← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2416/2014dismissed

Gulzar Singh v. Sukarna Devi And ORS

2016-03-29Mr. Justice Amol Rattan Singh10 pages



   

  !" #"$%&%'()*

+,- .%'/0  11",, '!  2".&+& +3 .' "2% '#!0".&  "&1'#"'!& ( 4 5 5 ."&"'!( .6%1%' 0 7 '8#2$ !"8

.!0" 11",, '!  58 . , 0%&%&!0"&"$'# 11" ,

8%' &+%! %,"#9:0%;

&""3%'/ #"$, . !%'8!0 !!0"$;1.;%&"9"!<""'!0"1 .!%"&!!0"&+%! 1.1".!:8 &< &$, %;"#!0 2"9""'"'!"."#%'!9:!0"."&1'#"'!&= #"

"'# '!&0"."%'

!".!9"."

".."#! &!0"#"

"'# '!&8< &%,,"/ ,82%# '#+'"'

.$" 9,"89"%'/ ."&+,! . +#8$".$%' '#+'#+"%'

,+"'$""

0 # +.!0".&+/0!1".; '"'!%'7+'$!%' / %'&!!0"#" "'# '!&8&""3%'/! ."&!. %'!0"; .;%'!".

".%'/%' ':; ''".%'!0"&+%!1.1".!:8%'$,+#%'/ ."&!. %'%'/!0"; .;.";2%'/!.""& '#9.%$3&"!$!0"."

.; 0"  &+%!  < &  #%&;%&&"#  9:  !0"  ," .'"#  %2%,  +#/"   +'%.

%2%&%'8 !0 '3!82%#"0".7+#/;"'! '##"$.""# !"# 

 '#!0"

%.&! 11" , %,"#!0"."

!".89:!0"1, %'!%

8< & ,&#%&;%&&"#9:!0"," .'"# ##%!%' ,%&!.%$! +#/"8 !0 '3!82%#"0%&7+#/;"'! '##"$.""# !"#

 *  0" $!&8! 3"' .;!0"7+#/;"'! !0"," .'"#%2%, +#/"8 ."!0 !!0"1, %'!%

8<0%&&! !"#!0 2"."!%."# .;!0".;:8$, %;"#!

 9"<'".%'1&&"&&%' !0"&+%!1.1".!: .!0", &!* :" .&"< '!"# !0"1.1".!:."1 %."#'%!&+!0".' '#>"&!".'&%#"&8 &%!0 #9""'1 .!,: #";,%&0"#?0 # ,,"' '!0"."2"'+"."$.#8!0"1.1".!:< &&0<'!9"<'"#9: !0"4 '$0 : !"048%'1&&"&&%'  '%'/08 !0".

 '# < &#"&$.%9"# &@ %.+;3%'9 #%? 2",%A 0"  1, %'!%

&4 !0".8   '  %'/08 %&  &! !"#  !  0 2" #%"#  '

)BB8!0+/0!0"."2"'+""'!.%"&$'!%'+"# %'0%& ' ;"C <0"." &8 $!+ ,,:8 $$.#%'/!!0"1, %'!%

80"0%;&", < &%'1&&"&&%' . 9+!* :" .& "; #" ' 11,%$ !%' .$.."$!%' !0"430 &. /%.# < .%4 9"

."!0"%.$,""2"'+"

%$".8<0%$00"$'!"'#"#0 #'!9""'#"$%#"# !!0"!%;" !0" %,%'/ !0"&+%!8' )  ))) !< &$, %;"#!0 !!0"#"

"'# '!&0 #'$'$".'<%!0!0"&+%!

1.1".!:9+!  &!%,, ; #"  ,&"  11,%$ !%'  9"

."!0" 1,%$" +!0.%!%"&8 ."&+,!%'/  %'  !0"  1, %'!%

 9"%'/  &+;;'"#  '#  ,,"/"#,:  0+;%,% !"#  '# !0." !"'"#  <%!0  %;;"#% !"  .."&!  '#  #"!"'!%'8  9:  !0"  1,%$"  "  < & ,,"/"#,:$".$"#%'!&%/'%'/ $;1.;%&"#""#<0%$00"0 #'!"'!"."# %'!!0"# !"'!0 2%'/9""'/%2"' 0"."

