High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/30032/2019disposed of

Jatinderbir Singh v. Punjab And Haryana High Court And Others

2019-11-06Mr Justice Rakesh Kumar Jain,Mr. Justice Suvir Sehgal25 pages

" #

%% $

$ ('

%% $

& % #

%% $

" #

$ ) %

" #

)& '

%% $

" #

" $

(

" #

) '

%% $ , () ( $ ' ($-)

$ ' . (

$ ' ( $ ' (

&%) $ '

((

* $ ' ( %$ ' (( ( $ ' ($%!

. $ ' ( & $ ' ( $ ' (!

.$ ' (&%&

%$ ' ( & )$ ' " (%

$ ' . (&. $ ' (

$ $ ' " /

($%(

!"# $% &'(& " '

" 01

(

'%%2 ". "' .

" ) " ' '

"' 3' "%

#)*)"+,&,- +)).)-( #/0-120#)3#+,1),)4 4 " '

%%5" 6

%%7 *01 898:;80< '"% ' "19"

=+>/'%/ '( " ' ' '

= ' !'

> ?3% ;80<

5" 6

3%. ' '

% => % 3%=>% 3%@ =>'

/. ) " 19 ""

%% ,/

!"#$"

!"# '

'"( )*+, -

. &

& )*+, - . /0 /1 "*2&"

3 "2&"

- - / #(*

( ) -4 *+, 5"#*" ,#6 7 84 #(*

( ) -

9$% 9)*+, 8 8- #(*

( - &

& )*+, 4 8 1"6"9:(," "6() -4 *+, 52#*" ,#6 7 - 8 1"6"9:(," "6() -

9$% 9*+, 8. 1#6; )*+, -4 8/8 1#6;

) -

9$% 9*+, .

% 3% . ' ' " / ' " %. 3%4.

' % '

2 2 . ""

' 6$6!6 A6+. % 2 ""

2 '

4 ' 0;9 % '

2 ' : %) '

%) " 8B8 %) " . .

%3%% %).

988

% 3%. ;98B;80<.

:CC<'

% .

)

. ;DB;80<

' "% ' ;BB;80<$'' C:CC %.

"% ' ' '

' '" BB 2 '% '%%

= '

>5" 6 '% '%%

7' ;<B;80< '

' "

' " %

:<;80<

% '% '%%

) ". ' 01<;80<,/ 9" <&

( 0* =<> & * 0 & &

) ( ;";

?*"

,;"(( # ?*#( # "

"# ""

( ?*"

, "! "

&#"! (#;(( ((! ,&

@ 5/ 56/ 5/ 5/

A*"

/ 8 A*"

- 8/ . ( " # " " " (

& 0; B" &# ( ;" ?*"

& 0; 6

& #( =0> =1> = > =%> A*"

. . - 0 %

A*"

8 . 4 1

A*"

- 8 .

1 0

A*"

- 84 ./ 1 0

A*"

-4 4 / % 0

A*"

4 - 84 %

(# " ! ##&( &

( C

'' .

)

. 01<;80< .

'" " B2 .

$'' D: % .

' '/

' ' " B 2 .

)

'% '%%

0<<;80< "

' "

" 3%E' " '

' % '% '%%

;:<;80< ''

"F .

)

;:<;80< "

" . ''

' ;9<;80< " 108 ' .

/ "% '

" '""%)$'

' " '

6 (

*D #"

<0$ -

9517

84/ $% 9517 '

E0<% D' -

4/ '<

%D9 '23 <) F G01 . D<

/8 < D ) F G01 / 3

8 2 F0$$H 2902< %) F G01 3 -8 0<2 2902< %) F G01 8 3 D<3D)

" .

-./ F G01 5F <

DF< D<% < 7 4

D3 < 4 4

/ 8 -

9$%

4 --

D< < D 10$92B2 4 4-

-88 90I312 2B3) F G01 10$92B2 90I312 2B3

9$% 9 )F G01 4 4

/8 F G01 $% 9) D - F G01

" ' . '

" "

)

% ' '

. . """ "+ % # + =- >

" 4 ' '"3

' '

' ""2 2 *;BCBB0A089.

) "% 6$

" % ' " 7 81)$*)39,)":).18,)G485 7

-4 C

" .

') % ' % ' ' " .

)

' '

% " .

% . 4

". " .

,/ / ( "B#6 );( && ,( ( F"! ")# ( #(( *, ; , ( #

# 6 ; *) (# ")"";

E ((6; ( *,* ,#

#*""&

! ,;

( "( * ,( ,;

," " &

# "

, &

2*,# , ;

) ( " ) " * , *#(

, , ; ! " ( & "#* *,+# ;

* #

# ( # "

( F"! " " "" " (" # , *, #6 ; ,

6) ;("#( # , * " F ( ,

6 !

