High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2679/2014dismissed

Pardeep And ORS v. Dhanpati And ORS

2015-02-26Mr. Justice Augustine George Masih15 pages

!"#$%&

'""((

)

&" &

' "

#%* +& '""(( )

&" &

' "

! #,+-. / - & )

&(,+-./ .

&""(( !$0 (. / - & !%* +&./ .

& /1 " 3&&" ( ("" %4*((-

&5$+%6 7* &" 689 : 3&& & 5$+% &$( * " & + 6

( $

(*4&"(

- *4& (

$/ 5$+% ""( " + & (-

: 7&

&-. .:

* &

$. & +$( ""(

" *4 : 3& .

" *4 ! &(

.& .-$(* *4 & + ("

& ;

(*4&"(

% &-

<(. & "4 "

*4 -4

" % &+%:

.>$ (% $ + =?( %( & ""4 ( & & ( * + :

. @ $ *4 . /$

.>$& (.- $((/ 5$ - ( ( %. + & %( +& ( 4% ; - /& ) +&.&"" *&- ""4.

$- & &/$ ) ((+ "$.7&

(

" +% ((:

.- @ $*4& %>$ & ( /$ & "(

. ( (

. . 1A $% .

1A- "$"&/*/ .*4-4

%4.

1A-" :

& % @ &+%& .

1A.

-" $* >$(4*$& %4 :

(- *@ $ /$ &"(

* :

. / + & *( (

B$&.

. %& $% .==. 1A %&"(

+(4. &>$

$% .==. 1A. &% .-

-C? ; .

+(4.>$

( &

+- &* ?"+ &+% /% &-

-( 4".&-/.

"& &>$

@ &

&$%* %"

$"&+% &

+;-

% &"(

& (-4 *4- (( + " %&

" . &>$ /(

@ $ & ( / +&*( (

.*$/ ( : :

."(

%?-& &

(& ""4 ./ +

(

--.& &(4@ $ +%:

. /$ &"(

.& (

- ((+(. " // . "

">$ . ?-(+& ( % &"(

.&$ .&

!$ $ &

$ *4 & $.

& $ "" &$+&&

$ (

&"4 %

(& - %=

.""(

- %/ *4&"(

& &

-4. (

< - * +"( - &"4 %"( &%% (- ( "( &

+ * /*4& ( $.(&$+& $ ( . $"" ((&

( + &+$%

& .*$ &4- %&

*&( .

((&% ( /.*&( &

< -

( ; "- %

(*4

. - "(. ( .&"(

$&" "

" % & +% ((:

. %- @ $ %$ & &@ &+%

@ $ & /$.*4 ."$ $ -&/& (- @ $

;

. / @ $ +% :

. /$ &"(

.- %"( "

$ + & " 4 & . " -

(*4&%. - "(. ( .&&4 &"$ & & ""4 % .

/ +

(

+(4.& / "

(- ( /&% ;-

% &&4-*

"$ & /($*(

B$&. & - / 4 +% *-&"(

. .

&(4 +% ((- &

%"&

$/ .& $ *(- ($& & @ & +% (( :

9@!- $(4"/ *4&"(

*4( +

+ / & + - *$+& *4 & "/&&+%9@!.-

+ *

$% $(. - $ &9@!9@!: &+%& " .- $(4 @ $ $% *4 . &$ .

* + $" & % + & +%

9@. & - "$" &/ * @ $*4 . /$ .

"9@. - * /&& $%

-*+$ $$((4""*4& - & & &"(

D >$(4.

& (

9@:.@ $"$ $

&+%

.- ( ((+(;

&"( .&&4-*

"$ &

. - ($&

&+ (@ $*4"(4 + $. / - &) +& .&4

/( ( /$

%$ & ./

. ( $&

5$ %( +& (.

*$ %"(

+& .&4 (( (&

""4 .

7&$ .

$( ( % * & *

"$ & 4 .& (@ $ &

/$ - & *4 & "

& $ & " . %% (4 &/ + %?- (@ $*4 . /$ .&*4 ( "/ &&& *4- (( +" %&

" &

& 4. .

" &

""4. "

&+%:

./ * &

@ @ ( /$

&"(

.&"/&&& % ( - - (( + " %&

" $((4.&

(*4 &"(

*/.&""( " + & (-

;&/&( $ ( &"

(+&"$ & #,+ -. ( $ ( &""(( $*% &""(4."(

( "/ & @ & +% :

E &&+% >$ -

((+ &/ * 4" *4 4- !3. -& -

%(44"

+$(- 7&$+&.&

( % &/ 4" & +%. *$ (( & % &* &

+*4& % ; .& % &

A@% & & ?- ) +&." ((4B$&.&"

$*% *4 @" $( * (? . * +

*( (-. &@".-&&$&& "- /@% 9/&-

.& & & " - @%(4 /+$ 7& & + -

&+%:

# +& - /@% *4&"(

"/&

( % ((

$&.& %4 &#$% $(* * +*4"( + &- /"(*" & % @ & +% 7& . &

&&"(

("/&@ & +% :

& - .

- & +4& +. "

" %

$+& &/ * + &

/$ & +%- / ! .( $ ( & /A " & *& & $ *(- &

$(4 $&&@ &+% :

.- $(4"/& 4.& $*%

&&+%.""$*4 .-

$ * *+$ + $% B$&.

