Sapean Technologies Private Limited And Others v. Incinque Business Solutions Private Limited
"#$ $%&'&()*++
",$"($%-(./&$'0#+1#2+"(2#-$3'
4$#&#&($3 5$3'6' (%&(76$6'&($'' .6#&('0#+1#2+ $',(2$(#
3$'$(#) 3+ "("63#$8 &(/-920%"#$9 3#-$,$#&#&($3'+ :::::
! "
#
$ % !
&$
"
' #"( !
' )
& "
* "
#"( +
, "
-----.$
*
"
"
"/0 12 #"( +
3-"-2"14"
! *
#"( !
! "
"
, "
5-----.$ ) " "/0 12 ) , "
5-----.$"
"
" 16
* "
, "
2-----.$
)
, "
5-----.$'
!
) "
"
%7 "
8 '9
$
"
+
"
:
!
)
" : ' ; (
12%0 ,(,%( "02/ ( % %
4 &$
&&&!-6/-%;,6(2&(/3$76&3$'%('$(# <#-,"3#&$'9 $0$(&("<'$(%$ '6%-%('$(#9#-$63#9&(#-$&(#$3$'#' 86'#&%$9( <$&(/'"#&'
&$2#-"##-$%;,."&("(#-"'<$$(26.=%;,$('"#$29%"(&(&#' 2&'%3$#&(%.'$#-$,3%$$2&(/'"(22&'%-"3/$#-$"%%6'$2+ &0!3%$263$ 3#3&". %"'$'6(2$3-",#$3>5 #-$ %#-"'(3;"..=#<$'6;;"3=+-$2&'%3$#&( #-$"/&'#3"#$6(2$3 '$%(2,30&'# $%#&(9#-.2#-"#&#?"'6(2$'&3"<.$##3=#-$ %"'$'6;;"3&.="''$(#$(%$ ;3$#-"(($=$"3;"=-"0$#<$,"''$29 &'#<$$@$3%&'$2"
#$3%('&2$3&(/#-$ 63#-$3 "%##-"#","3# 3;#-$ '$(#$(%$ &;,3&'(;$(#9#-$63#-"'863&'2&%#&(6(2$3 $%#&(* !3+++ # "?"32 '6&#"<.$ %;,$('"#&( ?&#- 2$ "6.# '$(#$(%$ 6(2$3 $%#&(A"(2?&#- 63#-$3,?$3' 3$%0$3=6(2$3 $%#&( 3+++B&#-#-&'",,3"%-9,3&'('$(#$(%$ ;3$#-"(($=$"3;"= (#<$3$76&3$2&("..%"'$'+ @@@ @@@ @@@ +(0&$? #-$"<0$9?$-.2#-"#?-$3$#-$%-$76$ ";6(#?&#-&(#$3$'#"(2 %'#"' "''$''$2<=#-$63#&',"&2<=" ',$%& &$22"#$9#-$63#&'$(#&#.$2#%.'$#-$,3%$$2&(/'&($@$3%&'$
&#',?$3'6(2$3 $%#&( #-$%#3$"2?&#- $%#&( C3+++'
".3$"2=<'$30$29(3;".36.$ 3#3&". %"'$'6(2$3-",#$3>5 #-$ %#&'# ..?#-$'6;;"3=,3%$263$"(2'6;;('#3&".,3%$263$%"(
<$ ..?$2?-$3$'$(#$(%$$@%$$2&(/($=$"3;"=<$($%$''"3=#"D&(/ &(#"%%6(##-$ "%##-"#%;,$('"#&(6(2$3 $%#&(* !3+++?&#- '$(#$(%$ .$''#-"(($=$"3?&..(#<$"2$76"#$9-"0&(/3$/"32##-$ ";6(# %-$76$9%(26%# #-$"%%6'$2"(2#-$3%&3%6;'#"(%$'+E % )
(
"
; 4
)
$(#&#.$2#%.'$#-$,3%$$2&(/'
&($@$3%&'$ &#',?$3'6(2$3 $%#&( #-$%#3$"2?&#- $%#&(
C 3+++ ; 352%3 ( ( <
' ":
( ( <
423 &$
; 03$
!!
!"#$ $$ %%&"F % #?&#-'#"(2&(/ "(=#-&(/ %(#"&($2 &( #-$ 2$ 3&;&(".
3%$263$9 * *!9"..
