← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/5722/2023dismissed

Competition Cell v. Harpreet Singh And Others

2023-10-06Mr. Justice Vikram Aggarwal11 pages

CR No.5722 of 2023 (O&M) 1 

      

 !"!#$%$&'() *+! $ $&!,,  - ! $ $&!. /!.%0% .+.!! 1$&23&" 3!.%  !%+&"!&  

  

               

   

      !"

#!#$% 

 & 

  



%  '(( (   (  #  

   

 %   '

     ') $*+%,%--  "." / 

%   & 0/    - 0 1 

 '($ )&2' $' .)'

3'

& / ( ( 0 *

 ' ( 

$ 4 

   

          /5'$0% -&

& .

!"

#! .

          .

!"

#!

   

( %  '

26- 3&&1 (( ( /5 '30  7      

    ' 

CR No.5722 of 2023 (O&M) 2 (1  

   (  (  %  % '8+ 9 ) ) :

 '    

(      %   &   &

  / 

0 &   "

!;

#!6        (   )%<

  

       

       !

!

#! '  = &( &  

  

  %  (       

   %  (  +  7  %       

%  =&(&  %%  



  7   

((    '    % 1  

    (  % 7  '

    )&2'$3'  )'$;' &   4 '

   %

 

  > 2          (  (   (  7      

      '

     <   ( (     7    %

  )'$;%  %  %  '

      (  ,   ( ((         % (  

(  %+ ? ! %   ( 1 ((  ( %<   +    ;

4 

  %   '

   7  

/5' 0      

(       

 1



CR No.5722 of 2023 (O&M) 3  '     

 (  <     '

5(  >''8)  7   '

   (      7 (       %  %  (   %       %(% 7      '   %

 

%(

   !!@ 

%  7  

(( % 

      

 

     >  %

  )'$;   %(



)&2 %%

% 

   (

((   (   



  7    

          '

A      '  (

 %(  

   (  

(( )( %  ((  

 A      '  %(  %  

(          

 (  %  = &( & 2- !  (  )&2 )'$;

 % %  A 

    

 '   

      % (  % 7 %     %  (     %   !

!

#!      

   .

!"

#! 

% A  

CR No.5722 of 2023 (O&M) 4   )&2  ) $;  %    %   '

    %  ( A %(  

% <   (

(

 % (  %  A       

   

   %

  

 ((

(   7%%( 

(  % &(& 2- !&&  (  !3 #!#$ 

(( ( %  #;

!

#!#$ 7  %%( (( ( %

     

   7            

+( & 

 !

"  # $  %# & '( #"    ')*+, '- ./01 2  !!

#3

 " #4

%"



./0*0 ()0*5##"  &# %4 " $(

 56 0*+/.  017 8"   &#  '

&  " " 9''& '#:'# ('  '-  &  .//07 6  1.  +(   8B%  )( &     & #

; "   $#'

;   .//,7 6 /1+18" "(#

%<<#"5 "" "( (=6( (".//0. (

 )>>  4"

 %$ # !!

#3

 "  '& .//>. 6  1,, =#(  =

  !

 " $#;  !

 ./0)0/ 6  7., & -  "%# ?'#:'# (' '- & "'#:'# (' '- & " 46 % &#" =#6 ( $(&./..)

3#

&7.)0 "

7 

(    (  %         4  (     

(  

 &  !

( 

  

   

     '  (       

 4    '('   )3&  '     

CR No.5722 of 2023 (O&M) 5  

4

 

 % -&

 .

!"

#!  

4

((

( #;

!

#!#$

 

 ( 

 ?%

2- !&&( % &( &   (  !3 #!#$ 8       &( 



%  ' ((% (( %    #!  7   (

%  '

 /5'#0 (

%+    %  ( $ ;

(  %+ 1 ('

                                                                   

                                                    

      

           !" !!# ! ! $%  &  '                           !                        

( 3 '

CR No.5722 of 2023 (O&M) 6 )

! $*   *                     

+

       ,                           !!

!

-

  

          !'  "                                                      "             ( * ( ; ('

.         "! !

!

-

        , /  0 '   1

,) ,+ ! 

2 3   "                          !  2 3     

                  (  4 (   (  

        % % ((  %  7 

  (( /5 '30  ((   %

'

. 4 1 ,5

         $ *  3 3  " !                        ,5 ,5 65,+7                  

CR No.5722 of 2023 (O&M) 7               

. 4 1 ,,

                8 7    "* !34 1

,),+ !  /  3 7 !34 1 +  +

 !  ,)2  3                      '              ! 

3                  9                  

 $  !  :

 4                        ( # 4 (((1  

 '(( '    ( 7 % (   %< ( %< % %

((



7   % 



   (     

 %<  

 

%% % (( %   

(  $ >    ((      8B%  5 & ((     - "%# ?'#:'# (' '- & "  46 % &#"=#6 ( $(& & '( #./..).1>7    '

)5 4    ; <= 4  "" 0  6 3.3                      

CR No.5722 of 2023 (O&M) 8           

                   4 ""0 63.3          <='

    

                                      

(     4 >"0 ,) 3.3 <=      

  <=                          <=      <=           <=       *     *         <=                            < = <= '          

      

   <=                         <=         <=       <=             <="                               

         <= :                                             

  <= :                                     

     ? 

CR No.5722 of 2023 (O&M) 9 <= '        

                     <?=2       

   :     

            

       

     ?=:                                         

   :                                                               

  <?=:           

                                                  '                                                      *                 

   8

                                        

  <! >- -  % -74

6566!334@ 2 ,+A)=( .

7( ?

"'-6 4(% % &#"@56 ':#"" #

"3 $2 @ ' " @ '( #" ./0/06  .,   8B%  5 &

 5(    %+  



   < ((  '

B) 4

 C 8 "               *       

            

CR No.5722 of 2023 (O&M) 10 <,= :                     D <6= :                  D < =                                   E < = 0          E < = :          

      

              D <B= '   

                          

    ( ;

75(      % 8B% 5&

(((%    +   %< 

 +   %   4

  

7 &     ((%( %  4

       ((  



  +      + 

%    

 +   6   7 +(

%    ' 4       +(

    

  !

 "  # $  %# & '( #" /0  2 !!

#3

" #4

%"



/0

  

'  C       % ((((%

 

   4        %   8B%  5 &     -

CR No.5722 of 2023 (O&M) 11  "%# ? '#:'# ('  '-  &  "  46 % &#" =#6 ( $(& &

'( #/0  %  8 %  

  (( % (  

   (  % 8B% 5& ( +(

%   '  

 7

(  (7   (  

 (  

 (  /4  56 ?('<#/>( ./.7   0 * :   *F  ; G F1 :    ; G F1