← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/4759/2017dismissed

State Of Haryana Through Collector, Mohindergarh And Others v. Dinesh Kumar And Others

2022-12-15Mr. Justice Anil Kshetarpal11 pages

!

"#

 $# %& '

(

" '

! )&% *

+,

-  .

.

' / ++0

.

.

 ( '

1.

..2233 45 '

6# '

1.

..2 "0 7&8 .

%#1

"

$8  



    

 

5+ 9:;50

 

 ! " 

 

$  %" &   ' $%'(

 " " 



 

#

 * #+  &     +" (

- .

/  )"

 

&   2

 3(   /  )"

%  &   ' /%'(  $%    " 

   

#

 *#+       +" 

  "

#



#   "

  1.

.

$+53 3- ' 



 

56 45

 !  /   "



"*

+ :

 $*  " ;

" : 

.



" 50 5< 45

.

"#  /%    4.



1 5< 45 < "  /% /%   ! " "

!   $ 6555555=*    : $%' 

5 56 45 < "  $% $%  ! "  $ 7050555=*   

 " #  "

:

  

"  /%  

     $% 

! "  

 "  "

+ 

 *"



 <

$+  ?

"

 

#

 



 

        

 6*-  "  

 

 

 

  "     , %  ? @ %  

*

 "

:

>,> , @"  %  

  #"   " 

 " 

 

 "

 %   

 $?

% @"  "+#   ?! "   ?! 

% %  ?!

?!

> 

?!

  A  ?!

%  % ?!  A  

  

 

 

  "#

 

   #"



  %  %"

#   

  ! "    $ 65555555=*    

 

A 



 

 

 /%

    

 

$ 6555555=*   

  "

   )"

$%    " " 

" +" * 

 

 



     

     !!

" 

 

               ##

   !!

$ 

 

            %

    #   !!

& B -+ 25 9<  2+- 2+0

>    C  

 *

!

'!

'"

 ( ) !

'$#  !

'*  + !

',  & ! - #.%/0

!

'

!

'   1#.%/0

!

'2  -%% !

'3!

'"  4%% #5  !

'6  & ) !

'7  8  4 4 >  "   "  

 

"      #"   



 - 7 +" * /0 !' /0 !'$ 9 /0 !'

91 : 

1",,' /0 !'2   /0 !'3 -;

   /0 !'6/0 !'" 91' < /0 !'7

9

/0 !'*   /0 !',!'"

9    <%     ,7 ","

/0 !'$ 91

 ", ,6 ","

/0 !'

' <%4

 /0 !'2

' <    %  .

 = /0 !'3 91       = "*    "

,7 ","

/0 !'6 91 = "

/0 !'7   /0 !'* 91  /0 !'", 91   %   /0 !'""

91 /0 !'"$ = 

 /0 !'"

 >  

 ?

91 4 6 A 



  

C  $ *

;"

$

"#*:

 @





 9"  @

  :

?D$ 

4 - >  "  

"  

 "    #"   



 - 7 +" * /0 &' /0 &'

9 /0 &'2 !

 1  %;

   

/0 &'3 !

 1  -% 99

 

/0 &'6 !

 1       = "3  * ,6 ","

/0 &'7 !

 1' < 3<+ /    9<  "0

$%

  "

  @C *4 &#

1<<(  ! " 



5E

  

   $% "  45E

  

" $ 7050555=*  " 

 C "  



   





    

"

  $%

    "

+"  ! " " " C 

= '+5+ 3<+ /  ;5> /   3

53 2+;

 2+0

?

  " 

  

 #    " #!

  %"  

 )"

 - 4 A 

  " 

  $%

   

 

      @C *4 &#

1<<(

  "

  @C *4

 5< 5 4551  



 

 

" 56 45

 "

       #" $%

 !

     45E " 

   "    

" 

 - 6 A 

  " 





  



   " 

  



" "#  $%





"

  @C *4 &#

1<<(

!   

# - -   " "  "    @C  6=? "  

  +"  =  

C 

"*

 

 :



      "  @C  -=?



 %



 

  

"  

"

 

"" C

# 



  " "       

  "     "

 #" 



 "    "   

#



"   "  "

 =  # 

"  "  @C $*0



   +" 

- 7 

 

     



   "  "   

 # '   

#" * 18 ' '

$'#" '

&(

8 '?

