High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/5374/2015dismissed

Maninder Bir Singh Kochhar v. Rajinder Kumar Bali

2019-05-08Mr. Justice Amit Rawal8 pages

"#$$%&'&() "* +,

- "(&(.$/&/&(012%11"/ 33$44"(# 5$/'6'

"7/ "7&(.$/268"/"4& $'3(.$(# ! "

#$%&' () *+!' +*,&

/$'$(#) /'1&'100"/9"4,$(&/.:%"#$9&#1 '1$8("";1"/9"4,.:%"#$, /#1$"33$44"(# /1"&4$(./"1"/8",.:%"#$, /#1$%":$"#/</$'3(.$(# ===== +*,&-( 1$3/$'$(# $064"/$%(.33$"4 &'.&/$%#$."0"&('##1$ 76.08$(#"(..$%/$$#1$>9$/33$44"#$6/#,91$/$;*#1$'6&##1$ "33$44"(#?34"&(#&/'3$%&&%3$//8"(%$#1$"0/$$8$(##'$44."#$.

.$%/$$.;*#1$#/&"46/#,1"';$$(.&'8&''$. 33$44"(#?34"&(#&'601##1$.&'%/$#&("/*/$4&$(#1$;"'&' #1$"0/$$8$(#"/$8$(#&($.&(/$'3$%#4"(.8$"'6/&(0@"("4' 8"/4"',&$,"%/$'

@"("4 8"/4"';$&(0 </.'1"/$6###"44"(.

8$"'6/&(0@"("4'"0/$$.#;$'4.A ,

<?3$/"%/$"0"&('# 3"*8$(# ,

<?"'$"/($'#8($*'3$/#1$#$/8'"(.%(.&#&(' #1$"0/$$8$(#,34"&(#&9"'/$B6&/$.#3"*"'68 ,

<?"#$/ .$.6%#&(0 ,

<?;*

"(."(#1$/'68,

<?;*

"(.'"4$.$$.9"'"0/$$.#;$$C$%6#$."##1$$(. "/%1,

D'3$/#1$":$/8$(#',34"&(#&'#"#$.#1":$3/$3"/$.#9./"#' "86(#&(0#+,

<?"(.D,

<?,##"44&(0 ,

<?"(.1".

'$(##1$'"8$##1$.$$(."(#;*/$0&'#$/$.3'#,;6##1$'"8$9"'/$#6/($. 9&#1#1$$(./'$8$(#E# $#F 4"&(#&9"'4";;$/0"'#$.#/$%$&:$"

4$##$/."#$.

( D

,91$/$;*#1$.$$(."(#%"(%$44$.#1$ "0/$$8$(#;*$(%4'&(0#1$%1$B6$ ,

<?1$"/$8$(#&($.'6&# 9"'&('#&#6#$.(

+ 1$ /$'3(.$(#?.$$(."(# %(#$'#$. #1$ '6&# ;* /"&'&(0 3/$4&8&("/*;7$%#&('B6"4&8&#"#&(,%6/#$$'$#%"(.(8$/&#'&#9"' "44$0$.#1"##1$"0/$$8$(#9"'"4'$"(..&.(#%(#"&(#1$3"/#&%64"/' #1$@1"'/"(68;$/' 4"&(#&.&.(#1":$"(*&("(%&"4%"3"%&#*#3$//8 #1$"0/$$8$(# 1$/$".&($''"(.9&44&(0($''9"'"4'9"(#&(0"'#1$ 34"&(#&.&.(#8"@$"(*$/#;*3$/'("44*1"(.&(0:$/#1$;"(@./"#' &('#$".'$(.&(0;*/$0&'#$/$.3'# &(%$#1$3"/#&$'9$/$"#:"/&"(%$,#1$#/&"46/#/"8$.#1$ 449&(0&''6$')?

! " #

4"&(#&, &( '633/# #1$ $:&.$(%$, ;/601# ( /$%/. .%68$(#'C

,&$,7"8";"(.&,"0/$$8$(##'$44,%3&$' %1$B6$',4$##$/."#$.

,3'#$(:$43$,4$##$/."#$. -

, 4$##$/ ."#$.

, %1$B6$ ."#$.

