← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/263/2014dismissed

Municipal Council, Phagwara And ANR. v. Naranjan Singh

2015-11-17Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan3 pages

   

      

 ! "#$ %$&'(')*+ ,)'&'-". ,)&'./0"12"3"")%")#0$3 --$..")#(  4$3(,( "3")5")')10 $(-)%$)#

 *  67    8 7  3$($)#*9 3 %'/%:&"#$/ 3#0$"--$..")#(  ;0$#0$3#0$$-3#$3( .&".)$2(-"-$3<"=>$"..2$%#($$ #0$5,%1<$)#?

 >$3$ $33$%##0$$-3#$33)#  ;0$#0$3#0$5,%1<$)#(0,.%>$3$-3#$%')#0$%'1$(#? 99 99 7 /

7!

<-,1)$%')#0$-3$($)#3$1,."3($&)%"--$".'(#0$ 5,%1<$)#  ")%  %$&3$$  %"#$%  @/  -"(($%  >=  #0$  .$"3)$% %%'#')".'(#3'&# ,%1$/ 8"-,3#0"."/"

'3<')1#0$5,%1<$)#")% %$&3$$%"#$% /-"(($%>=#0$.$"3)$% ':'.,%1$ ,)'3 ':'(')!/  0"12"3"/  :'%$  20'&0  #0$  (,'#    #0$  -."')#'

3 %$&."3"#')  ")%  -$3<")$)#  ')5,)&#')  2"(  %$&3$$%/  #0$3$>= 3$(#3"')')1  #0$  %$ $)%")#("--$..")#(  3<  %"<"1')1/  %$(#3=')1 ")%%$<.'(0')1#0$(,'#(0-)#0$>"('( '<-,1)$%)#'&$ 0":$0$"3%#0$.$"3)$%&,)($. 3#0$"--$..")#(")% 0":$".(&"3$ ,..=1)$#03,10#0$ '.$

 !

99 0$-$3,(". #0$5,%1<$)#( >#0#0$ ,3#(>$.2 (02#0"#>$ 3$#0$.2$3 ,3#/#0$%'(-,#$2"(#0"##0$-."')#'

/ 202)("(0-')")("2".""A"3/0"12"3"/0"%&)(#3,&#$% #2-'.."3(') 3)# 0'((0-)#0$<,)'&'-".(#3$$#3"%")% #0$3$>=<"%$$)&3"&0<$)#,-)#0$("<$)#'&$,)%$3$&#')  #0$,)5"> ,)'&'-".&#/@ ')(03#6#0$&#6!2"('((,$%/ 20'&02"(&0"..$)1$%>=#0$-."')#'

0$-$3,(". #0$5,%1<$)#(  >#0#0$ ,3#(>$.2(02#0"#>#0#0$ ,3#(0$.%#0"##0$ %$ $)%")#(  "'.$%  #  -3:$  #0"#  #0$  ("'%  -'.."3(  0":$  >$$) &)(#3,&#$%)#0$3"%>$.)1')1##0$<,)'&'-".&<<'##$$3) #0$(#3$$#>$.)1')1##0$<,)'&'-".&<<'##$$$ 3$#0$.2$3

,3#/#0$<,)'&'-".&<<'##$$%'%)#-3%,&$")=3$&3% #0$ <,)'&'-".(#3$$#33"%#-3:$#0"##0$&)(#3,&#')2"(<"%$) #0$ <,)'&'-".3"%(#3$$#  0$.2$3 ,3# ,3#0$3&"<$# #0$ &)&.,(')  #0"#  #0$  -3($&,#')  &,.%  >$  .",)&0$%  "1"')(#  #0$ $)&3"&0$3'

#0$-$3'% <3$#0")#03$$=$"3(0":$$."-($% 3< #0$%"#$ &<-.$#') &)(#3,&#')#2"( ,3#0$30$.%#0"#2'#0') ('B<)#0( '..$1".&)(#3,&#')/-$)".#=&,.%>$'<-($%"(-$3 $&#')@+ #0$&#)#0'(2"=/)#0')12"(%)$")%/#0$3$ 3$/

')%')1( "&#(0":$>$$)3$&3%$%#0"#%$ $)%")#( "'.$%#-3:$ #0"##0$("'%-'.."3(0":$>$$)&)(#3,&#$%)#0$<,)'&'-".(#3$$#3 3"%  )($C,$)#.=/#0$(,'#2"(%$&3$$% ).= ')%')1( "&#( 0":$>$$)3$&3%$%(,>(#")#'".C,$(#') ."2"3'($(')#0$

 !

99 -3$($)#"--$".0$3$ 3$/#0$3$'()13,)%#')#$3 $3$')#0$ &)&,33$)# ')%')1( #2 ,3#(>$.2$)&$/#0$-3$($)#"--$".

'(%'(<'(($%

7 !

 

+ (5D(