!".80"$ ;"!3'<!0 !#"

"'# '! <+,#.";2"

!0"9.%$3& .;!0"@3 +, &A '#< ,,& !0"1.1".!:8 & ,&!0"''= .+%!

9" .%'/!.""&8%' $$.# '$"<%!0!0"$;1.;%&"4$".$"#4+1'0%;8<%!0 #"

"'# '!!9"/%2"'&;"1 .! !0"1,!8'!0">"&!".'&%#"8," 2%'/ !0"!0".0 , 8'!0" &!".'&%#"8<%!0!0"1, %'!%

* !  < &  +.!0".  2".."#  !0 !  !0"  1,%$"  +!0.%!%"&  <"."  '!

* $;1"!"'!!#"$%#"!0".%/0!& !0"1 .!%"&8 &!0"& ;"$+,#9"#"$%#"# ',:9:$;1"!"'!+.!& , < '# &&+$08!0"$;1.;%&" .$"#'!0"

1, %'!%

< &!9"#"$, ."#'+,, '#2%# 1''!%$"8!0"#"

"'# '!& %,"# 7%'!<.%!!"'&! !";"'!! 3%'/ 1.",%;%' .:97"$!%'&<%!0."/ .#!!0"&+%!9"%'/9 # .''=7%'#".

'"$"&& .:1 .!%"&8 &!0". ; '$0: ! '#!0".&'&  '%'/08%"!0"

9.!0".&

80 #'!9""'%;1," #"# !< & +.!0".$'!"'#"#!0 !!0"1, %'!%

0 #'$'$".'<%!0 !0"&+%!1.1".!: '#!0+&0 #',$+&! %,"!0"&+%!!%,, +.!0".8%!< & &! !"#  !0 !  !0"  &+%!  , '#  9"%'/  ."$.#"#  !  9"  %'  !0"  <'".&0%1    !0"

 '$0 : !"08!0"7+.%&#%$!%' !0"%2%,+.!!0" .!0"; !!".8< & 9 .."#+'#"."$!%' * !0"+'7 96%,, /";;'5 '#&"/+, !%' $!8 )

0"."%'

!".!9"."

".."#! &!0"$! )

 ';".%!&8%!< &#"'%"#!0 !!0"1, %'!%

0 #9""'%'1&&"&&%'

.!0", &!"2"' :" .& '#%!< & $!+ ,,:9"$ +&" !0 ! $!8!0 !''"

< &%'1&&"&&%'8!0 !!0" 2",%0 # ,,"'#<'!< &&!%,, +.!0".

$'!"'#"#!0 !!0""'!.:%'!0"4$+,!%2 !%'$,+;'4 !0"."2"'+"."$.#8 &0<%'/!0"1, %'!%

&4 !0".!9"%'1&&"&&%'8< & $!+ ,,:%'$.."$!

9"$ +&"  !0"  "&! !"     '  %'/0  0 #  9""'  ;+! !"#  %'  2+.    !0"

#"

"'# '!&8 & '%'/0@< &'&!. '/".!!0"#" "'# '!&A 0"  $;1.;%&"  ..%2"#  !  9"!<""'  !0"  1, %'!%

 '#  !0"

#"

"'# '!&< & #;%!!"#9:!0"#"

"'# '!&8#"':%'/!0 !%!0 #9""'9! %'"# 9: . +#8$".$%' '#+'#+"%'

,+"'$""!$ D 1'!0"1, %'!%

%,%'/ ."1,%$ !%'8#"':%'/!0"$'!"'!& !0"

<.%!!"'&! !";"'!8!0" ,,<%'/%&&+"&<"." . ;"#9:!0"," .'"#%2%,



+#/"(= @ >0"!0".!0"1, %'!%

%&"'!%!,"#!!0".",%"

1".; '"'!

%'7+'$!%' &1. :"# .E  >0"!0".!0"1, %'!%

%&"'!%!,"#!!0".",%"

%'7+'$!%'

&1. :"# .E * >0"!0".  !0"  &+%!  %&  9 #  .  ''=7%'#".    '"$"&& .:

1 .!%"&E >0"!0".!0"$%2%,$+.!0 &'7+.%&#%$!%'!"'!".! %'!0" &+%!+'#".!0"+'7 96%,, /";;'5 '#&"/+, !%' $!E D ",%"

A

0"1, %'!%

"F ;%'"#!0.""<%!'"&&"&%'$,+#%'/0%;&",  '# !"'#"."#$1%"& !0"47 ; 9 '#%4."$.# .%/0!& '#430 &. /%.# < .%49:

< : #$+;"'! .:"2%#"'$"8<0"." &!0"#"

"'# '!& ,&"F ;%'"#!0.""