1 1.

.

@+9+

.

13 '

.

'

3  >5

+ . >5 $ 

+ . 4+33; *

6<0 5< 50 4551 -4 )  -5555=* -4..7.5=* *4

1<< 5< 5 4551

! 047555=* ..55555=* *6 -6-7 5- 54 4550

 77555=* 0055555=* *45 4550  .55555=*

4555555=* 18 ' '

$'#" '

&(

$*

0<-

4. 5. 4551 4;*  46 555=*

<.5555=* $*4

4< 50 4551 ) 

 5555=*

.55555=* $*6 <-<

. 5. 45

6;*- -05555=*

455555=* $*-

0 5. 45

;* - 665555=*

774555=* - .

A "

 



   6

7

. 4<

  @C *4 &#

1<<(

 

!   

   . !

  44=4 46= =4 A " "  @C $*0

   

  +" 

  @C *

&#

6<0(

A    

   . !

 0= 

      +"  

 

 

 









"

 

     :

    





 

    

"

  @C *

&#

6<0(

    :

 





  @C $*4 &#

(

 

       

   0 !

 0=

1=4=

"        

  @C $*

&#

 0<-( @C $*6 &#

 <-<( @C $*- &#

 1

(         !

 "#

    





  > "

 " 

%"

 

   @C * &#

1<<( @C $*4 &#

( @C *4

     

@C $*4 A   

!

 @C $*4

 

  @C *4

 

!

- < ;

   

  "         " 

   +"  

  #"  "

 #" 

- 0 "

  " 



 

  #

  @C *4 

 

  " "

    # "

  

      

"  

 "    "

   - 1 $%

  "  45E !

 F F    "

@C *4 &#

1<<(  " 

 C   

 

"# $%



!

 @C $*

&#

 0<-( @C $*4 &#

( @C $*6 &#

 <-<( @C $*- &#

 1

( "   



  

"

   %

 +"  

" %"

 

 !"#$ "35+0

;

   

  

 

"  $% )" ! "   

   

"

" " A " "   $%

 ! " "" "

 #   #"



C "  " 

    %"  

  

  .

'++0 .

;

     

 *#+    . 4  

 "  

  

 '>9B

$8

%#'!

%@ AB@=

  AB@= 1.

.

"

.

$+ '+3

.

 ( 1 4,1 '

6# 1 GA?9$* 61*454

,,@ AH $I A$

4,1 :>@  ;J$ A$

$H*-<.5*45 <

,,@ AH $I A$

4,1 $@:@$ ;J$ A$

$H*-<.

*45 <

,,@ AH $I A$

4,1 $> 

A$

GA?9$* 41*454

,,@ AH $I A$

4,1 $> 

A$

.

$H*-0 0*45 <

,,@ AH $I A$

4,1 J$/>:$ :@%@ @:

,$ /$

A$

< GA?9$* 40*454

,,@ AH $I A$

4,1 J$/>:$ :@%@ @:

,$ /$

A$

$H*-00<*45 <

,,@ AH $I A$

4,1 %> $ A$

GA?9$* 0*454

,,@ AH $I A$

4,1 %> $ A$

$H*-< *45

,,@ AH $I A$

4,1 $@  ;J$ A$

GA?9$*41*4545

,,@ AH $I A$

4,1 $@  ;J$ A$

$H*-<4*45

,,@ AH $I A$

4,1

, ,$> A$

GA?9$*00*454

,,@ AH $I A$

4,1

, ,$> A$

$H*-<6*45

,,@ AH $I A$

4,1 AA/ %:

&:@%@ @:( ,$ >

/$

GA?9$*06*454

,,@ AH $I A$

4,1 AA/ %:

&:@%@ @:( ,$ >

/$

.

$H*-<-*45

,,@ AH $I

A$

4,1

@A:> K $:> A$

< GA?9$* -4*454

,,@ AH $I

A$

4,1

@A:> K $:> A$

$H*-<7*45

,,@ AH $I A$

4,1 $9> // A$

GA?9$*01*454

,,@ AH $I A$

4,1 $9> // :

A$

$H*-0 <*45 <

,,@ AH $I

A$

4,1 ?>$ $

$8 %#'!