"(. $C"8&($. #9

9&#($''$',91$/$"'#1$.$$(."(#$C"8&($.1&8'$4"'G? ,;6#.&.(# #$(.$/"(*.%68$(# 1$#/&"46/#,(#1$;"'&'#1$$:&.$(%$"/$8$(#&($., .$%/$$.#1$'6&#,;6##1$>9$/33$44"#$6/#"%%$3#$.#1$"33$"4#1$ .$$(."(#"(..&'8&''$.#1$'6&#(#1$0/6(.4&8&#"#&("(./9"(# /$".&($''"(.9&44&(0($'' /'1&'100"/9"4,4$"/($.$(&/6('$4"''&'#$.;* ' 1$8(" ";1"/9"4, .:%"#$ /$3/$'$(#&(0 #1$ "33$44"(#?34"&(#& '6;8&##$.#1"##1$%6/#;$491"'#"@$(#1$%"6'$"%#&(<"44$0$.;/$"%1 /8

/#1$36/3'$%836#&(0#1$4&8&#"#&("(..&'8&''$. #1$'6&#&4$.&(64*,

+;$&(0;"//$.,91$/$"'&#9"'#;$'#"/#/8#1$ $(. "/%1,

D,&$,#"/0$#."#$#9"'"(6(&4"#$/"4"%#.$$(."(#&( %"(%$44&(0#1$"0/$$8$(#"(.#1$/$9"'('6%1%&/%68'#"(%$'"44$0&(0 ;/$"%1(#1$3"/##1$34"&(#& ( #1$ %(#/"/*, #1$ "33$44"(# :&.$ /$0&'#$/$. 4$##$/ ."#$.

C ,1".'$(##1$./"#'"/$8$(#&($.,;6##1$'"8$9"' /$%$&:$.;"%@9&#1#1$/$3/#E# $#F,91&%1"86(#$.#/$6'"4:$(" 4$##$/ C - ."#$. -

/$B6$'#&(0 #1$ .$$(."(# / 0&:&(0 1&' '&0("#6/$' # #1$ "6#1/&#* / #1$ 36/3'$ ;#"&(&(0 ;7$%#&( $/#&&%"#$9"'(#/$'3(.$.0/$$8$(##'$449"'(#.$(&$."(.&('6%1 %&/%68'#"(%$', >9$/ 33$44"#$ 6/# %64. (# 1":$ ((?'6&#$. #1$ 34"&(#&"'#1$&(0/$.&$(#'$%#&(

%!#1$3$%&&% $4&$%# 1":$;$$(3/:$.(/$%/. (#1$/0/6(./((?'6&#&(09"'&((#%1"44$(0&(0#1$ %"(%$44"#&(

&(:&$9#1$/"#&.$%&.$(.&%644$.6#&( + ./

12&34335 16 .

783-

!!.9. :#9"'"%"'$91$/$#1$#&8$9"'(#$''$(%$#1$ "0/$$8$(##'$449$:$/,&(#1$&('#"(#%"'$#&8$9"'$''$(%$1$ %"(%$44"#&( 9"' 3/&/ # #1$ ."#$ "(., #1$/$/$, #1$ /"#& &( #1$ "/$8$(#&($. 76.08$(# 964. (# "334* ( '633/# #1$ "/$8$(#&($. %(#$(#&(, /$4&$. 63( "( 6(/$3/#$. 76.08$(# #1$ %/.&("#$;$(%1#1&'6/#/$(.$/$.&(%4. 8433 ;2 % 3

783-

-.$%&.$.(

D,91$/$&(&( "/"'"(.D1$4."'6(.$/)?

$ !%

& '

( )

* + ( )

)

( ) *

, (

)

( + (

(

-.*

* *

(

* )

$ /%

* *

2 3 01 ( 45

&5 '*06-.! !7

85-! .

9/ *60 ( 0- &" :

'*.!088

" : ;;;*

5 0

7 ( 3:

76 *.!&'

"8"&8 ( ';&72'& : '# (%$#1$"0/$$8$(##'$449"'.$(&$.,/$'3(.$(#?.$$(."(# &'(#$(#&#4$.##"@$#1$34$"/$".&($''"(.9&44&(0($'' $4&$.63( 7 .

84336;.7 .

8-< !!.9. = 1":$1$"/.#1$4$"/($.%6('$4/#1$"33$44"(#?34"&(#&, "33/"&'$.#1$3"3$/;@,76.08$(#'%&#$."#;"/"(.#1$:&$9#1"##1$/$ &'(/%$"(.8$/&#&(#1$'6;8&''&('#1$4$"/($.$(&/6('$4/ #1$'&834$/$"'(#1"##$(/"(.8.$#1$9/&##$('#"#$8$(#.(#/$:$"4 #1$$831"#&%"4.$(&"4#1$"0/$$8$(#,;6#&#'%('#/6"4/$:$"4'#1"##1$ "0/$$8$(##'$449"'%"(%$44$.(

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

: &(&4&(0#1$'6&#&(64*,

+,#1601#1$>9$/33$44"#$6/#1"'#"@$( #1$."#$"'

/#1$36/3'$%836#"#&(#1$4&8&#"#&(( "%%6(#"44$0$.;/$"%1$C34"("#&(1"'%8$/#1&("''"&4&(0#1$ /$8$.*(/"(*4$0"4(#&%$/"(*$/##&4464*,

+91$(#1$'6&#9"'

&4$.1$4"99&#1/$0"/.##1$/$".&($''"(.9&44&(0($''&'(4(0$/

1$/$4$:"(#3"/" #1$76.08$(#/$(.$/$.&( %4.;2 %878.433> 9.7. 783-+ !