<%!'"&&"&8%'$,+#%'/!0" %.&!#"

"'# '!!0" !0". ."&1'#"'!& ! %'

!0%& 11" , '#!"'#"."#$1%"& !<7+#/;"'!& '# #"$.""&0""!%'

"2%#"'$"  '  ##%!%'8  '!0".  7+#/;"'!  '#  #"$.""  &0""!8  !0+/0  '! .; ,,:"F0%9%!"#48<"."1.#+$"# & .3& '# ."&1"$!%2",: G 0"," .'"#%2%, +#/"$'&%#"."# '##%&$+&&"#!0""2%#"'$"

,"#8 '# "2"'!+ ,,:0",# '!0"%&&+" !0"%'7+'$!%' &+/0!8!0 ! !0"

1, %'!%

0 #'!9""' 9,"!&0<0%;&", !9""%!0".<'". !0"&+%!

1.1".!:8."2"'%'1&&"&&%'!0"." 8 &%!< &'!$," . .;!0"7+#/;"'!& !0 !0 #9""'.",%"#+1'8 &!<0 !1 .! !0"&+%!1.1".!:0 #9""'<%,,"# 9:0%& !0".8 '%'/08!0%; '#!!0"#"

"'# '!& 0+/08 &1".!0"7+#/;"'! !0"," .'"#%2%, +#/"8 '

%'/00 #!<<%2"&80%&"F $!.", !%'&0%1<%!0!0"#" "'# '!&< &'!

#%&$+&&"#%'#"! %,

D '  ':  $ &"8  <%!0  !0"  ."2"'+"  ."$.#  &0<%'/  !0"  . ;  '$0 : !!9"!0"<'".!!0"&+%!1.1".!:8 '#',: '%'/0%' 1&&"&&%'!0"." 8<%!0'."

"."'$"!!0"1, %'!%

8!0"& %#%&&+"< & #"$%#"# / %'&!!0"1, %'!%

 B %;%, .,:8 &."/ .#&!0"$;1.;%&"9"!<""'!0"1 .!%"&0 2%'/ 9""'." $0"#9: . +# '#$".$%'"!$8%!< &0",#!0 !'"2%#"'$"0 # 9""',"#!1.2"!0"& ;"0 !%&&+"< &$'&"H+"'!,:#"$%#"# / %'&!!0" 1, %'!%

 <"2".8  &  ."/ .#&  !0"  %&&+"    ''=7%'#".    '"$"&& .:

1 .!%"&8%!< &0",#%' 2+.

8'!0"/.+'#!0 !!0+/00"< & '!!0"<'". !0"&+%!1.1".!:80"0 #',:&+/0! '%'7+'$!%' / %'&! !0"#"

"'# '!& '# &&+$08!0". ; '$0 : ! '#!0"!0".&'&  '

%'/0<"."'!'"$"&& .:1 .!%"& ) 2"'!+ ,,:8'!0"%&&+" !0"7+.%&#%$!%' !0"$%2%,$+.!8!0"

," .'"#%2%, +#/"0",#!0 !!0"7+.%&#%$!%' !0"$%2%,+.!%&"F1."&&,:

9 .."#'#"$%#%'/ ':; !!".&.", !%'/!, '#<'"#9:!0" '$0 : !"08 %'!".;& "$!%' * !0"$! )



"!8!0"#%&;%&& ,

&4&+%!< &9 &"#'!0" %'#%'/&  !0"%2%, +#/"' ,,%&&+"&81 .!%$+, .,:!0"1, %'!%

&41&&"&&%''!

