-&. "-#.,.#,"=>!'("&(&''1#!"!// -#(/=I1#'"&(>!'>-#"-#,"-#./!&("&

>!'#("&"/#$",#%#&0#"-#,#("

,<"-#$# #($!("7>-&%-&''1#-!$!/,#!$=8##(!$51$&%!"#$1.(&("-# .#"&"&( &/#$8# ,#"-#/#!,(#$
#("(",//#,7>-&%-7!$<&""#$/=7-!' 8##(!//>#$&( !01, "-#,#'.($#("A./!&("&

7>&"-"-'#.,%##$&(;'

-!0&(;8#%<# &(!/-#I1!("1< ,#("-!$!/'8##( &B#$8="-#
#("

(",//#,7&("#,<' >-&%-"-#,#%0#,=>!''1;-"8="-#,#'.($#("A ./!&("&

7&("-#'1&"$#%,##$&(-&' !01,7""-##B"#("$&'%1''#$!80#  #(%#7 &($&(;( <#,&"&("-#!..#!/ !($(#,,,&( "-# 51$;<#("' "-#/#!,(#$1,"'8#/>7"-#.,#'#("!..#!/&'$&'<&''#$7&( /&<&(#7>&"-(,$#,!'"%'"' 

?A

  (0&#> !%""-!""-#!..#!/-!'8##($&'<&''#$&(/&<&(# !'!80#7"-#I1#'"&( %($(!"&( "-#$#/!=  *$!='&( &/&(;"-# !..#!/&',#($#,#$!%!$#<&%!($&'(";(#&("

*+


 

 .6