$(%$'6(2$3#-&'-",#$3'-"..<$#3&$2 <="62&%&"."/&'#3"#$ #-$ &3'#%."''3<="$#3,.&#"("/&'#3"#$ "(2#-$,30&'&(' '$%#&(' # A <#-&(%.6'&0$! #-$'"&22$
'-"..9"' "3"';"=<$9",,.=#'6%-#3&".')30&2$2#-"#&(#-$%"'$ "(= %(0&%#&(&("'6;;"3=#3&".6(2$3#-&''$%#&(9&#'-"..<$."? 6. 3#-$ "/&'#3"#$#,"''"'$(#$(%$ &;,3&'(;$(# 3"#$3;(#$@%$$2&(/ ($=$"3"(2"(";6(# &($$@%$$2&(/ &0$#-6'"(236,$$')30&2$2
63#-$3#-"#?-$("##-$%;;$(%$;$(# 93&(#-$%63'$ 9"'6;;"3= #3&".6(2$3#-&''$%#&(9&#",,$"3'##-$"/&'#3"#$#-"##-$("#63$ #-$ %"'$&''6%-#-"#"'$(#$(%$ &;,3&'(;$(# 3"#$3;$@%$$2&(/($=$"3 ;"=-"0$#<$,"''$23#-"#&#&'9 3"(=#-$33$"'(96(2$'&3"<.$##3= #-$%"'$'6;;"3&.=9#-$"/&'#3"#$'-".."
#$3-$"3&(/#-$,"3#&$'93$%32"( 32$3##-"#$
$%#"(2#-$3$"
#$33$%".."(=?&#($''?-;"=-"0$<$$( $@";&($2"(2,3%$$2#-$"333$-$"3#-$%"'$&(#-$;"(($3,30&2$2<= #-$'"&22$+
!-$ #3&". "%"'$ 6(2$3#-&' '$%#&( '-"..9 ' "3 "' ,3"%#&%"<.$9 %('&'#$(#.=?&#-#-$&(#$3$'#' 86'#&%$9<$%(#&(6$2 3;2"=#2"=6(#&.
&#'%(%.6'&(96(.$''#-$63# &(2'#-$"2863(;$(# #-$#3&".<$=(2 #-$ ..?&(/2"=#<$($%$''"3= 33$"'('#<$3$%32$2&(?3&#&(/+ !0$3=#3&".6(2$3#-&''$%#&('-"..<$%(26%#$2"'$@,$2&#&6'.="' ,''&<.$"(2"($(2$"063'-"..<$;"2$#%(%.62$#-$#3&".?&#-&('&@ ;(#-' 3;#-$2"#$ &.&(/ #-$%;,."&(#+ @@@@ @@@@ @@@@
$%#&(* '# $!
( # %) '*( F#?&#-'#"(2&(/ "(=#-&(/%(#"&($2&(#-$2$ 3&;&(".3%$263$9 * *!9 $0$3=
$(%$,6(&'-"<.$6(2$3#-&'%#'-"..<$%;,6(2"<.$+E + * &%&' # * ,-./ $%#&( C
!
$!
)) #
*&'0$&'# !&'#$ $+F("(= '6;;('%"'$&('##$2#-$3?&'$#-"(6,(%;,."&(#9""/&'#3"#$
A #-$ &3'# %."'' 39 ?&#- #-$ ,3$0&6' '"(%#&( #-$ -&$ 62&%&".
"/&'#3"#$9"(=#-$362&%&"."/&'#3"#$9;"=9 33$"'('#<$3$%32$2 <= -&;9 '#, #-$ ,3%$$2&(/' "# "(= '#"/$ ?&#-6# ,3(6(%&(/ "(= 862/;$(# "(2 ?-$3$ '6%- '#,,"/$ ,3%$$2&(/' &' ;"2$ "
#$3 #-$ $0&2$(%$ #-$ ,3&(%&,". ?&#($''$' -"' <$$( 3$%32$29 ,3(6(%$ " 862/;$(# "%76&##".9"(2&("(=#-$3%"'$93$.$"'$#-$"%%6'$29"(2'6%- 3$.$"'$'-"..-"0$#-$$
$%# 2&'%-"3/$+ #!& '352$
"= ++++ ++++ ++++ %3> (
(
'
'
"
; ;
" : '
% (
+
' ; 03
;
15 352%3 ( "<"("
" (
; 02
*
+
' ; ( ""7.
7
<"#"
! ' ; 03
' "?
* ' +
; 03
) '
!
; ( ! ! "#%1- -5;((//3"
'
"% (
(
) ) " +
' ; 03
;
352%3 15 ( ( <
"
$
C
% ! (
' )
"
) )
+
' " >
"
,.,121,- 0%/"3/H2&($'- 3 $ % & ' $ & '