0 2%'/9""'1.2"#

'!0" %.&! 11" , %,"#9:!0"1, %'!%

8!0"," .'"###%!%' , %&!.%$!  +#/"  0",#  !0 !  <%!0  !0"  &+%!  1.1".!:  #;%!!"#,:  9"%'/  %'  !0" <'".&0%1 !0". ; '$0 : !8"2"'9:&0<%'/1&&"&&%'  1+9,%$ 1.1".!:8%'7+'$!%'$ ''!9"&+/0!9:!0"1&&"&&.!0"." 0"," .'"#

%.&!11",, !"+.!$%!"# 7+#/;"'! !0%&+.!%' 



  ))D*5D 8'!0" 92"1.1&%!%'

 2%'/0",# & 92"8!0",<".11",, !"+.!+10",#!0"

%'#%'/& !0"%2%, +#/"%' ,,."&1"$!& '##%&;%&&"#!0" 11" , !0"

11",, '!=1, %'!%





"

."!0%&+.!8.6%1%' 0 7 '8," .'"#$+'&", .!0"

11",, '!8&+9;%!!"#!0 !#"

"'# '!5 ,%'/0%'0%&!"&!%;': &>=*80 # #;%!!"# <%,,"F"$+!"#9:+;%!. '"2%8&"$'#<% "  '%'/08%'

2+. 0%;&",  & ,&!0"1, %'!%

8H+ !0"&+%!1.1".!: "'$"8!0"," .'"#+.!&9",<$;1,"!",:".."#%'%/'.%'/ !0 ! $! '##%&;%&&%'/!0"&+%!

8 +.!0".%/'.%'/!0 ! ,,!0"

<%!'"&&"&"F ;%'"#%' 2+.

80 # ,,!"&!% %"#!0 !0"< &%'

$!+ ,1&&"&&%' !0"&+%!1.1".!: 5" .'"#$+'&", +.!0".&+9;%!!"#!0 !%' ':$ &"8"2"'% !0"

<%,, +;%!. '"2%< &0",#!9"'!1.2"# . ':." &'8!0"1, %'!%

0 2%'/9""'%'1&&"&&%' !0"1.1".!:"2"'9"

."!0"#" !0 0%& !0".

%' ))B8%" .;."!0 '* :" .&80"<+,#9"$;"<'".!0"." "2"'9:

2%.!+"  #2".&"1&&"&&%' "'$"8!0"&+%!9"%'/'" ,&&""3%'/ #"$, . !%'8"2"'!0"9 . +'#"."$!%' * !0"$! )

<+,#'! 11,:0"."

."8!0"," .'"# $+'&",$'!"'#"#8!0 !<%!0!0"7+.%&#%$!%' !0"$%2%,+.!'!9"%'/ 9 .."#8!0" %'#%'/& ';".%!& ,&#"&".2"!9"&"! &%#" '#!0" 11" , ,,<"#

*  2%'/$'&%#"."#!0" ."& %# ./+;"'!&8 ;+' 9,"! /.""

<%!0!0"," .'"#$+'&",8 %.&!,:%'2%"< !0" $!!0 !!0" 11",, '! $!+ ,,:

$+,#'!1.2"0%&1&&"&&%'2".!0"&+%!1.1".!:%' ':; ''".0"

G ."2"'+"."$.#%!&",  #;%!!"#,:$'!%'+"#!&0<0%& !0".8 '%'/08! 9"%'1&&"&&%'8"2"'!0+/0 '%'/00 ##%"# 9+!

:" .&1.%.!!0"

%'&!%!+!%' !0"&+%! 0+/0!0" 11",, '!=1, %'!%

0 #$'!"'#"#!0 !0"0 # %,"# '

11,%$ !%'9"

."!0"%.$,""2"'+"

%$".80"#%#'!," # ':"2%#"'$"%'

!0 !."/ .#"'$"8 &!<0"' '#%  ! ,,8!0" 11,%$ !%'< & $!+ ,,:

%,"#8< &'!1.2"#9"

."!0"+.!&9",<8& &!"2"'; 3" ':

1."&+;1!%'!0 !0"0 2%'/9""'%'1&&"&&%' . ,'/1".%# * :" .&8 0%& 11,%$ !%' .$.."$!%' !0"."2"'+"."$.#%'!0 !."/ .#< &'!

