← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/4815/2017disposed of

The Deputy Chief Engineer And Another v. Tilak Raj And Another

2025-12-23Mr. Justice Harkesh Manuja6 pages

    

  

     

!"# $% &'

& ( )**          

) +, * - . - 



  ! "#

$%&  "

   "

 # '

($ "

( $ "

& ' "

#) " *

+  +  % ,,,,, . - *# /0%

 

!"# $%

     

- "    '  . "   "  '   #' )*

/   

  1&234 ( 330 '4 (

   -'     

          #   330 '4 ( 56(/ 230& 2& 4(60&70/&3/&5& 44 8&5    '  /   " " #   %" -"  '''  " " 

 

'5&#5% 0 &      "''  '  %"      12  "" 3 "4%" % "

   '#  """    ' 5 6"  

 ' 

# '

  ' "7  7 "% "

%    34580945:09 );< *  

  

   "

020:5:5= # ' 020" 2 :9'  #  :8 &    " #"7 % +' %  

    01:15::8      !"   2      6 "7 " 0182)  >0182"?*  '   ""  #@+ # 6  '& @ @ 4 @ .#  

5=:=5:0: !" 

  A 0182" ' A5":9' #  :=&  ' @ ( B 

@#  (   "#"7    020= 

 ")*"  !! "#$% & '

 (   )) *) + ) +

'

* +  ) , *) -,

 .%  

 + /( ( %  $)*  ( +

  / **)  

& $)( +  1(  ) *  (     2 %2 %

3 )'

#  )) (4 /+   *$  (  

5* !!

 ! 6 (  ( %  )#  /(  (++ ) # () $  + ) /  ( '



$  #  $ 4 +  # *) )+      +   )#4 & $% $ ) ( ( 

 $)( +    '

) (  ) 

 % (/ ) 4

'() 4 + *   (%

 #() / ***   #  ' '  $ + )

 +$( +  )#  0 + 

& $)(   /4   8(9 C D # %   "

 # 4'%  '

## "4%"   " #%    '   "

#   '

'#  %

  %   '6"7 " 0812 "

  %

  ' 2 3  #    #)*  /    -  )*/"4%" )* 

  

  % '  % % -" 

"

% '   )*% 

-"   =

   

    5C055:5=  #. - %    

E /

/( E%

/( !(

( 0 34210=45:09);< 5 34251545:09);< *# F4;@B400945:5= C 34252845:09);< *# F;@B42=45:52 2 3421:045:09);< = 3421:545:09);< A 3421:C45:09);< 9 3421:245:09);< 1 3421:=45:09);< 8 3421:A45:09);< 0: 3421:945:09);< 00 3421:145:09);< 05 3421:845:09);< 0C 34210:45:09);< 02 34210045:09);< 0= 34210545:09);< 0A 34210C45:09);< 34210245:09);< 34210A45:09);< 3421C845:09);< 5:

34C90845:09);< 34C95:45:09);< 34C95045:09);< 5C 34C95545:09);< 34C95C45:09);< 5= 34C95245:09);< 5A 34C95=45:09);<

 34C95A45:09);< 34C95945:09);< 34C95145:09);< C:

34C95845:09);< C0 34C9C:45:09);< C5 34C9C045:09);< CC 34C9C545:09);< C2 34C9CC45:09);< C= 34C9C245:09);< CA 34C9C=45:09);< C9 34C9CA45:09);< C1 34C9C945:09);< C8 34C9C145:09);< 2:

34C9C845:09);< 34C92:45:09);< 34C92045:09);< 2C 34C92545:09);< 34C92C45:09);< 2= 34=0A145:09);< 2A 34=0A845:09);< 34=09:45:09);< 34=09045:09);< 34=09545:09);< =:

34=09C45:09);< =0 34=09245:09);< =5 34=09=45:09);< =C 34=09945:09);< =2 34=09845:09);< == 34=01:45:09);< =A 34=01045:09);< =9 34=01545:09);< =1 34=01C45:09);< =8 34=01245:09);< A:

34=01=45:09);< A0 349545:01);< A5 345=045:01);< AC 345=545:01);< A2 34=A=45:01);< A= 34=AA45:01);< AA 34=A945:01);< A9 34=09145:09);<

. A1 34=50945:09);< A8 34252045:09);< 9:

34252545:09);< 34252C45:09);< 34252245:09);< 9C 34252=45:09);< 34252A45:09);< 9= 34252945:09);< 9A 34252145:09);< * 3425=:45:09);< 348:245:01);< 348:=45:01);< 1:

348:A45:01);< 348:945:01);< 348:145:01);< 1C 348:845:01);< 3480:45:01);< 5C055:5=  #. - %