← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/6691/2016dismissed

Suresh v. Santra Devi Deceased Through Her Lrs & ORS

2019-05-17Mr. Justice Amit Rawal4 pages





     



 !""#$%$&' ()* +,"%- .."// &!

0",%+%  &!, "1$ %$&#"2"#" %"2!-,+3-4 %  &!-",  "%.&2"&!

 !"#$%&' ()%)(*$

,"%"&!'

, ,15$!$&3-6-+, & *21# !"* ,!-" .."// &! 77777 )(*$+&

 )89:

,  !-"  ," %&%  ;"&!$&"2  $&  !-"  ../$# !$&*  <-$#-  $% %+..,!"2  =(  &  $2 1$!*  2"/ (    >  2 (%  $&  ,":$/$&3  !-"  .." /  $% #&2&"2  %! &2%2$%.%"2

 .."// &!:2""&2 &!$%$& "3+/ ,"#&2.." / 3 $&%!!-"

5+23;"&! &22"#,""!-"4<",.."// !"+,!*<-","=(!-"%+$!!-" ,"%.&2"&!:./ $&!$%. ,!/(2"#,""2=(!-"!,$ /+,!*- %=""&2"#,""2$& !!

"%.&2"&!:./ $&!$%  %+3-!  !-"  $&5+&#!$&  3 $&%!  !-" 2""&2 &!%$&,"%."#!. ,#"// &2#;.,$%$&36-"< !)8*6- !&$ *  "#!  6$//  ?@  $& :  - -$*  6- !&$  9

"#!*6$// ?@ $& :- -$* ):!! // &2;" %+,$&3 A & /%>; ,/ %&!-".,";$%"!- !!-"( ,"<&",%$&.%%"%%$& % !"& &!%&  ! $$- $-"2""&2 &!%"B!"&2"2!-," !1"&  < %



,"3$%!","2*=+!-"2$2&!%!. &2*!-",","*!-"%+$!< %$/"2 ""&2 &!% ..%"2!-"%+$! &2 //"3"2!- !!-"(- 2=""&$& .%%"%%$& &2#+/!$1 !$&!-"/ &2../$# !$&,,"#!$$# !$&!-" 3$,2 < ,$< %2"#$2"2&?>=(<-$#-!-"./ $&!$% 2;$!!"2!-" .%%"%%$&!-"2""&2 &!%!",,"#!$$# !$&!-"A- %, 3$,2 < ,$* %". , !"%+$!< %$/"2$&#,., !$&3!-"& ;"% %!"& &!%$&!-","1"&+" ,"#,2 &2 !",!-"2" !- ,& , $&*2""&2 &!< %,"/"#!"2 % !"& &!&!-"/ &2 $&#"!-". ,!$"%<"," !1 ,$ &#"*!-"!,$ /+,!, ;"2!-" //<$&3$%%+"%':

C

 

                

 

    

        D-"!-",  !-"  ./ $&!$%  ,"  "&!$!/"2  ,   2"#,""   ; &2 !,($&5+&#!$& 3 $&%! !-"2""&2 &!% % ., ("2 ,E

 9 D-"!-",!-"%+$!$%&!; $&! $& =/"$&!-".,"%"&!,;E

 8 D-"!-",!-"./ $&!$%- 1"&# +%" #!$&!$/"!-$% %+$!E  > D-"!-",./ $&!$%- 1"#&#" /"2!-"; !",$ / #!%,; !-"+,!E   D-"!-",!-"$1$/+,!- %&5+,$%2$#!$&!"&!",! $& !-".,"%"&!%+$!E  )

"/$"F

/ $&!$%  "B ;$&"2  $1"  <$!&"%%"%  &2  =,+3-!  &  ,"#,2 B G!B G8*B D9@*B D>@ &2B D>@ &!-"!-", - &2*  !-"  2""&2 &!%  "B ;$&"2  $1"  <$!&"%%"%  &2  =,+3-!  &  ,"#,2 2#+;"&!%B*B*BD8@ &2BD>@ ("B ;$&$&3 H& ;#- 0 A( !$B G8=" ,$&398

,

,"#!$$# !$&A- %, 3$,2 < ,$*!-"!,$ /+,!.,!"#!"2!-".%%"%%$&=( 3, &!$&3$&5+&#!$& 3 $&%!!-"2""&2 &!%&6$// ?@ $& : &2 ?@ $& :6-"< !)8*6- !&$* "#! &26- !&$ 9* "#!*=+!2"&$"2 <$!- ,"3 ,2!6$//  ):-"

4<",.."// !"+,!2"#,""2!-"%+$!$&!!

, ,15$!$&3-6-+, & */" ,&"2#+&%"/,!-" .."// &!: 2""&2 &!%+=;$!!"2!- !!-" . ! H& ;#- $%,"/"#!$&3!-"

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

,-","<+/2- 1"%;",#"- 2!-" 2""&2 &!%  %"!  +.   #+&!",  #/ $;  &  %+#-  #$,#+;%! &#"%*  !-"  4<", .."// !"+,!*="$&3!-"/ %!#+,! #! &2/ <*3 1"#,"2"&#"!!-" ,"1"&+","#,2!- &!-", /!"%!$;&( $&2$&3%+&2",#- //"&3"# &&!

% $2  !  ="  %+",$&3  ,;  &(  $//"3 /$!(  ,  .",1",%$!(    3,+&2  , $&!",","&#"$%; 2"+!*;+#-/"%%$&1/1";"&! &(%+=%! &!$ /I+"%!$& / <

-

"%+/! &!/(*!-" .." /$%2$%;$%%"2 ./+   )(*$

012 &'34% *252167 81

 918

*252 5: 918