#"$%#"# .&+$0 ,'/1".%# !%;"

&."/ .#&!0"<%,, +;%!. '"2%8&! !"#!9" #;%!!"#9:

."&1'#"'!=#"

"'# '!5 ,%'/08!0"," .'"#%2%, +#/" +'#!0 !!0"& %# <%,,< &&+97"$!; !!". 1."2%+&,%!%/ !%' '# .;!0 !,%!%/ !%'!8,"# %'"2%#"'$"9:< : 7+#/;"'!& '##"$.""&8F&= 8= '#=*8%!$+,# '!9"#%&$".'"#!0 !!0"&+%!1.1".!:%'2,2"#%'!0"1."&"'!,%&8< & $!+ ,,: 1 .! !0"1."2%+&,%& ,& "'$"8<0"!0". ! ,,!0"&+%!1.1".!:%'!0"1."&"'!,%&$ ;"! 9"%'!0"1&&"&&%'

= 11",, '!89:2%.!+" 0%;0 2%'/9""'

1+!%'1&&"&&%'!0"." 8'!0"9 &%& !0"<%,,8< &'! ! ,,1.2"#

D  %'#'." &'!#%& /.""<%!0!0 ! %'#%'/ !0"," .'"#%2%,

+#/"<%!0."/ .#!!0"1&&"&&%' !0" 11",, '!=1, %'!%

'!0 2%'/9""'

1.2"#8"&1"$% ,,: &'!0%'/!!0"$'!. .:0 &9""'&0<'!!0%&+.! "%!0".  0"  ." &'%'/  /%2"'  9:  !0"  ," .'"#  %2%,  +#/"8  &  #%&$+&&"# 0"."%' 92"8$ ,,& .'%'!".

"."'$"8%';:1%'%'

;%'/!!0"1,"   #2".&"1&&"&&%'8!0 !%' ':$ &"%&'!

B 2 %, 9," ! !0" 11",, '!89"$ +&" !0". !0 ' !0" $! !0 !  & 1". ;&!

7+#/;"'!&'!0"%&&+"8&+$01," %&',: 2 %, 9,"! #" "'# '! '#'! 1, %'!%

8!0"1," %!&", 8"2"'! #"

"'# '!8$ '',:9"! 3"'9:&0<%'/ &+$0#"

"'# '!!9"%'1"' '#0&!%,"1&&"&&%'8$, %;"# / %'&!!0"!.+" <'". '  !0"  1."&"'!  $ &"8  !0"  !.+"  <'".  %&  #;%!!"#,: !0"  . ;  '$0 : !    !0" 2%,, /"8  <0%$0 '!  9"%'/   1 .!:!  !0" ,%!%/ !%'8 !0" $'!"'!%' ," .'"#$+'&",8' 1."&+;1!%'!9". %&"#8<%!0."/ .#! !0" 11",, '!&4 ,,"/"# #2".&"1&&"&&%'8%&<0,,:+' +'#"# +.!0".8 #2".&"1&&"&&%'$ '',:9"$, %;"#"2"' / %'&!!0" !.+"<'".  1.1".!:8$'!"'#%'/!0 !&+$01&&"&&%'0 &9""'1"' '# 0&!%,"2". 1 .!%$+, .1".%# !%;"0 !'!9"%'/!0"$ &"8!0"1," 

#2".&"1&&"&&%'%' ':$ &"< &'!1"'!!0" 11",, '!8"2"' !!0" &! /" !0"%'&!%!+!%' !0"&+%!%!&", 8;+$0,"&& !!0%&&! /"

G &."/ .#&!0"9 .'!0"7+.%&#%$!%' !0"%2%,+.!8!0+/0 !0 !<+,#9" ; !!". #"9 !"<0%$0'""#'!9"/'"%'!%'!0"1."&"'! $ &"8%'2%"< !0" $!!0 !!0" 11",, '!&41&&"&&%' !0"&+%!1.1".!:8 !0 !  $!+ ,,:  9",'/&  !  !0"  . ;   '$0 : !8  0 &  '!  9""'  1.2"#8 '"2".!0","&&8&%'$"!0"," .'"#%2%, +#/"<0%,"#"$,%'%'/!/. '!%'7+'$!%'

'!0"/.+'#!0 !!0"."%&'1. !0"1&&"&&%'9:!0"1, %'!%

8 +.!0".

,&0",#!0"7+.%&#%$!%' !0"$%2%,+.!!9"9 .."#8 '#!0"," .'"#,<". 11",, !"+.!#%#'!." ,,:/%'!!0 !H+"&!%'8"F$"1!!"