</$".#16')?

' " 6 & '

: =

= :0

( > 0

*&.99 ' 088.*

? 0 +

( =A * :

= 0

</@ 0 ./

+ & '*&' &' 6 * *

( (

1 @

* * +

(

0 ./&'

(

= :0

# #&'(#"($831"#&%"4.$(&"4"(.,#1$/$/$,#1$/"#&&(

8$3 33 -&83'&(0"($'#33$463(#1$.$$(."(###"@$#1$ 34$"/$".&($''"(.9&44&(0($''964.(#"334* G1$#1$/#1$>9$/33$44"#$6/#1"."44$(&($///&(((? '6&#&(0 #1$ 34"&(#& ( #1$ 0/6(. 4&8&#"#&( ;* /$$//&(0 # #1$ 3/:&'&('%4"6'$ !/#&%4$#1$>&8&#"#&(%#,#1$4"9('6%1 3/3'&#&(&'(4(0$//$'&(#$0/",/,#1$%"6'$"%#&(#":$(.$$ "/&'$'(4*("%%6(##1$;/$"%1.6;#,#1$.$$(."(#1".%"(%$44$. #1$"0/$$8$(#3/&/##1$#"/0$#."#$,&$,$(. "/%1,

D#%"((#;$ %('#/6$.#1"#34"&(#&9"'/$B6&/$.#9"&#/#1$#"/0$#."#$#"''6"0$ %"6'$"'4"#$"'&(64*,

+1$&(#$(#&(9"'%4$"/ $8$.*'164.1":$ ;$$(#"@$(9&#13/83#&#6.$44#1$'$"%#/'1":$;$$(9$&01#&(#1$8&(. #1$>9$/33$44"#$6/#$C#$('&:$4*;$&(0#1$4"'#%6/#"%#"(. 4"9

(/$3/#$.76.08$(##1$4$"/($.&(04$6.0$964.(# "334*,/,#1$"%#'"'$(68$/"#$. #1$/$/8:&'?"?:&' &@"(."/H' %"'$ '63/"!, "/$##"44*.&$/$(#,/,&( &@"(."/ #1$'$44$/9"&#$. B6&$#4*"(.$:$($C#$(.$.#&8$/$C$%6#&(#1$&('#/68$(#,;6#('#$3' 9$/$#"@$(/'3$%&&%3$//8"(%$"(.&('6%1%&/%68'#"(%$',.$$(."(# /$'%&(.$.#1$%(#/"%#1$$C34"("#&((#1":&(08".$"(*$/## 1"(. :$/ #1$ ./"#' &( 3$/'(, %"(%$44"#&( #1$ "0/$$8$(# 9"' " ($%$''"/*%/44"/*

/#1$/$"'('"/$8$(#&($.,.(#&(."(*&44$0"4&#*/ 3$/:$/'&#*&(#1$&(.&(0'6(.$/%1"44$(0$0/6(./&(#$/$/$(%$&' 8".$ 6#, 86%1 4$'' &(:4:$8$(# "(* '6;'#"(#&"4 B6$'#&( 4"9

$'64#"(#4*,#1$"33$"4&'.&'8&''$. ##1&''#"0$,4$"/($.%6('$4/#1$"33$44"(#?34"&(#&8".$"

= /$B6$'# #1"# #1$$"/($'# 8($* ,

<? 8"*;$/.$/$. # ;$ /$6(.$. / 1"4$(./" 1"/8", 4$"/($. %6('$4 / #1$ /$'3(.$(#< %":$"#/'6;8&##$.#1"#1&'%4&$(#&'(#":$/'$#&''6$#1$/$'1%1$B6$

<?3/:&.$.#1"##1$34"&(#&<"33$44"(#&'.&/$%#$.#/$#6/(#1$4. %1$B6$ >$"/($. $(&/ 6('$4 / #1$ "33$44"(#?34"&(#&, ( &('#/6%#&('/81&'%4&$(#,'6;8&##$.#1"##1$4.%1$B6$964.;$/$#6/($. &(:&$9#1$%('$('6'"//&:$."#;$#9$$(#1$3"/#&$' (:&$9#1$";:$,&(%"'$#1$4.%1$B6$&'/$#6/($.##1$ /$'3(.$(#?.$$(."(#,($9%1$B6$ ,

<?9&44;$'$(#;*/$0&'#$/$.

3'###1$"33$44"(#?34"&(#&9&#1&("3$/&.&#$$(."*'

2=-< +*,&

638 ()0?'

,8783/.

A3@

,878 71"

A3@