High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/43716/2019allowed

Lukman And Others v. State Of Haryana

2019-10-29Mr. Justice Gurvinder Singh Gill16 pages

! " #$ % &

! '( ) *+ ,*( & + - *++-*$ % +(#.*+ , &(

/ & (%

* 0

. & %1( . , 234

5 # *6 3! # !7#7+

!(# 8 43/* 2 1 *) % && 9&,.1

1% ( ) # !* ((.)

')1

/23)( . & :) ((.

.)( )4

. 1 & ( ,((. (& 7

5*))(&. ; % < * 1 +*0

**')1

(( ,((. .... * 1(% - .) ((

&& 3((. %

- & (,. #*( )%

) & 1 . 1 ,((. (& / ) ,. 1% &( & ( ,.*) (%')1)

9 9(%)(& . . # !.')1* . & ) &( 4 /+ . *&

* .1 1(:(,(%1% #*

=&&&(,.1 ( 1%& # !*& ) 1

1% ( , 5

;+: ! <*( .&& & . . /( ( & 1 & ,((%1 &( & &(( ,( %,((. ) & : ( (.) ')1 *

( ;+: !<*(

& & , /(

( 1 %& , 1

) # !&& ((* ( . 9

% )(( ,%(& &/ ( (*

1 * &( (&

!! " #! $

$%& ' ( )#

!! " %+#& 6

. . * ( ( ( > . (, 1%?$@1(#&

,, - % !! " (.

. . ( % .A * #*) )

* >

.& )

# !* 5

;+: ! <*1.)> *& % ( & %1( 7 *#(*)(&&.& 1 ) & : . ((%

& 23 ( ((.) ) # !* * ( , %*

(%&

* &

& ,(, )) ( . 3 11 ,) ) , * . & %1( #1 1 1(& 5

;+: ! <*, )& ,

* 1 & 1% ) > * * 1 1 , % /( ( (%1 . > .

1% $@1( #& - % + * )( .

. . *

. #* ( % .A* #( , .A. 9(% ) #: &) # !)(% 1: ..A3**11

#( ,

& . 5 3, 1 ,(& > .

- % + /1

&9& .&) #

( . ..A # ! / (,: &

> .

(() B / 9 ) 9 ? (() < :::

< :::

,< # 0 .

# (! .(> C

$@1(#& *)() . 9&

5- % + *( (() / :9) #

* . ) 9 .A 1

. #3)((( .A (% 1 3 ,* . .A

#*9 . .A * *&

* )()3.A1 *( 1 1%. 1% #/(.. # , %( (%

#1%( . * # .(> (( . ) &> /& ,#

)((* *,1 ( . &(%. &, (

. # .

&( & ) 1(1% # 4 1%%9& .A1. 1% . & .A1. 1%( # 0 . $% &

' ( )

# /$@1(#& **)(1 ,.).

#*& . &, ( 1 , .A *

( #))( .A& ,. 1

9(%* )( 1 & ,>

( , % (.1 (,(1( & ( # ! + * 1( & # ) &

( 1& 1% &(( /9) 1(1() . & & )> & . ( . & %1(11 && (.> .

$@1(#& ) ( ,1 3,/ !! " 0 % %""+ "!*$@1(#& : 9& & %.1(1() . & ) 19 1.)

&&(((..9()& .$@1(#& *)() .9 , & ( 1 ( (() B / 1 1 )(. .&((, &&(. 9(&( . & 1%, + ( )+ ( *: &) )$. # 8 * & 11 1%.1(1() 1(1() * ) (% +(.*

: > ((%*&1( &

1( ( , 1 ) : ? (%& .* )(

, * * D

* , * &( *&1(%1 .*( . &1( #D/ !! 1*# !

*2 / / 3

* %( & .

)& .. ) & . 1() & )( (%(&1 &&( & ( . 3:* 1 1

, . % > + ( , & .(%*:&(*) 9( 1%$. & , ( (% ( . .>

/ 0

3 $

4 &&&

+ 3 5 /$

# 3 , 3 4" 5"6

' "!

!! " 0!! ' "!*(. , %) . 9.

23 . #

3!*1 #& (: 9)) ( 1 ( (() B6 + &1(* &

)(( ..&& *

1(1( ) ( 1& /) 1(1( 1(1( ( , 1 ) & & % &( &&( * : (% 9

) ) / , % ((%: ) ( &( 231(

)1(9 ,

77 &

)

1 4

1 75

+ '

1 79

1 # 3

!! " #! * $@1(#&

1 &&( # !,.1& 1% ( / #& * )( ( . 1 % .> ( ) (() B +! (# (! )( ( (% 1>, & %1 @ @ @

@ % 9 && , %& 1.