*, ( ( ; "! , ( * " #

# (6; ""#

# * ;( (! & ("

2 " 1 ""

"", &&

( #

(

9"#

" F " ,

6 & # ",

( 2 "

*#(6 ; (*,+# ( * (! " "!

;( " # " " ( ,

6 ( ,

6 *&&

(# (**2("; # *,) ; ;

* (! *?*"

, &

( 6 ; 1* " ( " , ( *,)";

*,*"

&" ( *

"!" ; ;("#(##

;"((6; )(" ) ;"( ; ;("#( " , ;

C " "

' " 7 ;23 "+, 9,) " $9,) -857 .

.' . .

)

". .

% ,/ - ( ; ( *,+# " (

) ?*" # ; &

& ("("( ;"""## #*"

( @5"72 *)<*

<*"

! " ""

& "( !*"

; (

# *" ; ( "() ( ( *(

" # *#"(""

& ""J 5""7 2 *) <*

<*"

! """

& "

!*"

# *" ; ( 5 ""#

(","" "7 ( (

* & " !*"

# *" " " " ! # );"( *" "&

, &

C "

#&"

#( "

( ,# "J5"""7(

* ( * !*

# *"":(; ( #"K"( & " "( #"# , #"#J 5"!7 (

* ( * & *(#

# (6; &

# (*&"

J5!72 (! *,)(,"( * (""

" ( ( (#"C

*-88-

7 ,- ,) 2,10-")*::,) 4 ' 8C89;80B + !

" +

7, 63 +)) .)-( >, #+, 1) -,4 ' 8008;80< ' ' " .

)

% " 2 " + '

= % >?3%;80<

" ' .

' % 3%.) E' ' " .

)

." ' '

. ' '% '' '

. ' ) %) " C9C / ' ' "" %)

'"+!

7%,8- "+, ,) ; " #)3,)4 ' 0C8;;80< %

3%' ' " "

=+> ' "

= '!'

>4 '

' .

% ' ' .

)

'% '%%

'% "9

' D 2 .

)

" B 2 . .

" '

' ' " .

)

% " ' " .

)

"2 *001 .

% '' " ' '4." %

! " #$% 72)3;>," #)3,)4'

. % 0:C;80< .

"" '

*-88-

7#)310- ")* :: >, " #)3 ,)4 ' C8<;80< % ' ' .

)

' ' " % "$"

> ?

/444% ' .

3% " :D 2

' .

'%%

" " " '%%

'' 1 2 % .

)

%%" ''

'%%

12 '

2 " :% 2 % " .

." ' ' '

" '%%

4% "

' " "

' :2 .''

'" +!

% '%%

. " ''

- ' " %

' "

% '%"

'".

"+ ' " , 63 <"18)= ' " %,8- "+, ,) <"18)= % 3% ' '

= '!'

> ' " '" ' ' '

' " 81) $*)39,)<"18)= ;23"+,9,)<"18)= .

' "

" % ' . "

" '

F .

)

. % . "

" .

' '

)

/ " '%%

' .

' '

'"%3

2 "2 ( ) ( $ '

" "

% " :2 2 *;BCB B0 089 ) "% 6$ . " "

2 *089 .

,/ -. F ;("#( ( ;"# ""

57 ;

" * # , L "! #

#; ,*"(# J 7( *,&*,"#*J ,7 ( * , &#""#

*J #7( *,# "(

#( *J 7( "(*,*,"" (

(&""

@ 07057)5,7)5#757 #

# 17D57)5,75#7 #

7D575#7 #

# %7D575,7 #

# $'' .

)

' ' .

6!.

'' ' '.

6$4

'" ' " 7)) "-:(,)% 88),)4

-- 5 7

/8.

% , 0 * " !", " &*,"# *(

" "#*" "" "! # , ")";

*" & ;( "* *"& ,*

,(# ; & "#* #2

,";

"(* *)(&&"#( " ( ( ( "( ( &

# * , ( & " ;( (*" *(*#( "(* ,*,"" ( (&""

' "

' "7" $,)#), ,),)444/547

-4.

F (

"*"

* # , "* , (

* ;( ( &&"# ,"( ( ( ( "( ( &

# * , ( & " ;( (*" *(" "(; *,"" ( (&""

C # ' "

% '

" 2 ) .

" )E.

2 .

2 '

" " % " % 2 ' .

" 2 4% 2 ' * ;("#( ( ;"# ""

57;

*#, LC . 6 ' 2 .I.

" ". ' ."% %' 6" G4" %

2 . % ' ' " % " "% .

% ' ' "

" " ' '

% " ' " '

)% % " ."% %' "" " " .

. '% 3'

. " ' " ' "2 *089

* 32 *B0.

,/ 8 (9# *(>"&&" ;("#( ( ;"L 02" 12 "#"

1 (507517 %

(, ! $'' " '%%

' ' .

" 2 6 .

'' ' '.