* +

. $(

( %&% (/ *&*

"$ & $ &$+& $(

& %

$.;%

/ -&& ""( -&((4/ % &$ .( *(*

& &* + & (

. "(

* ( "4 .&- >$ "/&&+% >$ :

9@!.- @ $ *4

%$ %& .* +

/. & $ "" &$+&&

$ (.-& $"" ((&

( + & +$% *$ / & & ( % & "(

9/&

A A % -

(4- % &!3: & & "(

% &- 0 ((. -& ( % &/

%" &

& & % @ & +%."/& &+%( & $% .

1A.-/ *4 -4 %4 & % @ & +% $* >$(4."$ $&%% *4 .& $% .

1A.-( " .& %44-!3.-&4"&+% :

&&&4"&+% >$ & . ) +& .& .&$& & &"

/& +-

.&/ +$ % +& %* . "" &

&$%* %"

$"& $% &

&" & +-

< ?-

."(

% &- & + -

(

+ & $% E $& "/ *& & " :

9@!>$ $% .

1A9@!:>$ .

1A.-&

&-&$%*%?*4 ) +&B$&.%!? &!3. & + -

&+%:

.( "/& $/( @ &+%:

E"$" &/?-*& "(

" ((4 E " & " .

1A %& $% .

& "(

& *$+& & %$ % &% " & %$ "" &

&$%* %"

$"& /$ %"

@& "9@!:& %- (

+ *4 & % & & + -

*4 ( $ ( & " ."$ $ ""(

%/*4&& .

*& & +% . ""$ *4 & "(

. :

" 9@! 9@!:. & (

9@:- (4

&B + ! C$$&"9@! $*% &

/( &&+%9@! "9@!: * &&$%* %"

) +& " 9@!.

"*( 4 %

$ .&$ . $(*% /+$

7&/

4 " $(*>$ & &% (/ $% 9@ 9@& + 4 (

+ "

"9@! - $*% *44" / @"*$*4& +! C$$D (4. &4*5 -

(+ & "4""(

- %/*4 (( & @" & "$"

A@% &

+7&* + .

&+$%* +/ *4( $ ( & ""(( & & " 9@! - %

*( / .( ?

* $ 9/

.4-!3- (44"

+$( - & +% * &

+$ .&*4 ( -

(-/ & /

4 & +% :

. -&

& / &-

- $((4"/E

%4/( &&-

+ 4"

(" &( 4 -$( 4" +% /44 & "(

&!3:. ( %&/*" & %

@ &+%:

.-&

&- >$ $(.

* + .&

%" &

& ; .

%!? &!3. * &

&*& "(

*$+& & %(+- &&& +-

. &(

$ ":

$ . - "(*4 &"(

&&/ & %4 . " &-

&- / -

&+%.&- &(44

((4 "( & / & - " & %

@ &+%7& .&&&-

&+% # +&- @% .

(

>$ (-."

$((4-&&@ &

+% - $(4 "/ - & & / (4 7&$+&. $+&((+&& +% :

. - + *

$%.*$& +- *$+& $*

&"( ($*4*&& $ *(-. ( - @ $*4 . /$ .

.%$ &* &

@ @ ( /$ &"(

. "(

(&"

. %% (4

% +?- (

.&$ . - "/ & & "(

& (-4 * 4 - (( +" %&

" E-/. "

* + ."(

-$( ((* ( "4 ."/ - "/& &

@ $ +%

. &-

" " %. /$ 7& +%

9@ &- & !"

: & "$ & & %" "" =

% &"F$ $% G % & #$%.%").(

. &".;7<.

-(& 7&$+&.% &#$%- $

-& $(*@% *4 ."/& +%.*$ $"

+(4.&- @% *4&"(

% &#$%!3

&& %""" .$"

&&+%

*. *&

%"-&4/ (*4& %B$&.&

%" "" ( * &

+$ +

$%*B$&.& %""" .& (

$(4 +

((4 $*% - &&

* /.

&+%

- @ $ *4 . $( (-4 >$

."/ && %""" -"$ & %% &#$% =

% $ %& .-&&

%""" -

(4/ (*(".&- (4 ?

(% -4 % & / ((+. ( @"( -&- & ((+(& *$ ?

(% -4"$ & & %""" %$ &

./ -(./ 3 (@"(

%-&%& +%- +4"*4& % 7&

$ *4 . - &. -

"$ $+%

9@. (

9@:- @ $*4 . & /$ E-/.(4

( &- & & - & 4 & +%

9@& "9@ & * /*4& $ *(-. &-

@% *4 & " & 9@ 9@

-4"@ $/ H &%*:=.- (& .-& &-

&@ &

$% & / ((+7&* + . - +&(4

($ *4 *& & $ *(- & & +% 9@ "9@- *+$ $% - $$((4"".- & $ & +& &"(

./& (

9@:( "(

+ &>$ .-&& -*

"$ &

4. "

. + ( & ""4. / (

.& (& ""4 /$

;-$(*""

" $&

5$ $.

&& (- @ $$ +&" 4

& &$ .& ( /$ .- & *4"

"( (

" 9/&-

&4 /& ( % &

(

9@:.@ $ & /$.

.&4 $(&(4

/( ( /$

(( $&. % & " &-

*@"/& ( % &- & " "

+ & *4 & (

" %% ""( 7&$ . / *- & /

.- - (+& & 9@ & +% :

9@!. &/ + * $(4 "/ +%

. ""$ *4 .* +*+$ *

. &/ + ( "/ & &4 - *

"$ &

7& (4 & / *(

$( /

& "

" % &+% ((: .&

+&(4*+&"(

;&-? &"

. $*/.& &(4@

4+$. - && ($

&&/ $(4* /*4*&&D$

*(- >$ (-. %$ & (

4 $* ( >$ (-.

""( * +/ % .

+(4.

( Arun Palli ) Judge February 26, 2015 Rajan