)& ( 1 . )( % . & / ( : > ( (%

., ) & & &

(() ( . ( / &1%/ ( )( : .&) : %&) (

1 1% , %& .(% 1% .& &( (() 1 (()> & ,

; : : , 3 $

, 8

! # $$

995=

; >

, 9% <

- ;

3 $

7 & '

)

) ) )1 )

,) )

2 1

) '

, 1

4 '

1 8

1 1

& >

? *

!"% & & # $'( )

1 #

6 / )( (().

+ * ( (() $

$2 )#

!! " %+#& B / **1 1 (

( . 23 & (1 1 /9* ), * ) % ( & 1(2 .9*& &( ( )- 1 #.#11@;& < 1 (( 3) ( > # 5 ! 1 : 1%) ( 3 1(,)( 1 1(1(* )( 1( , & ,# 5 ! /. (1( ) : &) *)( 1 3 *& ,1

( #

3!* && 1 * % , 1( && % )( 1 %/*&( & %1( , + ( . .( (1 %A (() , 1 +(( () &&( % (& &(( ) ;

;& <& *</*

( ) %() % (* &( & % 1( 1 *1>& &(( %( )- 1 #.#11@;& </.#5 ! . 1. % (& % 1(* &( )( , ) ,(1( & 3&&

( 1 %)( & .& .* &( & % 1( 1 & 3 ( 1 & .# !* & & );<1

(

$),

. # !(%1 ( &%. & # !7& ( *

(

. /* ( & % & %1( . (): 1%,...% 1%) E 3 . 1 .> (& . .)& 1

&((%) & .1

( )(, .&) # !3* , %(..# ! . 1 1 # ! (() !78F/7!7FF +-+34#/7/$F!F#74#+!!F+34-/7?F -=3/G72722F4F ;< 8 * %9 %* (**&&

, %& 1.

% )& ( 1 . ) * % & . & ) && ,

*$ A

* 3

*/ A

1 *

@ ;1< 1>& ,(;<* %& & 1 & ) .A &)9 % ()

/ &) &

( # ! ! : . &) # !1: (% , 1 . . ) > # ! %1,

#$), * 1 & & : &) # ! # !

)

1(1() 1(1( ) 1 )( & & 3 (1 ( )1 : & (% . 1. , . $@1(#& 73 / + "+! $ !! ! 1*# !

*2( )( , ** * , * &( *&1(%1 .*( . &1(

#*)(: . 5 ? * . . 11

)( . ( 1&( (()*) (% :, ;< ) * &(*& . .

*& . * (%& .& ( 1 1%)%

$), * &1. , && * ( %& 1(1() 1(1() H ;< (%*)

) # ! # !* ) ( (% ,%(& &* . 1. ,. ( % ( * &

( . (. 1 1%

1 .:&( .& H ;< . ( . .

1( ( ., ( % ,

,) &((. ( . * * H ;,< ., ) 1

I%1 ( * %(., .&% *..,& (1

( ( & * ( )( 1 ( H ;,< ( ( . & &( )H ;,< ( ( 1 . (. >H ;,< ( (%: & &( 1 &( 4 : &( &. ( )( *%* ..1(,19(%

* ) ) %,. #5 ! / *) 9 1 )( . ) .,

) 1 *)( &&(%)9( , )( . . & %1()

&& . !3 1 &A .

1( (, %) (( () # ! # ! ( . & % 1( (( (% ,.( 8( &1(%1 && ((1 %A& *1 1(( 9 1 )&

. % %4 .> (1

, +( % 1, 9 1: 1 .

, .1 & *)(& : 23*,...%& (( .(% & . & ( 4 +& & :) ) 1

% )& & ( 3 ((. .... 1(% )%- .) ) & 1%(( . ,.* &((( /". (( & (& : .(%1 /" . ) & : . ,( (%)')1) ((. (( *... 1(% )%3 1 & . /( ( % &% 8

( .8

5 1%&(

) /". / 3,) &*& & &(((. 1 11(2 * & :* (% ((. 1 *) ,((. - & ;><*) (, ')1 *)(

( ),(, ')1 / ..%& &( ) & 1 . (

.. &$ & &1.. &*& :)( ,1 - & >')1@ (, , %: %

$,. . * %&* . & %1(/&*&

& *, .1 ( )) %(( 1 ( 1( 1> .1(1 %1 ( * ) % &% && & .

& .( (%1 (

3*), *( 1 , 1,((1 1:&

' ( 8 J& .C GJ4 8 & 1(C GJ4