" 2 6$

" % ('*

"% ' "J

('*

+ ('*

. " ."% "? . +%%

' "

% ( " ? . "

('*

'2 4% ('*

. ''" "% " '' 3' ' "% 4

4= ?3'

>" 4 0BD8 5" 6 4 7 ' " ' "

" % '" ' " "3'' . "

'B: B9" 4 .

,/ 8 0# & * * "M

(" " # ;("#( " , & ;( ) ( " " ") ,

* *

") " "#&, 6 ;"(* (#)

((" ";(""( ;

# ; 8.0# & "#&, +* , " "#"

#*"(" ;"M

("" #;("#(" ,& ;( )(" "")") , " "#"

) "#&, 6 ;"(* (#)

((" ";(""( ;

)

# ;J &

!" ( ( (" ;("#( " "# (" ; "" (" ;"( *("6 ;

"(";"C

' "

' "7"1,?)" )-4;808=08>

9B; .

% GK #"

8 ( 2"

# ": ( # "" 2 " "* @ N

("" #;("#(" ,& ;( (" " "), * * ") ""#&, 6 ;"(* ( #)

( ( " " ;( " "( ;

# ;N 0 , & * (

" #"

;

* ( ; ( "

*##) ( && ;

* (! &

!( ,

* * ") ( ; "#&, 6 ;" ( * ( # # ",("2( #)( ;

*(! &

!((;"#&,

6 ;"((; ";(""( ;

# ; (

" #"

# "!*

# ""

(# ""! &,(

$; " #""

(3 * $

"(# < %" 9# *( 8 << .4@

< 853$7 2 ( #) ( 3 * $

* ( * 9# *( <* ( ," ( "! ?*"

) ;("#((,

(;"( ( # "" ( # # , " # ;( 9#

*( ; #( ;"( ( * , (

" ; % * ) ;( ; (! # (( "9""

< , ( ##* 9# *(&

*#"#!"# &

! () ( ; ) ( " # ""(#)" * " 3 #" ( ( ; * "

"*"

(( "9"" ; (

("&

,3( #" ( * ( " *"

) ( "

6 % *

( "9"" # "("* , (

" (" ( & "" ; ##& 9# *( ; * *") (

* ""C # '

" " .

" '%%

% ('*

. ' "3' .

6. "

'B:A

B9" 4 %%'

'' ' "). """

. ' . " "% "3' . ' ('*

' "

" ' ' " ''

H . "

" 2 .

""*&( ,6; " ( ?*"

) #(

( , &"

* ( "!

C . "2 *B0 % . 6$ I G .

' . ' " (' *

. ""

"% % "% 3' .

" " 2

' .

2 ' 6$ "6

" "

2 *CB .

,/ 8 ("*"* )*" ",*C" OOOOOOOOO 00 * * !"# 10 * * ;

1 (507517 %

(, !

6$ .

'% 6+

" % %3% ' 4 '

% ' "7:)?"+,": "+,,)" 2,444 57

./.

*"* *" ",*

". '

# ' " .

" '%%

2 ' " " % % ' 3% ) % " %3% ' ' 3. 4 '

4% 2

) ' " %3% ' 3 . 4 '

6+.

' ' % " %3%) "% 3%

. .

!') -. +' .

)

. " "' ''%'

" ' "'

2 2 *;B .

8 ("&"

" !;( 00 & ( ,# * * " 10 & ) ( ( ( & *") " *" # *# ;("#( " "6 # & +*"#" ( #

" ( ,*" ," ( ( * ( ,*"

0 & ( , +*"# " ! %( ,*" ( "

# , #

" ! $ .

)

" .

2 6 .

'' 2 " % 4

' " %

4 " 4 $'0<C;5" 6 $'7 . 6+ "L%.

':8 6+

' :0" $' . 6 %

':;" $' "

6+ "'

':C " $' 6+ '

" .

' ::" $' 6+ $'' 2 ) / E 3% %' " "% 2 .

6 ' '.

' . " " '

' .

':;= >" $' 3%

" "' .

':0" $' . 6'% .

' :; . " '

' .

' '' .

" "%

" %

':0=>" $'

% $'*C0";80D.

. I % +K$"% K=> '" " GH

:;" $' " "%

' '' .

" '

' .

' '

':;= >" $' %' 4 ." " "' ''%'

" ' 2 *;B% .

'' $ 2 ' .

' ' .

)

2 *B0"J 6$$ 2 *;B"J 6$

$'' 01 . " . ". ',/ =>

" 108 ' .

/ '

' " ;9<;80< => 4 ' " % ' =.

> '%

% ""' '.

)

2 *B0"J 6$ 2 *;B"J 6$ "% 2

% ' ' " ' 2 " J 6!6 6+ => $" ' ' " % '

. .

)"% "'

=> # " ' . 108 / ' / ' ' '

'% % " %. 3% => !

' .

"% % . "

( ' % % .

/%4+ %

" 2" % 3% " %. 3% $ ' " '

" " ' ' '

#&$$ #$% E(( &6" @ H

E(( <&

, @ H