"$!%2",:0,# !0 ! & ; !!". 1+9,%$1,%$:8%'7+'$!%'&0+,#'!9"/. '!"#<0"." 1+9,%$, '#%&%'2,2"#8!0"1.2%&%'& !0""$!%' * ."&!%,,9"%'/ ."1.#+$"#0"."%'+'#".89"$ +&" !," &! ." "."'$"!0"."!%& ",!'"$"&& .:(=

) @     

 $%2%,$+.!&&0 ,, 0 2"7+.%&#%$!%'==  !"'!".! %'. #7+#%$ !"+1' ':H+"&!%'8<0"!0". ':1.1".!:. ':.%/0!!.%'!"."&!%' ':1.1".!:%&.%&'!    2"&!"#  .  #"";"#  !  0 2"  9""'  2"&!"#  %'   '$0 : !+'#".!0%&$!C.

9 ! H+"&!%'  !0","/ ,%!:  ': $!%' ! 3"'  9:!0"

;;%&&%'"..!0",,"$!..!0" '$0 : !8+'#".!0%&$!C .

$ %'."&1"$!  ':; !!".<0%$0!0";;%&&%'"..!0"

,,"$!.%&";1<"."#9:.+'#".!0%&$!!#"!".;%'"A  

  

    

 

     

 



    



         



      

   

   

!

"      

   

       

    # $%  

 

         

  #! <"2".8  $=.#%' !"  "'$0"&    !0%&  +.!  0 2"  0",#  %'

 

     8 D %2%,)  '#  !

   "!# 8

 %2%,

G8 !0 !<0"."!0"%&'!9"!<""' 1.%2 !"1 .!: '# . ; '$0 : !89+! ',:9"!<""'!<1.%2 !"1 .!%"&&""3%'/&%;1,: '%'7+'$!%'8!0"%2%, +.!7+.%&#%$!%'8"2"'H+ 2%,, /"$;;', '#&8<+,#'!9"9 .."# &%;%, .2%"<< & ,&0",#9: #%2%&%' "'$0 !0%&+.!%'  

$   8 )BDDG8 <0%,"#" ,%'/<%!0&%;%, .

1.2%&%'&%'!0"$! )

8 & 11,%$ 9,"! .: ' 



B

"!8 & ,." #:&! !"#" .,%".8!0 !H+"&!%'%&'!9"%'//'"%'! %'!0"1."&"'!1.$""#%'/&8"2"'!0+/0!0%&+.!; :0,# #%

"."'!2%"<8 !0"."

."8."H+%.%'/."

"."'$"! , ./". "'$089"$ +&" !0" $!!0 !

"2"'';".%!&8<%!0!0"1, %'!%

= 11",, '!+' 9,"!1.2"0%&1&&"&&%'

2".!0"&+%!1.1".!:8 

!0"H+"&!%' 7+.%&#%$!%' !0"%2%,+.!8 %'7+'$!%'%' ':$ &"$+,#'!0 2"9""'/. '!"# / %'&!!0"."&1'#"'!&

) '&"H+"'!,:8 . ,,!0"." &'&#%&$+&&"#0"."%' 92"8 %'#%'/ ';".%!%'!0%& 11" ,8%!%&#%&;%&&"#  <%!0'.#". &!$&!& !%&0<"2".; #"$," .!0 !!0"1.1".!:9"%'/ #;%!!"#,:%'!0" <'".&0%1 !0". ; '$0 : !8'!0%'/0",#0"."%' 92"8.9:!0"+.!& 9",<8<+,##"9 . ': 11.1.% !"1.$""#%'/&9" ." $;1"!"'! +!0.%!:

+'#".!0"$! )

8 / %'&! ':1".&'8H+ !0"%'!"."&! !0". ;

 '$0 : ! %# &'(%)*+ '2%"< !0" $!!0 !!0" 11" ,0 &9""'#%&;%&&"#%',%;%'"8 &0",# 92"8!0"H+"&!%' $'#' !%' #", :%' %,%'/!0" 11" ,%& ."'#"."# $ #";%$ '#%&'!/'"%'! )*

,-.$-//-# 0#12 13?2$/ ./  3